- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mahendra Singh Bhadauria v. State Of M.P And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 227 challenging the appellate order dated 7 January 2008, which affirmed the District Magistrate's order dated 31 July 2007. [1]
The petitioner held arms licence no. 644/88 for personal safety. On 10 July 2007, police stopped his vehicle and, during a search, found that he was carrying cartridges exceeding the permissible limit of 30 rounds. A criminal case was registered under Sections 20, 25, 27 and 30 of the Arms Act, 1959. On the police recommendation, the District Magistrate suspended the licence until finalisation of the criminal case. [2]
The petitioner's appeal under Section 18 of the Arms Act, 1959 was dismissed by the Commissioner, Gwalior, on 7 January 2008 because the criminal case was pending and the petitioner had been found in possession of 30 rounds. [3]
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the authorities could suspend the petitioner's arms licence merely because a criminal case under the Arms Act was pending against him. [4]
- Whether the District Magistrate's suspension order and the appellate order should be set aside. [5]
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The licence had been suspended for a petty offence, without a valid ground, and the petitioner was neither accused of a serious crime nor a hardened criminal. [6]
- The petitioner relied on amrik chand saluja vs. State of m. P. and ganesh chandra bhatt vs. District magistrate, almora and others. [7]
- The petitioner further relied on the decision in surya pal singh vs. State of m. P. And others, which held that cancellation of an arms licence merely on the ground of pendency of a criminal case was erroneous. [8][9]
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| amrik chand saluja vs. State of m. P. , 1990 mplj 601 | Relied upon in support of the contention that suspension of an arms licence requires a valid basis beyond a petty offence. [7] | The judgment records the petitioner's reliance on this decision but does not separately analyse it. [7] |
| ganesh chandra bhatt vs. District magistrate, almora and others, air 1993 allahabad 291 | An arms licence should not be impounded, cancelled, or refused merely because of involvement in petty crimes; stronger circumstances such as accusation of a serious crime or being a hardened criminal were identified. [7][10] | The principle was adopted through the Court's reliance on surya pal singh. [9][4] |
| surya pal singh vs. State of m. P. And others | Pendency of a criminal case, without actual use of the arm, was held insufficient to justify cancellation of an arms licence. [9][11] | The Court applied this reasoning to hold that suspension based on the pending Arms Act case was erroneous. [4][5] |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court noted that the petitioner was prosecuted under the Arms Act after being found in possession of 30 rounds during a police search. [4]
It relied on the earlier decision in surya pal singh, which treated suspension or cancellation of an arms licence merely because of a pending criminal case as erroneous where the circumstances did not establish the kind of serious criminality contemplated by the cited principle. [9][10][11]
Applying that reasoning, the Court held that the authorities had erred in suspending the licence solely on the ground of pendency of the criminal case. [4]
Holding and Implications
The petition was allowed, and the order suspending the petitioner's arms licence together with the appellate order dated 7 January 2008 was set aside. [5][12]
The direct effect was restoration of the petitioner's arms licence, with no order as to costs. The decision applied the principle stated in the cited authorities and did not set out a broader new precedent. [12]
(1) Heard. The petitioner in this writ petition under article 227 of the constitution of india is challenging the order dated 7 - 1 - 2008 passed by the appellate authority, whereby the learned appellate authority affirmed the order of the district magistrate dated 31 - 7 - 2007 passed in case no. Q/rdm/no. 5/83/2007.
(2) It is not in dispute that armed licence bearing no. 644/88 for personal safety has been granted to the petitioner. On 10 - 7 - 2007, the petitioner was going to his relation from gwalior to morena, near police station purani chhawani, gwalior, his vehicle was stopped and during search he was asked to produce his arms licence to the police person. He produced his arms licence to the police person. During checking it was found that more than the permissible limits of cartridges (30 rounds) was being carried by the petitioner and therefore a case was registered against the petitioner, by the respondent no. 3 vide crime no. 513/07 under sections 20, 25, 27 and 30 of the arms act, 1959 and the incident was also informed to the respondent no. 2 and the respondent no. 2 in turn intimated the same to the district magistrate, gwalior, vide letter dated 23 - 7 - 2007 and recommended to cancel the licence of the petitioner. The district magistrate after receiving the letter from the respondent no. 2 suspended the licence vide order dated 31 - 7 - 2007 with immediate effect till the finalization of the case registered against the petitioner by the police station, gwalior vide crime no. 513/07.
(3) The petitioner challenged the said action by filing an appeal before the commissioner, gwalior, under section 18 of the arms act, 1959. The appeal was dismissed on 7 - 1 - 2008 on the ground that the criminal case is going on against the petitioner and during search he was found in possession of 30 rounds.
(4) Learned counsel for the petitioner drew my attention to the offence registered against the petitioner and submitted that the armed licence is suspended for a petty crime and there is no valid ground for suspending the licence because the petitioner is not an accused of a serious crime or hardened criminal and such action cannot be taken against him.
(5) In support of the said contention, he drew my attention to the decisions of this court in the case of amrik chand saluja vs. State of m. P. , 1990 mplj 601 and the single bench of allahabad high court in the case of ganesh chandra bhatt vs. District magistrate, almora and others, air 1993 allahabad 291.
(6) He lastly submitted that the other bench of this court considered the cases of the allahabad high court and passed an order dated 9 - 11 - 2006 in w. P. No. 9038/03 by holding that the authorities have committed error in cancelling the arms licence of the petitioner on the ground of pendency of criminal case against the petitioner.
(7) In the instant case, the petitioner is on the better footings. His licence was suspended on 31 - 7 - 2007. Paras 5 and 6 of the order dated 9 - 11 - 2006 passed in w. P. No. 9038/03, surya pal singh vs. State of m. P. And others, read as under: -
5. In the case before the allahabad high court, it has been held that sometimes arms licences are suspended for petty crimes like 323, 324 or 325, indian penal code. This is not a valid ground for impounding or cancelling or refusing to grant an arm's licence. It is only where one is an accused of a serious crime or hardened criminal, such action can be taken.
6. In the present case, allegations against the present petitioner are that he has threatened to use arm against the complainant and thus, he has not actually used the arm. In such circumstances, i find that the authorities have committed error in cancelling the arms licence of the petitioner on the ground of pendency of criminal case against the petitioner.
(8) In the present case, the allegations against the present petitioner are that he was in possession 30 rounds when the search was made by the police person and the case has been registered against him under the provisions of the arms act, 1959. In such situation, i find that the authorities have committed error in suspending the arms licence of the petitioner on the ground of pendency of the criminal case against the petitioner.
(9) In view of the law laid down by the other bench of this court in the case of surya pal singh (supra) , this petition is allowed and the order of suspension of the armed licence of the petitioner as well as the order passed by the appellate authority on 7 - 1 - 2008 are set aside.
(10) In the result, this petition is allowed and the order suspending the arms licence of the petitioner is set aside. No costs.
Alert