Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Boiron v. Sbl Pvt. Ltd. And Others.

Delhi High Court
Dec 16, 1998
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Dr. M.K. Sharma, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges the judgment and order dated 11.3.1998 of the Company Law Board (CLB) in Company Petition No. 63/1997. The appellant is a French company holding 30% of the share capital of SBL Pvt. Ltd. and had filed a petition under Sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act alleging acts of oppression and mismanagement by the majority shareholder and controller, respondent No. 3 (acting through respondent No. 2). The CLB considered allegations including diversion/siphoning of company funds to associate companies without board approval or interest, an allegedly unnecessary rights issue to increase share capital, dealings related to SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd., advances and security deposits to associated companies (Aspire Investment Pvt. Ltd., Rockland Estate Pvt. Ltd., Himal Enterprises), and the purchase/investment in gas cylinders. The CLB made findings on these matters (including directions to enter into a manufacturing agreement with SBL (Sikkim) and findings about interest on loans and disclosure in accounts). The appellant appealed under Section 10-F of the Companies Act, contending that the CLB's findings were unsupported by record and contrary to various statutory provisions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the findings of the Company Law Board are unsupported by material on record and are contrary to or irreconcilable with the evidence, as alleged by the appellant.
  2. Whether the transactions identified (advances/security deposits to associated companies, non-charging of interest, diversion of funds, rights issue increasing share capital, investment in gas cylinders, and dealings with SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd.) amount to oppression or mismanagement under Sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act.
  3. Whether the Company Law Board erred in not directing an investigation under Section 402 into the affairs and management of SBL Pvt. Ltd.
  4. Whether alleged violations of statutory provisions (including Sections 283, 291, 209(4A), 370, 301, 370 and 295 as pleaded by the appellant) amount to acts of oppression or otherwise required specific relief by the CLB.
  5. Whether the appeal is maintainable before this Court, i.e. whether any substantial question of law arises from the CLB’s primarily factual findings.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The CLB's judgment and order are infirm because the findings are not supported by the materials and are contrary to the evidence on record.
  • The CLB failed to comply with several mandatory statutory requirements and its findings conflict with provisions of the Companies Act (Sections 283, 291, 209(4A), 370 and 301 were specifically mentioned by the appellant).
  • Respondent No. 3 (majority controller) diverted company funds to associated concerns without board approval, without agreements and without charging interest, causing siphoning of funds.
  • The appellant contended that loans and advances to Aspire Investment Pvt. Ltd., Rockland Estate Pvt. Ltd., Himal Investment Ltd. (and related security deposits) were wrongly made and not properly accounted for or returned.
  • The appellant complained that investment of Rs. 50.11 lacs in 10,000 gas cylinders produced no return and amounted to gross mismanagement.
  • The appellant sought an investigation under Section 402 and argued that the CLB should have ordered such an investigation; it relied on the respondent’s written submission consenting to scrutiny by an independent auditor as a basis for investigation.
  • With regard to SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd., the appellant argued that the entire profits (past and future) of SBL (Sikkim) should have been allotted to SBL Pvt. Ltd., and that the CLB’s manufacturing agreement direction only addressed future profits and not past transactions.

Respondent's Arguments (Respondent No. 1)

  • The appeal is not maintainable because it does not raise any substantial question of law; it is primarily a challenge to findings of fact made by the CLB, and such findings are not open to re-appreciation on appeal to this Court.
  • The CLB considered the evidence and reached clear factual conclusions that the management acted transparently and there was no mismanagement or oppression.
  • The CLB’s direction to enter into a manufacturing agreement with SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd. resolved the grievance; a subsequent board decision fixed a minimum 15% margin (and respondent contended this margin applied retrospectively as well).
  • Counsel relied on authority (cases cited in the text) to support the proposition that appeals are not maintainable against findings of fact on which no substantial question of law arises.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Minoo H. Modi v. Hemant D. Vakil and others; (1997) 89 Company Cases 456 Relied upon by respondent to support the contention that findings of fact by a tribunal are not open to challenge on appeal where no substantial question of law arises. The respondent relied on this decision to argue non-maintainability of the appeal; the court treated the issues as factual and concluded it could not interfere with findings of fact under Section 10-F.
Mattulal v. Radhalal; AIR 1974 SC 1596 Relied upon by respondent for the proposition that appeals are not competent against findings of fact which do not raise substantial questions of law. The respondent cited this authority in support of the submission that the CLB’s factual findings were final; the Court upheld the CLB findings as factual determinations not to be disturbed under Section 10-F.
Sri Sinha Ramanuja Jeer v. Sri Ranga Ramanuja Jeer; AIR 1961 SC 1720 Relied upon by respondent in similar vein—that challenges to findings of fact do not necessarily give rise to a substantial question of law. The respondent relied on this case; the Court, treating the appeal as a challenge to factual findings, dismissed the appeal and declined to interfere with the CLB's factual conclusions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the CLB’s findings on the specific grievances and the documentary evidence before it, and proceeded issue by issue as follows:

