Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

R.K Saxena (Lt. Col.). v. Imperial Forestry Corporation Ltd. Through Official Lequidator..

Delhi High Court
May 31, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant filed a petition under sub-section (1) of Section 439 of the Companies Act, 1956 for winding up the respondent company. The petition was admitted and a provisional liquidator appointed on 10.6.1998. However, no direction was initially given to advertise the petition as required under Rule 24 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959. The appellant subsequently filed an application seeking directions to advertise the petition in two daily newspapers (one English and one regional language) but requested that the mandatory advertisement in the Official Gazette be dispensed with. The learned Company Judge ordered advertisement in the two newspapers and the Delhi Gazette but rejected the prayer to dispense with the Gazette publication. The appellant challenged this part of the order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the mandatory requirement under Rule 24 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959 to advertise a winding up petition in one issue of the Official Gazette can be dispensed with by the Company Court.
  2. Whether the discretionary power vested in the Court under Rule 99 and Rule 9 of the Rules allows the Court to dispense with the Gazette advertisement in winding up proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Rule 24’s requirement to advertise in the Official Gazette can be dispensed with by the Company Court under Rule 99, which provides discretion "subject to any directions of the Court."
  • The Court has ample power under Rule 99 and inherent powers under Rule 9 to dispense with the mandatory Gazette advertisement in the interest of justice or to prevent abuse of process.
  • The discretion includes directing advertisement in only one newspaper or in a particular manner different from the prescribed method.
  • Relied on precedents such as U.P Twiga Fiberglass Ltd. v. Parekh Marketing P. Ltd. and Plastisac P. Limited v. Gujarat Lease Finance Limited to support the contention that Gazette advertisement can be dispensed with.

Respondent's Arguments (Official Liquidator)

  • There is no power vested in the Company Judge to dispense with the mandatory requirement of advertising the petition in the Official Gazette in addition to the two daily newspapers.
  • Maintained that the impugned order rejecting the prayer to dispense with Gazette advertisement was correct.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
U.P Twiga Fiberglass Ltd. v. Parekh Marketing P. Ltd., (1986) 59 Company Cases 886 Discretion under Rule 99 to direct advertisement and possibility to dispense with Gazette publication. Court rejected this view as inconsistent with the mandatory requirement of sub-rule (2) of Rule 24 for winding up petitions.
Plastisac P. Limited v. Gujarat Lease Finance Limited, (2000) 101 Company Cases 334 Inherent powers under Rule 9 to dispense with Gazette advertisement. Court disagreed, holding this view incorrect in light of the Supreme Court precedent and mandatory nature of Rule 24.
National Conduits (P) Ltd. v. S.S Arora, (1967) 37 Company Cases 786 Mandatory nature of advertisement for winding up petitions and inherent powers to postpone advertisement. Supported the mandatory requirement of Gazette advertisement before hearing but recognized inherent powers to defer advertising to prevent abuse.
Ramchandra Keshav Adke v. Govind Joti Chavare, (1975) 1 SCC 915 Strict compliance with procedural requirements as mandated by statute. Approved the principle that statutory procedural requirements must be strictly followed.
Shiv Kumar Chadha v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi and others, 1993 (3) SCC 161 Compliance with procedural rules under Code of Civil Procedure. Reinforced principle that procedural requirements must be complied with as prescribed.
Taylor v. Taylor, (1875) 1 CH D 426 Principle that if statute requires a thing to be done in a particular manner, it should be done accordingly or not at all. Applied to hold that advertisement must be in the manner prescribed by Rule 24.
Nazir Ahmed v. Emperor, AIR 1936 PC 253 Same principle regarding compliance with statutory procedural requirements. Supported strict adherence to prescribed manner of advertisement.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the relevant Rules of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959, focusing on Rule 24, Rule 96, Rule 99, Rule 6, and Rule 9. Rule 24 mandates that winding up petitions must be advertised in the Official Gazette and two newspapers not less than fourteen days before the hearing date. Sub-rule (2) of Rule 24 expressly removes the discretion to dispense with advertisement for winding up petitions.

