Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Smt. Sangeeta Devi v. State Of U.P & Ors.

Allahabad High Court
May 21, 2008
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This intra Court appeal arises from the judgment of the Hon'ble Single Judge dated 7-4-2008 which dismissed Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 17785 of 2008. The writ petition sought quashing of the District Magistrate, Kushinagar's order dated 30-3-2008 withdrawing the petitioner-appellant's financial and administrative powers under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 ("the Act").

A preliminary enquiry under Rule 4 of the Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans, Up-Pradhans and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1997 ("the Rules") was ordered and the District Social Welfare Officer, Kushinagar was nominated to conduct that enquiry by order dated 3-10-2007. The enquiry officer submitted a report on 22-12-2007 which, in the preliminary view, found various alleged irregularities against the petitioner-appellant to be prima facie correct. Notices were served on the appellant on 14-1-2008 and 14-2-2008 under Section 95(1)(g); the appellant filed a show cause on 26-2-2008. The District Magistrate, being satisfied with the preliminary enquiry report, passed the impugned order on 30-3-2008 withdrawing the appellant's financial and administrative powers and constituting a three-member Committee of the Gram Panchayat to exercise those powers until the appellant is exonerated in a final enquiry.

The Single Judge dismissed the writ petition primarily on the ground that the sufficiency of evidence and the appellant's defence could not be examined at the preliminary stage since the order was an interim measure pending a formal enquiry. The present appeal challenges that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order passed under the first proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 withdrawing financial and administrative powers of a Pradhan/Up-Pradhan on the basis of a preliminary enquiry is valid.
  2. Whether principles of natural justice require that the Pradhan/Up-Pradhan be given notice or an opportunity to be heard or be supplied the preliminary enquiry report before the State (or delegated authority) withdraws financial and administrative powers under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g).
  3. Whether non-supply (prior to the impugned order) of the preliminary enquiry report to the appellant vitiates the order withdrawing powers under Section 95(1)(g).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that she was not given sufficient opportunity to submit an effective reply to the charges.
  • The appellant also contended that a copy of the enquiry report was not provided to her, and on that basis the impugned order withdrawing her financial and administrative powers should be set aside.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the State-respondents' specific submissions beyond noting that the Court heard Sri O.N. Rai, learned Standing Counsel for the State-respondents and perused the record.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Radhili Devi v. The District Magistrate, Padrauna, 1997 (1) AWC 251 : 1997 All LJ 1065 The proposition that no opportunity of hearing is necessary before resorting to an interim measure under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) — analogous to suspension of a government servant; opportunity to be afforded at the stage of regular enquiry before final order. The Court endorsed this view and relied on it to hold that the preliminary enquiry and consequent interim withdrawal of powers do not require the procedural opportunities that are mandated at the stage of a formal enquiry.
Moti Lal v. District Magistrate, Lalitpur, 2003 (1) UPLBEC 736 : 2003 All LJ 1358 That while holding a preliminary enquiry under Rules 3 & 4 and the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) the Enquiry Officer is not obliged to give opportunity to the person facing charges nor conduct the preliminary enquiry in his presence. The Court adopted and endorsed the Division Bench's view to support the conclusion that preliminary enquiry does not require giving an opportunity to the appellant and therefore the impugned interim order was not vitiated for lack of a hearing at that stage.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds from the statutory text of Section 95(1)(g) of the Act and the Rules framed under the Act (specifically Rules 3, 4 and 5 of the 1997 Rules). The Court extracted and considered the proviso to Section 95(1)(g), which authorizes cessation of financial and administrative powers of a Pradhan or Up-Pradhan where a preliminary enquiry prima facie finds financial or other irregularities; those powers are to be exercised by a Committee of three members until final exoneration.

The Court noted that the power conferred on the State Government by Section 95(1)(g) had been delegated to District Magistrates by notification dated 30-4-1997 under Section 96-A of the Act. The Rules provide for a two-stage process: (i) a preliminary enquiry (Rule 4) to determine whether there is a prima facie case for a formal enquiry and (ii) if prima facie involvement is found, a formal enquiry under Rule 5 (and Rule 6 prescribing detailed procedure) in which the accused is to be supplied articles of charge, lists of documents and witnesses and be given opportunity to file defence and be heard.

From a plain reading of the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) read with Rule 4, the Court concluded that a preliminary enquiry is a fact-finding exercise and does not contemplate requiring notice or an opportunity to be heard to the Pradhan/Up-Pradhan at that preliminary stage. Only when the preliminary enquiry report shows prima facie involvement does Rule 5 require initiation of a formal enquiry with specific procedural safeguards.

