Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

T.V Subramania Kurukkal v. State Of Kerala And Others

Kerala High Court
Jan 2, 1986
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The Bazar U.P. School, Thathamangalam is an aided school whose petitioner-manager's family started the institution in 1907; the petitioner became manager in 1945. Around 1984 the petitioner, citing old age and financial difficulty, served Ext. P1 (dated 4-5-84) — a one year's notice of intention to close the school effective 1-6-85 — said to be given under S. 7(6) of the Kerala Education Act.

There was initially no responsive action from Government or educational authorities. On 30-5-85 the Deputy Director of Education issued Ext. P5 asking the petitioner to set aside closure proceedings pending permission. On the same date the Director of Public Instruction (D.P.I.) issued Ext. P6 rejecting the manager's request to close the school and directing that the manager continue to run it.

The petitioner filed a writ petition originally seeking quashing of Exts. P5 and P6. Subsequently, Government issued Ext. P7 — a show-cause notice under S. 14 of the Act — proposing to take over management of the school for up to five years on grounds of alleged neglect. The petitioner replied by Ext. P8. The writ petition was amended to challenge Ext. P7 as well.

The State's counter-affidavit and file materials described inquiry activity: the Assistant Educational Officer (A.E.O.) reported the manager's reasons as genuine, but the D.P.I. advised Government that closure would create problems (insufficient accommodation and staff in neighbouring schools), considered the manager's intention tantamount to negligence, and recommended takeover. The counter also states that the Headmaster (the manager’s son) did not open the school on 1-6-85, the Senior Assistant Teacher opened it on 3-6-85 under A.E.O. guidance, and that Ext. P6 was being implemented.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the statutory scheme (S. 7 of the Kerala Education Act and the Rules) required the manager of an aided school to obtain "permission" from educational authorities before closing the school, and whether Exts. P5 and P6 were validly issued on that assumption.
  2. Whether Ext. P7 — the Government's show-cause notice under S. 14(1) proposing takeover of management — satisfied the procedural and substantive requirements of S. 14(1) (in particular specification of the duties allegedly neglected, the giving of a reasonable opportunity to show cause, and consideration of any cause shown).
  3. Whether the respondents could take possession and run the school (effect a takeover) immediately after issuing a show-cause notice, without issuing a considered order after hearing and without complying with the statutory process under S. 14.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Manager's) Position

  • The petitioner asserted his entitlement to give one year's notice under S. 7(6) of the Act and proceed with closure; the statutory provision does not impose any requirement of prior "permission" from the D.P.I. or other authority to close the school.
  • The petitioner challenged Exts. P5 and P6 as premised upon an assumption of a permission requirement which the statute and valid Rules did not support.
  • The petitioner challenged Ext. P7 on grounds that it failed to specify any particular duty neglected, and therefore did not afford a reasonable opportunity to show cause as required by S. 14(1); further, no final decision was taken before actions constituting a takeover were effected.

Respondents' (State and Education Authorities') Position

  • The authorities (via the D.P.I. and Government) contended that the manager's intention to close the school would create practical difficulties: neighbouring schools lacked accommodation and staff, and the school catered to a large pupil population (including Tamil medium students).
  • The D.P.I. and others considered the manager's intention to close the school to be a form of negligence in performance of duties under the Act, and therefore the Government relied on S. 14(1) as empowering a takeover for public interest reasons.
  • The counter-affidavit described administrative steps already taken: directions by the D.P.I., representations from local public bodies urging Government action, the A.E.O.'s involvement in reopening the school on 3-6-85, and implementation of Ext. P6.
  • An affidavit by a senior departmental officer (Sri Sivasailam Iyer) asserted the educational authorities' view that on receipt of notice they are expected to inquire into reasons and satisfy themselves that closing would not adversely affect public interest, implying a duty to supervise and possibly to withhold closure where public interest required continuation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Krishna Kumar v. State of Kerala 1977 Ker LT 496 : (AIR 1973 Ker 14) Striking down R. 24(2) of Chap. V (a sub-rule introduced in 1965) on the ground that it exceeded the rule-making power conferred by the Act. The court relied on this decision to conclude that the struck-down sub-rule could not sustain any requirement of "permission" by the Director to close a school; accordingly, Exts. P5 and P6 (premised on such a permission requirement) had no statutory basis.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by examining the statutory text and the actual steps taken by the authorities, and by evaluating whether those steps complied with statutory prescription and principles of fair procedure.

