- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chief Engineer,Betwa... v. Central Government I...
Factual and Procedural Background
This writ petition challenges an award dated 15-7-1996 issued by respondent No. 1 (the Central Government Industrial Tribunal) in 41 industrial disputes (Industrial dispute Nos. 1–32, 38, 39, 46, 48, 54–57 of 1990 and 113 of 1993). All employees concerned were daily rated workers (daily wagers). The Central Government, Ministry of Labour, by notification dated 1-1-1990, referred the question whether the demand of the union to regularize certain workmen of Betwa River Board (Rajghat Dam, Jhansi) with retrospective effect was justified and, if so, what relief was due.
In total 41 references were registered before the Presiding Officer, Central Government Industrial Tribunal, Kanpur; several employees were involved in each reference and the total number of employees mentioned in the notifications was 606. The Tribunal found that these workers had been engaged for the purpose of construction of the dam (i.e., for construction work), held that they had worked continuously for about 15–16 years (employed between 1978 and 1986), and concluded that the workmen had made out a case for regularization. The Tribunal directed the management to prepare a seniority list and take steps for regularization within one year of publication of the award (or else the workmen would be deemed regularized after one year), but held they were not entitled to be regularized from the date of their appointments and that regularization would not make them entitled to wages and other facilities at par with similarly placed Central Government employees.
The Tribunal mainly relied on State of Haryana v. Piara Singh (1992). Subsequent to that award, the Supreme Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi (Constitution Bench, AIR 2006 SC 1806) overruled the authority relied upon by the Tribunal. A related earlier writ (Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 4442 of 1997) concerning other work-charged employees of the same Board became infructuous after the Board regularized those employees and was dismissed on 21-8-2006.
No stay was granted in this writ petition. The parties agreed that of the 606 daily wagers initially referenced, about 475 were at that time still working (the rest had died or retired). Counsel for the petitioners stated the project was completed in October 2005 and only maintenance work remained.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Tribunal's direction to regularize the daily-rated workers (daily wagers) pursuant to its award of 15-7-1996 is legally sustainable in light of the Constitution Bench decision in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi.
- Whether the Betwa River Board's functions in constructing and operating the Rajghat Dam are sovereign functions exempting it from the jurisdiction of industrial adjudicatory bodies (i.e., whether the Board is an "industry" amenable to Labour Court/Industrial Tribunal jurisdiction).
- If regularization cannot be sustained, what interim protections and remedies (including retrenchment compensation under Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act and any additional monetary relief) should be afforded to affected workmen who have worked for ten years or more.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner (Betwa River Board / Management) — Primary Arguments
- Before the Labour Court and in this writ petition, the petitioner argued that it was discharging a sovereign function and therefore not an "industry" amenable to the jurisdiction of the Labour Court. (The court records the argument and rejects it in light of precedent.)
- Counsel for the petitioner also stated that in compliance with the Labour Court award the Board retained and paid the concerned employees (those not beyond superannuation) though their services were no longer required given the reduced volume of work after project completion; counsel asserted that work normally done by one employee was being distributed among several (an assertion denied by employee counsel).
- Petitioner's counsel noted the project was completed in October 2005 and only maintenance work remained.