Applying this framework to the facts, the Court observed that the District Social Welfare Officer conducted the preliminary enquiry, submitted a report on 22-12-2007 finding prima facie irregularities, notices were then served, a show cause was filed by the appellant on 26-2-2008, and the District Magistrate on 30-3-2008—being satisfied with the preliminary enquiry—passed the impugned order withdrawing the appellant's powers and constituting a Committee to exercise those powers.

The Court rejected the appellant's claim that non-supply of the preliminary enquiry report vitiated the order because the appellant did not demonstrate any prejudice caused by non-supply. The Court also observed that the appellant had filed a show cause after receiving notice and had not shown that she had sought a copy of the report before furnishing the show cause. The Court relied on the cited precedents to support its view that no hearing is required at the preliminary enquiry stage and therefore found no violation of natural justice or prescription of law that would warrant interference with the impugned order.

The Court further held that the order under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) is of an interim nature intended to prevent misuse of powers while charges are pending, and therefore upheld the interim withdrawal. The Court nevertheless directed that the formal enquiry under Rule 5 be concluded expeditiously, preferably within three months from production of a certified copy of the order, and cautioned that the enquiry officer or District Magistrate must not be influenced or prejudiced by the Court's observations in this litigation when taking the final decision.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The special appeal is dismissed. The Court upheld the Single Judge's dismissal of the writ petition and sustained the District Magistrate's order dated 30-3-2008 withdrawing the appellant's financial and administrative powers under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the impugned interim order withdrawing the appellant's financial and administrative powers remains in force and a three-member Committee of the Gram Panchayat will exercise those powers until the appellant is exonerated in the final enquiry.
  • The Court ordered that the formal enquiry under Rule 5 of the Rules be completed expeditiously, preferably within three months from production of a certified copy of this order.
  • The Court directed that the enquiry officer or District Magistrate must not be influenced or prejudiced by the Court's observations in this litigation when making the final decision in the formal enquiry.
  • The Court recorded the dismissal of the appeal without costs.
  • The opinion does not indicate that it establishes any new legal precedent beyond endorsing prior decisions on the procedural nature of preliminary enquiries under Section 95(1)(g) and the applicable Rules.

Show all summary ...

1. This is intra Court appeal, under the Rules of the Court arising from the judgment of the Hon'ble Single Judge of this Court dated 7-4-2008 dismissing the petitioner-appellant's Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 17785 of 2008 for quashing the order of the District Magistrate, Kushinagar dated 30-3-2008 whereby the financial and administrative power of the appellant has been suspended under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 (for short the Act).

2. We have heard learned counsel for the appellant and Sri O.N Rai, learned Standing Counsel for the State-respondents and also perused the record. It appears that a proceeding under Section 95(1)(g) of the Act is initiated against the petitioner-appellant. It further appears that the District Magistrate being satisfied with the report of the preliminary enquiry showing prima facie involvement of the petitioner-appellant in the alleged financial and other irregularities, withdrew the financial and administrative power of the appellant in exercise of the power conferred under the first proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the Act, The aggrieved appellant preferred the aforesaid writ petition, which has been dismissed by the Hon'ble Single Judge of this Court, mainly on the ground that at this stage the defence of the petitioner-appellant and sufficiency or insufficiency of the evidence in support of the allegations cannot be looked into as the formal enquiry is yet to be concluded and the order to suspend the financial and administrative power is as an interim measure pending formal enquiry.

3. Learned counsel for the petitioner, however, contended that the appellant was not given sufficient opportunity to submit effective reply to the charges nor the copy of the enquiry report was provided, hence the impugned order withdrawing the financial, administrative power deserves to be set aside.

4. In our view, there is no substance in the submission. The order impugned in the writ petition is passed under first proviso of Section 95(1)(g) of the Act, which empowers the State Government to withdraw financial and administrative powers and function of Pradhan or Up Pradhan, who is prima facie found to have committed financial and other irregularities until he is exonerated of the charges in the final enquiry and till then such power shall be exercised by a Committee consisting of three members of Gram Panchayat. For ready reference Section 95(1)(g) of the Act is extracted hereinafter:

“Section 95(1)— The State Government may-

(a) to (f) xxxxx

(g) Remove a Pradhan, Up-Pradhan or member of a Gram Panchayat or a Joint Committee or Bhumi Prabandhak Samiti, or a Panch, Sahayak Sarpanch or Sarpanch of a Nyaya Panchayat if he