  1. Construction of S. 7 and the Rules: The court observed that S. 7 requires only (i) one year's notice expiring on 31st May, (ii) delivery of records and accounts to the Department upon closure, and (iii) penal consequences for non-compliance. R. 24(1) largely reproduced S. 7(6) but a sub-rule introduced in 1965 (R.24(2)) purported to make the Director's permission necessary; that sub-rule had been struck down in Krishna Kumar as ultra vires. The court therefore found no statutory provision requiring the manager to obtain permission to close the school.
  2. On the D.P.I.'s conduct and assumptions: Exts. P5 and P6 were issued on the basis that the manager needed permission and that the D.P.I. could examine and decide the merits of the manager's reasons — including by gathering reports without affording the manager an opportunity to be heard. The court found these assumptions unsupported by statute and contrary to principles of natural justice if permission were to be treated as required.
  3. Requirements of S. 14(1): The court set out essential elements for operation of S. 14(1): (i) some material indicating neglect of duties under the Act or Rules; (ii) a reasonable opportunity to the manager to show cause against proposed takeover; and (iii) consideration by the Government of any cause shown before a decision is taken. The court emphasized that Ext. P7 failed to specify the particular duties allegedly neglected — it merely charged the manager with not conducting the school properly — and therefore could not furnish the manager with a reasonable opportunity to make an effective reply.
  4. The court rejected the contention that issuance of Ext. P1 (the notice to close) could itself be characterized as neglect of duty; the record revealed no material of failure to perform other duties. To hold that a manager's compliance with the notice requirement amounted to negligence would be absurd.
  5. On the timing and effect of the respondents' actions: The court criticized the respondents for acting as if the show-cause notice itself effected a takeover — physically administering the school and running it — without a considered Government order after hearing. The statutory scheme (including sub-sec. (4) and sub-sec. (5) procedures) contemplates a decision following consideration; a mere notice could not operatively transfer management. Thus actions taken by respondents on the basis of Exts. P5, P6 and P7 were irregular and without lawful basis.
  6. Relief fashioned: The court declared Exts. P5, P6 and P7 invalid and set aside actions taken on their basis. However, recognizing the academic year's progress, the court permitted the current (respondent-imposed) dispensation to continue until the end of the year subject to specific conditions: the A.E.O. must return the physical school property to the petitioner on 1-4-1986; the respondents must arrange, via the District Collector, for early payment of rent due under S.14(5) for the period 1-6-85 to 31-3-86; the Collector's fixation of rent remains subject to S.14(7); and the petitioner is entitled to costs.

Holding and Implications

Holding:
The petition was allowed; Exts. P5, P6 and P7 were set aside and all actions taken by the respondents on their basis were declared invalid and inoperative.

Direct consequences and directions pronounced by the court (as stated in the opinion):

  • The respondents' actions based on Exts. P5, P6 and P7 are invalid and inoperative.
  • The present administrative arrangement (respondents' running of the school) may remain in place until the end of the academic year, subject to these conditions:
    • The A.E.O. must return the school buildings, furniture and accessories to the petitioner-manager exactly on 1-4-1986.
    • Respondents must make arrangements, through the District Collector, for early payment of rent due under S. 14(5) for the period 1-6-85 to 31-3-86.
    • The fixation of rent by the Collector will be subject to sub-section (7) of S. 14 of the Act.
  • The petitioner was awarded costs against the respondents.

Broader implications: The opinion confines its pronouncements to statutory construction and procedural fairness under the Act; it does not record the creation of any novel legal precedent beyond application of the existing decision in Krishna Kumar. The court's decision directly affects the parties by nullifying the immediate administrative acts of takeover and by prescribing return of management property and payment procedures; the opinion does not purport to lay down wider principles beyond those explicitly reasoned from the statute and prior authority.

Petition allowed.
Show all summary ...