While Rule 99 confers discretion "subject to any directions of the Court" regarding the timing and manner of advertisement, the Court held this discretion does not extend to dispensing with the Gazette advertisement altogether. The discretion relates only to when the advertisement is to be published, not whether it must be published.

The Court referred to the Supreme Court decision in National Conduits (P) Ltd. v. S.S Arora which clarified that although the Court has inherent powers under Rule 9 to postpone advertisement to prevent abuse or harassment, the petition cannot be heard unless the advertisement requirement is fulfilled.

The Court rejected the appellant’s reliance on the decisions in U.P Twiga Fiberglass Ltd. and Plastisac P. Limited, holding that the mandatory nature of the Gazette advertisement as per Rule 24 and the principle that statutory procedural requirements must be strictly complied with preclude dispensing with the Gazette advertisement.

The Court emphasized the purpose of Gazette publication—to ensure wider publicity and confer authenticity to the advertisement—and found no infirmity in the learned Company Judge’s order requiring Gazette advertisement.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

The Court upheld the mandatory requirement under Rule 24 that a petition for winding up a company must be advertised in one issue of the Official Gazette of the concerned State or Union Territory in addition to two daily newspapers. The Court held that the discretionary powers under Rule 99 and inherent powers under Rule 9 do not permit dispensing with this Gazette advertisement. The direct effect is that parties seeking winding up must comply with the Gazette advertisement requirement, ensuring procedural safeguards and wider publicity. No new precedent altering the mandatory nature of Gazette advertisement was established.

Show all summary ...

Devinder Gupta, J.— The question involved in this appeal is that whether the requirement of petition to be advertised in one of the issues of Official Gazette of the State or Union Territory concerned, as provided in Rule 24 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959 (hereinafter referred to as “the Rules”) can be dispensed with.

2. The facts in brief are that the appellant filed a petition under sub-section (1) of Section 439 of the Companies Act, 1956 for winding up of the respondent Company. The said company petition was admitted for hearing and a provisional liquidator was appointed on 10.6.1998 No direction was given to advertise the petition, as required under Rule 24 of the Rules. Application (CA. 631/2000) was filed by the appellant for directions to advertise the petition praying further that while directing the petition to be advertised in a daily newspaper in English language and daily newspaper in regional language circulating in Delhi, requirement of advertising the petition in the Official Gazette be dispensed with. Learned Company Judge by the impugned order directed the advertisement of the winding up petition in one of the issue of Statesman English publication from Delhi) and in one issue of Amar Ujala (Hindi publication from Bareilly, U.P). The prayer for dispensing with publication in the Official Gazette was rejected. The petition was also directed to be advertised in the Delhi Gazette. The appellant has challenged that part of the order by which prayer to dispense with advertisement in the Gazette has been rejected.

3. Learned counsel for the appellant contended that Rule 24 has to be read with Rule 99 of the Rules. There is ample power in Rule 99 vested with the Company Court to dispense with even the mandatory requirement of Rule 24 because of the wordings of Rule 99, which says:—

“Subject to any directions of the Court”.

4. It was urged that learned Company Judge failed to correctly appreciate the ratio of the decisions cited before him, namely, U.P Twiga Fiberglass Limited v. Parekh Marketing P. Limited, (1986) 59 Company Cases 886 and Plastisac P. Limited v. Gujarat Lease Finance Limited, (2000) 101 Company Cases 334.

5. Shri S.K Luthra, Advocate, appearing for the Official Liquidator has tried to support the impugned order urging that power is not vested in the Company Judge to dispense with the mandatory requirement of advertising the petition in the Official Gazette in addition to its being advertised in the two dailies.

6. We have duly considered the respective submissions. On a petition being filed, Rule 96 of the Rules provide for the manner of its admission and advertisement, if any. Rule 96 of the Rules reads:—

“96. Admission of petition and directions as to advertisement - Upon the filing of the petition, it shall be posted before the Judge in Chambers for admission of the petition and fixing a date for the hearing thereof and for directions as to the advertisements to be published and the persons, if any, upon whom copies of the petition are to, be served. The Judge may, it he thinks fit, direct notice to be given to the company before giving directions as to the advertisement of the petition.”

