Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Alexander Lindo, Abraham Lindo, and Henry Lindo v. Edward Moulton Barrett (United Kingdom)

Privy Council
Feb 7, 1856

IX MOORE, 465

the case to warrant their Lordships departing from the language of the deed of

partnership. Whatever, therefore, the deed gives with reference to the ternis there

subpisting, will be given, and is conceded, with regard to the extended term. If

.persons to whom licences have been granted, or any of them, will renew their licences,

the Petitioner (Jerram) will be entitled to that benefit, but we do not see any r eami

for giving the right or power of substitiition beyond that which is given by the

deed of partnership. In point of form, probably, there should be an undertaking

by Dr. Normandy to concur in granting the licences to such personr to whoin

licences have already been granted, as will renew them. There will be no costs of

the present application.

LINDO 11. BARRETT [1856]

The following Order in Council was made upon the Committee’s report :-

“ It is liereby ordered, that the Right Honourable the Lord Chancellor upon

receipt hereof, do cause new Letters Patent, according to the term and effect of

this Order, t o be made and sealed, for su(*h parts of the [Jriited Kingdom of Great

Britain and Ireland, as the said original Letters Patent extended to and were

available i n , viz. fc,r England, ‘Pales, and the town of ‘!rr wick-upor! T w e d , f o r

‘ cc-rtain improvements in the manufacture of soap,’ as described in the [455] Ixtter.2

Patent granted to the said Alphonso Rknl. Le Mire de Normandy, for the furtlirr

terln of three years, from and after the expiration of the term granted in tlie said

original Letters Patent, provided that application be made to fix the seal to auch

new Letters Patent within three months from the date of this Order, and provided

also that an undertaking he given by the said Alphome Rknk Le Mire de Normandy

t o George Turner Jerram in the said new Letters Patent, all the terms, rights, and

privileges t o which the said George Turner Jerram and William Whitaker were

entitled under the original Letters Patent by the deed of dissolution of partner-

ship of the 7th of September, 1843, the partnership then subsisting between the

said George Turner Jerram and Williani Whitaker having been dissolved by mutual

consent on the 1st of January, 1848, whereof the Lord Chancellor and all other

persons whom i t may concern are to govern theniselves accordingly.”

[Mews’ Dig. tit. PATENT ; F. CONF[RMATION, RENEWAL, AND EXTEN~IOU o F LETTER^

PATEKT ; a. Generally-As to Partiter.]

[&6] O N APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT O F JUDICATURE O F

JAMAICA.

ALEXANDER LINDO, ABRAHAM LINDO, and1 HENRY LINDO,-Appellants;

EDWARD MOULTON BARRETT,-Respondent * [Feb. 7, 13561.

Held not t o exempt an

absentee orrner of a public wharf at Jamaica from liability to be sued as a

public wharfinger, for negligence of his agent in the conduct of the m-harf.

Although the subject in dispute was under the appealable value prescribed by

che Royal Instructions, regulating appeals from Jamaica, yet the Judicial

Committee from the fact of the public importance of the question at issue,

allowed an appeal [9 Moo. P.C. 456, 4571.

Rule 1 of the Order in Council of the 13th of June, 1853 [Stat. R. and 0. Rer.

iv. 3051, allowing the Appellant costs upon a successful appeal, is discretionary

in the Court, and only to be allowed in special circumstances.

Up011

petition by Appellant f o r a Supplemental Order allowing costs, the Judicial

Committee refused to interfere.

Construction of the Jamaica Act, 7th Victoria, c. 57.

Upon a reversal, the Order in Council contained no direction as t o costs.

To entitle an Appellant to costs. application ought to be made at the hearing.

*Present: The Right Hon. T. I’emberton Leigh, the Right Hon. Sir Edward

Ryan, the Right Hon. Sir John Patteson, and the Right Hon. Sir William H. Maule.

371

IX MOORE, 467 LINDO v. BARRETT [1856]

In this case a nonsuit was entered by the Supreme Court of Jamaica in an action

brought by the Appellants against the Respondent. for negligence, who, in the first

instance, had obtained a verdict against him for &80 Is. Tlie question resolved

itself into one of con~truction of the Jamaica Act, 7 Vict., e. 57, entitled “ A n Act

of construction to regulate wharves and the rate of wharfage,” etc. The facts are

fully stated in the joint special earn hereinafter set forth. The Supreiiie Court

allowed an appeal to ~ n g l a ~ d , upon security being given for 3500, but as the

amount of the verdict was under 32300, the appealable value prescribed by the

48 No. of the Royal Instructions, [457] a petition was presented t o Her Majesty ill

Council praying for leave to appeal, notwithstanding the amount was under the

appealable value.

