Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Purushotam Mantri Petitioner v. Vinod Tandon Alias Hari Nath Tandon

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Jan 30, 2008
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 against the respondent. The respondent was directed to be summoned on July 18, 1991, but could not be served despite multiple attempts through summons and warrants of arrest. Consequently, the respondent was declared a proclaimed offender on July 31, 1998. The petitioner filed several applications for warrants of arrest, which remained unserved. On January 23, 2002, the complaint was dismissed in default by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sirsa, due to the petitioner’s non-appearance. An application for restoration of the complaint was dismissed as not maintainable on March 31, 2005, and this dismissal was upheld by the Additional Sessions Judge, Sirsa, on May 15, 2006. The petitioner challenged these orders in the present petitions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the dismissal of the complaint in default for the petitioner’s non-appearance on one date was justified, considering the respondent had evaded service and was declared a proclaimed offender.
  2. Whether this Court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure has the power to restore a complaint dismissed in default if sufficient cause is shown for non-appearance.
  3. The maintainability of an application for restoration of a complaint dismissed in default by the trial court.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The respondent was declared a proclaimed offender under Sections 82 and 83 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, and despite multiple attempts, the petitioner could not serve him or attach any property as the respondent had none in his name.
  • The complaint was dismissed in default merely because the petitioner did not appear on one hearing date, which was harsh and unjust given the circumstances.
  • Although the application for restoration before the trial court was not maintainable, this Court under Section 482 of the Code can restore the complaint if sufficient cause is shown for non-appearance.
  • Relied on the precedent set in Jitender Bajaj v. State (U.T Chandigarh) and others, 2005 (3) RCR (Crl.) 69, which recognizes the power of this Court to set aside dismissal orders for non-appearance where the magistrate has improperly exercised discretion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jitender Bajaj v. State (U.T Chandigarh) and others, 2005 (3) RCR (Crl.) 69 The Court’s power under Section 482 of the Code to set aside an order of dismissal and acquittal due to non-appearance of the complainant, if the magistrate has not properly exercised discretion. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the dismissal of the complaint in default was unjust and to justify restoration of the complaint since the petitioner’s non-appearance was not intentional and the magistrate’s discretion was not properly exercised.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the facts and found it excessively harsh to dismiss the complaint solely because the petitioner failed to appear on one date, especially when the respondent had been evading service and was declared a proclaimed offender. The Court noted that the petitioner had made multiple efforts to serve the respondent and locate his property, but without success. The Court emphasized that justice should not be dispensed with "closed eyes" and that the petitioner should not be punished for the respondent’s evasions. The Court accepted that the trial court’s dismissal and refusal to restore the complaint were improper. It relied on the precedent in Jitender Bajaj to affirm that under Section 482 of the Code, this Court has the inherent power to restore the complaint if sufficient cause is shown for non-appearance. The non-appearance was found to be unintentional, justifying setting aside the dismissal order and restoring the complaint.

Holding and Implications

The petitions are allowed.

The Court set aside the order dated January 23, 2002, which dismissed the complaint in default, and restored the complaint to its original number. The petitioner was directed to appear before the trial court for further proceedings. The decision directly benefits the petitioner by reinstating the complaint and allowing the matter to proceed on merits. No broader precedent beyond this restoration under Section 482 was established by this decision.

Show all summary ...

Rajesh Bindal, J. — This order will dispose of three Criminal Misc. Nos. 36522-M of 2006, 36524-M of 2006 and 36526-M of 2006 as the common questions of law with similar facts are involved in these petitions.

2. The facts have been extracted from Criminal Misc. No. 36522-M of 2006.

3. The challenge in the present petition is to the order dated January 23, 2002 whereby complaint filed by the petitioner under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (for short “the Act”) was dismissed in default and order March 31, 2005 passed by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sirsa whereby application filed by the petitioner for restoration of the complaint was dismissed as not maintainable. Further challenge is to the order dated May 15, 2006 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge, Sirsa whereby order passed by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sirsa was upheld.

4. Briefly the facts are that petitioner filed complaint under Section 138 of the Act against respondent, who was directed to be summoned vide order dated July 18, 1991. But respondent could not be served through summons and warrants of arrest and ultimately he was declared a proclaimed offender vide order dated July 31, 1998. Thereafter on application of the petitioner, warrants of arrest were issued against respondent several times but the same were received back unserved. However, vide order dated January 23, 2002 passed by Addl. Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sirsa, the complaint was ordered to be dismissed in default, since no one turned up on behalf of the petitioner. Vide order dated March 31, 2005, the application for restoration of the complaint was also dismissed being not maintainable. In revision, order dated March 31, 2005 was upheld by learned Additional Sessions Judge, Sirsa.

5. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that in the complaint case, respondent was declared as proclaimed offender under Sections 82 and 83 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short “the Code”) vide order dated July 31, 1998. Thereafter statement of serving constable was recorded stating therein that the accused did not have any moveable or immoveable property in his name. Vide order dated July 31, 1998, learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sirsa consigned the file to record with the observation that when the presence of accused, who had already been declared as proclaimed offender, cannot be procured by way of attachment of property, the file be put up as and when the accused is produced by the police. However, subsequently on January 23, 2002 the complaint was dismissed in default merely on account of non-appearance of the petitioner on one date.

6. Learned counsel for the petitioner did not dispute that application filed by the petitioner Page: 444before the Court below for recalling the order was not maintainable and accordingly the same was rightly dismissed by the Court below. However, submission is that this Court under section 482 of the Code can certainly direct restoration of the complaint, which was dismissed in default if sufficient reason is found for his non-appearance on the date fixed. For the purpose he has relied upon the observations made by this Court in Jitender Bajaj v. State (U.T Chandigarh) and others, 2005 (3) RCR (Crl.) 69 : 2005 Crl.L.J 3136 (P&H), which are reproduced below :

“…………..When the Magistrate, in a summon case, has dismissed the complaint and acquitted the accused due to absence of the complainant on the day of hearing, he cannot later on restore the complaint and set aside the order of acquittal, even if the complainant shows very good reasons for his failure to be present on the day of dismissal of the complaint. In such situation, the only remedy available with the complainant is to file appeal or revision against such order or petition under Section 482 of the Code before this Court for setting aside the said order of dismissal of the complaint and acquittal of the accused on the ground that in the given facts and circumstances, the dismissal of the complaint and acquittal of the accused was not justified or there were sufficient reasons for non-appearance of the complainant before the Court on the date fixed, or the Magistrate has not properly exercised his discretion while not adjourning the complaint and dismissing the same.”

7. If the facts of the present case are examined, it would be too harsh on the petitioner to non-suit him merely for his non-appearance on one date. The Courts are not to dispense justice with closed eyes. Here is a case where the petitioner filed three complaints against respondent but was not able to serve him as he is based in Kolkata. He could not even find details of his property after the respondent was declared as proclaimed offender. However, merely because of his non-appearance on one date, his complaints were dismissed. The net effect of the entire proceedings is that it is the petitioner/complainant who has been punished as against respondent, who had been successfully evading service of summons and appearance before the Court to face trial.

8. In the above factual matrix, I find that the non-appearance of the petitioner/complainant on the date fixed was not intentional accordingly the order dated January 23, 2002 passed by Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sirsa is set aside and the complaint filed by the petitioner is restored to its original number. The petitioner is directed to appear before the Court below on February 29, 2008 for further proceedings.

9. Accordingly, the petitions are allowed.

Petitions allowed.