Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mojaffar Alias Moja Alias Mojrek Alias Mojek Sk. Alias Khan And Etc. v. State Of West Bengal

Calcutta High Court
Nov 12, 2010
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion delivered by Ashim Kumar Banerjee, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

On 5 November 2003 at about 1:50 p.m. a gang of six persons armed with firearms, knives and other weapons entered the Punjab National Bank, Salboni Branch (District Midnapore West) and committed a dacoity. They cut the alarm system, forced entry into the cash counter, took cash of Rs. 41,910 from the cash counter and another Rs. 10,000 from the vault, and snatched a mobile phone and keys. The gang confined staff and customers inside the strong room and left at about 2:15 p.m., after which the confined persons were freed.

The police arrested three persons (the appellants) after a chase, recovered part of the robbed money, and charge-sheeted them. The accused pleaded not guilty and were tried. Twenty-seven witnesses were examined, including bank staff, customers and police personnel. The Additional Sessions Judge, 4th Court, Paschim Midnapur, by judgment and order dated 27 and 30 July 2005 convicted the three accused of offences under Sections 395, 397 and 412 of the Indian Penal Code, and sentenced them to terms of rigorous imprisonment and fines as described in the trial court's order. Three convicted persons appealed (CRA 701/2005 and CRA 702/2005), and both appeals were heard together by this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, having convicted accused of dacoity under Section 395 IPC, the trial court could also impose a separate conviction and sentence under Section 397 IPC (i.e., whether Section 397 permits a separate sentence in addition to punishment under Section 395).
  2. Whether a conviction and sentence under Section 412 IPC could be sustained simultaneously with a conviction for dacoity under Section 395 IPC.
  3. Collateral factual/contention issues relevant to conviction and sentence: the validity and timing of Test Identification Parades and whether any delay or identification procedure impropriety warranted interference with convictions; and whether, in view of detention already undergone, the sentences should be modified.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (Defence) Arguments

  • Counsel for the appellants pointed to alleged anomalies in the depositions of the twenty-seven prosecution witnesses and argued these anomalies entitled the appellants to benefit of doubt (though counsel did not deny the incident itself).
  • It was contended as a legal proposition that once the court found the accused guilty of dacoity and convicted them under Section 395 IPC, no separate conviction and sentence could be imposed under Section 397 IPC; rather, Section 397 should enhance the punishment under Section 395 (i.e., conviction should be framed as Section 395 read with Section 397).
  • Counsel argued that the Test Identification Parade was a farce because the witnesses had been shown the accused before the parade (relying on answers in Section 313 CrPC examination) and that there was an unusual delay in holding the parade, which raised suspicion that police had identified the accused to witnesses prior to the parade.
  • It was further argued that since there was no recovery from Saidar and the appellants had already undergone detention for around seven years, the Court should, if not ordering acquittal, at least modify and reduce the sentences.
  • To support the legal propositions, the defence cited several authorities (enumerated in the precedents table below).