Respondent / Employees — Primary Contentions
- The employees contended that they had been working continuously from their respective dates of appointment and were performing work of a permanent nature; they sought regularization (in some instances retrospectively from the date of appointment).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State of Haryana v. Piara Singh, 1992 (4) SCC 118 | The Tribunal had relied upon this authority in support of its direction for regularization. | The court observed that the Tribunal mainly based its award on this case, but noted that this authority has been overruled by the Constitution Bench decision in Uma Devi and therefore the Tribunal's reliance on it undermines the award's sustainability. |
| Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi (Constitution Bench), AIR 2006 SC 1806 | Clarified that certain irregular (but not illegal) appointments of duly qualified persons in duly sanctioned vacant posts who have worked for ten years or more may be regularized as a one-time measure; also reconsidered earlier authorities on project-based temporary employment. | The court treated Uma Devi as the controlling authority: it held the Tribunal's blanket direction of regularization cannot be sustained but applied paragraph 53 of Uma Devi to direct the Betwa River Board to consider one-time regularization of persons who meet the Uma Devi criteria, subject to seniority and availability of work. |
| Director, Institute Of Management Development, U.P v. Pushpa Srivastava, 1992 (4) SCC 33 | One of the cases discussed in Uma Devi concerning project-related temporary engagement: if engagement was for a particular project, on completion temporary workers cannot claim continuation. | Cited by the court (via Uma Devi's analysis) as part of the principle that temporary/project-specific engagement does not confer a right to continue after project completion. |
| Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad v. A.K. Misra, AIR 1994 SC 1638 | Discussed in Uma Devi as authority supporting the proposition that project-engaged temporary employees cannot claim continuation after project completion. | Used (through Uma Devi) to support the proposition that engagement for a particular project ordinarily ends with project completion and cannot automatically be converted into a permanent right. |
| State of Himachal Pradesh v. Suresh Kumar Verma, AIR 1996 SC 1565 | Caution that judicial directions to re-engage project employees or appoint them against vacancies could make the judicial process operate as a mode of recruitment outside established rules. | Referred to (via Uma Devi) as a cautionary precedent; the court treated it as part of the authorities justifying careful application of regularization principles rather than wholesale judicial appointments. |
| M.P. Housing Board v. M. Srivastava, 2006 (2) SCC 702 | Held that daily wagers hold no post. | Cited by the court to support the principle that daily wagers do not occupy a formal post, relevant to the analysis of entitlement to regularization. |
| M.L. Jain v. Indore Development Authority, 2005 (1) SCC 693 | Held that daily wagers do not hold a post. | Relied upon by the court (along with other authorities) to reinforce that daily wagers do not hold defined posts for purposes of automatic regularization. |
| M.P. State Agro Industrial Development Corporation v. S.C. Pandey, 2006 (2) SCC 716 | Held that daily wagers hold no post; also cited as applying Section 25-F to daily wagers in certain contexts. | Used by the court both to support the "no post" principle and (where cited later) as part of authorities showing Section 25-F applies to retrenchment of daily wagers. |
| Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. R. Rajappa, AIR 1978 SC 548 | Clarifies that only strictly "sovereign functions" (narrowly understood) qualify for exemption from being an "industry"; welfare or economic activities of government/statutory bodies are not exempt. | The court relied on this leading authority to reject the petitioner's claim that the Betwa River Board's functions are sovereign and therefore outside industrial jurisdiction. |
| General Manager Telecom v. S.C. Rao, AIR 1998 SC 656 | Overruled contrary Division Bench decisions regarding whether departments are "industry" and quoted Bangalore Water Works to the effect that only strictly sovereign functions qualify for exemption. | The court cited this decision to support the proposition that welfare/commercial activities (such as generation of power) are not sovereign functions exempting the Board from labour jurisdiction. |
| Agricultural Produce Market Committee v. Ashok Hariauni, AIR 2000 SC 3116 | Referenced in relation to whether certain activities are commercial and not sovereign. | Used by the court to note that generation of power is a commercial activity, supporting the conclusion that the Board is not discharging a sovereign function that would exclude it from industrial adjudication. |
| State Of Mysore v. S.V. Narayanappa, (1967) 1 SCR 128 : AIR 1967 SC 1071 | One of the authorities referred to in Uma Devi concerning irregular (but not illegal) appointments of duly qualified persons in sanctioned posts. | Through Uma Devi the court indicated that such authorities provide principles governing one-time regularization of irregular appointees who have worked ten years or more; the court directed the Board to consider regularization in light of those principles. |