1. The Bazar U.P School, Thathamangalam is an aided school, and the petitioner is its manager. The institution was started in the year 1907 by his grandfather. He himself became manager in 1945. By about 1984 the petitioner found that because of old age and financial troubles in the family, he was no longer in a position “to run the school effectively”. On 4-5-84, therefore, he gave Ext. P1 notice of his intention to close it down from 1-6-85, as required by S. 7(6) of the Kerala Education Act. For a long time there was no response either from the Government or from the Educational authorities, despite reminders. On 30-5-85 the Dy. Director of Education, Palghat requested the petitioner, as per Ext. P5 communication, to “set aside the proceedings of closure action”, till permission from the competent authority was received. On the same date, the Director of Public Instruction also passed Ext. P6 order in the following terms:

“In the Notice read above, the Manager, Bazar U.P School, Thathamangalam has requested permission of the Director of Public Instruction to close down the said school from 1-6-1985. The reason adduced for is financial troubles. The request made by the Manager has been examined in detail. The controlling Officers and the local public including Parent Teachers Association of the School were consulted.

The school is now functioning smoothly in permanent buildings and the accommodation now available is sufficient for the class divisions now existing. There is also sufficient number of pupils to study in the school. There will be no necessity of additional finance for improving the school in the near future. The academic interest of the locality was also examined. The school has Tamil Medium classes also. The strength of pupils in the school is above 600. There are no adequate facilities in the locality to admit all these students conveniently to continue the education of these pupils.

In the circumstances, the Director of Public Instruction, Kerala does not find the reason put forth by the Manager for closing down this school as satisfactory. Considering this and also considering the educational interest of the locality, the request made by the Manager, B.U.P School, Thathamangalam is rejected. The Manager will continue to run the school. The school will continue to function as usual. The departmental Officers and Headmaster will also ensure this.”

This writ petition, as originally filed, was for quashing Exts. P. 5 and P. 6.

2. Subsequently, however, Government issued Ext. P7 notice to the petitioner asking him to show cause why the management of the school should not be taken over under S. 14 of the Act. The notice read:

“Whereas, the Government have received reports that you have neglected to perform the duties imposed by the Kerala Education Act, 1958, and the rules issued thereunder, namely, by not conducting the school properly and whereas, the Government consider that in public interest it is necessary to take over the management of the Bazar Upper Primary School, Tathamangalam in Chittur Sub District in Palghat District for a period of five years.

Now, therefore, you are hereby required to show cause within ten days in writing to the undersigned why action should not be taken for taking over management of the school for the above period.”

The petitioner furnished Ext. P. 8 reply, and it is common ground that no further orders were passed in the matter. The writ petition was subsequently amended to include a challenge to Ext. P7 also.

3. From the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the first respondent-State, and a file made available by the learned Govt. pleader, what seems to have transpired after Ext. P1 notice was this. The Asst. Educational Officer, Chittur enquired into the matter and reported to his superiors that the reasons put forward by the manager for the proposed closure were genuine. But on 25-1-85 the Director wrote to the Government that the closing down of the school would create problems. The neighbouring schools had not enough accommodation to absorb the pupils from the Bazar School; those schools were also not having enough staff. The Chairman of the Chittur Municipal Council had requested the Director to take action for taking over the management of the school. S. 14(1) of the Education Act empowered Government to do so, when the manager neglected to perform any of the duties imposed on him; and according to the D.P.I

“the intention of the manager to close down the school is itself a true act of negligence especially when there is no alternative for the education of the children and for providing the staff of the school”.

He was therefore “strongly” of the view that the management of the school should be taken over with immediate effect. It appears that one Thiruvenkatam, Convener of the “Bazar School Samrakshana Samithi” had also made a representation to the Minister for Education, to take all necessary steps to see that the school was not closed down, particularly because it was catering to the needs of Tamil medium students also. It was in this background that Ext. P. 7 notice was drawn up by the Government and issued. The other details furnished in the counter-affidavit regarding the number of pupils and teachers involved, the need to protect their interests, the non-availability of additional accommodation in neighbouring schools etc. are not important because, as will presently be seen, the question for decision is one of law — of the power of the Government and the authorities to act in the manner they have done — and not one relating to the propriety of the manager's action. But the averments in para (9) of the counter are relevant, and they are therefore extracted below:

“When the schools reopened after vacation the Headmaster of the school, who is none other than the son of the Manager, did not turn up to open the school on 1-6-1985, the date of reopening of the school during 1985-1986. However, the Senior Assistant Teacher of the school under the guidance of the Assistant Educational Officer, Chittur started the school on 3-6-1985. The school is now functioning smoothly from 3-6-1985. There is no problem — academic or otherwise facing the school at present. Ext. P 6 order of the Director of Public Instruction is being implemented.”

