Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Major Singh v. Presiding Officer, Electidon Tribunal (A.D.C). Sangrur And Others

Punjab & Haryana High Court
May 24, 2010
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary: Appeal from Order of Election Tribunal (Addl. Deputy Commissioner), Sangrur

Factual and Procedural Background

The matter arises from an election to constitute the Gram Panchayat Bushera held on 26.5.2008, in which nine Panches were elected including the present appellant (Major Singh) and the five persons who later filed the election petition (Harpal Singh, Zila Singh, Sukhdev Singh, Tarsem Singh and Lajjo Devi). A meeting to elect the Sarpanch was convened on 20.7.2008 in which Major Singh was elected as Sarpanch.

On 28.7.2008, the five petitioners filed a writ petition (C.W.P No. 13195 of 2008) seeking mandamus to direct respondents to hold a meeting to elect the Sarpanch and to declare Harpal Singh as Sarpanch; that writ was disposed of on 29.7.2008 by reference to earlier orders in Gurmeet Singh. After disposal of the writ, an election petition was filed on 10.9.2008 through an Advocate before the Election Tribunal. Notices were issued and the appellant filed a written statement dated 21.10.2008 raising preliminary objection that the election petition was time-barred and not maintainable; the petition was also contested on merits. The petitioners filed replication on 11.12.2008. The Election Tribunal allowed the election petition by its order dated 30.12.2008.

Aggrieved, the returned candidate Major Singh filed the present appeal. The appeal was admitted on 16.1.2009 and listed for hearing; the operation of the impugned order was stayed. The present judgment records the parties' arguments, considers statutory provisions (Sections 76, 77, 80 and 81 of the Punjab State Election Commission Act, 1994), examines precedents relied upon by the parties, and decides the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the election petition filed on 10.9.2008 was barred by limitation under Section 76 of the Punjab State Election Commission Act, 1994 (45 days from the date of election of the returned candidate), and consequently whether the Election Tribunal was bound to dismiss it under Section 80 of the Act.
  2. Whether an election petition presented through an Advocate (i.e., not presented by the election petitioner personally) complies with the requirement of presentation under the governing law (and therefore whether an election petition filed through an Advocate is maintainable).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The election petition is time-barred under Section 76 of the Punjab State Election Commission Act, 1994 because limitation is 45 days from the date of election of the returned candidate; the election petition filed on 10.9.2008 was beyond this period.
  • The election petition was not presented by the election petitioner personally but was presented through an Advocate; therefore it did not comply with the requirement in Section 76 and is not maintainable. This point was supported by reliance on decisions including G.V. Sreerama Reddy and a decision of this Court (Gurlal Singh).
  • The Election Tribunal did not frame the issue of limitation in terms of Section 81 of the Act and did not dismiss the petition under Section 80 despite the alleged non-compliance.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The Court below's order should not be set aside on technicalities; the appellant does not enjoy a majority of Panches (a factual point raised in support of upholding the Tribunal's order).
  • As to presentation, it was submitted that the election petition was filed along with the petitioners through the Advocate on 10.9.2008 and that the Election Tribunal erred in not recording the petitioners' presence (i.e., respondents contended that the filing was acceptable and that factual recording by the Tribunal was flawed).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gurmeet Singh (order dated July 23, 2008) (this Court) Directions for conduct of the first meeting of Gram Panchayat and safeguards (police not to arrest, security to complaining Panch, secret ballot if demanded, presiding officers not to change notified date/time/venue, ensure Panchayat Secretary presence, maintain attendance register, Deputy Commissioners to act as observers and maintain registers for complaints). The writ petition filed by the petitioners was disposed of by reference to the directions in Gurmeet Singh; those directions form part of the factual/procedural background referenced by the Court.
Ashok Shankar Gholap v. Krishnarao H. Deshmukh, AIR 1980 Bombay 224 Non-compliance with statutory presentation requirements (example given of petition filed on last day without requisite copies) and non-compliance with the corresponding provision in Representation of the People Act. Applied as authority that non-compliance with presentation/formatting requirements goes to the root of the petition and disentitles the petitioner; used to support the proposition that failure to comply with statutory presentation requirements invalidates the petition.
Ajit Singh v. Nusrat Ali Khan, 1997 (4) R.C.R (Civil) 460 Illustration on filing deadlines when limitation expires on a day when filing may or may not be possible (court's closure/registry open issues). Referred to for the proposition that strict adherence to limitation rules is required (the Court noted the decision's holding about filing on the next working day only where appropriate factual circumstances exist).
G.V. Sreerama Reddy v. Returning Officer, 2009 (5) R.A.J 36 : 2009 (3) R.C.R (C) 937 (Supreme Court) Held that an election petition must be presented by the candidate himself and not through an Advocate; presentation by Advocate is violative of statutory provision (Representation of the People Act context cited). Relied upon by the Court to hold that presentation of an election petition through an Advocate is not compliant with the statutory requirement and therefore disentitles the petitioner — supporting the view that the Election Tribunal's order permitting the petition was illegal.
Gurlal Singh v. Presiding Officer, Election Tribunal, Block Lehra, District Sangrur (FAO No. 1012 of 2010, decided 26.3.2010) Used as local authority on presentation/maintainability of election petitions (as relied upon by appellant's counsel). Relied upon by the appellant; the judgment is cited by the Court as part of the authorities supporting the position that presentation should be by the candidate personally and that non-compliance affects maintainability.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by first recalling and reproducing the relevant statutory provisions (Sections 76, 77, 80 and 81 of the Punjab State Election Commission Act, 1994). The Court emphasized two principal statutory requirements:

