Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bhagat Singh v. Jagdish Kaur .

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Aug 11, 2010
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition by the tenant challenges the appellate authority's order dated 12.6.2010 directing his eviction from the premises. The respondent filed a petition under Section 13 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949, seeking eviction on grounds of nonpayment of rent, material impairment, and personal necessity for the use and occupation of herself and her son Bhagwant Singh, who required the premises to run his casting business. The tenant tendered the arrears of rent and denied the allegations. The trial proceeded on four issues: entitlement to ejectment, arrears of rent, maintainability of the application, and relief. The Rent Controller initially rejected the respondent's plea, but the appellate authority reversed that finding, prompting this revision petition by the tenant.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the applicant is entitled to ejectment on the grounds mentioned in the petition under Section 13 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949?
  2. Whether the respondent is not in arrears of rent?
  3. Whether the eviction application is maintainable?
  4. What relief is to be granted?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The respondent's personal need for the premises was not established by any material on record.
  • The respondent did not personally testify; only her power of attorney appeared, whose testimony was insufficient to establish personal need.
  • The respondent had a vacant shop nearby, evidenced by photographs placed on record, and sufficient accommodation was available, undermining the claim of necessity.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Atma S. Berar v. Mukhtiar Singh, 2003 (1) Rent Control Reporter 42 The landlord is the best judge of his residential requirements. The court relied on this principle to uphold the respondent's claim of personal need, rejecting the petitioner's argument about available alternative premises.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the pleadings and evidence concerning the respondent's personal need for the premises. It held that the respondent's expressed need for herself and her son to occupy the premises for residential and business purposes fell within the ambit of Section 13(3)(a)(ii) of the Act, which extends protection to family members' needs as well. The court rejected a narrow interpretation that would limit the benefit only to the landlady herself.

The court further rejected the petitioner's contention that the power of attorney's testimony was invalid, reasoning that the son, as the power of attorney holder and the party requiring the premises for business, was competent to testify on the matter.

Regarding the petitioner's claim of alternate vacant premises, the court found the photographic evidence unproven and accepted the appellate authority's view that the alleged vacant shop was merely a corridor. It emphasized that the landlady is the best judge of her residential needs, consistent with the cited Supreme Court precedent.

Holding and Implications

The court dismissed the revision petition, thereby upholding the appellate authority's eviction order against the tenant.

The direct effect is the tenant's eviction from the premises. The decision reaffirms the principle that a landlord's personal need, including that of close family members, is a valid ground for eviction under the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949. No new precedent was established beyond reaffirming existing legal principles.

Show all summary ...

Mahesh Grover, J. — This petition by the tenant is directed against the order of the appellate authority dated 12.6.2010 vide which he has been ordered to be evicted from the premises in question.

2. The respondent filed a petition under Section 13 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) seeking eviction of the petitioner on the grounds of nonpayment of rent, material impairment and that she requires the premises for her own use and occupation and also for the use and occupation of his son Bhagwant Singh who requires it for running the business of casting which he is presently carrying on in the premises occupied by the respondent. The petitioner tendered the arrears of rent, denied the allegations of material impairment as also that of personal necessity. The parties went to trial on the following issues:—

1) Whether the applicant is entitled for ejectment on the grounds mentioned in the petition? OPA

2) Whether the respondent is not in the arrears of rent? OPR

3) Whether the application is not maintainable? OPR

4) Relief.

3. The learned Rent Controller rejected the plea of the respondent-landlady and in appeal the findings were reversed which has led to the filing of the instant revision petition.

4. Learned counsel for the petitioner has addressed his submissions only on the ground on which the personal need of the respondent has been upheld. He has contended that the need of the landlady did not stand established from any material on record. He contended further that she did not step in the witness box and only her power of attorney appeared whose testimony cannot be relied upon to establish the personal need of the landlady. He also contended that it has been proved on record that the respondent was having a vacant shop in the vicinity of Page: 525the demised premises which is reflected from the photographs which are placed on the record as Annexure P-1. He further contended that there is sufficient evidence to show that the respondent had sufficient room for her accommodation.

5. I have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and have perused the material on record.

6. In so far as the plea that the respondent did not require the premises for her own use is concerned, I am of the opinion that there is categoric pleading of the respondent that she requires the demised premises for her own use and also for the use of her son Bhagwant Singh who requires it for running the business of casting. The need of the landlady if coterminous with that of the family members i.e her son, daughter or any other such related member, then the benefit of the provisions of Section 13(3)(a)(ii) of the Act would certainly be extended to them also. The court cannot adopt a constrictive approach to determine the need of the landlady so as to restrict the benefit of the said provisions of law only to herself and not to her family members. Therefore, the plea of the learned counsel for the petitioner on this score has to be rejected.

7. The next contention which has been raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner is that the landlady did not depose before the Rent Controller and that the testimony of her power of attorney holder could not be construed to be a valid testimony to establish the need of the landlady. This contention too has to be rejected for the simple reason that the power of attorney holder was none other than the son of the landlady for whose personal need the petition had been filed and he being the best judge of his need was very well competent to depose on such an aspect of the matter.

8. The next contention that has been raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner is that the respondent had a vacant shop in the vicinity and there were sufficient rooms available for her in the residential area where her son could carry on the business of casting. I am afraid this contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner has to be rejected. Although the photographs were produced on record but the same have not been proved. The appellate authority had returned a finding that it appeared to be a mere corridor and in any eventuality the landlady is the best judge of her own needs and thus the premises which she requires can hardly be expected of her to carry on the business of casting in the area where she is residing. The Supreme Court in Atma S. Berar v. Mukhtiar Singh., 2003 (1) Rent Control Reporter 42, held that the landlord is the best judge of his residential requirements.

Thus, looking from any angle, there is no merit in the revision petition and the same is dismissed.

Petition dismissed.