Prosecution's Arguments

  • The prosecution emphasized that the dacoity occurred in broad daylight and that bank staff and customers uniformly supported the prosecution case.
  • Test Identification Parade results were relied upon: particular witnesses (P.W.15, P.W.16 and P.W.17) identified the accused in the parade.
  • Part of the stolen money was recovered from two of the accused (Moza and Ajit), supporting the conviction and sentence passed by the trial court.
  • On these factual and evidentiary bases, the prosecution argued the trial court's judgment and conviction did not merit interference.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gaya Bhakta v. The State of Orissa (1988 Cri LJ 1576) Held that Section 397 does not create a separate substantive offence; punishment under Section 397 is an enhancement and the correct mode is to convict under Section 395 read with Section 397 rather than impose separate sentence under Section 397. The Court agreed with this proposition and held the trial judge should have treated punishment as Section 395 read with Section 397 (single punishment) rather than imposing a separate sentence under Section 397.
Kallu alias Ramkumar v. State of Madhya Pradesh (1992 Cri LJ 2380) Observed that Section 397 provides for enhanced punishment and that there could be only one punishment for the offence under Section 395 read with Section 397; no separate sentence under Section 397 is permissible. The Court relied on this view to conclude that separate sentence for Section 397 was impermissible and modified the sentence accordingly.
Kamal Haldar v. State of West Bengal (2002 Cal. Cr. LJ 488) Division Bench observed similarly that Section 397 is to be read as enhancing punishment under Section 395 and does not create a separate sentence in addition to Section 395. The Court cited and followed the Division Bench's observation in accepting the defence legal proposition on sentencing under Section 397.
Dilip Malik v. State of West Bengal (1991 Cri LJ 2171) Division Bench held that when an accused is convicted of having committed dacoity under Section 395, there cannot be a further conviction under Section 412. The Court applied this principle to set aside the conviction and sentence under Section 412 in the instant case.
Mohan Chetri v. State of West Bengal (1992 Cri LJ 2374) Another Division Bench decision holding similarly that Section 412 conviction should not stand in addition to conviction for dacoity under Section 395. The Court referred to and followed this authority in concluding that the Section 412 conviction and sentence could not co-exist with Section 395 conviction and therefore set it aside.
Shri Phool Kumar v. Delhi Administration ((1975) 1 SCC 797) The Apex Court observed that Section 397 applies where the offender used a deadly weapon at the time of committing dacoity; it is immaterial whether the weapon was successfully used or whether the robbery succeeded — mere presence/possession of a deadly weapon attracts Section 397. The Court relied on this principle to hold that the presence of weapons among the gang members brought the offence within the mischief of Section 397, supporting imposition of enhanced punishment (but as an enhancement to Section 395, not as a separate sentence).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined both the factual evidence and the legal propositions raised on appeal.

On facts and identification:

  • The Court found consistent testimony from the bank staff (P.W.1, P.W.2, P.W.15, P.W.16 and P.W.17) corroborated by other eyewitnesses (P.W.6, P.W.7, P.W.11, P.W.12, P.W.13, P.W.22 and P.W.26). The evidence established that the dacoity took place and that the gang members were armed.
  • The Magistrate (P.W.21) supported the Test Identification Parade report. Arrest and identification dates were noted: Ajit arrested same day (5 Nov 2003) and identified on 18 Nov; Saidar and Moza arrested on 20 Nov and identified on 4 Dec. The Court concluded there was no unusual delay in conducting the parade and no scope for interference on that score.
  • Part of the recovered money was recovered from Ajit (and Moza as indicated), reinforcing the prosecution case.

On the legal issue of sentencing under Sections 395 and 397:

  • The Court analyzed the statutory scheme in Sections 390–402 IPC dealing with robbery and dacoity, explaining that Section 391 defines dacoity (five or more persons) and that Sections 395 and 397 prescribe punishment. Section 397 provides for enhanced punishment when weapons are used.
  • Applying precedent (Gaya Bhakta, Kallu, Kamal Haldar), the Court concluded Section 397 does not create a separate substantive offence but provides for enhanced punishment. Therefore the correct approach is to treat the offence as punishable under Section 395 read with Section 397 and to impose a single punishment reflecting the enhancement; a separate additional sentence under Section 397 is impermissible.

On the issue of concurrent convictions under Sections 395 and 412:

  • Citing Division Bench authorities (Dilip Malik and Mohan Chetri), the Court held that where an accused is convicted of dacoity under Section 395, a separate conviction under Section 412 (dishonestly receiving stolen property) cannot be maintained simultaneously. Applying those authorities, the Court set aside the conviction and sentence under Section 412.

Disposition of sentencing and fines:

  • The Court modified the sentencing scheme: the ten-year sentence imposed by the trial judge should be treated as a single sentence for the act under Section 395 read with Section 397 for Ajit, Moza and Saidar.
  • The separate sentence of seven years imposed under Section 397 and the separate conviction and sentence under Section 412 were set aside.
  • The imposition of a fine of Rs. 53,000 against the three appellants was left to remain as a single fine-punishment enforceable with the specified default period.

Administrative directions:

  • The Court directed the trial court to issue modified jail warrants in accordance with the modified sentencing and to send a copy of this judgment to the Superintendent of the Correctional Home where the appellants were imprisoned and to the trial court along with lower court records for necessary action.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Court held that punishment for dacoity where deadly weapons are used should be treated as a single punishment under Section 395 IPC read with Section 397 IPC (i.e., Section 397 enhances punishment under Section 395), and a separate sentence under Section 397 is impermissible. The Court also held that a separate conviction and sentence under Section 412 IPC cannot be maintained alongside a conviction for dacoity under Section 395 IPC.