  1. Limitation: Section 76 requires an election petition to be presented within 45 days from the date of election of the returned candidate. The Court stated the settled position that there is no scope for extension of this period and that failure to file within this statutory period requires the Election Tribunal to dismiss the petition in view of Section 80.
  2. Presentation: The Court considered the contention that the election petition must be presented by the candidate personally (not through an Advocate). The Court relied on precedent (G.V. Sreerama Reddy) holding that presentation by the candidate himself is required and that presentation through an Advocate violates the relevant statutory requirement (as analogous under the Representation of the People Act).

The Court then applied these principles to the record before it: the election petition had been filed on 10.9.2008 whereas the Tribunal's record indicated the election was held on 20.7.2008; thus, on the face of the record the petition was beyond the 45-day period. Further, the petition had been filed through an Advocate and the Tribunal had not recorded the petitioners' presence. The Court observed that the Tribunal had not even framed the issue of limitation (an omission the Court characterized as violative of Section 81, which requires that election petitions be tried in accordance with the procedure of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908).

Drawing on the cited authorities (Ashok Shankar Gholap; Ajit Singh; G.V. Sreerama Reddy), the Court concluded that non-compliance with the prescribed presentation and limitation requirements goes to the root of the petition and disentitles the petitioners. Because the Tribunal failed to address the limitation point and allowed the petition notwithstanding the apparent non-compliance with presentation requirements, the Court found the Tribunal's order to be patently illegal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed and the impugned order dated 30.12.2008 of the Election Tribunal is set aside. Appeal allowed.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the order of the Election Tribunal that had allowed the election petition is set aside by this Court.
  • The Court based its decision on statutory non-compliance (limitation under Section 76 and presentation requirements) and on the Tribunal's failure to frame and decide the limitation issue in accordance with Section 81 and the procedural rules; the decision does not claim to lay down any novel principle beyond applying the cited authorities and statutory provisions.
  • No broader new precedent is claimed or articulated in this opinion beyond the application of existing authorities and the statutory text; the decision operates to reverse the specific Tribunal order in this case.
Note: This summary is strictly confined to the material and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not add factual or legal information beyond what the Court recorded in that opinion.
Show all summary ...

Rakesh Kumar Jain, J. (Oral):— This appeal is directed against order of learned Election Tribunal (Addl. Deputy Commissioner), Sangrur, dated 30.12.2008, whereby an election petition filed at the instance of five persons, namely, Harpal Singh, Zila Singh, Sukhdev Singh, Tarsem Singh and Lajjo Devi (respondents herein) has been allowed.

2. Election to constitute Gram Panchayat Bushera, was held on 26.5.2008 in which total nine Panches were elected including the election petitioners and the appellant herein. In order to elect Sarpanch, a meeting was convened on 20.7.2008 in which appellant Major Singh was elected. All the petitioners filed C.W.P No. Page: 93513195 of 2008 on 28.7.2008 before this Court seeking a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents to hold the meeting of Panches to elect the Sarpanch and to declare Harpal Singh (petitioner No. 2) as Sarpanch without any delay as he is having majority of five Panches, whereas the opposite group has the support of four Panches, but the official respondents are not holding the meeting to elect the Sarpanch at the instance of Ruling Party and on that pretext, no meeting was held on 20.7.2008 as the Election Officers are dilly-dallying the meeting in order to elect Major Singh clandestinely. The said writ petition was disposed of by this Court on 29.7.2008 with the following order:—

“This petition is disposed of in view of order dated July 23, 2008 passed in C.W.P No. 12694 of 2008 entitled Gurmeet Singh v. State of Punjab Copy dasti on payment of usual charges”.

3. In the case of Gurmeet Singh (Supra), this Court had issued following directions:—

“1. The police shall not arrest any Panch until the first meeting of the Gram Panchayat has been held and the Sarpanch has been elected.

