- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Pearl Hosiery Mills v. Union Of India
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaint is a suit for recovery of the price for the supply of 4,000 jerseys (amount stated to be over Rs. 1½ lakhs). The plaint alleges that the goods were supplied, inspected and passed by the Inspector, but payments were not made. The plaintiff also claimed interest under S. 61 of the Sale of Goods Act. An application under S. 34 of the Arbitration Act was filed seeking a stay of the suit on the ground that an arbitration clause in the contract required the dispute to be referred to arbitration.
Procedurally, the court considered the S. 34 stay application and, after reasoning set out below, rejected the application for stay and dismissed it with costs. The court directed that Suit No. 655/76 be listed before the Deputy Registrar for receiving the written statement and extended time to file the written statement to 15th September, 1978 (the date on which the matter would be listed). The order concludes with the notation "Application dismissed."
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether non-payment of the price for goods supplied (where goods were delivered and passed by inspection) constitutes a "dispute" or "difference" within the meaning of an arbitration clause and hence is referable to arbitration under S. 34 of the Arbitration Act.
- Whether an application under S. 34 must specify the precise dispute or difference alleged to fall within the arbitration clause and what the consequence is if such particulars are not provided.
- How the court should evaluate the scope of an arbitration clause relative to the specific matter which the claimant says is agreed to be referred to arbitration (i.e., the interplay between the arbitration clause language and the specific facts/claims pleaded).
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The applicant relied on the existence of an arbitration clause in the contract and submitted that the suit should be stayed and the matter referred to an arbitrator.
- Learned counsel for the applicant specifically stated that the amount claimed by the plaintiff was not due (i.e., asserted non-liability / non-payment justification).
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any other party's (for example, the plaintiff's) counter-arguments in the application record beyond the facts pleaded in the plaint (supply, inspection, non-payment, and claim for interest under S. 61 of the Sale of Goods Act).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| National Research Development Corporation of India v. Bhupal Mining Works etc., 1973 Delhi LT 37 | Referred to as part of earlier decisions clarifying the legal position on when matters fall to be referred to arbitration and the necessity for specifying disputes. | The court relied on the body of authority, including this Delhi judgment, in assessing the correct approach under S. 34 and the need to identify the actual dispute or difference. |
| Daman Anand v. Hira Lal, AIR 1974 Punj and Har 232 | Used to support the proposition that applications under S. 34 should normally specify the exact difference or dispute; the judgment and those mentioned therein emphasize the need for particulars. | The court invoked this Punjab & Haryana judgment to explain that an S. 34 application should ordinarily specify the dispute/difference and that absence of such particulars is significant. |
| Union of India v. Birla Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills Ltd., AIR 1967 SC 688 | Cited as a Supreme Court authority relevant to the question whether non-payment of price is a dispute referable to arbitration. | The court referred to the Supreme Court judgment (and, in effect, the proposition attributed to Shah, J. in that case) as supporting the view that mere non-payment of price is not a dispute under a contract for purposes of arbitration. |
| Dwarka Nath Kapur v. Rameshwar Nath, (1966) 68 Pun LR (D) 91 | Cited for the proposition (in the Punjab decisions) that if a difference or dispute is not specified in the S. 34 application it may be rejected in limine. | The court discussed this authority and expressly declined to adopt the strictest possible rule of rejecting in limine in every case, while endorsing that particulars ought ordinarily to be given; discretion to permit specification was acknowledged. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court framed the core legal analysis around the proper meaning and scope of the words "difference" and "dispute" in arbitration clauses and the statutory language of S. 34 of the Arbitration Act ("in respect of any matter agreed to be referred").
Key steps in the court's reasoning:
- The court observed that arbitration clauses, however broadly worded, only permit differences or disputes "relating to or arising out of or in connection with" the contract to be referred to arbitration; but this does not mean every contractual non-performance is a dispute within the meaning of arbitration law.
- The court gave a working definition: a "dispute" or "difference" requires a party to make a proposition (for example, a claim) and the other party to deny or refute that proposition — i.e., there must be an actual contention. By contrast, mere non-payment where there is no assertion by the purchaser of a ground for withholding payment (like defects, late delivery, loss etc.) is simply non-performance of a condition and not a dispute in that sense.
- The court illustrated examples that would constitute a dispute: purchaser alleging improper quality, late delivery causing loss and seeking reduction, or other affirmative reasons justifying withholding payment. Those situations create a dispute because there are competing contentions to be decided.
- The court emphasized that S. 34 is restricted to matters "agreed to be referred" and therefore the crucial inquiry is what specific matter was intended by the parties to be referred — this requires examination of both the arbitration clause and the particular dispute alleged in the S. 34 application.