Direct consequences and orders:

  • The ten-year sentence imposed by the trial court is to be considered a single sentence under Section 395 read with Section 397 for Ajit, Moza and Saidar.
  • The separate seven-year sentence under Section 397 and the conviction and sentence under Section 412 are set aside.
  • The fine of Rs. 53,000 imposed against the three appellants remains as a single fine-punishment with the existing default imprisonment provision.
  • The trial court was directed to issue modified jail warrants and relevant copies of the judgment were to be sent to the Correctional Home and the trial court for implementation.
  • The appeals were disposed of accordingly; urgent certified xerox copies to be given if applied for.

Broader implication: The Court followed existing High Court and Apex Court authorities in holding that Section 397 operates as an enhanced punishment clause to be read with Section 395 rather than as an independent ground for a separate sentence; no new precedent was formulated beyond the application of those authorities to the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

Ashim Kumar Banerjee, J.:— On November 5, 2003 at about 1.50 p.m there had been a bank robbery in Punjab National Bank, Salboni Branch in the District of Midnapore (W). Shri Satyabadi Behara (P.W 15) lodged a written complaint with the Officer in-charge, Salboni Police Station inter alia stating that on the said date i.e November 5, 2003 at about 10.00 a.m the bank was open for public transactions. Five bank staff being P.W 1 (Kanchan Kirit Das), P.W 2 (Smt. Joyanti Mondal), P.W 15 (Satyabadi Behara), P.W 16 (Santosh Kumar Mondal) and P.W 17 (Raju Singh) were working there. Mr. Kanchan Kirit Das (P.W 1) was at the Cash Counter. At about 1.50 p.m a gang of six persons armed with firearms, knives and other weapons entered the bank premises. They immediately cut the alarm system of the bank. Two of them entered into the Cash Counter while others gheraoed the customer and other staff, threatening them with the fire arms. Two miscreants who entered the Cash Counter forcibly took away cash amounting to rupees forty one thousand nine hundred and ten. They forced the Manager as well as Cashier to open the vault and from there they also took away rupees ten thousand in cash causing loss aggregating to rupees fifty-one thousand nine hundred and ten. The miscreants also snatched a mobile phone from one Pravat Kumar Dey (P.W 22), a customer of the bank. The miscreants also snatched the bag of the Manager containing bunch of keys of the bank as well as the scooter/bike keys being used by the Manager and the other staff. The miscreants belonged to the age group of thirty years. They left the bank premises at about 2.15 p.m confining all the staff members and customers inside the strong room by closing the same from outside. After the miscreants had left, Ananda Mohan Mondal, the landlord of the said premises got the confined staff and customers freed by opening the strong room.

2. The police team chased and ultimately arrested three of the miscreants being the appellants above named. The police also seized a part of the amount robbed from the bank. Despite frantic efforts the other miscreants could not be identified and arrested. All the three accused were chargesheeted. They pleaded not guilty and opted to be tried. Altogether twenty seven witnesses were examined. They were customers, staff of the bank apart from the Police Personnel and the Investigating Team. The learned Additional Session Judge, 4th Court, Paschim Midnapur by judgment and order dated July 27, 2005 and July 30, 2005, held all the three accused guilty of the offence under Sections 395, 397 and 412 of the Indian Penal Code. Perusal of the judgment depicts that the learned Judge held all the accused guilty of the offence under Sections 395 and 297 of the Indian Penal Code whereas the accused Ajit Ghnati and Mojaffar alias Moja were held guilty of the charges under Section 412 of the Indian Penal Code. The other accused Saidar Khan was acquitted of the charge brought under Section 412 of the Indian Penal Code against him. While awarding sentence the learned Judge passed an order of sentence for ten years for the “respective offences” under Sections 395 and 412 of the Indian Penal Code and seven years for the offence committed under Section 397. The three convicts were directed to suffer rigorous imprisonment for ten years coupled with a fine of rupees five thousand each and in default rigorous imprisonment for one year more for the offence committed under Section 395 and rigorous imprisonment for seven years coupled with a fine of rupees three thousand each and in default to suffer imprisonment for six months for the offence committed under Section 397 of the Indian Penal Code. The learned Judge also sentenced Ajit and Moza for ten years and to pay a fine of rupees three thousand each and in default to suffer further imprisonment for one year for the offence committed under Section 412 of the Indian Penal Code. Being aggrieved Mojaffar alias Moja preferred appeal being CRA 701 of 2005 whereas the other two convicts being Ajit and Saidar preferred the other appeal being CRA 702 of 2005. Both the appeals were heard by us simultaneously and are being disposed of by this common judgment.