  1. Interest on loans/advances: The CLB found the appellant was aware of the loans because they were disclosed in annual reports; an arbitrator had awarded 14% interest to respondent No. 2 and the Company had agreed to charge interest on certain loans (letter dated 10.12.1997). The CLB therefore upheld the position that the grievance about interest was, in part, well founded (interest should be charged) but factual disclosures showed appellant's awareness.
  2. Security deposits and non-charging of interest: The CLB concluded that non-charging of interest on security deposits would not prejudice the Company because rent payments would have been broadly equivalent to the interest that could have been charged. The CLB noted that amounts (e.g., Rs. 72 lacs with Rockland) were being refunded and only small balances (e.g., Rs. 2.77 lacs with Aspire) remained. These transactions had been disclosed in annual accounts and, since the Company enjoyed use of premises without rent, the CLB found no mismanagement on this count.
  3. SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd.: The CLB treated SBL (Sikkim) as a separate legal entity and not funded by the main Company. The CLB directed entry into a manufacturing agreement between SBL Pvt. Ltd. and SBL (Sikkim) to fix charges for production. The Court noted that the Board of Directors of respondent No. 1 later approved an arrangement fixing a minimum 15% margin for products procured from SBL (Sikkim), and found the CLB direction to be just and proper; this, in the Court’s view, addressed the appellant’s grievance regarding Sikkim operations.
  4. Increase in share capital (rights issue): The CLB found the proposal to increase share capital had been under consideration and was approved by a board meeting on 29.3.1994 with a decision to issue shares to respondent No. 2 against outstanding loans. The CLB considered that the directions issued and procedures followed took care of grievances; if differences persisted, the CLB suggested the appellant could sell its shares to respondent No. 2 based on a valuer’s valuation.
  5. Loans/advances and disclosure: On scrutiny of advances to Aspire, Rockland and others, the CLB found these had been entered into with full knowledge of concerned parties and were disclosed in the company’s accounts (including the year 1994–95 balance sheet signed by the appellant’s nominee director). Given the disclosure and benefits (use of premises without rent), the CLB found no mismanagement or oppression.
  6. Investment in gas cylinders (Rs. 50.11 lacs): The CLB noted this amount was reflected in the balance sheet and was therefore known to the appellant; the appellant had not raised this issue in pleadings before the CLB. The CLB held that diversification with disclosure to the board and shareholders does not, by itself, amount to mismanagement or oppression.
  7. Alleged statutory violations (Sections 370, 295 etc.): The CLB held that in the absence of full particulars it could not make specific findings on alleged violations; additionally, mere contravention of statutory provisions that themselves provide penal consequences does not automatically constitute oppression for remedy under Sections 397/398.
  8. Investigation under Section 402: The CLB refused to order an investigation because the appellant did not furnish the detailed particulars required to justify such an inquiry. The CLB found that the respondent had furnished the information necessary to adjudicate the issues and that the transactions were reflected in audited accounts; consequently, no ground for investigation was made out.
  9. Standard of review and final disposition: The Court emphasized that the CLB’s conclusions were findings of fact. Relying on the principle (as urged by respondent counsel and supported by cited authorities) that findings of fact are not ordinarily disturbed on appeal where no substantial question of law arises, the Court held it could not interfere with the CLB’s factual findings under Section 10-F.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed.

Implications:

  • The Company Law Board's judgment and order in Company Petition No. 63/1997 (dated 11.3.1998) is upheld in all material respects by this Court.
  • The CLB’s factual findings regarding disclosure of transactions in the accounts, the separate identity of SBL (Sikkim), the reasonableness of the manufacturing-agreement remedy (and subsequent approval of a 15% margin by the respondent’s board), the non-prejudicial nature of non-charging interest on certain security deposits, and the absence of grounds for ordering an investigation under Section 402 were accepted and not disturbed.
  • The Court left the parties to bear their own costs.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal precedent; it affirms that, as a matter of appellate review in this context, findings of fact by the CLB will not be interfered with under Section 10-F where no substantial question of law is raised.

Note: This summary is strictly confined to the facts, arguments, reasoning and conclusions contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

Dr. M.K Sharma, J.— The present appeal is directed against the, impugned judgment and order passed by the Company Law Board on 11.3.1998 in Company Petition No. 63/1997.