4. Exts. P. 5 and P. 6 communication were obviously issued under the assumption that the provisions of the Education Act and the rules required an aided school manager to obtain “permission” from the authorities to close down the school. Ext. P. 6 contained the further assumption that it was open to the D.P.I to consider the reasons put forward by a manager, find out their truth or otherwise and take a decision, after taking into account other relevant matters also. And all these, of course, on the strength of reports he could collect behind the back of the manager, and without affording him an opportunity to establish his case. These assumptions however appear to be unsupported by anything in law; and even if the D.P.I had the power to examine the merits of the manager's case and apply other objective standards in the matter of granting “permission”, that could have been done only by following fair procedure and in accordance with the principles of natural justice.

5. All that S. 7 of the Act provides is (i) that no manager shall close down his school without giving one year's notice (expiring with the 31st May of any year) of his intention so to do; (ii) that in the event of closure he shall make over all the records and accounts of the school to the Department and (iii) that violation of the above two conditions could entail conviction requiring payment of fine not exceeding two hundred rupees. R. 24(1) of Chap. V of the Rules practically reproduces the terms of S. 7(6), with the difference that the authority to whom the one-year notice is to be given is specified as the D.P.I Sub-rule (2) introduced in 1965 provided that the Director was to consider all aspects of the question and grant permission and that his order was to be final; but this sub-rule was struck down by this court in Krishna Kumar v. State of Kerala 1977 Ker LT 496 : (AIR 1973 Ker 14) on the ground that it was beyond the rule making power conferred by the Act. The respondents have not been able to draw my attention to any other statutory prescription relevant for the purpose; and evidently, the provisions of S. 7 and of R. 24(1) of Chap. V do not speak of any “permission” from any one. The only obligation of the manager is to give one year's notice of his intention to close down, so that if the authorities are so min ded, they can make other arrangements for the staff and the pupils. For the simple reason that it is inconvenient for the State, the D.P.I or the others to absorb the students and staff elsewhere, they cannot decree, without authority of law, that someone else like the manager should carry the burden for ever. ‘Public interest’ is something that should bother the public authorities more than private agencies, and they are not expected to preach what they cannot practise. Sri Sivasailam Iyer, a Senior Grade Assistant of the Education Department of the Secretariat, has stated the following, in para (5) of the counter-affidavit shown to by him on behalf of the Government:—

“A school is primarily a public institution intended to serve the educational needs of the public and not meant for the benefits of the Manager or the educational agency. Therefore the educational agency or the Manager cannot be allowed to close down the school without satisfying the Government or the authorised officer that the closing down of the school will not adversely affect public interest and the interest of the pupils and the teachers of the school. Therefore on receipt of notice from the educational agency the educational authorities are expected to enquire into the reasons stated in support of the intention to close down the school and to satisfy themselves whether the reasons stated are genuine and whether the closing down of the school will adversely affect the public interest and the interest of the students and the teachers.”

Lofty ideas indeed, but so long as they do not find their reflection in the statute or the Rules made by those whom he represents, Sri Iyer cannot expect the court to adopt and enforce them. If the establishment and administration of an aided school have anything to do with Art. 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, the manager of such a school should also have the freedom to close it down, subject of course to such reasonable restrictions as are permissible under Art. 19(6). It is also to be remembered that under Art. 30, the minorities have also some special rights in the matter of establishing and administering educational institutions, as appears to have been recognised under S. 14(9) itself. The validity of R. 24(2) of Chap. V was open to doubt for reasons other than those urged or considered in Krishna Kumar's case; but it is enough to say that as it has been struck down by this Court, whatever be the reason, no question of “permission” as required by Exts. P 5 and P 6 could have arisen.