| R.N. Nanjundappa v. T. Thimmiah, (1972) 1 SCC 409 : (1972) 2 SCR 799 | Referenced in Uma Devi in the context of irregular appointments that may merit regularization on merits. | Invoked via Uma Devi as part of the jurisprudential basis for one-time regularization where appropriate. |
| B.N. Nagarajan v. State of Karnataka, (1979) 4 SCC 507 : 1980 SCC (L&S) 4 | Referenced in Uma Devi on the subject of irregular appointments and consideration for regularization. | Applied by the court (through Uma Devi) to justify that the Board must consider regularization of appropriately qualified irregular appointees who have worked 10+ years. |
| S.F. Products v. LIC, AIR 1996 SC 2410 | Holds that High Courts exercising Article 226 can take cognizance of facts and pass appropriate orders to give complete and substantial justice; extraordinary jurisdiction guided by natural justice and equity. | The court invoked this authority to justify issuing equitable directions (such as the extra Rs.10,000 payment and bar on retrenchment until decision) even though those directions were not strictly necessary for disposal of the writ petition. |
| U.P. State Brassware Corp. v. U.N. Pandey, 2006 (1) SCC 479 | Explains the purpose of the Industrial Disputes Act and that industrial adjudication should aim at substantive justice rather than mechanical application of statutes. | Cited to support the court's view that industrial adjudicators and writ courts should aim at justice and equitable outcomes; used to justify discretionary equitable directions issued by the High Court. |
| LIC of India v. D.J. Bahadur, (1981) 1 SCC 315 | Cited within U.P. State Brassware to explain the purpose of the Industrial Disputes Act in preventing industrial tensions and ensuring industrial justice. | Referred to via Brassware as illustrative of the industrial law's remedial and protective purpose; used to justify equitable reliefs. |
| G.M. Haryana Roadways v. Rudhan Singh, 2005 SCC (L&S) 716 : 2005 (1) LBESR 42 (SC) | Holds that Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act is attracted even in the case of retrenchment of daily wagers. | Cited by the court to require that retrenchment compensation under Section 25-F be paid to retrenched daily wagers, if any are retrenched following the Board's decision. |
| Dhampur Sugar Mills Ltd. v. Bhola Singh, 2005 (2) SCC 470 | Another authority holding that Section 25-F applies to daily wagers upon retrenchment. | Cited to support the requirement that retrenchment compensation under Section 25-F be paid to any retrenched daily wagers. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in a stepwise manner:
- It summarized the Tribunal's findings: that the concerned daily-rated workers were employed for construction of the dam, had worked continuously for many years (15–16 years), and that the Tribunal had directed their regularization with specified limitations (not from the date of appointment and without entitlement to parity with Central Government employees).
- The court noted the Tribunal had relied principally on State of Haryana v. Piara Singh. However, the court observed that Piara Singh has been overruled by the Constitution Bench decision in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi (AIR 2006 SC 1806). Because Uma Devi is now the controlling authority, the Tribunal's reliance on Piara Singh undermined the Tribunal's direction for broad regularization.
- The court reviewed the line of authorities (some discussed in Uma Devi) establishing that where engagement is for a particular project, temporary employees engaged for the project do not, upon its completion, have an automatic right to continue in service or to be regularized. The court referenced the triplet of cases discussed in Uma Devi (Pushpa Srivastava; A.K. Misra; Suresh Kumar Verma) that support this position and the caution against using judicial directions as an alternate recruitment method.
- The court also examined the petitioner's contention that the Board discharged a sovereign function and thus lay outside industrial jurisdiction. Relying on Bangalore Water Supply v. Rajappa and General Manager Telecom v. S.C. Rao, the court rejected that contention: only strictly sovereign functions qualify for exemption, and activities such as generation of power are commercial/welfare/economic activities, not sovereign acts exempting the Board from labour jurisdiction. The court cited Agricultural Produce Market Committee v. Ashok Hariauni to underscore that generation of power is a commercial activity.
-
Applying Uma Devi (particularly paragraph 53), the court directed that the Betwa River Board must consider whether some affected workmen qualify for one-time regularization under the principles laid down in Uma Devi. The court specified two basic criteria that must be applied:
- The principle of seniority must be strictly followed; seniority is to be counted from the date of joining (and regularization should favor the most senior employees).
- The Board must ascertain whether the type of work performed by a particular workman still exists in the Board—i.e., whether the work continues in connection with maintenance of the dam or generation/maintenance of the power house and allied continuous work.