2. In case any Panch demands security or complains of harassment by the opposite group, his complaint should be recorded in the daily Diary at the police station and full security should be provided to him;

3. If any Panch at the meeting demands that the election of Sarpanch should be conducted by a secret ballot, then a procedure for election through secret ballot shall be adopted.

4. Presiding Officers should not change the date, time and venue of the first meeting once these have been notified to all the members of the Panchayat. If the first meeting of the Gram Panchayat concludes without electing the Sarpanch or is adjourned for lack of quorum, in such an event, the notice of the adjourned meeting should be sufficient notice of stay 2 or 3 days.

5. Presiding Officers should ensure the presence of the Panchayat Secretary in the meeting.

6. Presiding Officers should maintain an attendance register to show the names of Panches who attended the meeting.

7. The Deputy Commissioners of each district shall act as observers to ensure that first meeting of the Gram Panchayat and the election of Sarpanches takes places in a free and impartial manner, without any panch facing any kind of threat, pressure or inducement. A register should be maintained by Deputy Commissioners to receive and decide complaints, in the same manner as Election Observers in the State Assembly elections. In other words, the mechanism for redressal of complaints should be an effective one, in order to instill confidence in the members of Gram Panchayat”.

4. After disposal of the writ petition, the writ petitioners filed the election petition on 10.9.2008 through an Advocate as is apparent from the record of the Election Tribunal. The English translation of the order which has been recorded in vernacular reads as under:—

“This election petition has been filed through counsel for the election petitioners. Counsel for the petitioners is heard. Be registered. Notices be issued to summon the respondents. Summons should also accompany a copy of the election petition. File be produced after service of the respondents on 26.9.2008

10.9.2008

Presiding Officer,

Election Tribunal,

(A.D.C) Sangrur)”

5. In the election petition, notice to appear was issued to appellant Major Singh, who filed his written statement dated 21.10.2008 in which preliminary objection was taken to the effect that the election petition is time barred and is not maintainable in the present form. Besides, the election petition was also contested on merits.

6. The election petitioners filed replication on 11.12.2008 denying the averments made in the written statement and reiterating the stand taken in the election petition alleging that the election petition is in time and maintainable. However, the election petition was allowed by order dated 30.12.2008

7. Aggrieved against the order of the Election Tribunal, the returned candidate Major Singh filed the present appeal which was admitted on 16.1.2009 and was ordered to be heard within six months but in the meantime, operation of the impugned Page: 936order was stayed.

8. After admission, this appeal is listed for regular hearing. Record of this has also been requisitioned.

9. Learned counsel for the appellant has made two pronged attack while assailing the order of Election Tribunal i.e (i) that the petition is barred by limitation and (ii) the election petition has not been presented in accordance with law. To buttress his arguments, learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that limitation to file election petition as provided under Section 76 of the Punjab State Election Commission Act, 1994 (for short, the Act) is 45 days from the date of election of the returned candidate which cannot be extended in any case. It is submitted that there is an endorsement on the record of the Election Tribunal that election was held on 20.7.2008, whereas the election petition was filed on 10.9.2008, which is beyond limitation. It is also apparent from the record that no issues have been framed in terms of Section 81 of the Act nor the election petition has been dismissed by the Tribunal in terms of Section 76 read with Section 80 of the Act. In this connection, learned counsel has relied upon a decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of Ashok Shankar Gholap v. Krishnarao H. Deshmukh AIR 1980 Bombay 224 and a decision of this Court in the case of Ajit Singh v. Nusrat Ali Khan, 1997 (4) R.C.R (Civil) 460.

10. In respect of the second argument raised by learned counsel for the appellant, it is submitted that in case of election, provisions of the Act have to be strictly construed. Since the election petition has not been presented by a candidate/election petitioner himself and has been presented through an Advocate, therefore, it could not be presumed to have been duly presented before the Court below in terms of Section 76 of the Act. In this regard, learned counsel has placed reliance on a decision of the Supreme Court in the case G.V Sreerama Reddy v. Returning Officer 2009 (5) R.A.J 36 : 2009 (3) R.C.R (C) 937 and a decision of this Court passed in FAO No. 1012 of 2010 Gurlal Singh v. Presiding Officer, Election Tribunal, Block Lehra, District Sangrur decided on 26.3.2010

11. On the other hand, Mr. J.S Bhandohal, learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 3 has submitted that this Court should not set aside the well reasoned order of the Tribunal merely on technicalities as the appellant does not enjoy the majority of Panches. It is further submitted that insofar as the presentation of the election petition is concerned, it was filed alongwith the petitioners through the Advocate on 10.9.2008, but the learned Election Tribunal has erred in not recording their presence.