7. Rule 96 thus provide that he said petition will be laid before the Judge in Chambers for admission and for fixing a date for hearing and for directions as to the advertisements, if any, to be published and the persons, if any, upon whom copies of the petition are to be served. The Judge may, if he thinks fit, direct notice to be given to the company before giving directions as to the advertisement of the petition. Thus the company petition on being filed, when is posted before the Company Judge for admission, he may either; (a) issue notice to the company to show cause why petition be not admitted; or (b) admit the petition and fix a date for hearing and issue a notice of the company before giving direction about advertisement of the petition or (c) admit the petition, fix a date of hearing of the petition and order that the petition be advertised and direct that the petition be served upon persons specified in the order.

8. Rule 24 of the Rules deals with the mode and manner of advertising such of the petition, which is required to be advertised. It reads:—

“24. Advertisement of petition - (1) Where any petition is required to be advertised, it shall, unless the Judge otherwise orders, or these rules otherwise provide, be advertised not less than fourteen days before the date fixed for hearing, in one issue of the Official Gazette of the State or the Union Territory concerned, and in one issue each of a daily newspaper in the English language and a daily newspaper in the regional language circulation in the State of the Union Territory concerned, as may be fixed by the Judge.

(2) Except in the case of a petition to wind-up a company the Judge may, if he thinks fit, dispense with any advertisement required by these rules.”

9. A petition for winding up cannot be placed for hearing before the Court unless the petition is advertised, which would be clear from the terms of sub-rule (2) of Rule 24. Though there is a discretion vested in the Judge while issuing direction to advertise a petition but sub-rule (2) of Rule 24 has taken away the said discretion, which mandates that a petition to wind up a company must be advertised. Requirement the Rules is that a petition for winding up of a company is mandatory and the requirement of the Rule is that it shall be advertised in one of the issues of the Official Gazette of the State, one issue of a daily newspaper in English and daily newspaper in regional language. Submission of learned counsel for the appellant was that this mandate stands diluted because of the wording of Rule 99, which says that subject to any directions of the Court.

10. He contended that it is not impermissible for the Company Judge to exercise discretion in either way. The Court may direct that the petition be or be not advertised or be advertised in a particular manner or be advertised only in one newspaper instead of two.

11. We are not convinced by what has been urged by learned counsel for the appellant. The requirement of advertising the petition in the Official Gazette is mandatory. No doubt on reading Rule 99 it may be said that there is a discretion vested in the Court, but the said discretion is limited only to the extent that at what stage the petition be advertised. It may not be advertised forthwith or advertising the petition may be deferred for some time:—

12. Rule 99 reads as under:—

“99. Advertisement of petition - Subject to any directions of the Court, the petition shall be advertised within the time and in the manner provided by Rule 24 of these rules. The advertisement shall be in Form No. 48.”

13. In U.P Twiga Fiberglass Ltd. v. Parekh Marketing P. Ltd., (1986) 59 Company Cases 886, the decision relied upon by the appellant's counsel, the question was whether advertisement could not have been issued without affording opportunity to the Company to oppose the same. In that context learned counsel for the Company had urged before the Bench that the petition had not been advertised in the Gazette on the day on which advertisement in the newspaper was made, therefore, there was violation of the requirement of Rule 24, which submission was turned down observing that Rule 99 lays down expressly that the manner provided for advertisement in Rule 24 is subject to any direction of the Court and this leaves no room for doubt that the Company Judge could give specific direction with respect to advertisement as he did under the impugned order and dispensed with publication in the Gazette.