- The court imposed interim protective measures: until the Board passes its reasoned order, no affected workman who is still working shall be retrenched. If, after the Board's decision, some workmen are to be retrenched, they shall be paid retrenchment compensation in accordance with Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act. The court supported the applicability of Section 25-F to daily wagers by reference to G.M. Haryana Roadways v. Rudhan Singh, Dhampur Sugar Mills Ltd. v. Bhola Singh, and M.P. State Agro Industrial Development Corporation v. S.C. Pandey.
- In addition to statutory retrenchment compensation, the court directed that each retrenched employee be given an extra Rs. 10,000, payable by bank draft along with the termination order; technical arguments about timing of payment would be disallowed and non-payment would attract interest at 2% per month. The court clarified that in case of non-payment the workman would be entitled to recovery as per the Industrial Disputes Act.
- The court acknowledged that the equitable directions (non-retrenchment until decision, extra Rs. 10,000, interest provision) were not strictly necessary to dispose of the writ petition but were issued to effect complete justice between the parties, invoking the High Court's discretionary Article 226 jurisdiction and relevant authorities (S.F. Products v. LIC and U.P. State Brassware Corp. v. U.N. Pandey) emphasizing substantive justice in industrial adjudication.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition was DISPOSED OF (the court concluded its order by disposing of the writ petition and directing accordingly).
Core legal conclusions and immediate consequences:
- The Tribunal's blanket direction for regularization as recorded in the impugned award cannot be sustained insofar as it relied on an authority (Piara Singh) subsequently overruled by the Constitution Bench in Uma Devi.
- However, pursuant to paragraph 53 of Uma Devi, the Betwa River Board (the petitioner) is directed to examine, on merits and with a reasoned order, whether some of the affected workmen who had worked for ten years or more are eligible for one-time regularization. In doing so the Board must (a) strictly follow the principle of seniority (counted from date of joining) when selecting employees for regularization, and (b) ascertain whether the type of work a workman performed continues to be required by the Board (maintenance/generation work etc.).
- Until the Board passes the reasoned order, no affected workman still in service shall be retrenched.
- If, after the Board's decision, any workmen are retrenched, retrenchment compensation under Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act shall be paid to them (the court cited authorities holding Section 25-F applies to daily wagers). Additionally, each retrenched employee shall receive an extra Rs. 10,000, payable by bank draft along with the termination order; non-payment will attract 2% per month interest and recovery will be as per the Industrial Disputes Act.
- The court framed those additional equitable measures to ensure complete and substantial justice between the parties while applying the principles in Uma Devi and related authorities.
Broader precedent: The court applied and followed the Constitution Bench decision in Uma Devi and other settled authorities; it did not purport to lay down a new precedent but applied existing Supreme Court jurisprudence to the facts of this case and issued consequential directions to effectuate justice between the parties.
S.U. Khan, J.-
This writ petition is directed against the award dated 15-7-1996 given by respondent No. 1 in the following industrial disputes : Industrial dispute Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 38, 39, 46, 48, 54, 55, 56, 57 of 1990 and 113 of 1993 (total No. 41). All the employees who raised the aforesaid disputes were daily rated workers (daily wagers).
2. Central Government, Ministry of Labour, New Delhi through its notification dated 1-1-1990 referred the following dispute to the Labour Court :
“Whether the demand of union to regularize the workmen (named below) of Betwa River Board, Rajghat Dam, Nandanpura, Jhansi against the post on which they are working with retrospective effect from the date of their appointment is justified? If yes, to what relief the concerned workman are entitled.”
3. In all 41 notifications were issued and the above mentioned 41 industrial disputes were registered before Presiding Officer, Central Government Industrial Tribunal, Kanpur. In every reference several employees were involved. Total number of employees was 606. The details of notification numbers and names of employees mentioned in each of the notification are given in the award, copy of which is Annexure-1 to the writ petition. The employees contended that they were working from the dates of their appointments continuously and were doing work of permanent nature. Date of appointment of each employee was different.
The Central Government Industrial Tribunal held that :
“These workers were employed for the purposes of construction of dam.”