(i) Absents himself without sufficient cause for more than three consecutive meetings or sittings,

(ii) Refuses to Act or becomes incapable of acting for any reason whatsoever or if he Page: 164is accused of or charged for an offence involving moral turpitude,

(iii) has abused his position as such or has persistently failed to perform the duties imposed by the Act or rules made thereunder or his continuance as such is not desirable in public interest, or

has taken the benefit of reservation under sub-section (2) of Section 11-A or sub-section (5) of Section 12, as the case may be, on the basis of a false declaration subscribed by him stating that he is a member of the Scheduled Castes, the Scheduled Tribes or the Backward Classes, as the case may be.

(iv) being a Sahayak Sarpanch or a Sarpanch of the Nyaya Panchayat takes active part in politics, or

(v) suffers from any of the disqualifications mentioned in clauses (a) to (m) of Section 5-A:

Provided that where, in an enquiry held by such person and in such manner as may be prescribed, a Pradhan or up-Pradhan is prima facie found to have committed financial and other irregularities such Pradhan or Up-Pradhan shall cease to exercise and perform the financial and administrative powers and functions, which shall, until he is exonerated of the charges in the final enquiry, be exercised and performed by a Committee consisting of three members of Gram Panchayat appointed by the State Government.”

5. Thus, where a proceeding for removal of a Pradhan or Up-Pradhan or a Member of a Gram Panchayat is undertaken and the matter is being enquired under Section 95(1)(g) of the Act, the State Government, if satisfied that the Pradhan or Up-Pradhan is prima facie found to have committed financial and other irregularities, can cease the financial and administrative powers and functions, till he is exonerated of the charges in the final enquiry in the manner prescribed.

6. The power vested in the State Government under Section 95(1)(g) of the Act has been delegated to the District Magistrates vide Notification No. 1648/33-1-1997-123/97, Lucknow dated 30th April, 1997 issued by the State Government in exercise of powers under Section 96-A of the Act which enables the State Government to delegate all or any of the power under the Act to any officer or authority subordinate to it subject to such conditions and restrictions as it may deem fit and proper.

7. The State Government has framed Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans, Up-Pradhans and Members) Enquiry Rules. 1997 (hereinafter referred to as the Rules) under Section 110 read with clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section 95 of the Act. Rule 3 provides about procedure relating to complaints against Pradhan or Up-Pradhan. Rule 4 provides about preliminary enquiry. It reads as under:

“4. Preliminary Enquiry.— (1) The State Government may, on the receipt of a complaint or report referred to in Rule 3, or otherwise order the Enquiry Officer to conduct a preliminary enquiry with a view to finding out if there is prima facie case for a formal enquiry in the matter.

(2) The Enquiry Officer shall conduct the preliminary enquiry as expeditiously as possible and submit his report to the State Government within thirty days of his having been so ordered.”

8. Thus, where a complaint is made against a Pradhan or Up-Pradhan under Rule 3 of the Rules a preliminary enquiry is made to find out the truth as to whether the alleged com plaint is vexatious, frivolous or mala fide etc. Where in the preliminary enquiry some sub stance in the allegation and prima facie involvement of Pradhan or Up-Pradhan in the alleged financial and other irregularities is found from the report submitted in the preliminary enquiry, the State Government shall direct for formal enquiry under Rule 5 of the Rules which provides as under:

“5. Where the State Government is of the opinion, on the basis of the report referred to in sub-rule (2) of Rule 4 or otherwise that an enquiry should be held against a Pradhan or Up-Pradhan or Member under the proviso to clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section 95 it shall forthwith constitute a committee envisaged to proviso to clause (g) of sub-section 95 of the Act and by an order ask an Enquiry Page: 165Officer, other than the Enquiry Officer nominated under sub-rule (2) of Rule (4), to hold the enquiry.”

9. Therefore, from a plain reading of 1st proviso of Section 95(1)(g) read with Rule 4, it is evident that in the preliminary enquiry Pradhan or Up-Pradhan facing charges in the alleged complaint is not required to be noticed nor any opportunity is to be provided for the reason that it is merely a fact finding enquiry to ascertain the correctness of the allegations and to find out the bona fide of the complaint. Obviously, if in the preliminary enquiry allegations are found baseless, the proceedings would be dropped. However, the involvement of Pradhan or Up-Pradhan, if prima facie is found then only a regular enquiry is to be initiated under Rule 5 of the Rules whereunder the Enquiry Officer shall deliver a copy of the Articles of charge, the statement of the imputations and a list of documents and witnesses by which each article of charge is proposed to be sustained and shall require that person by a notice in writing to submit his written statement of his defence within the specified time and to state whether he desires to be heard in person and to appear before him on the specified date and time. The detailed procedure has been prescribed for holding such enquiry in Rule 6 of the Rules.