14. With due respect to Hon'ble Judges, such a view is not possible because of mandate of sub-rule (2) of Rule 24, which as per the decision of the Supreme Court in National Conduits (P) Ltd. v. S.S Arora, (1967) 37 Company Cases 786 is mandatory in nature in so far as petition for winding up of a company is concerned. The question, which had come up before the Supreme Court was that once a petition is admitted, whether the Court is bound forthwith to advertise the petition. The High Court had held that once a petition is admitted the Court is bound forthwith to advertise the petition. Judgment of the High Court was set aside holding that the view taken by the High Court in contrary to the plain terms of Rule 96. If the petition is admitted, it is still open to the Company to move the Court that in the interest of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of Court the petition be not advertised. The Court is such a case has ample power to entertain such an application of the Company under its inherent powers contained in Rule 9 of the Rules. Contrary view if accepted that once petition is admitted to file it must be advertised, would make the Court an instrument, in possible cases of harassment and even of black mailing in as much as once a petition is advertised the business of the Company is bound to suffer serious loss and injury. In other words, the inherent powers of the Court to postpone the act of advertising the petition was reiterated in National Conduits (P) Ltd's case (supra) but it was simultaneously observed that the petition for winding up cannot be placed for hearing before the Court unless the petition is advertised.

15. The method and manner of publication is provided in sub-rule (1) of Rule 24 saying that it shall be advertised not less than 14 days before the date fixed for hearing; (a) in one issue of the Official Gazette of the State or Union Territory concerned; and in one issue each of daily newspaper in English language and a daily newspaper in the regional language circulating in the State.

16. In Plastisac P. Limited v. Gujarat Lease Finance Limited, (2000) 101 Company Cases 334 also learned Single Judge of Gujarat High Court has read the inherent power of the Company Court contained in Rule 9 to be a power sufficient to dispense with the mandatory requirement of advertising the petition in Official Gazette, which view taken, with due respect, in our view, is not the correct view, more particularly in what has been said in National Conduits (P) Ltd's case (supra). The extent of applicability of the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure is provided in Rule 6 of the Rules, which reads:—

“6. Practice and Procedure of the Court and provisions of the Code of apply - Save as provided by the Act or by these rules the practice and procedure of the Court and the provisions of the Code so far as applicable, shall apply to all proceedings under the Act and these rules. The Registrar may decline to accept any document which is presented otherwise than in accordance with these rules or the practice and procedure of the Court.”

17. Inherent powers of the Company Court are contained in Rule 9, which reads:—

“9. Inherent powers of Court: Nothing in these rules shall be deemed to limit or otherwise affect the inherent powers of the Court to give such directions or pass such orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the Court.”

18. A combined reading of aforesaid Rules 6 and 9 indicates that the inherent powers of the Court could be exercised in the same manner as provided in Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure by the Court except in cases where the companies act and the rules framed thereunder provide otherwise. There is a specific Rule 24, which require that the petition shall must be advertised unless the Judge otherwise orders. Exercise of discretion is implicit in this Rule but is confined only to the time limit for advertisement. The discretion, which can be exercised is relatable only to that part of the Rule, which says;

“be advertised not less than fourteen days before the date for hearing.”

19. Rule 24(1) also provide a particular manner in which advertisement is to be made. There is no scope for exercise of inherent jurisdiction of dispensing with such a requirement. Rule 24(1) requiring publication to be done in Gazette and two newspapers attracts the principle, that if a statute requires a thing to be done in a particular manner, it should be done in that manner or not all. This principle was approved and accepted in the well-known cases of Taylor v. Tayulor [(1875) 1 CH D 426, 45 U Ch 373] and Nazir Ahmed v. Emperor, AIR 1936 PC 253(2): 63 1A 372 : 37 Cr. LJ 897). Supreme Court has also expressed the same view in respect of procedural requirement of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act in the case of Ramchandra Keshav Adke v. Govind Joti Chavare, (1975) 1 SCC 915 : AIR 1975 SC 915 and as regards compliance of requirement contained in Rule 3 of Order 39 of the Code in Shiv Kumar Chadha v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi and others, 1993 (3) SCC 161.

20. There appears to be a purpose for the manner in which advertisement is to take place that it must have a wider publicity and by its publication in the Official Gazette an authenticity is but to the advertisement. We find no infirmity in the order passed by learned Company Judge holding that in view of the clear mandate of sub-rule (2) of Rule 24 of the Rules, Company Court cannot invoke powers under Rules 6, 9 or 99 to dispense with advertisement of the winding up petition of a Company in Official Gazette.

21. Dismissed