Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Stefan v. The General Medical Council (Medical Act 1983)

Privy Council
Nov 22, 1999

Stefan v. The General Medical Council (Medical Act 1983) [1999] UKPC 48 (22nd November, 1999)

Privy Council Appeal No. 24 of 1999

Dr. Marta Stefan

Appellant

v.

The

General Medical Council

Respondent

FROM

THE HEALTH COMMITTEE OF THE

GENERAL MEDICAL COUNCIL

---------------

JUDGMENT OF THE LORDS OF THE JUDICIAL

COMMITTEE

OF THE PRIVY COUNCIL,

Delivered

the 22nd November 1999

------------------

Present at

the hearing:-

Lord Slynn of

Hadley

Lord Nicholls of Birkenhead

Lord Hoffmann

[Delivered

by Lord Slynn of Hadley]

------------------

1. Dr. Stefan appeals from a decision of

the Health Committee of the General Medical Council on 27th May 1999 that her

registration as a doctor should be suspended for a period of twelve months

pursuant to section 37(1)(a) of the Medical Act 1983 and that such suspension

should have immediate effect pursuant to section 38(1) of that Act.

2. Dr. Stefan was given temporary

registration as a medical practitioner in the United Kingdom from 1967, limited

registration from 1979 and provisional registration from 1985. From 1993,

however, she appeared before the Health Committee for them to consider whether

her fitness to practise was "seriously impaired by reason of [her] physical

or mental condition". On 21st June 1993 and on 20th June 1994 her

registration was made subject to conditions for periods respectively of eight

months on the basis that her fitness to practise was seriously impaired.

Subsequently on 23rd February 1995 when she refused to agree to conditions her

registration was suspended for eight months and on 21st February 1996 and 24th

February 1997 respectively further suspensions of twelve months were ordered.

Appeals to the Board against the decisions of 21st June 1993, 23rd February 1995

and 24th February 1997 were dismissed.

3. On 23rd February 1998 the Committee

ordered indefinite suspension but on 8th March 1999 her appeal was allowed by

the Board since reasons for indefinite suspension on the ground of unfitness to

practise were not given.

4. In the decision now challenged the

Committee said that having considered the written and oral evidence "the

Committee have judged your fitness to practise to be seriously impaired by

reason of paranoid personality disorder". They continued:-

"In reaching this finding the

Committee have had regard to paragraph 24(2) of their procedure rules. The

Committee do not consider that your cardiac condition is relevant to your

fitness to practise.

The Committee have carefully

considered whether it would be sufficient to direct that your registration

should be subject to conditions, so that you could return to medical

practice. However, they take the view that your medical condition could

seriously affect your ability to make sound professional judgments.

They are concerned in particular by

the evidence that your condition is a continuing and episodic one.

Accordingly, whilst noting Dr.

AdamsÂ’ opinion on your fitness to practise, the Committee have felt bound

to direct that your registration be suspended for a period of 12 months.

The Committee have further

determined that it is necessary for the protection of members of the public,

and would be in your own best interests, to order that your registration be

suspended forthwith."

5. Rule 24(2) of the Procedure Rules

provides:-

"In reaching their judgment

the Committee shall be entitled to regard as current serious impairment

either the practitioner's current physical or mental condition, or a

continuing and episodic condition, or a condition which, although

currently in remission, may be expected to cause recurrence of serious

impairment."

6. Dr. Stefan in her case set out many

criticisms of the Health Committee, of things which she contended had been said

about her and the way the proceedings had been conducted. In addition she set

out her contentions as to the merits of the decision. At the hearing before the

Board she challenged the accuracy and honesty of the transcript of the hearing

before the Committee and denied that she was in any way suffering from paranoia.

7. In the written evidence given by Dr.

Adams, a psychiatrist who examined her, it was said that she was now able to

control the expression of her opinions about her colleagues and minority groups

but that "any emotional disturbance that might occur would be liable to

precipitate paranoid comments". In his written opinion he wrote that

"Dr. Stefan is able to practise on a limited basis in her chosen speciality

under Consultant supervision and with medical supervision from the GMC". In

his oral evidence he said that he thought "perhaps she could [practise]

under supervision" but that the condition was a continuum and that problems

could occur under stress. Members of the Committee and the clinical assessor of

the Committee, a psychiatrist, asked many questions. On the basis of the answers

to those questions and the written report, it cannot be said that there was no

evidence on which the Committee could conclude as it did.

8. The remainder of Dr. StefanÂ’s

submissions go to the correctness of the decision and as to the way events of

the past had been taken out of context. They raise matters for the Committee but

they do not show any question of law either as to the decision to suspend

registration or as to the decision that the suspension should take immediate

effect.

9. Accordingly since by section 40(5) of

the Act of 1983 an appeal lies to the Board only on a question of law, their

Lordships will humbly advise Her Majesty that this appeal ought to be dismissed.