Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Parmeshwar Prasad v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Oct 30, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant entered the Bihar Statistical Service on 22-8-1968, rose to a Class I post in July 1992, and received senior selection grade in July 1994. His department recommended him for appointment to the Indian Administrative Service (IAS) by selection on 15-11-1994, but no State Scrutiny Committee meetings were convened for 1994-95 or 1995-96. A fresh recommendation was made on 12-12-1996. Because the appellant was over 54 years of age on 1-4-1996 (the stipulated cut-off date for the 1996-97 cycle), the State Scrutiny Committee declined to shortlist him.

The appellant challenged this omission before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Patna Bench, in OA No. 213 / 1997. An interim stay was initially granted but vacated once the Tribunal learned of his age bar; the Patna High Court likewise refused relief. On 14-9-1998 the CAT dismissed the main OA, holding that the proper cut-off date was 1-4-1996 and that the Regulations imposed no obligation to hold annual selections. The appellant then filed the present civil appeal before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, despite being over 54 years of age on 1-4-1996, the appellant was entitled to consideration for appointment to the IAS by selection on the ground that State-level Scrutiny Committee meetings had not been held in earlier years.
  2. Whether provisions and principles governing promotion of State Civil Service officers under the IAS (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955 could be invoked to override the age bar and procedural framework in the IAS (Appointment by Selection) Regulations, 1956.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Invoked the proviso to Regulation 5(3) of the IAS (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955 to argue that delays in holding meetings should not prejudice eligible officers.
  • Cited Supreme Court decisions—Union of India v. Vipinchandra Hiralal Shah, Syed Khalid Rizvi v. Union of India, T. Sham Bhat v. Union of India, and Sant Ram Sharma v. State of Rajasthan—to contend that administrative delays should not defeat substantive rights and that executive instructions could fill perceived gaps.
  • Relied on a Bihar Government circular dated 18-10-1996 and a UPSC letter dated 19-9-1996 to support flexibility in applying the age criterion.

Respondents' Arguments (Union of India & State of Bihar)

  • Adopted the CAT’s reasoning that the applicable Regulations for selection (not promotion) governed the case and embodied a mandatory age limit of 54 years.
  • Maintained that there is no statutory requirement for annual selection of non-State Civil Service officers, so administrative delays did not shift the cut-off date.
  • Asserted that precedents cited by the appellant dealt with promotion cases and were therefore inapposite.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sant Ram Sharma v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1967 SC 1910 Executive instructions may fill gaps where statutory rules are silent. Held inapplicable; only the rule-making authority, not State circulars, can modify or supplement Regulations.
Syed Khalid Rizvi v. Union of India, 1993 Supp (3) SCC 575 Interpretation of “ordinarily” in Regulation 5 of Promotion Regulations and need for annual selection meetings. Distinguished; pertained to promotion of State Civil Service officers, not selection of non-SCS officers.
T. Sham Bhat v. Union of India, 1994 Supp (3) SCC 340 Consequences of delay in convening Promotion Selection Committees. Found irrelevant; factual and regulatory matrix different from appointment by selection.
Union of India v. Vipinchandra Hiralal Shah, (1996) 6 SCC 721 Effect of administrative delay on promotion processes. Distinguished on the ground that it dealt with promotion, not selection, and could not displace the age bar.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court endorsed the CAT’s interpretation of the two distinct regulatory regimes:

  • Regulatory distinction: Promotion of State Civil Service officers is governed by the IAS (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955, which mandate annual meetings (shall ordinarily meet at intervals not exceeding one year). In contrast, Regulation 3(1) of the IAS (Appointment by Selection) Regulations, 1956 states that the State Government may, from time to time consider eligible non-SCS officers, imposing no obligation of annual exercise.
  • Age bar: Regulation 3 explicitly prohibits consideration of officers who have attained 54 years on 1 April of the relevant year. The appellant was indisputably over 54 on 1-4-1996.
  • No substantive right to post-dated consideration: The Court rejected the argument that earlier administrative inaction could shift the statutory cut-off date, noting that vacancies for 1996-97 were only two and that ten eligible officers were forwarded, satisfying the five-times-vacancy limit.
  • Irrelevance of cited precedents and circulars: All cases relied on concerned promotion, not selection. Executive circulars from the Bihar Government lacked authority to override central Regulations, and the UPSC letter provided no contrary mandate.
  • Nature of Scrutiny Committee: Any lapse by the State Scrutiny Committee was an internal administrative matter and did not equate to a breach of the statutory selection process.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. No costs awarded.

The decision upholds the primacy of the IAS (Appointment by Selection) Regulations, 1956, particularly the mandatory age limit of 54 years and the discretionary, non-annual nature of the selection process for non-State Civil Service officers. While providing no new legal precedent, it reinforces that promotion-related jurisprudence cannot be transposed onto selection cases and that executive instructions cannot override statutory regulations.

Show all summary ...

Doraiswamy Raju, J.— The appellant, who joined the Bihar Statistical Service in a Class II gazetted post on 22-8-1968, was promoted to Class I post in July 1992 and again in July 1994 he was given the senior selection grade. His name was said to have been recommended on 15-11-1994 for appointment by selection to IAS by his parent department. But since no meeting of the State Committee for shortlisting of candidates took place for the years 1994-95 and 1995-96 for officers of the said category, the proposal by his parent department did not materialize. On 12-12-1996, it appears that the name of the appellant was again recommended by his parent department for being considered for appointment by selection to the post of IAS. The State Scrutiny Committee, whose task is to shortlist the names of such candidates received from various departments of the Government other than the State civil service for further consideration by the Select Committee as per the Regulations, seems to have not favourably considered the claim of the appellant since he was above 54 years as on 1-4-1996 i.e the relevant cut-off date for consideration of claims for the year 1996-97. Apparently, on coming to know that he was not one of the persons called for interview while others had been, the appellant moved the Central Administrative Tribunal, Patna Bench at Patna, by filing OA No. 213 of 1997. In the said application, interim orders of stay appear to have been obtained also, which came to be ultimately vacated by the Tribunal on 18-9-1997 on being brought to its notice that the appellant was overaged as on 1-4-1996. The High Court also declined to interfere at its instance at that stage, in CWJC No. 9334 of 1997.

