Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Podyami Sukada v. State Of Madhya Pradesh (Now Chhattisgarh) .

Supreme Court Of India
Jul 23, 2010
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 9 December 1999, Madvi Pali discovered the body of Madvi Mase, who had suffered multiple burn injuries, in the latter’s home. After informing PW 1 Madvi Rama, a village meeting (panchayat) was convened. During this meeting the appellant—son of the deceased—allegedly confessed that, angered by his mother’s remarks about his drinking habits, he struck her with a burning wooden plank, causing her death.

PW 1 reported the incident to Police Station Tongpal, leading to registration of an offence under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code. An inquest and post-mortem followed; the autopsy surgeon (PW 5) opined that death resulted from shock due to burn injuries. A wooden plank, purportedly used in the assault, was recovered on the appellant’s statement during investigation.

The First Additional Sessions Judge, Bastar, convicted the appellant of murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment (18 February 2000). The Chhattisgarh High Court upheld the conviction and sentence on 22 June 2005. The present Supreme Court appeal challenges those concurrent findings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an extra-judicial confession, allegedly made before village members who later turned hostile, is reliable enough to sustain a conviction for murder.
  2. Whether recovery of the alleged weapon of offence, standing alone or coupled with the disputed confession, provides sufficient corroboration to uphold the conviction under Section 302 IPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Accepts the finding that the deceased suffered a homicidal death, but contends that the witnesses to the extra-judicial confession are unreliable because they were declared hostile and contradicted themselves.
  • Asserts that the recovery of the wooden plank is tainted and cannot independently corroborate the confession.

State's Arguments

  • Maintains that the extra-judicial confession before the panchayat is voluntary and trustworthy.
  • Argues that recovery of the weapon at the appellant’s instance further corroborates the confession, conclusively proving guilt.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court emphasized that the evidentiary value of an extra-judicial confession depends on the trustworthiness of the witnesses who narrate it. While testimony of a hostile witness is not legally inadmissible, courts require corroboration as a matter of prudence.

All four witnesses (PWs 1-4) to the alleged confession were declared hostile:

  • PWs 2 and 4 never mentioned any confession in either examination-in-chief or cross-examination.
  • PWs 1 and 3 omitted any mention of a confession during examination-in-chief; after being declared hostile they affirmed such a confession, but on defence cross-examination they retracted, admitting no confession was made.

The Court held that these contradictions rendered the testimony “slippery,” failing to inspire confidence. Given this uncertainty, the Court found it unsafe to base a conviction solely on such an extra-judicial confession. Regarding the recovered wooden plank, the Court stated that weapon recovery, without credible evidence linking it to the crime, could not by itself sustain a conviction. The combined weaknesses warranted extending the benefit of doubt to the appellant.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed—Conviction and Sentence Set Aside. The Court ordered the appellant’s immediate release unless required in any other case.

Implications: The decision reinforces the principle that extra-judicial confessions, particularly when supported only by witnesses who later turn hostile or contradict themselves, require strong corroboration before grounding a conviction. Mere recovery of an alleged weapon, absent reliable testimonial linkage, is insufficient. While the ruling grants relief only to the appellant, it underscores judicial caution in relying on uncorroborated extra-judicial confessions and thus may influence future assessments of similar evidence.

Show all summary ...

C.K Prasad, J.— This appeal, by grant of leave arises from the judgment and order dated 22-6-2005 passed by the Chhattisgarh High Court in Criminal Appeal No. 936 of 2000, whereby it had upheld the conviction of the appellant under Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860 and punishment of life imprisonment inflicted by the order dated 18-2-2000, passed by the First Additional Sessions Judge, Bastar in Sessions Trial No. 45 of 2000.

2. According to the prosecution, on 9-12-1999 Madvi Pali went to the house of Madvi Mase to borrow money and when she reached there, she found her dead. She informed PW 1, Madvi Rama about the incident. Madvi Rama went to the house of Madvi Mase and found her dead with wounds at different places on the body. PW 1 Madvi Rama, according to the prosecution, convened a meeting and on enquiry, the appellant confessed in the meeting that on the night of 8-12-1999 his mother (deceased) Madvi Mase scolded him alleging that he wanders after consuming liquor which enraged him and he picked up a burning wooden plank and assaulted her which caused her death. On the basis of what had been disclosed in the meeting PW 1 Madvi Rama gave report to Police Station Tongpal.

3. On the basis of the aforesaid information, a case under Section 302 of the Penal Code was registered against the appellant. During the course of investigation inquest report of the dead body was prepared in the presence of the witnesses and the dead body sent to Primary Health Centre, Tongpal for post-mortem examination. Dr. S.L Dhangar (PW 5), a Civil Assistant Surgeon, posted at Primary Health Centre, Tongpal conducted the post-mortem examination and found a large number of burn injuries on the person of the deceased and in his opinion the death had occurred due to shock on account of burn injuries. PW 6, P.L Nayak, the investigating officer of the case arrested the appellant during the course of investigation and on his statement, the wooden plank, alleged to have been used in the commission of the crime, was recovered.

4. After usual investigation, the charge-sheet was submitted under Section 302 of the Penal Code and the appellant was committed to the Court of Session to face the trial for commission of the abovesaid crime. The appellant abjured his guilt and claimed to be tried.

