Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vijay Singh v. State Of U.P.

Allahabad High Court
Mar 16, 2005
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 26.1.2005, the applicant was alleged to have put up a banner in front of a statue of Ambedkar bearing slogans such as “Baba Saheb Ambedkar Amar Rahen,” “Ambedkar Pradesh Zindabad,” “Pak Rashtrapati Mohd. Ali Jinnah Amar Rahen,” and “Desh Ka Loktantra Murdabad.” The banner was issued in the name of another person, Amit Kumar Jatav, described as ‘Purva Pratyashi, Lok Sabha.’ The applicant was also accused of shouting these slogans and distributing pamphlets that suggested political statements including references to Jinnah, the partition of India, and the demand for Ambedkar Pradesh. Additionally, the applicant was carrying a green flag with a moon and stars. These actions were alleged to have prejudicially affected the integrity of the nation, leading to his custody. The case was registered as Case Crime No. 16 of 2005 under section 153-B of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) at PS Civil Lines, District Meerut.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the applicant’s actions and slogans constituted an offence under section 153-B of the IPC, which deals with promoting enmity between different groups on grounds of religion, race, place of birth, residence, language, etc.?
  2. Whether the applicant’s conduct amounted to prejudicially affecting the integrity of the nation?
  3. Whether the applicant was entitled to bail considering the nature of the offence and the circumstances of the case?

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The slogans and actions were the rantings of a frustrated individual and did not demonstrate an intent to dissolve the country.
  • The applicant’s statement about Jinnah being made Prime Minister to prevent partition echoed historical suggestions by Mahatma Gandhi and should not be construed as inciting hatred or disharmony.
  • The slogans, pamphlets, and banners did not amount to written or spoken representations likely to cause disharmony or prejudice the country’s integrity.
  • Section 95 of the Penal Code advises against taking cognizance of acts that no reasonable person would complain about, implying the conduct was not serious enough for prosecution.
  • The applicant had been in custody for over a month and a half with no likelihood of early trial conclusion, justifying bail.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court acknowledged the allegations against the applicant involving slogans and pamphlets that purportedly affected national integrity. However, it considered the possibility that the applicant’s statements were expressions of frustration rather than a genuine threat to the nation’s unity. The court noted the historical context of similar suggestions by Mahatma Gandhi regarding Jinnah. It also referenced section 95 of the Penal Code, which discourages prosecution for acts that no reasonable person would find objectionable. Without commenting on the merits of the case, the court found that the applicant’s conduct did not clearly amount to an offence warranting continued detention, especially given the prolonged custody and uncertain trial timeline.

Holding and Implications

The court granted bail to the applicant, Vijay Singh, involved in Case Crime No. 16 of 2005 under section 153-B of the IPC, directing his release upon furnishing a personal bond and two sureties to the satisfaction of the concerned court.

This decision directly affects the parties by allowing the applicant’s release on bail but does not establish any new legal precedent or broader implications beyond the specific facts of the case.

Show all summary ...

Amar Saran, J.:— Heard learned Counsel for the parties and perused the papers.

2. The allegation against the applicant were that on 26.1.2005 he was putting up a banner in front of a statute of Ambedkar on which slogans were written like “Baba Saheb Amedkar Amar Rahen, ‘Ambedkar Pradesh Zindabad’, ‘Pak Rashtrapati Mohd. Ali Jinnah Amar Rahen’, ‘Desh Ka Loktantra Murdabad.’ The banner was issued in the name of another person, Amit Kumar Jatav, styled as ‘Purva Pratyashi, Lok Sabha’. The applicant is also alleged to have shouted the aforesaid slogans and he had pamphlets which he was distributing and in this manner the integrity of the nation was said to have been prejudicially affected and the applicant was taken into custody. The applicant was also carrying green flag which had moon and stars on its right corner and in his other hand he had pamphlets stating that by not making Shere-Hind Jinnah Saheb the Prime Minister, the country was divided and Pakistan was given and manuwadis treated the dalits as slaves and some other slogans for making Ambedkar Pradesh and making it part of the Pakistan etc. were also recited.

3. It is contended that the allegations against the applicant of ranting appears to be an act of a frustrated man and it cannot be said that if a person raises a slogan that if Jinnah had been the Prime Minister of India at the time of Independence, then the partition of the country could have been averted. It is urged that this could not be definitely said that the applicant was interested in dissolution of the country. The offence under section 153-B, IPC is only punishable upto 3 years.

4. It is contended by the learned Counsel for the applicant that the aforesaid allegations disclose the rantings and ravings of a wholly frustrated man against the Page: 217system and if a person out of a wrong ideological understanding merely suggests that Jinnah should have been made the Prime Minister of India as that would have saved the country from being partitioned, this would only amount to echoing the suggestions of Mahatma Gandhi who had also tried to persuade the then national leaders to accept Jinnah as their head in order to prevent the partition of the country and the aforesaid slogans, pamphlets and banners could certainly not be construed as spoken or written representation which is likely to cause disharmony or feelings of hatred towards the other community, or which were in any manner prejudicial to the integrity of the country. It is further urged that under section 95 of the Penal Code, there is a specific exhortation not to take cognizance of acts which causes such harm which no man of ordinary sense and temper would complain of. It is further mentioned that for the said offence the applicant is in jail for a month and 20 days since 26.1.2005 and there is no likelihood of the trial being concluded at an early date.

5. In this view of the matter, without making any comment on the merits of the case, I direct that the applicant, Vijay Singh, involved in Case Crime No. 16 of 2005, under section 153-B of IPC, PS Civil Lines, District Meerut, shall be released on bail on his furnishing a personal bond and two sureties each in the like amount to the satisfaction of the Court concerned.

Bail Granted.