- In the present application, the court found that the applicant failed to specify the precise dispute or difference alleged to fall within the arbitration clause. The application only broadly asserted that there were disputes to be referred and made a bare statement that the amount was "not due" without setting out reasons or particulars explaining why non-payment was disputed.
- Because the applicant did not plead or point to pre-existing facts, documentary material, or any contemporaneous dealings showing an actual dispute/difference referable to arbitration, the court could not conclude the matter fell within the arbitration clause and hence could not grant a stay.
- The court acknowledged prior authorities that require specification of the dispute; while it did not adopt the extreme view of dismissing every deficient application in limine, it held that ordinarily the party seeking stay should be able to state the exact reasons why a stay is sought and that the dispute should be obvious to the court.
- Finally, the court relied on the cited Supreme Court authority (and related reasoning) to support the statement that non-payment of price, without more, is not a dispute arising out of the contract for arbitration purposes.
On the basis of the absence of particulars and the legal principle that mere non-payment is not, by itself, a reference-worthy dispute, the court concluded that the application for stay under S. 34 must be rejected.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court dismissed the application for stay under S. 34 of the Arbitration Act and rejected the stay application with costs. The short formal notation in the record is: "Application dismissed."
Direct consequences and practical implications (as stated in the opinion):
- The stay was refused and the suit will proceed in the civil court.
- The court ordered Suit No. 655/76 to be listed before the Deputy Registrar to receive the written statement and extended the time for filing the written statement to 15th September, 1978, which is also the date fixed for listing.
- Costs were awarded in connection with the rejected application for stay (the opinion states the application was rejected "with costs").
The opinion does not announce a novel legal principle nor does it state that it is laying down new precedent; rather it applies and explains existing authorities and the court's approach to applications under S. 34 in the factual context before it.
Application dismissed.
This is an application for stay under S. 34 of the Arbitration Act moved in respect of a suit filed by the plaintiff for the recovery of some amount (over Rs. 1½ lacs) said to be due as a result of a contract for the supply of 4,000 jerseys. The plaint states that the goods were supplied and were passed by the Inspector and then payments were not made. The plaintiff also claims some interest under S. 61 of the Sale of Goods Act. The suit is, therefore, a suit for the recovery of price of goods supplied. The application under S. 34 is to the effect that there is an arbitration clause and the matter has to go to the arbitrator.
2. The subject-matter of this application, namely, that there is an arbitration clause and the matter should be referred to arbitration is the subject-matter of many reported cases. In spite of those cases which have fully clarified the whole legal position, there seems to be some misapprehension or misconception regarding the scope of S. 34 of the Arbitration Act which results in applications of the present type being moved on the assumption that because there is an arbitration clause hence all claims have necessarily to be referred to an arbitrator and a suit based on such a claim should be stayed. I must say that the argument that such a matter should be referred to arbitration has points in its favour and also points against it. As far as the points in favour of the matter being referred to arbitration are concerned it is useful to say that if a simple claim for price could be referred directly to an arbitrator, it might avoid considerable expense to the parties. However, if the dispute is such that it cannot properly be referred to arbitration, then there is no choice for the parties but to institute a civil suit in spite of the additional expenses involved.
3. Coming to the legal question and the nature of the misconception which seems to lead to the filing of such applications for stay, I think, it is useful to mention that an arbitration clause, even though it may be worded in the widest possible language, only allows differences end disputes relating to or arising out of or in connection with a contract to be referred to an arbitrator. It may well be said that the non-payment of the price of goods supplied is also a dispute or difference which should lead the matter to be referred to arbitration. However, the word ‘Difference’ or word ‘Dispute’ is not to be understood in this way when applying the law of arbitration. A dispute means that one party has a claim and the other party says for some specific reasons that this is not a correct claim. This is a dispute. A dispute of this type requires that there should be a statement or proposition made by one side and there should be denial or refutation of that proposition by the other side. Then only can there be a dispute. Under a contact for the supply of goods, the payment of price and the delivery of goods are concurrent conditions. This is the definition of a sale under the Sale of Goods Act. If goods have been delivered and price not paid, this is not a dispute within the meaning I have just ascribed to the word ‘Dispute’. A mere failure to pay the price is not a dispute. It is a mere non-performance of a specific term or condition of a contract. A dispute regarding the price could arise if, e.g, the purchaser says that goods are not of the proper quality and he refuses to pay the price, or he might say that goods have been delivered late, so, he would pay less price or he would hold up part of the price, or he might say “You have delivered the goods late, I have suffered loss, I would reduce the price by the amount of loss.” If the purchaser makes any of these claims or similar claims then there is a dispute. If no such position is taken, then there is no dispute.
