- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Darshan Singh v. State Of Punjab .
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners filed a petition under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure read with Article 227 of the Constitution seeking quashing of FIR No. 43 dated May 3, 1993, registered under Sections 435/148/149 of the Indian Penal Code and all consequent proceedings. The FIR arose from a complaint by Ajmer Singh and others alleging that the petitioners set fire to their standing wheat crop on agricultural land they possessed, while being armed with deadly weapons. Following investigation, charges under Sections 435/506/148/149 IPC were framed by the Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Kharar, on July 28, 1994. The petitioners challenged the framing of charges by filing a revision petition, which was dismissed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Ropar, on December 24, 1994.
The petitioners also relied on a Civil Suit No. 347 of 1989 filed by Ajmer Singh and Sohan Singh for permanent injunction against certain respondents, which was dismissed on March 17, 1993, with the Civil Court holding that the plaintiffs were not in possession of the disputed land. The petitioners contended that this civil judgment negated the basis of the FIR and charges, as the complainants were not in possession of the land where the alleged arson occurred.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the FIR and consequent proceedings under Sections 435/148/149 IPC can be quashed on the ground that the complainants were not in possession of the land as per the civil decree.
- Whether the petitioners are entitled to invoke the High Court's inherent powers under section 482 Cr. P.C. to file a second revision against the framing of charges, despite dismissal of their earlier revision petition under section 397(3) Cr. P.C.
- The extent to which the High Court can examine the factual basis of allegations in the FIR while exercising powers under section 482 Cr. P.C.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The Civil Court's decree held that the complainants Ajmer Singh and Sohan Singh were not in possession of the disputed land, thus negating the basis for the FIR alleging arson on their crops.
- Based on the civil judgment, the charges framed under the IPC sections were wrongly instituted and should be quashed.
- The petitioners relied on the decision in Hamir Singh v. Bhag Singh to argue that the High Court's inherent powers under section 482 Cr. P.C. are not barred by section 397(3) Cr. P.C. and can be exercised even after dismissal of a revision petition by the Sessions Court.
Respondent's Arguments
- The learned Assistant Advocate-General relied on Dharma Lal v. Smt. Ram Shri to contend that section 397(3) Cr. P.C. bars a second revision petition by the same party, and thus the petitioners cannot use section 482 Cr. P.C. to circumvent this bar.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Dharma Lal v. Smt. Ram Shri, 1993 (1) RCR 696 (JT 1993 (1) SC 61) | Section 397(3) Cr. P.C. bars a second revision petition by the same party. | The Court held that inherent powers under section 482 Cr. P.C. cannot be used to circumvent the express bar in section 397(3) Cr. P.C. |
| Hamir Singh v. Bhag Singh, 1995 (2) RCR 1 | The High Court’s inherent powers under section 482 Cr. P.C. can be exercised even if revision was dismissed by the Sessions Court. | The Court acknowledged the power to interfere where the basis of the revisional court’s decision did not exist, but emphasized that this power must be exercised sparingly. |
| State of Tamil Nadu v. Thirukkural Perumal, 1995 (2) RCR 124 (JT 1995 (3) SC 166) | The High Court should not examine the genuineness of allegations or evaluate evidence collected during investigation when exercising section 482 Cr. P.C. powers. | The Court cautioned that quashing powers under section 482 Cr. P.C. should be exercised sparingly and not based on evidence not yet produced before the trial court. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the civil decree and noted that the Civil Court had held the plaintiffs Ajmer Singh and Sohan Singh to be in possession of certain Khasra numbers, though they were non-suited on other grounds. The petitioners’ claim that the complainants were not in possession of any agricultural land was found unsustainable, as the petitioners themselves admitted possession of other Khasra numbers different from those held by the complainants.
The Court considered the legal bar under section 397(3) Cr. P.C. against filing a second revision petition, as established in the Dharma Lal case, and held that the High Court's inherent powers under section 482 Cr. P.C. cannot be used to bypass this statutory bar. Although the petitioners cited Hamir Singh to argue for the exercise of inherent powers, the Court emphasized that such powers must be exercised sparingly and only where the basis of the revisional court’s decision does not exist.
Further, relying on the State of Tamil Nadu v. Thirukkural Perumal decision, the Court reiterated that it is not justified in probing the evidence or the genuineness of allegations during the stage of quashing proceedings under section 482 Cr. P.C., especially when the trial has commenced and charges have been framed.
Given that the trial had already commenced and the factual question of possession and alleged offences was to be decided by the trial court, the Court found the petition not maintainable.
Holding and Implications
The petition under section 482 Cr. P.C. for quashing the FIR and consequent proceedings is dismissed.
The decision directly affects the parties by allowing the trial to proceed on the charges framed. The Court did not set any new precedent but reaffirmed the limited scope of inherent powers under section 482 Cr. P.C., the statutory bar against second revision petitions under section 397(3) Cr. P.C., and the principle that factual disputes should be resolved at trial rather than in quashing petitions.
Dr. Sarojnei Saksena, J.:— The petitioners have filed this petition under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure read with Article 227 of the Constitution, for quashing FIR No. 43 dated May 3, 1993, under Sections 435/148/149 of the Indian Penal Code (Annexure P-1) and all consequent proceedings thereon.