Xr. ahor^ or^, in support of the petition.--The Court below was favourable to

the appeal (June 21, 1855 *) ; the question as to the operation of the Island Statute,

7th Vict., e. 57, being the first which had been brought before that Court for

decision. Although the Court below had no power to grant leave to appeal, the

subject-matter involved being under the prescribed value, yeti this Court has jurisdic-

tion to admit it under Statute, 3rd and 4th Will. fV., c. 41. Spoonel. v. ~~&~~~~~

(6 &ore’s P.C. Cases, 257) was referred to.

Mr. G. Barrett opposed, and cited 1% re Havvey (3 Moore’s P.C. Cases, 148).

The Lord Justice Knight Bruce.--This appeal has received the s a ~ l c ~ ~ o ~ ~ of tlir

Supreme Court in the Island. The question involved i s one of iniportance to the

whole of the community of the Island of Jamaica. Leave will be granted, aiid

adhering to the general practice, security for costs in the usual amount, namely,

2300, must be entered into.

A joint special case (this was the first case under the Order in Council, dated the

13th of June, 1553 [Stat. R. and 0. Rev. 3051, in whicli a special case was agreed

upon and stated for the opinion of the Judicial ~ o m ~ i t t e e ) was subn~itted by the

parties [&8] for theopinion of their Lords~ips, and was in substance as foll~ws:---

The Respondent, before m d during the period of the accrual of the cause of

actioir ~ ~ e ~ . e ~ ~ a f t e ~ ” men ioned, was, and still is, the owner of a wharf called the

Trelawney x-harf, situate in the tonin and harlmur of ~ a i m ~ u t l i , in the County of

Comx-all, in the Islarid of Jamaica. This d r n r f was a public one, witliiri the mean-

ing of tile Statute Vtb Fict., e. 57. Thcb Respoildent before and during tlie period

aforesaid resided, and had continued to reside, in ~ n g l a n d , and did not perfornt

iii person any of the duties required by tlre above Act, but managed, carried on, and

conducted the business of the said wharf by an agent, who was paid by salary, and

R I I O perfornied, either by hiniself or by assistants, all the duties required of a

‘. wharfinger ” under that Act or otherwise; ellgaged arid disniissed the clerks,

liibourers, and other persons eniployed in and al30ut the wliarf ; and, in bibief, trana-

ilcted, as the known and recognised agent, of the Respondent, all the business of the

;\liar€. and accounted €or and paid over to him all the profits and proceeds.

The ~ p ~ ~ e ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ t s are ~iierchants at ~ a l i ~ o u t ~ i aforesaid, and on the 7th of July,

1x53, sereral casks of brandy belongi to thein were warehoused at the wharf, in

tlie ordinary way of busitless, and r a 31ed there until the 1st of Map. 1854, when

they were reniorecl ; and it was alleged by the Appel lan~ that several of tlie casks,

ahile warehoused at the said wharf a h aforesaid, had been broached i i ~ several

places, and had lost a large portion of their contents, tlwougli the negligence of the

Res~onde~~t ‘ s agent.

For t h i s alleged loss the A p p e l l ~ ~ i t ~ comirenced against the Respuiident an

action on tlie case a 6 for [459] ilrgligeirce as a public wharfinger; the declaration

c~orrtained also a count iii trover; and the general issue being pleaded, and issue

joined thereoil, a verdict was found for tire Appellants for the1 value of the brand?

alleged to be lost, leave being reserved ta the lhfendant (the R e s ~ ~ ~ d e I ~ t ) to move

to enter a nonsuit, on the ground that he, being an alrnseiitee owner of a wliarf, could

* Present: The Right Hon. T. Peniberton Leigh, the Right N O ~ . the Lord

Justice Knight Bruce, the Right Hen. Sir Edward Ryan, the Right Hoti. the Lord

Justice Turner, and the Right Hon. Sir John Patteson.

3’12

~ - - I_ ___. - ____ __ - - I

LINDO v. ~ A R R ~ T T (r1856j IX XOOBE, 460

not be sued as a public wharfinger for alleged negligence in the conduct of his agent

acting in this Island as wl~arfiriger.

to enter a rtonsuit oil tlie almve ground, or

for a new trial, was obtained in the S erne Court, and after argument, so much of

i t i ls related to entering the nonsuit %as made absolute.