3. Mr. Kamal Zahiruzemal, learned counsel appearing for the appellants being led by Mr. S.S Roy, learned counsel placed the deposition of all the twenty seven prosecution witnesses and pointed out anomalies, which according to them, would deserve a benefit of doubt in favour of the appellants. Mr. Roy, however, in his usual fairness did not seriously contend that there had been no incident at all or that the appellant did not have any hand in it. Mr. Roy rather attacked the judgment and order of the learned Additional District Judge on a legal proposition. According to Mr. Roy, once the Court found that the accused were guilty of the offence by committing dacoity and were convicted under Section 395 there could not be any separate conviction and sentence imposed under Section 397. According to Mr. Roy this apporoach of the learned Judge was totally erroneous and contrary to law. Mr. Roy also drew our attention to the reply given by the appellants while being examined under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code to the extent that all the witnesses were shown the accused before the Test Identification Parade. Hence the so-called Test Identification Parade held by the learned Magistrate was farce and the learned Judge should not have relied on the same. Mr. Roy also contended that there had been unusual delay in holding the Test Identification Parade which would lead to a genuine suspicion in the mind of the Court that the accused were earlier identified by the Police Personnel to the witnesses. Mr. Roy further contended that having regard to the fact that there was no recovery from Saider and having regard to the fact that all three of them suffered the period of detention for last seven years this Court, if not satisfied with the case made out by the appellants for acquittal, should modify the sentence by lessening the same. To support the legal proposition so advanced by Mr. Roy on the issue of imposition of separate sentence under Section 397 Mr. Roy cited the following decisions:—

i) Gaya Bhakta v. The State of Orissa, reported in 1988 Criminal Law Journal 1576.

ii) Kallu alias Ramkumar v. State of Madhya Pradesh, reported in 1992 Criminal Law Journal 2380.

iii) Kamal Haldar v. State Of West Bengal, reported in 2002 Calcutta Criminal Law Journal 488.

4. To support the other legal proposition that the conviction under Sections 395 and 412 could not go simultaneously, Mr. Roy cited the decisions reported in 1991 Criminal Law Journal 2171 (Dilip Malik v. State of West Bengal) and in the case of Mohan Chetri v. State of West Bengal reported in 1992 Criminal Law Journal 2374.

5. Sk. Abdul Salam, learned counsel appearing for the prosecution while opposing the appeal contended that the dacoity was committed in broad day light. All the staff members as well as customers came forward to support the case of prosecution. P.W 15, 16 and 17 identified the accused in Test Identification Parade. Part of the money was recovered from Moza and Ajit. Taking a sum total of such salient features the learned Additional Judge wrote the judgment and conviction which did not deserve any interference from this Court.

6. We have considered the rival contentions. On a close look to the evidence we find that P.W 1, 2, 15, 16 and 17 all five members of the bank staff supported the case of the prosecution. They corroborated each other. The other eye-witnesses being P.W 7, 6, 11, 12, 13, 22 and 26 also corroborated the bank staff. With due respect to Mr. Zahiruzemal, we do not find any anomaly in the evidence led by the prosecution on the occurrence. The learned Magistrate (P.W 21) supported his report on the Test Identification Parade. The incident occurred on November 5, 2003. On the same day Ajit was arrested. Money was recovered from him. On November 20, 2003 Saider and Moza were arrested. Ajit was identified in Test Identification Parade on November 18 whereas the other two were identified on December 4. There was no unusual delay in conducting the parade. On that score, we do not find any scope of interference.