Immediately before the said finding it was held that :
“Thus, these daily rated workers were engaged for the purpose of construction of dam only and not by Betwa River Board.”
The Tribunal also held that :
“There is no dispute that at present these concerned workmen have continuously worked for 15 to 16 years (They were employed in between 1978 to 1986). I was also informed by the management that it would take five or more years for completion of project.”
In penultimate para (para-33) tribunal held as follows :
“In my opinion from the above analysis of facts it becomes clear that after meeting out objections of the opposite party management the concerned workmen have made out a case for regularization. This regularization will serve them as an umbrella to protect them from the policy of hire and fire and of course they will be entitled for wages and other facilities at par to those of other Central Government servants similarly placed.”
In the last para it was held that :
“The concerned workmen are not entitled for regularization from the date of their respective appointments. In view of above my award is that the opposite party management shall prepare a list of seniority of the concerned workmen and shall take steps for their regularization within one year from the date of publication of this award or otherwise these concerned workmen will be deemed to be regularized after one year from the date of publication of award By regularization they shall not be deemed to be entitled to equal, wages and other facilities at par to those of Central Government employees placed in similar circumstances.”
4. The Tribunal mainly based its award upon the authority of the Supreme Court State of Haryana v. Piara Singh, 1992 (4) SCC 118. The said authority has now been over ruled by a Constitution Bench authority of the Supreme Court Secretary State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi, (3), 2006(3) LBESR 260 (SC) : AIR 2006 SC 1806.
5. At this stage it may be mentioned that similar references were made in respect of several work charge employees of the same Board, i.e., Betwa River Board and similar directions as given, in the instant case were also given by the Tribunal in respect of those work charged employees. The said award was challenged through Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 4442 of 1997. However, meanwhile, the Board regularized their services hence the said writ petition according to learned Counsel for both the parties became infructuous and was dismissed as such on 21-8-2006.
6. It may be mentioned that in this writ petition no stay order was granted. Learned Counsel for the petitioner has stated that in compliance of order of the Labour Court all the concerned employees (apart from those who have crossed the age of superannuation) are being retained and paid salary in accordance with the award even though services of all of them are no more required by the Board keeping in view the volume of the work learned Counsel has further stated that the position is that the work which may normally be discharged by one employee is being distributed to 4 or 5 employees (of course learned Counsel for employees has denied this assertion). During arguments learned Counsel for both the parties have agreed that out of total 606 daily wagers in respect of whom references were made at present only about 475 are working and rest have either died or retired. Learned Counsel for the petitioners has also argued that the project was completed in October, 2005 and now only the maintenance work remains.
7. Parliament enacted Betwa River Board Act, 1976 to provide for the establishment of Board for creation of Reservoir at Rajghat by construction, on behalf of the Government of Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh, a dam on the Betwa river at Rajghat and for the regulation of such reservoir. Through Section 4 of the said Act it was directed that there shall be established for the purposes of the said Act a Board to be called Betwa River Board. Accordingly, the Board was established. Under Section 10 functions of the Board were provided which include carrying out of surveys and investigations in the Betwa Inter-State river valley and prepare a comprehensive project for the construction of Rajghat Dam and appurtenant work and for the generation of power and to construct the said dam and power house and a common carrier from the dam to irrigate areas in Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh and perform any other function which is supplemental, incidental and consequential to all or any other functions specified under clause 8(e) of the said Section. Under Section 12 it was further provided that Board shall have the power to do anything, which may be necessary or expedient for the purpose of carrying out function and its work. It was provided under Section 11 that the entire expenditure incurred by the Board in discharge of its function shall be shared by Governments of Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh. Under Section 13 it was provided that a fund known by the name of Betwa River Board fund shall be constituted for meeting out the salaries of officers and other employees and for other expenditure.