The reasons assigned by the Supreme Court for this judgment were as follows:-

-‘ In this case a rule was obtained to enter :I nonsuit oii a point raised at the trial,

viz, that under the Island Act of the 7th Yict., c. 5‘7, the Defendant, being 511 absentee,

could not. be a public wharfinger, in which capacity alone it is contended the

liability sought to be fired on the Defendant will arise, o r for a new trial, on the

irnproper receipt of a certificate of gauging given by one Borland, who, before

his death, was employed on the wlimf. The action is brouqht io recorer the value

of forty gallons of brandy found deficicnt in quarter casks and octaves whiclt l i d

been warehoused on the wharf of the Defelidant, who is the proprietor, situated i 1 i

Falmouth, the acting wharfinger being Mu. Wilcon.

“The rule for a nonsuit was supported oii the provisions of the Act to which

I have referred, which defines what shall he a public wharf, p rescr ib i~ i~ the E4601

duties which the wharfinger is to perform. and the object for which tliose duties are

to be p e r f o r ~ ~ ~ e d : aiid as they can only be doiie by him in person, i t was contended

that an absentee proprietor cannot be sued for any neglect of duty on his wharf, and

therefore the Plaintiff should be nonsuited.

“ On the pleadi1lg.s it is clear, that if tlie Defendant be not a public wharfinger,

or .vvirhixi the meaning of an Island Act, this action cannot Ire maintained, for there

is no evidence to show a bailment to support the second count; and it is clear, OII

tlie authority of Ross v. Johnson, that the trover, which is the third and last count,

c a n not be ma int a ined.

‘‘ Tlie becoud section of the Act definee what shall be a public wharf : and it

dedares, wheii the owner or person acting under him shall rweive payineat for any

oods landed on it, such wharf slid1 be taken t~ be a public wharf, to which all the

rovisions of this Act dial1 apply. The seventh section imposeR on every ~ ~ ~ i a r f i ~ ~ ~ e r

tlie duty of four times each year, on days specified, to rneke declarat,ior~ that the

accounts eiitered in his wharf ImoB I are true uiid just,’ and the entries so declared

shdl be recei.iued, deemed, arid takeii as good d i d evidence in d l m d every of the

several courts of law arid equity.’

*‘ Those surely are personal dutieh whicli ea11 d o n e be performed hy liiiii on whoiii

the law has impulxed them, and he can be iio other than the wharfinger. iii the actual

pt~,ssession and ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ e ~ i e ~ t of the wli rf. This would appear to be cleai from t l ~

portion of the section which require\ the declaration to he taken belore a Justice of

tlie peace of the parish wherein the wharf is situated; but wheri we see what the

Statute declares shall be the effect of the declaration, E4611 viz. that the books aild

accounts so verified shall be evidence viithout further proof in all Courts, and con-

sidsr to whst aa extent the rights and iiiterests of third parties may be bouiid by the

acts of kh0 wharfinger, i t is surely giving a safe and reasonable irtterpretation t o

this Statute to hold that lie only can Ine a public diarfinger who resides in the Island

and conducts the wharf, and he only can be responsible for neglect of duty, and

answerable for the penal provisions of this law, of which there are ninny, and I

vould refer to the 3rd, l l th , and 13th sections. This being our opinion, it is un-

i~eces6~ry to consider the points on which the rule was granted, in the alter~iative,

for a new trial ; yet we feel it would be cwrpixlg the ~ ~ p o I i s i ~ i l i ~ y of the priricipnI

to a dangerous extent to hold that the relation of irraster and servant existed txt,ween

tlte ~ e f e n d a ~ ~ i and Borland, so as to f ix tlie forrnea by an act of the latter in the

perforniarice of a duty which the VV1ial.f Act hiis imposed by the 4th section on the

vc.harfin,aer only, on request of the owner of tlie goods to be weighed or gauged. We

are not insensible of the difioulties pointed out t ~ s likelv to arise from the interpreta-

tion we have given to this Act, hit those are question8 for the Legislature arid not,

for us to deal with.”

In tlie October term, 1854, a rule i t

The question stated for the dsision of the Judicial Committee was-

Whether, having reference to the provisions of the above Act, the Respondent,

Ipi1lg Ru& 811 ahsentee oxnier and ana^^^ as aforesaid, was lilttile in law to 1)e sued

373

IX lKooRE, 462 LINDO ‘u. BARRETT [18561

as a public Ixharfinger for the alleged negligence of his agent in the conduct of

the uharf.

If the Sudicial Committee should be of opinion that lie was so liable, the judgment

of nonsuit, was to be set [$@I aside. If it should be of q i n i o u that he was not, the

appeal was to be disnlissed.