7. Let us now come to the legal issue raised by Mr. Roy. A composite interpretation of dacoity as provided in Indian Penal Code would be fruitful for our present purpose. Sections 390 to 402 of the Indian Penal Code deal with the offence of “robbery” and “dacoity”. Section 390 defines “robbery” as theft or extortion. Theft is a robbery and when it is done threatening the victim and causing voluntary hurt to the person or causing death in him or by any wrongful restraint whereas robbery is done in identical circumstance through extortion. When five or more persons are involved in robbery the offence is termed as “dacoity” under Section 391 and would attract punishment under inter alia Sections 395, 396 and 397 of the Indian Penal Code. Section 395 provides for punishment for imprisonment for life or rigorous imprisonment for a maximum term of ten years coupled with a fine whereas Section 396 provides for an identical punishment when any murder is committed in course of dacoity. Section 397 however provides for an enhanced punishment when any weapon is used for committing dacoity by causing grievous hurt to any person and in such case an additional punishment of minimum seven years is provided therein. In the instant case, the eye-witnesses clearly deposed that all the gang members involved in dacoity were armed. In this regard we may refer to page 25 being the evidence of P.W 1, the Cashier, P.W 2 being a customer and P.W 3 being another customer who consistently stated in pages 16, 25 and 28 of the Paper Book that all of them were armed with weapons including firearms. Hence, in our view the offence committed by the appellants squarely comes with the mischief of Section 397. Now question remains whether the learned Judge was right in awarding separate sentence for the same. In the case of Gaya Bhakta (1988 Cri LJ 1576) (supra) the learned single Judge of the Orissa High Court considered similar case and held that Section 397 did not create any substantive offence and the Court should have charged the accused under Section 395 read with Section 397 of the Indian Penal Code. In the case of Kallu alias Ramkumar (1992 Cri LJ 2380) (supra), the learned single Judge of the Madhya Pradesh High Court observed in the similar way. According to the learned single Judge of Madhya Pradesh High Court, Section 397 provided for an enhanced punishment and there could be only one punishment for an offence committed under Section 395 read with Section 397 and no separate sentence was permissible. In the case of Kamal Haldar (supra), the Division Bench of our Court observed in the same way as referred to above. We fully agree with the proposition of law so canvassed by Mr. Roy on this score. The learned Judge should have enhanced the punishment by taking recourse to Section 397 instead of imposing separate sentence as there could be only one punishment under Section 395 read with Section 397 of the Indian Penal Code.

8. With regard to the other proposition that Section 395 and Section 412 could not be simultaneously invoked, our attention was drawn to the decision in the case of Dilip Malik (1991 Cri LJ 2171) (supra). The Division Bench observed, when the accused was convicted of having committed dacoity there could not be any further conviction under Section 412. In the other case being in the case of Mohan Chetri (1992 Cri LJ 2374) (supra), an other Division Bench of this Court held in the same day. In the case of Shri Phool Kumar v. Delhi Administration reported in (1975) 1 SCC 797 : All India Reporter 1975 Supreme Court 905 : (1975 Cri LJ 778) the Apex Court observed that the provision of Section 397 would apply to the offender who would use deadly weapon at the time of committing dacoity. The Apex Court considering such fact ultimately held that if an offender was armed with a deadly weapon at the time of committing robbery whether the weapon was put to any fruitful use or whether the offender succeeded in committing robbery, would be of no consequence. Once the person was armed with deadly weapon the mischief of Section 397 would automatically attaract. The Apex Court observed that the evidence against the appellant was that he carried the knife in his hand when he went to the shop of the victim, was sufficient to support the conviction. In the instant case all the persons were armed as consistently stated by the prosecution witnesses. Hence, that would attract enhanced punishment and not a separate punishment.

9. Hence, we modify the punishment to the extent that the punishment of ten years so imposed by the learned Judge should be considered a single punishment for the act committed by Ajit and Moza as well as Saidar under Section 395 read with Section 397. With regard to the offence committed under Section 412, we are of the view that no separate sentence could be passed in view of the decision in the case of Dilip (1991 Cri LJ 2171) (supra) and such conviction and sentence is set aside. Similarly the separate sentence given under Section 397 inter alia for seven years is also set aside. The imposition of fine of rupees fifty-three thousand as against all the three appellants would however remain as a single punishment of fine and in default to suffer rigorous imprisonment for one year more.

10. Learned Trial Court is directed to issue modified jail warrant in respect of the appellants in accordance with Rules.

11. Let a copy of this judgment be sent to the Superintendent, Correctional Home where the appellants are now suffering his sentence for information and necessary action.

12. Let a copy of this judgment along with Lower Court Records be sent down at once to the learned Trial Court for necessary action.

13. Appeals are disposed of accordingly. Urgent xerox certified copy will be given to the parties, if applied for.

14. Order accordingly.