2. The main OA No. 213 of 1997 itself was subsequently taken up for consideration and by an order dated 14-9-1998, the same came to be dismissed rejecting the plea of the appellant for a different cut-off date and that so far as his claim was concerned, it could be anything other than 1-4-1996 for the reason that there was no meeting of the Scrutiny Committee held for the years 1994-95 and 1995-96 at the State level in respect of appointment to IAS through selection method. The Tribunal has meticulously analysed the difference between the consideration of claims of State civil service officers as envisaged under IAS (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955 on the one hand and IAS (Appointment by Selection) Regulations, 1956 on the other, by highlighting the fact that unlike the statutory obligation to have an annual selection for appointment by promotion, no such duty was cast under the Regulations, for obvious reasons, for such annual consideration in respect of appointment by selection method. Not satisfied, the appellant has come before this Court.

3. Heard the learned Senior Counsel on either side. Shri A. Sharan appearing for the appellant sought to draw inspiration based on the proviso to Regulation 5(3) of the IAS (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955 and also the decisions reported in Union of India v. Vipinchandra Hiralal Shah (1996) 6 SCC 721, Syed Khalid Rizvi v. Union of India 1993 Supp (3) SCC 575, (1994) 26 ATC 192, T. Sham Bhat v. Union of India 1994 Supp (3) SCC 340, (1994) 28 ATC 400 and Sant Ram Sharma v. State of Rajasthan AIR 1967 SC 1910 to project the claim of the appellant besides placing strong reliance upon the circular dated 18-10-1996 issued by the Government of Bihar and the letter dated 19-9-1996 of the Union Public Service Commission. Per contra, Shri N.N Goswami, learned Senior Counsel for the Union of India, and Shri B.B Singh, learned counsel for the State of Bihar, adopted the reasoning of the Tribunal and submitted that the decision of the Tribunal calls for no interference since they are quite in accordance with the Regulations and the procedure governing the selection for appointment by selection method from the category of non-State civil service officers.

4. We have carefully considered the submissions made by the learned counsel on either side. In our view, the reasons assigned by the Tribunal below accord with the relevant Rules and Regulations governing the selection for appointment of non-State civil service officers by selection method. The reliance placed on the decision reported in Sant Ram Sharma AIR 1967 SC 1910 is inappropriate for the reasons that the circulars issued by the Government of Bihar cannot be considered as those which could fill up even the assumed gaps, though, in our view, there is none such, for the simple reason that it is only the authority which had the competency to make the Rules or Regulations that could be said to have even such powers. The communication of the Union Public Service Commission, noticed above, also does not lend any support to the claim of the appellant. The decision of this Court in T. Sham Bhat 1994 Supp (3) SCC 340, (1994) 28 ATC 400 has no relevance whatsoever to the issue raised before us; nor could the reasons, which weighed with this Court in arriving at the decision therein, be stretched to the extent of obliterating all differences and distinctions specifically envisaged in the respective Regulations providing for different manner or procedure of consideration in respect of appointment by promotion of the State civil service officers and appointment by selection of the non-State civil service officers. The decision in Syed Khalid Rizvi 1993 Supp (3) SCC 575, (1994) 26 ATC 192 as well as the one reported in Vipinchandra Hiralal Shah (1996) 6 SCC 721 related to appointment by promotion of State civil service officers and they cannot be of any assistance for considering the claims and rights of the appellant under the IAS (Appointment by Selection) Regulations. This Court in explaining the meaning of the word “ordinarily” in Regulation 5 of the IAS (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations had come to the particular conclusion having regard to the mandate contained in clause (1) of Regulation 5 that the Selection Committee shall ordinarily meet at intervals not exceeding one year and prepare a list of such members of the State civil service, as are held by them to be suitable for promotion to the service. So far as the IAS (Appointment by Selection) Regulations, 1956 are concerned, clause (1) of Regulation 3 only envisages that the State Government may, from time to time, consider by way of selection the cases of persons not belonging to the State civil service but serving in connection with the affairs of the State. The provisions contained therein also interdict the State Government from considering cases of persons, who have attained the age of 54 years on the first day of April of the year in which the cases of the persons are considered and consequently, no claims can be asserted in derogation of such stipulation. So far as the case on hand is concerned, the factual details disclosed show and that there is no controversy over the same, that the vacancies being only two, the number of officers proposed for the consideration of the Selection Committee by the State Government shall not exceed five times the number of vacancies and that as a matter of fact, ten eligible persons under the said category have been proposed by the State Government. The omission or lapse, if any, on the part of the State Scrutiny Committee, which is meant to shortlist the candidates proposed by the heads of various departments of the Government, is purely an internal working arrangement and such a selection cannot be equated to consideration and selection by the Select Committee envisaged under the Regulations. Consequently, we see no infirmity whatsoever in the findings of the Tribunal in non-suiting the appellant, so as to call for our interference.

5. The appeal, therefore, fails and will stand dismissed. No costs.