MI*. Ketltiug, Q.C., and Mr. M c ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o r ~ , in supportt of the appeal.--The Island

Statute, 7th Vrct., c. 57, does not deprive the Appellants of their coninion law right

of action for negligence occasioned by the Bekpondeiit’s agent, he being a public

wharfinger.

The Court stopped them, and called upon the Respondent to support the judgment

of the Court below.

Mr. Montagu Smith, Q.C., and Mr. G. Uarrett, for the Respondent.-~l~e j u d g i ~ e ~ t

was well founded, as by the Island Statute, 7th Vict., c. 57, the Reqondent could

on$ be liable as a wharfinger to a i l action for negligence when in the actual posses-

sion aiid i ~ i ~ ~ r ~ a g e ~ ~ ~ e ~ i t of the wliarf. Here, it is not disputed that lie was an absentee.

+Sir W. H. Maule: The action is brou@t for not perforniing a duty imposed on

the wharfinger, who is represented by tiis agent.]-The agent is acting only as a

keeper of M puMic wIiarf.-[Sir W. H. Naule: 1 cannot find that the Island Statute

relied xigtoril, relieves the principal or his agent of his liability a t coninion 1 a w . j

They referred to ~ ~ e ~ c ~ Z ~ v. ~ ~ ~ f ~ / e ~ . ? ~ ~ ~ / ~ v / ? (21- Law Rep., 314).

This is apparent from the 11th and 16th sections of that Statute.

The Itight Hon. T. Pemberton Leigh.--Tlieir Ilordships are of opinion, havrlig

regard to the provisions of tlie Island Statute /7 Viet. c. 57 (Jamaica)] that tlie

judg-[463]-rnmt of the Court below cannot be sustained, and must be reversed, as

they corrsider the Respondent liahle to he sued, and, therefore, will order &he jtidg-

riient of nonsuit to be set aside. They fully approve of the mode in which the special

case has heen prepared and presented to them.

By the Order in Council made u p u the appeal, it was ordered axid directed

that the judgment of nonsuit entered against tlie Appellants in the Supreme

Court of Judicature of Jamaica in the October term, 1854, be set aside; 1)ut no

directions vere given as to costs of appeal. The Order in Couiicil mas transmitted

to Jamaica by the Appellants’ agent in due course.

A petition was afterwards presented (9th July, 1856 *> by the Appellauts, pray-

iitg that the jud~ineii t tilight be aiiierrded by ordering tlie A~pel lants their costs,

or that an i t~d~~pendent o r supple~i~enta~ Order for the costs of the appeal might be

granted to them This petitiori alleged that LIO direction was contained in the

Order in Council with respect to costs, and that absence of such direction arose frarn

the Appellants’ impression that their Lordsliips did not mean to interfere w ith

their right to corts as given by the Order in Council of the 13th of June,

1853 (IXula I. 7 Xoore’s P.C. Cases, p. ix. [See Stat. R. and 0. Rev. vol. iv. p. 306]),

they having succeeded in their appeal: that there was no intimation at

the Iiearirrg to deprive them of their costs, and that they Bere as of

right entitled to thein under [4M] such Order without any special a ~ ) ~ ~ l i c a t i o n f r

the same. That the Order reversing the j u d g ~ n ~ ~ n t was debe red from the Council

Office to the offre of the Appellants’ solicitor on the evening of the 26th of February,

1856, during their absence from town, and was on the following day transrtiitted

to Janiaica for service, aiid had riot yet heen returned ; and they insisted that they

aere entitled to costs as of right, independent of any supplemental Order, submit-

t ing that i t would be contrary to the letter and spirit of the Order in Council of

the 13th of June, 1853, not to allow costh.

Mr. MrMalion, for the Petitioners.- Tliis application is founded upon tlie first

rule of the Order i u Council of the 13th of June, 1853, which directs that if the

Appellant succeeds ill reversing a decree, or judgment, he shall be entitled to

xecover h i s costs of appeal against the l~espo~ident, ur11ess the Commit~ee otherwise

direct. Here there was no direction against allowing costs, and, therefore, costs

ought, to have been allowed by the Order i n Couiicil as of right. So it is at Coniinon

law, costs wodd be allowed.-[He was stopped, the Court calling upon the Respond-

ent to show cause why the Appellants should not have their costs.]

* Present: The Right Hon. T. Penherton Leigh, the Right Hon. S i r Edward

Ryan, and the Right Hon. Sir William H. Maule.