8. There cannot be any doubt that for constructing a dam or any other project much more people are required than for maintaining it after its construction is complete. In paragraphs 28, 29 and 30 of the aforesaid Constitution Bench authority of Uma Devi the Supreme Court has discussed three of its earlier cases pertaining to employees of the projects. The first one is Director, Director, Director, Institute Of Management Development, U.P v. Pushpa Srivastava (Smt).)., 1992 (4) SCC 33. The other is Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad v. A.K. Misra, AIR 1994 SC 1638. In the said authority. It was held that if the engagement was made in connection with particular project, on completion of project those who were temporarily engaged in the project could not claim any right to continue in service. The third case is State of Himachal Pradesh v. Suresh Kumar Verma, AIR 1996 SC 1565. In the said case the Supreme Court cautioned that if directions are given to re-engage the employees engaged for a particular work in any other work or appointing them against existing vacancies “the judicial process, would become another mode of recruitment dehors the rules.”
9. In the following authorities it has been held that daily wagers hold no post :
(1) M.P. Housing Board v. M. Srivastava, 2006(2) SCC 702,
(2) M.L. Jain v. Indore Development Authority, 2005 (1) SCC 693, and
(3) M.P. State Agro Industrial Development Corporation v. S.C. Pandey, 2006 (2) SCC 716.
10. Several other authorities were also cited by learned Counsel for both the parties. However, in view of Constitution Bench authority of Uma, Devi I do not consider it necessary to mention those authorities in detail.
11. In view of the above authorities particularly the Constitution Bench authority of Uma Devi the direction of regularization given by the impugned award cannot be sustained.
12. Before the Labour Court it was argued on behalf of the petitioner that petitioner is discharging sovereign function hence it is not Industry and therefore, not amenable to the jurisdiction of the Labour Court. The same argument has also been raised in this writ petition. The argument is not tenable in view of leading authority of the Supreme Court Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. R. Rajappa, AIR 1978 SC 548. In 1996 and 1997 two Division Benches of the Supreme Court consisting of two Hon'ble Judges in each case had taken a contrary view and had held that Telephone department is not an Industry. The decisions were overruled by the Supreme Court in General Manager Telecom v. S.C. Rao, AIR 1998 SC 656. Supreme Court quoted para 143 of Bangalore Water Works authority Para 143 (b) of the said authority is to the following effect :
“Notwithstanding the previous clauses, sovereign functions strictly understood, (alone) qualify for exemption, not the welfare activities or economic adventures undertaken by Government or statutory bodies. “
13. In this regard reference may also be made to Agricultural Produce Market Committee v. Ashok Hariauni, AIR 2000 SC 3116. In the instant case generation of power is one of the important functions of the petitioner Board. Generation of power is naturally a commercial activity hence it cannot be said that petitioner Board is discharging sovereign function and is not an Industry.
14. At this juncture it is essential to quote paragraph 53 of the Constitution Bench authority of the Supreme Court Secretary State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi, (supra).
“One aspect needs to be clarified. There may be cases where irregular appointments (not illegal appointments) as explained in State Of Mysore v. S.V Narayanappa, (1967) 1 SCR 128 : AIR 1967 SC 1071; R.N. Nanjundappa v. T. Thimmiah, (1972)1 SCC 409 : (1972) 2 SCR 799 and B.N. Nagarajan v. State of Karnataka, (1979) 4 SCC 507 : 1980 SCC (L&S) 4 : (1979) 3 SCR 937 and referred to in para 15 above, of duly qualified persons in duly sanctioned vacant posts might have been made and the employees have continued to work for ten years or more but without the intervention of orders of the Courts or of tribunals. The question of regularization of the services of such employees may have to be considered on merits in the light of the principles settled by this Court in the cases above referred to and in the light of this judgment. In that context, the Union of India, the State Governments and their instrumentalities should take steps to regularize as a one-time measure, the services of such irregularly appointed, who have worked for ten years or more in duly sanctioned posts but not under cover of orders of the Courts or of tribunals and should further ensure that regular recruitments are undertaken to fill those vacant sanctioned posts that require to be filled up, in cases where temporary employees or daily wagers are being now employed. The process must be set in motion within six months from this date. We also clarify that regularization, if any already made, but not subjudice, need not be reopened based on this judgment, but there should be no further bypassing of the constitutional requirement and regularizing or making permanent, those not duly appointed as per the constitutional scheme.”