10. In the case in hand, the impugned order has been passed by the District Magistrate under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the Act after receipt of the report in the preliminary enquiry made under Rule 4. It is apparent from the perusal of the order of the District Magistrate dated 30-3-2008 impugned in the writ petition (Annexure-8 to the writ petition) that upon receipt of the complaint against the petitioner-appellant, the District Social Welfare Officer, Kushi Nagar was nominated to hold preliminary enquiry vide order dated 3rd October, 2007. The District Social Welfare Officer, Kushi Nagar submitted report on 22nd December, 2007. In the report various irregularities alleged against the petitioner-appellant were prima facie found to be correct, hence notice was served on her on 14-1-2008 and 14-2-2008 under Section 95(1)(g) of the Act calling upon to show cause pursuant to which show cause was filed on 26-2-2008. The District Magistrate since did not find any substance in the cause shown and having satisfied with the report in the preliminary enquiry wherefrom the appellant is prima facie found to have committed financial and other irregularities, passed the impugned order whereunder she has been prevented to exercise financial and administrative powers and functions till she is exonerated of the charges in the regular enquiry and also constituted Committee consisting of three Members of Gram Panchayat to exercise and perform the financial and administrative powers of the Panchayat.

11. The contention that copy of the enquiry report was not provided and, therefore, the impugned order is bad, can also not be accepted since it has not been demonstrated before us or in the writ petition as to what prejudice has been caused on account of non-supply of the report. Further, admittedly after receipt of the show cause notice, the petitioner had filed show cause and nothing has been brought before us that she asked for copy of the report before furnishing show cause, hence it does not lie in the mouth of the appellant at this stage to contend that in the absence of the copy of report provided to the appellant the order passed under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g).of the Act is vitiated.

12. That apart, having regard to the provisions of U.P Panchayat Raj Act and the Rules framed thereunder referred to above, we are of the view that the order withdrawing financial and administrative power and function of the Pradhan or Up Pradhan under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the Act is in the nature of interim order pending enquiry to prevent misuse of financial and administrative power and function by the Pradhan facing charges of financial and administrative irregularities and thus, at this stage the Act or the Rule does not contemplate to provide any opportunity of hearing or show cause or participation of Pradhan or Up Pradhan facing charges in the preliminary enquiry. The Hon'ble Single Judge of this Court in the case of Page: 166Smt. Radhili Devi v. The District Magistrate, Padrauna, 1997 (1) AWC 251 : (1997 All LJ 1065), took the view that no opportunity of hearing is necessary before resorting to such interim measure as it is analogous to a suspension order passed against a Government servant and only at the stage of regular enquiry before passing final order of removal, opportunity of hearing is to be extended. Similar view was expressed by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Moti Lal v. District Magistrate, Lalitpur, 2003 (1) UPLBEC 736 : (2003 All LJ 1358) wherein their Lordships having taken note of the provisions contained in Rules 3 & 4 and proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the Act, held that while holding preliminary enquiry the Enquiry Officer is not obliged to give opportunity to the appellant nor the rule requires holding of preliminary enquiry in the presence of the appellant. We, with respect endorse the above view. Therefore, we do not find any substance in the contention that the impugned order has been passed in violation of the principles of natural justice nor we find any violation of prescription of law calling for interference in the impugned order.

13. Therefore, there is no fault in the judgment of the Hon'ble Single Judge assailed in this appeal.

14. No other point is urged before us.

15. However, looking to the facts of the case, we are of the view that the formal enquiry initiated under Rule 5 of the Rules requires early disposal. We, therefore, direct that the formal enquiry initiated against the petitioner shall be concluded expeditiously, preferably within a period of three months from the date of production of a certified copy of this order.

16. We further provide that the enquiry officer or the District Magistrate while taking final decision shall not be influenced or prejudiced in any manner by the observations made by this Court in the writ petition and in this appeal as it was only for the purpose of deciding the validity of the order passed under proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the Act.

17. With the above observations the special appeal stands dismissed but without costs.

18. Appeal dismissed.