-- I ~- I ” - _ _ I - -

374

DE BRETTES 1). GOODMAN [1855] IX MOORE, 465

Mr. blontagu Smith, Q.C., aiid Mr. 1:. Barrett, for tlre Respondent, argued,

that the Court had now 110 jurisdiction to award costs, and that to entitle a success-

ful Appellant to costs as against the Respondent, he must apply at the hearing, it

being a matter of discretion in the Conmiittee to allow or not costs. Xoreover,

E4651 they urged that the Order in Council upon the appeal had been acted upon

in Jamaica.

The Right %Ion. T. Pemberton Leigh :--Their Lordships will make nn Order

upon this petition. The rule which has been referred to is merely a regulation

describing the course of practice which is to form the guidance of the Lords of the

Committee, in giving or refusing costs. The effect of that rule is, that if tlie judg-

ment of the Court below is reversed, the Appellant is to have his costs, but then he

must ask for those costs; and if he does not ask for them, the Order in Council is

merely to reverse.

I n this case, their ~ o r d s I ~ i p s are not at all satisfied that costs ought riot to have

been given, and that if asked for, they would not have given them. Although.

Iiovvewr, the rule is general, there must‘ be special circumstances, and that would

be a matter to be discussed at the time; it is impossible nov, after the matter has

been disposed of, and the Order in Council acted upon, to grant costs.

Upon the whole. their Lordships are of opinioii, that they can inake no Order.

[News’ Dig. tit. COLONY: 111. AwEAuAs T o PRIVY C~IJNCII,: 3 Leave to App~d,--

~ n t ~ ~ r t ~ n ~ ~ of Q ~ P s ~ i ~ , - ~ ~ ~ b r n ini*olwrl below ~ ~ p e ~ ~ f f b ~ ~ Amount, 6 Pvartict.,

-Public WJLarfs. On point as to (i.) costs of GhotayTd v. Mandckclrzcnd am?

Rmisreechumd, 1866, 10 Moo. P.C. 139; (ii.) special leave to appeal in civil

cases, see note to RetPmeyrr 17. O b r r t n d e r , 1837, 2 Moo. P.C. at p. 125. As

to appeals froni Jamaica, sech 0. in C. of 14th April, 1851 (Stat. R. and 0.

Rev. iv. 33 L).]

n. C l J S f S : tit. W A R E H O ~ ~ S E M E ~ , ~ ~ ~ A ~ ~ I N G E R A D WHARF, 1. WH-4RF

[&6] OK APPEAL FROM TEE S ~ ~ 1 ~ E ~ ~ ~ CIIrIL COURT OF APPEAL

OF TEIE I s u m OF SSIXT LVCIA.

CHARLES DE BRETTES,-A~?~clln7~; JOHN GOODMAN, E E N R Y PHYCE, arid

CHARLES MUREAT PAL^^^, ~ ~ s ? ~ o ? z ~ e r ~ f s * [18tli and 19th June, 18551.

Uiider a judicial sale of real estate in St. Lucia, Z. professing to act as attorney

for W. and wife, resident in Fraiioe, purchased the estate on their behalf.

The purchase-money was to be paid, according to the Ordinancc of the 22nd

of January, 1833, by instalnients, and D. becaiiie surety, ~ 1 % soZ?do, for pay-

ruent of the second i i ~ s ~ a l ~ ~ e I ~ t . The deed of a i . r a ~ i ~ e n ~ e l ~ t for the pnrcliase,

and tlie notarial deed was executed by oiie of the trustees, who was resident

~ I I the Coloiiy, and by such deed it was stipulated that tlie sale sliouid lie

confirmed aiid ratified by h i s two trustees resident in Eiiglaiid within six

months. By a deed poll, tile sale to W. and his wife was ~ o n f i r ~ ~ i e d an

ratified bj- the trustees i n E n ~ l a n ( ~ . Pefault was made in payment of the

second instalmerit, when the trustcw brouzht an action against, D. as suretF

for the aiiiount of the second iiistaltiwnt. It was afterwards discovered

that the power of attorney to L. was confined to W. alone, and contained no

authority from his wife, alien tlie trustees discliarged the n ife from the

contract. Held, that D. WBS not liable as surety, as tlie sale professed to be

to W. and wife by the three trustees, while in fact tlie sale was to W, onl),

arid as fiurh was an ineffectual and void sale.

her by the French law in force in St. Lucia, D’s liability as surety

v T ~ ~ ~ , was not effectual as agaiiist W.’s acts, p o a d the wi fe?

- - . I. - - . ____ __ __ __ - _. .- -

* Preseiit: The Right Hon. T. Pemberton Leigh, the Riglit Hon. the Lord

Justice Knight Bruce, and the Right Hon. the Lord Justice Turner.

375