12. I have heard both the learned counsel for the parties and have perused the record with their assistance.

13. Before adverting to the rival contentions of learned counsel for the parties, a look at the relevant provisions of Act is necessary and for that purpose, Sections 76, 77, and 80 and 81 are reproduced below:—

Sec 76. Presentation of petition—

(1) An election petition may be presented on one or more of the grounds specified in sub section (1) of Section 89 to the Election Tribunal by any candidate to such election or by any elector within a period of 45 days from the date of election of the returned candidate or if there are more than one returned candidates at the election and there are different dates of their election, then the later of these dates shall be taken into account for this purpose.

(2) Every Election petition shall be accompanied by as many copies thereof, as there are respondents mentioned in the petition and every such copy shall be attested by the petitioner under his own signatures to be a true copy of the petition.

Sec 77. Parties to the petition.—A petitioner shall join as respondent to his petition--

(a) where he, in addition to claiming declaration that the election of all or any of the returned candidates is void, claims a further declaration that he himself or any other candidate has been duly elected, all the contesting candidates and where no such further declaration is claimed, all the returned candidates; and

(b) any other candidate against whom allegation of any corrupt practice is made in the petition;

Sec. 80 Trial of Election petitions.—

(1) The Election Tribunal shall dismiss an election petition which does not comply with the Page: 937provisions of Section 76 or section 77 or section 103.

(2) Where more than one election petitions are presented to the election Tribunal in respect of the same matter, the Presiding Officer of the Election Tribunal, may, in his discretion, try them separately or in one or more groups.

(3) Any candidate not already a respondent shall, upon application made by him to the election Tribunal within fourteen days from the date of commencement of the trial of the election petition and subject to any order as to security for costs which may be made by the Election Tribunal, be entitled to be joined as a respondent.

(4) The Election Tribunal may, upon such terms as a costs and otherwise, as it may deem fit, allow to particulars of any corrupt practice alleged in the petition to be amended or amplified in such manner, as may in its opinion be necessary for ensuring a fair and effective trial of the petition, but shall not allow any amendment of the petition which will have the effect of introducing particulars of a corrupt practice which has not been previously alleged in the petition.

(5) The trial of an election petition shall, so far as is practicable consistently with the interest of justice in respect of the trial be continued from day to day until the conclusion, unless the Election Tribunal finds the adjournment of the trial beyond the following day to be necessary for reasons to be recorded in writing.

(6) Every election petition shall be tried as expeditiously as possible and every endeavor shall be made to conclude the trial within a period of six months from the date on which the election petition is presented to the election Tribunal for trial.

Sec. 81. Procedure before the Election Tribunal.—

(1) Subject to the provisions of this Act and of the rules made thereunder, every election petition shall be tried by the election Tribunal, as nearly as may be, in accordance with the procedure contained in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (Central Act 5 of 1908) to the trial of suits;

Provided that the election Tribunal shall have the discretion to refuse, for reasons to be recorded in writing, to examine any witness or witnesses, if it is of the opinion that the evidence of such witness or witnesses is not material for the decision of the election petition or that the party tendering such witness or witnesses is doing so on frivilous grounds or with a view to delay the proceedings of the election petition;

(2) The provisions of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (Central Act 1 of 1872) shall, subject to the provisions of this Act, be deemed to apply in all respects to the trial of an election petition”.

14. Taking up the first argument with regard to limitation, it is now well settled that the election petition has to be filed within 45 days from the date of election of the returned candidate and there is no scope for any extension of time. If the election petition is not filed within period of limitation, then there is no alternative with the Election Tribunal but to dismiss the election petition in view of Section 80 of the Act. Similarly, if the election petition has to be presented by a candidate, namely the election petitioner and not the Advocate and if the election petition is not presented by the election petitioner, then it is violation of Section 76 read with Section 80 of the Act which disentitles the election petitioner as it goes to the root of the case as held in the case of Ashok Shankar Gholap (Supra). In the said case, the petition was filed on the last day of limitation without requisite number of copies, which were kept in Board Department and were handed over to the designated officer of the Court and objection in that regard was removed. It was held that there was non compliance with Section 81(3) of Representation of the People Act, 1951. Similarly, in the case of Ajit Singh (Supra), election petition could not be filed being Saturday. It was held that if the Court is closed on the day when limitation expired, it could be filed on the next working day of the Court, but as on Saturday, High Court Registry was open, the petition should have been filed on that day.

15. Insofar as the presentation of the election petition is concerned, in G.V Sreerama Reddy's case (Supra), the Supreme Court has held that the election petition has to be presented by the candidate himself and not through the Advocate, failing which it is violative of Section 81 of the Representation of People Act, 1951.

16. In view of the above, I find that the order Page: 938passed by the Court below is patently illegal specially when the Court below has not even framed the issue of limitation which is violative of Section 81 of the Act which provides that the election petition has to be filed in accordance with the procedure contained in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.

17. In view of the above, the present appeal is allowed and the impugned order is set aside.

Appeal allowed.