4. Now turning to the word ‘Difference’ this also has a similar meaning to the word ‘Dispute’. A difference may be, for instance, regarding the meaning of a particular term in the contract. It may be that one party feels that he has performed the contract but the other party says that the real meaning of the contract is something else and what has been done is not a true performance of the contract. This then would be a difference. It is really not necessary to specify what is a difference and what is a dispute other than to say that it is much easier to understand what is not a dispute and what is not a difference. When a party says I have supplied the goods you pay me the price and the other side does not pay the price, this is not a dispute and not a difference. This is one way of looking at the application now before me.
5. There is also another point of view. The application under S. 34 has merely stated that there are disputes which Page: 66should be referred to arbitration. No particulars of those disputes have been given. In order that there should be a dispute or a difference there must be some pre-existing facts which would show that there was a dispute and there was difference and there was a move to refer the matter to arbitration. The terminology of S. 34 of the Act is restricted to cases where a person commences legal proceedings against any other party “in respect of any matter agreed to be referred.” Therefore, the vital question to be seen is what is the matter which has been agreed to be referred. In order to see what is the matter agreed to be so referred one has to look at the arbitration clause. The usual language of such arbitration clauses is that disputes or difference relating to or arising out of or in connection with the contract or in relation to any matter connected therewith shall be referred to arbitration. The normal terms of an arbitration clauses requires that there should be dispute or difference. Now how is the Court to deal with an application of this type when it comes for decision ? The Court has naturally to see what is the dispute and what is the difference and then look at the arbitration clause to find out if it falls within its scope. Therefore, the Court has necessarily to look both at the arbitration clause as well as the particular dispute or difference which is specified in the application under S. 34. Normally when the case is very obvious, the dispute or difference is also obvious and there is no difficulty in such cases. Whenever there is a conflict regarding the very existence of the dispute or difference, then the objector filing the said application has to specify what is the dispute and what is the difference and what is the arbitration clause. In this particular application neither the dispute or difference nor indeed the reason for the matter being referred to arbitration is set out in the application for stay.
6. Learned counsel for the applicant states that the matter should be stayed because the amount is not due. Still, the mere statement that it is not due is not sufficient. The question that requires consideration is why it is not due ? The difference or dispute between the parties would arise out of the reasons for nonpayment. If that difference which has arisen for non-payment is referable to arbitration only then the matter can be said to fall within the arbitration clause and then the Court will have to consider whether it is a suitable case for stay. In the absence of particulars and in the absence of specifications, the Court is unable to find out if the matter falls within the arbitration clause and has necessarily to reject the application for stay.
7. In dealing with the matter I have had the advantage of considering several reported judgements such as the judgement of this Court in National Research Development Corporation of India v. Bhupal Mining Works etc., 1973 Delhi LT 37 and the judgement of Punjab and Haryana High Court in Daman Anand v. Hira Lal, AIR 1974 Punj and Har 232 and the judgements mentioned therein as well as the judgement of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Birla Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills Ltd., AIR 1967 SC 688.
8. In the judgements mentioned earlier, i.e, Punjab and Delhi judgements, reference has been made to the necessity for stating the exact difference and exact dispute in the application itself and in fact reference has been made to the judgement of Grover, J. in Dwarka Nath Kapur v. Rameshwar Nath, (1966) 68 Pun LR (D) 91 where it was held that if the difference or dispute is not specified in the application under S. 34 then the application should be rejected in limine. I do not go so far. I feel the Court can in its discretion allow the applicant to specify the matter to be referred to arbitration even if not initially clearly stated in the application for stay. However, the party applying for stay should ordinarily be able to state in the application for stay the exact reasons why stay of the suit is prayed for. I am hence prepared to agree to the view that the difference or dispute should be quite obvious to the Court when deciding the question of stay, and when it is not obvious that there is such a dispute or difference or where such dispute or difference does not fall within the scope of the arbitration clause then the stay has to be refused.
9. With regard to the question whether a dispute of this type, i.e non-payment of price of goods is a referable dispute, the judgement of Shah, J. as he then was in the Supreme Court in the case just cited above is very plain and states that the non-payment of price is not a dispute under or arising out of a Contract. As I have said a dispute or difference requires the statement of a proposition and a denial thereof by the Page: 67other side. As the existence of such a dispute or difference is not alleged or proved or even pointed out from any documentary material or contemporary dealings between the parties, I come to the conclusion that this suit cannot be stayed and I accordingly reject the application for stay with costs.
10. The Suit No. 655/76 may now be listed before the Deputy Registrar for receiving the written statement. Time for filing the same is extended to 15th September, 1978 which is also the date on which the matter will be listed.
Application dismissed.
Alert