2. The facts of the case are that on May 3, 1993, Ajmer Singh son of Gurmukh Singh, Jat, resident of village Fatehpur Therri, Tehsil Kharar, District Ropar and others lodged a complaint that they are in possession of agricultural land and had sown wheat crop in their fields. When the crop was ripe, the accused persons/petitioners at about 3 p.m set fire to their standing crop. At that time they were armed with deadly weapons. On the basis of this FIR Annexure P-1, offence under the aforesaid sections were registered. After concluding the investigation challan was put up before the Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Kharar. After considering the challan papers, the said Magistrate has framed charges under Sections 435/506/148/149 IPC against the accused persons/petitioners on July 28, 1994. The petitioners filed a revision petition against the said order of framing of the charges, which was dismissed by Shri V.C Rajput, Addl. Sessions Judge, Ropar, vide order dated December 24, 1994.
3. The petitioners' contention is that Civil Suit No. 347 of 1989 (instituted on September 23, 1992) is pending in the Court of Shri Harminder Singh, Subordinate Judge IInd Class, Kharar, which is filed by Ajmer Singh and Sohan Singh sons of Gurmukh Singh against Didar Singh son of Nika Singh, Gurdev Singh, Bhupinder Singh sons of Jawahar Singh, Kesar Singh, Swaran Singh and Nachhattar Singh sons of Gurmukh Singh, residents of village Fatehpur Theri, Tehsil Kharar, District Ropar, for permanent injunction. This suit was decided on March 17, 1993. Copy of the judgment is filed at Annexure 1-3. Petitioner's learned counsel contended that in this judgment the Civil Court has held that Ajmer Singh and Sohan Singh sons of Gurmukh Singh are not in possession of the disputed land. Hence, the relief of permanent injunction was declined and the suit was dismissed. On the basis of this decree of the Civil Court, the petitioners' learned counsel further contended that as the Civil Court has held that the complainant Ajmer Singh is not in possession of the disputed agricultural land, the question of setting on fire to the standing crops on the land which is alleged to be in possession of the complainant, does not arise. Hence the charges have been wrongly framed and on that basis the FIR and consequent proceedings are liable to be quashed.
4. Learned Assistant Advocate-General, Punjab relying on Dharma Lal v. Smt. Ram Shri, 1993 (1) Recent Criminal Reports 696 : JT 1993 (1) SC 61, objected that as the petitioners have already filed a criminal revision against the order of framing of the charges and it is dismissed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, they have no legal right to file a second revision in the garb of section 482 Cr. P.C which is clearly barred under section 397(3) Cr. P.C
5. To meet this contention, the petitioners' learned counsel has relied on Hamir Singh v. Bhag Singh, 1995 (2) Recent CR 1, wherein it is held that if the revision is dismissed by the Court of Session, the provisions of Section 397 Cr. P.C do not constitute or operate as a bar to exercise by the High Court of its inherent powers under section 482 Cr. P.C It further held that the High Court is justified to interfere with finding of fact recorded by the revisional court where the very basis of decision of subordinate revisional court did not exist.
6. A plain perusal of the Civil Court's decree Annexure P-3 makes it clear that plaintiffs Ajmer Singh and Sohan Singh are held to be in possession of Khasra Nos. 1811 (8-0), 12(8-0) and 13(8-0), though on a different count they were non-suited.
7. In the petition under consideration the petitioners have clearly mentioned in para No. 1 that petitioner No. 3 is in possession of land comprised in Khasra Nos. 6/16/2(4-13), 17/1(1-6), 17/2 (3-8), 18/2(6-8), 24(7-12), 25/1(6-7) and 25/2(1-5), thus. This assailment is not sustainable that as the complainant-Sohan Singh is not in possession of any agricultural land in the said village, he could not have lodged the complaint Annexure P-1 stating that he is in possession of agricultural land on which his crop is standing, to which the petitioners have set fire illegally.
8. In Dharam Pal's case (supra) the Apex Court has clearly held that section 397(3) bars a second revision petition by the same party. Inherent powers under section 482 of the Code cannot be utilised for exercising powers which are expressly barred by the Code. Even in Hamir Singh's case (supra) a single Bench of this Court has held that this power under section 482 Cr. P.C is to be exercised sparingly. In State of Tamila Nadu v. Thirukkural Perumal, 1995 (2) Recent Criminal Reports 124 : JT 1995 (3) SC 166 the Apex Court has held that the High Court is not justified in embarking upon an enquiry as to the genuineness of the allegations made in the FIR or complaint on the basis of evidence collected during investigation only while dealing with petition under section 482 Cr. P.C The Apex Court has cautioned that the High Court is not justified in evaluating such evidence which is yet to be produced before the trial Court. Such power of quashment should be exercised sparingly by the High Court.
9. In this case the charges have already been framed against the petitioners and the trial has commenced. It is a question of fact whether on May 3, 1993, complainant Ajmer Singh was in possession of agricultural land on which his crop was standing, which was flamed by the petitioners and at that time they committed the alleged other offences also under Section 506/148/149 IPC for which they are facing trial before the trial Court. In view of these facts, I found that this petition is not maintainable and is dismissed accordingly.
Alert