15. In the aforesaid paragraph it was directed that instrumentalities of Union of India and State Governments which term clearly includes “Betwa River Board” shall take steps to regularize as a one time measure the services of those irregularly (but not illegally) appointed who have worked for 10 or more years. In the instant case all the workmen had worked for more than 10 years when the award was given. In the light of the aforesaid judgment of the Supreme Court the petitioner shall decide as to whether some of the affected workmen are entitled to be regularized or not. In this regard among others the following two basic things must be kept in mind :
(1) Principle of seniority must strictly be followed and senior most employees (seniority to be counted from the date of joining) shall be regularized. This will be in consonance with Section 25-G of industrial disputes act.
(2) It must be ascertained as to whether the type of work which a particular workmen was doing is still available with the Board in respect of maintenance of the dam or any other function which is continuously to be performed by the Board in respect of the maintenance of dam and allied work and for the generation of power and maintenance of the power house.
A reasoned order in this regard must be passed as early as possible.
16. Until passing of the aforesaid order no workmen affected by the impugned award who is still working shall be retrenched. If after taking decision regarding regularization of workmen affected by the impugned award some workmen are to be retrenched then retrenchment compensation in accordance with Section 25-F of industrial disputes act shall be given to them. It has been held by the Supreme Court in the following authorities that Section 25-F is attracted even in the case of retrenchment of daily wagers :
(1) G.M. Haryana Roadways v. Rudhan Singh, 2005(1) LBESR 42 (SC) : 2005 SCC (L&S) 716,
(2) Dhampur Sugar Mills Ltd. v. Bhola Singh, 2005(2) LBESR 928 (SC) : 2005 (2) SCC 470,
(3) M.P.S. Agro Development Corpn. v. S.C. Pandey, 2006 (2) SCC 716.
17. Apart from the retrenchment compensation as aforesaid each retrenched employee shall also be given Rs. 10,000 extra. These amounts shall be paid though bank drafts drawn in favour of each concerned employee, alongwith termination order. However, in this regard technicalities of prior, simultaneous or subsequent payment or payment being condition precedent etc. shall not be permitted to be raised. Non payment will entail 2% per month interest. In case of non payment workman concerned will be entitled only to recovery of the amount due in accordance with the provisions of industrial disputes act.
18. The above directions in respect of bar of retrenchment until decision by the Board and in respect of payment of compensation and Rs. 10,000/-extra are not necessary for the disposal of this writ petition. However, these directions are being issued in order to do complete justice between the parties. Writ Court while deciding a case, apart from legalities is also to be guided by equity. The Supreme Court in S.F. Products v. LIC, AIR 1996 SC 2410, has held in para 11 as follows :
“It is well settled that the High Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under article 226 of the constitution of india can take cognizance of the entire facts and circumstances of the case and pass appropriate orders to give the parties complete and substantial justice. This jurisdiction of the High Court being, extra ordinary is normally exercisable keeping in mind the principles of natural justice to promote honesty and fair play.”
19. In this regard reference may also be made to the Supreme Court authority U.P. State Brassware Corp. v. U.N. Pandey, 2006(1) LBESR 348 (SC) : 2006 (1) SCC 479, wherein it has been held in paras 40 and 41 as follows :
Para-40. The industrial disputes act was principally established for the purpose of pre-empting industrial tensions, providing the mechanics of dispute resolutions and setting up the necessary infrastructure so that the energies of partners in production may not be dissipated in counter-productive battles and assurance of industrial justice may create a climate of goodwill. See LIC of India v. D.J. Bahadur, (1981)1 SCC 315 : 1981 SCC (L&S) 111.
Para 41. The Industrial Courts while adjudicating on disputes between the management and the workmen, therefore, must take such decisions which would be in consonance with the purpose the law seeks to achieve. When justice is the buzzword in the matter of adjudication under the industrial disputes act, it would be wholly improper on the part of the superior Courts to make them apply the cold letter of the statutes to act mechanically Rendition of justice would bring within its purview giving a person what is due to him and not what can be given to him in law.
Writ petition is accordingly disposed of.
Ordered accordingly.
Alert