- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S. Security And Finance (P.) Ltd. v. Chandan Singh And Others
1. M/s. Security and Finance Private Limited, the appellant herein, filed an application in the Court of the Sub-Judge, Ist Class, Delhi, under Section 14 of the Indian Arbitration Act, 1940 (hereinafter referred the Act) for directing the arbitrator to file his award into Court and for making the award as rule of the Court. In pursuance of this application, the Court directed arbitrator to file the award and after the same was filed, issued notices to both the parties of the filing of the award. The respondents filed their objections, one of the objections being that the award was based upon a unilateral reference to the arbitrator made by one of the parties to the dispute and that, therefore, the arbitrator had no jurisdiction to enter upon the reference. This objection was upheld by the learned Sub-Judge and the application filed by the appellant was dismissed. The appellant has filed the present appeal against the said judgment of the learned Sub-Judge.
2. Admittedly, the reference to the arbitrator was made only by one of the parties to the dispute, namely, the appellant herein, and the respondents did not join in the reference. It is now well settled that such a unilateral reference does not confer any jurisdiction on the arbitrator to enter upon the reference and that the proper course for the party who wants the dispute to be referred to the arbitration is to file an application under Section 20 of the Act. This rule, however, is subject to one exception, namely, that even if the reference to the arbitrator was made in the first instance only by one of the parties and the other party had not joined in the reference, but if the other party, subsequently submitted to the jurisdiction of the arbitrator, then the arbitrator would get jurisdiction to enter upon the reference notwithstanding the fact that the reference in the first instance was a unilateral reference. The question, therefore, for consideration in this case is whether the respondents or any one of them had submitted to the jurisdiction of the arbitrator even though they did not join in the reference made to the arbitrator by the appellant. According to the proceedings of the arbitrator, which have not been challenged before me, notices were issued by the arbitrator to the appellant and the respondents to appear before him on 16-5-63. On that date, counsel for the appellant-company was present and the first respondent Chandan Singh was also present along with his Advocate Shri Harish Chander. The second respondent was not present nor was he represented by counsel. A copy of the appellant's statement of claim was handed over to respondent No. 1 and the case was adjourned to 31-5-63 for filing the written statement of the first respondent. Neither the first respondent nor his counsel, however, appeared before the arbitrator either on 31-5-63 or subsequently and the arbitrator proceeded ex parte against both the respondents. The first respondent having appeared before the arbitrator on 16-5-63 did not challenge the jurisdiction of the arbitrator to enter upon the reference. He only wanted time for filing the written statement and time was given to him till 31-5-63. In my view, this amounted to the submission by the first respondent to the jurisdiction of the arbitrator. Although he did not participate in the further proceedings before the arbitrator, it cannot be said that he did not submit to the jurisdiction of the arbitrator. A person having submitted to the jurisdiction may choose to remain ex parte for various reasons and once both the parties submit to the jurisdiction of the arbitrator, it confers valid jurisdiction upon the arbitrator to enter upon the reference and it is immaterial whether any of them participates in the subsequent proceedings of the arbitrator.
3. The rule laid down by H.R Khanna, J. (as his Lordship then was) in Dewan Amolak Singh v. Lajpal, (1966) 2 Delhi LT 100, in my view, applies to the facts of the present case. The present case is, therefore taken out of the ambit of the rule laid down by the Supreme Court in Seth Thawardas Pherumal v. Union Of India, AIR 1955 SC 468 or the rule laid down by a Full Bench of this Court in F.A.O No. 139-D/62 (P.C Aggarwal… v. Banwari Lal Kotiya…) decided on 10-11-71. The learned Subordinate Judge, in my view, failed to appreciate the distinction between the facts in Thawardas Pherumal's case and the facts in the present case and he was, therefore, wrong in applying the rule laid down in Thawardas Pherumal's case to the present case and dismissing the application filed by the appellant.
4. The judgment of the learned Subordinate Judge is set aside and the case is remanded for considering the other objections raised by the respondents. Since, however, the second respondent did not appear before the arbitrator at any time, it cannot be said that he had submitted to the jurisdiction of the arbitrator. Therefore, the award of the arbitrator cannot be enforced against the second respondent. The appeal is, therefore, partly allowed. There shall be no order as to costs.
5. Appeal partly allowed.
Alert