5. To bring home the charge, the prosecution has altogether examined six witnesses out of whom PW 1 Madvi Rama; PW 2, Mangdu; PW 3, Aaita and PW 4, Lekhan have been declared hostile and cross-examined by the prosecution. Besides the aforesaid witnesses, prosecution has also examined PW 5 Dr. S.L Dhangar, the autopsy surgeon and PW 6 P.L Nayak, the investigating officer. The plea of the appellant is denial simpliciter and false implication but no defence witness has been examined.

6. On the basis of evidence on record the trial court came to the conclusion that Madvi Mase met with a homicidal death, which finding has been affirmed by the High Court in appeal. Further, relying on the extra-judicial confession and recovery of the weapon of crime at the instance of the appellant the trial court convicted and sentenced the appellant as above and it has been maintained by the High Court in appeal.

7. Relevant portion of the judgment of the High Court in this regard reads as follows:

“In view of the above, we are of the considered opinion that extra-judicial confession regarding causing death of his mother and attacking her with the teak wood plank was made by the accused before the panchayat; this evidence of extra-judicial confession by the accused before these witnesses inspires confidence of the Court as the same stands corroborated by FIR, Ext. P-1, recovery of weapon of offence as well as medical evidence also corroborates the confession. Therefore, the finding of the trial court convicting the accused for the offence under Section 302 is based on the legal evidence and we do not find any circumstance to differ from the view taken by the trial court.”

8. We have heard Mr D.N Goburdhun for the appellant and Mr Atul Jha for the State. Mr Goburdhun submits that in view of the evidence on record, the finding recorded by the courts below that the deceased met with the homicidal death, cannot legitimately be assailed. However, he submits that the witnesses to the extra-judicial confession are not reliable and hence the conviction and sentence of the appellant deserve to be set aside. He points out that alleged recovery of the weapon of crime at the instance of the appellant is tainted and hence, not enough to accept the case of the prosecution.

9. Mr Jha, however, submits that extra-judicial confession of the appellant together with the recovery of the weapon of crime at his instance conclusively establishes the guilt of the appellant.

10. There is no eyewitness of the crime and in order to bring home the charge the prosecution has relied on the extra-judicial confession said to have been made by the appellant in the panchayat in the presence of PWs 1 to 4 and further recovery of weapon by the investigating officer at his instance. Hence, what needs to be considered is as to whether the extra-judicial confession said to have been made by the appellant in the presence of the witnesses deserves to be relied upon.

11. As stated earlier, all the witnesses to the extra-judicial confession have been declared hostile by the prosecution. True it is that the evidence of the hostile witness is not altogether wiped out and remains admissible in evidence and there is no legal bar to base conviction on the basis of the testimony of hostile witness but as a rule of prudence, the court requires corroboration by other reliable evidence. In the present case PW 1 Madvi Rama, PW 2 Mangdu, PW 3 Aaita and PW 4 Lekhan in their evidence had stated that the meeting was called in the village after the death of the deceased, but PW 2 Mangdu and PW 4 Lekhan have nowhere stated that extra-judicial confession was made by the appellant admitting that he had killed the deceased. PW 1 Madvi Rama and PW 3 Aaita too have not stated anything about extra-judicial confession in their examination-in-chief but after being declared hostile and cross-examined by the prosecution they disclosed that the appellant had confessed that he killed the deceased with the burnt stick as she told him that he was wandering after consuming liquor. However, when cross-examined by the defence, again they admitted that no such confession was made by the appellant. Thus there is complete somersault in their evidence.

12. Evidentiary value of extra-judicial confession depends upon trustworthiness of the witness before whom confession is made. Law does not contemplate that the evidence of an extra-judicial confession should in all cases be corroborated. It is not an inflexible rule that in no case conviction can be based solely on extra-judicial confession. It is basically in the realm of appreciation of evidence and a question of fact to be decided in the facts and circumstances of each case.

13. In the face of the evidence aforesaid, the question that falls for consideration is as to whether the conviction of the appellant is fit to be sustained only on the basis of the extra-judicial confession coupled with the recovery of weapon of crime at the instance of the appellant.

14. As stated earlier PW 2 Mangdu and PW 4 Lekhan neither in the examination-in-chief nor in the cross-examination had stated anything about the extra-judicial confession said to have been made by the appellant. PW 1 Madvi Rama and PW 3 Aaita in the examination-in-chief did not support the case of the prosecution and after being declared hostile and cross-examined by the prosecution did say about the extra-judicial confession by the appellant but again on cross-examination by the defence they admitted that no such confession was made by the appellant. Thus the evidence of both the prosecution witnesses is slippery and from their evidence, it is difficult to hold with certainty that any extra-judicial confession in fact was made by the appellant. This state of evidence leaves us in doubt and we are of the opinion that the witnesses of the extra-judicial confession do not inspire confidence and merely on the ground of recovery of weapon of crime at the instance of the appellant, it shall be unsafe to sustain the conviction of the appellant. Accordingly, we grant the appellant the benefit of doubt.

15. In the result, we allow the appeal, set aside the impugned judgment of conviction and sentence of the appellant. The appellant is in jail, he be released forthwith, unless required in any other case.