6. Section 14(1) of the Education Act, in purported exercise of power under which Ext. P7 notice was issued to the petitioner, reads:

(1) Whenever it appears to the Government that the manager of any aided school has neglected to perform any of the duties imposed by or under this Act or the rules made thereunder, and that in the public interest it is necessary to take over the management of the school for a period not exceeding five years, they may, after giving the manager and the educational agency, if any, a reasonable opportunity for showing cause against the proposed action and after considering the cause, if any, shown, do so, if satisfied that such taking over for the period is necessary in the public interest.”

It is clear that for the above provisions to operate, the following conditions, among others, should be satisfied:—

(i) there should be something to suggest that the manager has neglected to perform any of his duties under the Act or the Rules;

(ii) he should be given a reasonable opportunity to show cause against the proposed take over;

(iii) the cause, when shown, should be considered by the Government before the final decision is taken.

Now, what is the duty (or what are the duties) under the Act or rules which the manager in this case has neglected to perform? Ext. P7 does not refer specifically to any single duty of that kind, it simply accuses the manager of having not properly conducted the school. When? In what manner or in what respect? It seems to me that some kind of specification of the duties neglected to be performed by a manager, apart from a vague accusation of not properly conducting the school, is a minimum requirement of a show-cause notice under S. 14(1). Without such a specification, the manager will not get a reasonable opportunity of showing cause against the proposal. On this ground alone, I should say that Ext. P7 cannot be treated as a valid notice under S. 14(1).

7. Again, if one reads Ext. P7 along with the Director's recommendations to the Government (in his letter dt. 25-1-85), the duty neglected to be performed by the petitioner in this case was one and one only: the issue of Ext. P1 notice under S. 7(6). There was no material before Government regarding failure of any other duty; and it will be absurd to hold that issue of a notice as enjoined by the statute itself amounted to neglect of duty thereunder.

8. What is more startling than all the above is the conduct of the respondents in actually taking over the school immediately after issue of the show-cause notice, and without anything more. Section 14(1) postulates consideration of the objections preferred by a manager and the taking of a decision thereon by the Government. Sub-sec. (4), if not sub-sec. (1) itself, suggests that some kind of Government order is necessary in that connection, and that a mere notice to show cause cannot itself operate as takeover. Under sub-sec. (5), the Collector has to fix the rent payable to the owner of the school, and the owner has a right of appeal to the District Court. It is not as if the Government or its officers can invade the premises of an aided school, drive out its owner or manager, take over its administration and start running it “smoothly”, as claimed in para (9) of the counter, under cover of a communication like Ext. P-6 or a notice like Ext. P-7. The taking of a decision after a consideration of the manager's objection to the proposal, and communication of such a decision to him were absolutely indispensable, if at all Ext. P7 was a proper notice and a valid take-over could be thought of on its basis. “There is no problem — academic or otherwise……………”: claims the counter-affidavit with smug satisfaction: If the State Government believes that its educational problems are solved by the D.P.I passing some unauthorised orders and the Asst. Educational Officers trying to enforce them by presenting themselves at the doors of aided schools on the reopening day to give “guidance”, it is their look out; but how can they assert that the legal problems involved, and staring at their face in a writ petition pending before the High Court, also get resolved by such methods?

9. I therefore set aside Exts. P-5, P-6 and P-7 and declare that all actions taken by the respondents on their basis are invalid and inoperative. However, since the academic year has already entered the last term, I think it will be proper to accede to the request of the Government Pleader to permit the present dispensation to continue till the end of the year, but on condition that the A.E.O returns the school — the buildings, furniture, accessories etc. — to the petitioner-manager precisely and without fail on the 1st Apr., 1986 and arrangements are also made, by the respondents, through the District Collector, for early payment of rent due under S. 14(5) for the period from 1-6-85 to 31-3-86. It is needless to add that the fixation of rent by the Collector will be subject to sub-sec. (7) of S. 14 of the Act. The petitioner will also be entitled to get his costs from the respondents.

Petition allowed.