2. By this judgment and order, I propose to dispose of the said appeal preferred by the appellant under section 10f of the companies act. The appellant assails the findings of the Company Law Board on the ground that the said findings are not supported by materials on record and are contrary to or irreconcilable with the evidence on record. According to the appellant, the said judgment is also contrary to several mandatory requirements of the Companies Act, particularly, the provisions of Sections 283, 291, 209(4A), 370 and 301 of the Companies Act.

3. The appellant which is a French Company holding 30% of the share capital of SBL Pvt. Ltd. has filed a petition under Sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act alleging various acts of alleged oppression and mismanagement in the affairs of the Company. SBL Pvt. Ltd., the respondent No. 1 was incorporated some time in the year 1979 with the technical know how provided by the appellant. Originally there were four groups of shareholders including the appellant Company, but, some time in the year 1985, there was Change in the shareholding and the respondent No. 3 through its associate Company, respondent No. 2, became the major shareholder holding about 60% shares in the Company. The aforesaid change of shareholding came about with the consent and concurrence of the appellant who is holding 30% shares in the Company. After gaining majority control, the respondent No. 3 has been managing all affairs of the Company. The relationship between the two took a different turn some time during later part of 1996 culminating in filing of the application under section 397 and 398 by the appellant.

4. The main grievance of the appellant as raised in the petition under Sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act is that respondent No. 3 being in control of the management of the Company has been diverting the funds of the Company to various of its associated Companies without proper notice or approval of the Board resulting in alleged siphoning of funds. According to the appellant, the same was done without any resolution of the Board and without any agreement. After considering the pleadings and arguments of the counsel for the parties, the Company Law Board found that there are mainly three grievances of the appellant which were that certain funds had been given to associate Companies of respondent No. 3 without any interest and that to without the knowledge and consent of the petitioner, that increasing the share capital of the Company by a right issue when there is no need for increasing the share capital and that matters relating to M/s. SBL India Limited.

5. The Company Law Board on appreciating of the pleadings and documents placed on record found that so far non-charging of interest on various loan advanced by the respondent No. 1 was concerned, it was not that the appellant was not aware of such loan as the same were reflected in the annual reports. It was, however, found by the Company Law Board that the question of interest was never raised as the respondent No. 1, was not originally paying any interest to respondent No. 2 and once the arbitrator had awarded 14% interest to respondent No. 2, it was but natural that the loans given by the Company should also be subject to interest and, therefore, the grievance of the appellant to that extent was found to be well established. The Company Law Board as a matter of fact found that the Company agreed to charge interest on certain loans given to the parties as indicated in their letter dated 10th December, 1997 although there was no such indication of charging of interest on security deposit given to Rockland Estate Pvt. Ltd., Team Designs Pvt. Ltd. and SBL India Pvt. Ltd., which are the main grievances of the appellant.

6. On appreciation of the documents on record, the Company Law Board found that non-charging of interest on the security deposit would not prejudicially affect the Company inasmuch as the payment of rent would have been more or less equal to the interest chargeable. The Company Law Board also found that the Company was vacating the premises belonging to Rockland Estate Pvt. Ltd. and the amount of Rs. 72 lacs outstanding and given as security deposit was being refunded by Rockland Estate Pvt. Ltd., and that only a sum of Rs. 2 lacs was kept as security deposit with Aspire Investment Pvt. Ltd. On the basis of the same, the Company Law Board was of the opinion that the interest of the Company was in no way being jeopardised by the aforesaid transactions. Regarding the violation of the provisions of section 370 and other provisions, Company Law Board stated that in absence of full details, it was not possible to give any finding and even otherwise mere violation of provisions of a statute when it itself provides for penal action, per se, would not be treated as an act of oppression.

7. The Company Law Board found that SBL (Sikkim) is a separate entity and was not funded by the Company in question and the said controversy relating to SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd., could be put to an end by entering into a manufacturing agreement with SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd., for fixing such charges as it deemed fit, for production of company's products in SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd., which according to the Company Law Board, would set at rest the grievance of the petitioner.

8. It was also found that increase in the share capital had been under the consideration of the Board for a long time and that there was a decision to increase the share by the Company and was approved in the Board meeting held on 29.3.1994 wherein it was also decided to issue shares to respondent No. 2 against the loans outstanding. On appreciation of the evidence on record, it was held that the directions given in the letter would take care of all the grievances and even after that in the event of any difference arising between the parties, the only solution could be that the appellant would sell his shares to respondent No. 2 on a valuation made by a valuer since the respondent No. 2 is the major shareholder and respondent No. 3 has been in management of the Company for long. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and order, the present appeal has been preferred.

9. Mr. S. Ganesh appearing for the appellant during the course of his submissions stated that the said judgment and order of the Company Law Board suffers from many infirmities as the Company Law Board failed to consider and deal with various materials and evidence on record in respect of dealings with SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd., loans and advances by SBL Pvt. Ltd., to Shreshta Group and regarding payment of interest on the advances made by SBL Pvt. Ltd. to Rockland Estate Pvt. Ltd. and Aspire Investment Pvt. Ltd. Counsel also submitted that the Company Law Board also disregarded the materials and evidence on record in respect of investment of Rs. 50.11 lacs in gas cylinders made by the Company with absolutely no return to SBL Pvt. Ltd which amounts to a gross act of mismanagement. According to him the Company Law Board also faulted in not directing any investigation although the respondent agreed to the same in their written submission filed before the Company Law Board.

10. Mr. M.G Ramachandran, counsel appearing for respondent No. 1 submitted that the present appeal is not maintainable as it does not give rise to any substantial question of law. According to him, the challenge of the appellant is mainly on findings of fact arrived at by the Company Law Board on the basis of which no appeal would lie before this Court. In support of his contention, the learned counsel relied upon the decisions in Minoo H. Modi v. Hemant D. Vakil and others; reported in (1997) 89 Company Cases 456, Mattulal v. Radhalal; reported in AIR 1974 SC 1596 and Sri Sinha Ramanuja Jeer v. Sri Ranga Ramanuja Jeer; reported in AIR 1961 SC 1720. He further submitted that the Company Law Board has considered all the issues and, thereafter as given a clear and categorical finding that the respondent had conducted the affairs of the Company in a transparent manner and there is no case of any mismanagement and oppression and, therefore, no question of law arises from the aforesaid findings of fact recorded by the Company Law Board. He also submitted that so far dealing with SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd. is concerned, the Company Law Board has directed for entering into a manufacturing agreement with SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd., for fixing such charges as it deemed fit in pursuance of which directions such an agreement has been arrived at and, therefore, there could be no grievance in respect of the said transactions. He similarly contended that in respect of other dealings also there was no act of any mismanagement or oppression and thus the appeal is required to be dismissed.

11. In the light of the aforesaid submissions of the learned counsel appearing for the parties, I propose to deal with the contentions in seriatim.

12. Mr. S. Ganesh, counsel for the appellant submitted that the entire profits made by SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd., should be to the account of SBL Pvt. Ltd., not only for future, but, for the past as well. According to him although the Company Law Board had given a direction for entering into a manufacturing agreement with SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd., the same takes care only of the future, but, does not create any obligation for the past transactions and thus, the findings suffer from infirmity.

13. My attention was also drawn to the letters dated 21.8.1995, 24.8.1995 and 12.12.1995 which deal with operating profit and not the entire profit. In the letter dated 21.8.1995, the appellant accepted that the Sikkim Laboratory is an investment of Himal Enterprise Pvt. Ltd., and not of respondent No. 1. The letter dated 24.8.1995 also speaks about Sikkim operations being self-financed through tax-free profits being generated in Sikkim. These letters when read in its true content and perspective would clearly suggest that the parties did not intend that the entire profits of SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd. would go to SBL Pvt. Ltd. Admittedly SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd. is a separate legal entity, having an independent identity. It is also not the case of the appellant that SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd. was founded by the respondent No. 1. Subsequent to the aforesaid directions issued by the Company Law Board, the Board of Directors of respondent No. 1 decided that a clear margin of minimum 15% on the products procured from SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd., would be beneficial to respondent No. 1 and is an appropriate arrangement. During the course of his arguments, Mr. M.G Ramachandran stated that the aforesaid margin of minimum 15% obligation is not only to the future, but, also to the past transactions. The order passed by the Company Law Board directing a manufacturing agreement to be signed between SBL (Sikkim) Pvt. Ltd., and SBL taking into account all relevant factors and further leaving the reasonableness of the arrangement to the wisdom of the Board of Director of SBL is found to be a just and proper order in the case subsequent to which such an agreement has been approved by the Board of Directors of the respondent No. 1 with clear margin of 15% and, therefore, it cannot be held that there is any mismanagement or oppression on that count.

14. Regarding the grievance of the appellant with regard to loans and advances made to various parties, I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel appearing for the parties in respect of the same. According to the appellant, loans and advances to Aspire Investment Pvt. Ltd., Himal Investment Ltd. and Rockland Estate Pvt. Ltd., were wrongly advanced by respondent No. 1. So far Aspire Investment Pvt. Ltd., is concerned, the allegation was that an amount of Rs. 21.50 lacs was advanced to the said Company by the respondent No. 1. According to the respondent as of today, outstanding advance from Aspire Investment Pvt. Ltd., is only Rs. 2.77 lacs. It is true that an amount of Rs. 21.50 lacs was advanced to Aspire Investment Pvt. Ltd., towards security deposit for commercial use of the premises made available to respondent No. 1 by the said Company. Aspire Investments Pvt. Ltd., had given its premises on lease at Calcutta to the Company. The Company Law Board on consideration of the evidence on record found that for leasing the said property to the respondent No. 1, the respondent No. 3 had taken only security deposit and not any rent. It is stated that the entire security deposit except Rs. 2.77 lacs has since been returned by Aspire Investments Pvt. Ltd., to respondent No. 1 leaving a balance of only Rs. 2.77 lacs.

15. So far advances made to Rockland Estate Pvt. Ltd., towards security deposit for commercial use of its premises is concerned, the same was advanced for an area of about 1100 sq.ft in Connaught Place to respondent No. 1 in the year 1991. So far that premises is also concerned, the respondent No. 1 had the benefit of using the said premises also without payment of rent.

16. The aforesaid transactions were entered into with the full knowledge of all concerned and were duly disclosed in the annual accounts of the Company which would be disclosed from the accounts for the years ending 31.3.1995, 31.3.1996 and 31.3.1997 and the balance sheet of the year 1994-1995 was also signed by the nominee director of the appellant wherein the said advances were disclosed. The balance sheet for the concerned year was also stated to have been sent to the appellant. Since the Company Law Board has also found that the Company had the benefit of the premises without payment of rent and, therefore, there was no case of mismanagement and oppression, no objection could be taken to such a finding and, therefore, the grievance of the appellant on that count is found to be baseless and without merit.

17. The grievance of the appellant with regard to entering into the business of dealing with gas cylinders and purchase made of 10,000 gas cylinders worth Rs. 50.11 lacs, was found by the Company Law Board that the said amount spent on the gas cylinders was reflected in the balance sheet and, therefore, was to the knowledge of the appellant. The appellant did not raise any issue with regard to the same in any of his pleadings before the Company Law Board. The fact that respondent No. 1 commenced leasing business was discussed in the Board Meeting and was duly disclosed in the annul accounts of the Company for the year ending 31.3.1996 Such diversification of business by a Company with full knowledge of the Board of Directors and the shareholders cannot amount to acts of mismanagement and oppression and, therefore, the grievance of the appellant on the count is misplaced and the contention has no basis.

18. Regarding alleged violation of Sections 370, 295 etc., of the Companies Act, the Company Law Board has held that regarding the contention that there is violation of the provisions of section 370, no details have been given and, therefore, no finding could be given on the aforesaid allegations. It was also held that mere violation of the provisions of a statue when it itself provides for penal action, per se, could not be treated as an act of oppression. The said findings cannot be said to be illegal and unjustified and thus, the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant has no force at all.

19. Counsel for the appellant also submitted that at least an order should be passed under Section 402 and investigation into the affairs of SBL Pvt. Ltd., and its management was required and orders should have been passed by the Company Law Board under Section 402 directing an investigations into the affairs of SBL Pvt. Ltd., and its management. Counsel for the appellant submitted that the respondent in its written submissions also agreed to get the records scrutinised by an independent auditor as may be nominated by the Board. He submitted that in spite of the aforesaid stand taken by the respondent, the Company Law Board illegally rejected the prayer for investigation on the ground that the petitioner did not furnish the detailed particulars to convince that an order of investigations was to be made. The transactions at all times, particularly, as against which the grievance has been raised were reflected in the accounts of the Company duly audited by the auditors. The Company Law Board has come to a finding of fact that the appellant was fully aware of the dealings and that the respondent No. 1 had furnished all the information in respect of the same. The Company Law Board held that the respondent No. 1 was able to furnish every information that was needed to adjudicate on the issues before the Company Law Board and, therefore, no ground has been made out for an investigation.

20. The said finding of the Company Law Board is a finding of fact and cannot be interfered with by me exercising powers and jurisdiction under Section 10-F of the Companies Act. No other issue and/or contention is raised by the counsel appearing for the appellant. On consideration of the records, I am of the considered opinion, that the findings and the order of the Company Law Board do not suffer from any infirmity in any manner and, therefore, the appeal stands dismissed, but, in the facts and circumstances of the case, I leave the parties to bear their own costs.