- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shaik Ali v. District Collector
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners filed a writ petition aggrieved by the refusal of respondent No. 4 to receive documents for registration concerning a land parcel measuring 2 acres and 40 cents in Sy. No. 15/1 of Bodumalluvaripalle Revenue Village, Piler Mandal, Chittoor District. The petitioners traced their title to a registered sale deed dated 11.2.1947, under which their grandfather, Khasim Saheb, purchased the property. The grandfather's name was mutated in revenue records, and after his death, his son Shaik Modin Saheb succeeded to the property with pattadar passbooks issued in his name. The petitioners claim through Modin Saheb as his lineal descendants. Respondent No. 4 declined to issue a certificate of market value on the ground that the land is classified as Assessed Waste DRY (D.K.T) per the M.R.O's List, effectively treating the land as Government property and refusing registration of the documents presented by the petitioners.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the refusal by respondent No. 4 to receive and register documents relating to the land classified as Assessed Waste DRY (D.K.T) under the Registration Act, 1908, is justified.
- Whether entries in revenue records such as R.S.R or A-Register constitute conclusive proof of ownership of land for registration purposes.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners relied on a registered sale deed dated 11.2.1947 showing purchase of the land by their grandfather, Khasim Saheb.
- The grandfather's name was mutated in revenue records, and pattadar passbooks and title deeds were issued in favor of their father, Shaik Modin Saheb.
- They contended that the land should be treated as private property and that the documents presented for registration should be accepted.
Respondents' Stand
- Respondent No. 4 refused to issue a certificate of market value and register the documents, stating the land is classified as Assessed Waste DRY (D.K.T) and thus falls under Government land as per the Registration Act, 1908.
- Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 maintain the position that the land belongs to the Government and are free to assert their title before a competent court.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| P. Suresh v. A.P. State, 2009 (3) ALD 802 | Entries in revenue records (R.S.R) do not constitute conclusive proof of title. | The Court relied on this principle to reject the respondents' claim based solely on revenue record entries. |
| K.M Kamulla Basha v. District Collector, WP Nos. 27249 and 28393/2007, 2009 (3) ALD 385 | Same principle regarding non-conclusive nature of revenue entries. | Reaffirmed the position that revenue records alone cannot establish ownership. |
| Meda Subbarayudu v. Sub-Registrar, WP No. 11675/2008 | Revenue records entries are not conclusive proof of ownership. | Supported the petitioners' case against treating the land as Government property. |
| S. Zakhir v. District Collector, WP No. 19419/2008 | Revenue entries do not conclusively establish title. | Used to emphasize that mere classification in revenue records does not bar registration. |
| Shaik Dudekula Pyari Jan @ Lal Bi v. The Revenue Divisional Officer, WP No. 6016/2010 | Reiteration of the principle that revenue records are not conclusive proof of title. | Confirmed the Court's consistent stance, supporting the petitioners' entitlement to register documents. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the petitioners' evidence, including the registered sale deed from 1947 and subsequent revenue records such as pattadar passbooks and title deeds. It noted that while the respondents treated the property as Government land based on classification in the M.R.O's List and revenue records, such entries do not constitute conclusive proof of ownership. The Court referred to established precedents which held that mere entries in R.S.R or A-Register cannot establish title conclusively. Given the petitioners' evidence of private ownership and registered transactions, the Court found no justification for respondent No. 4's refusal to receive and register the documents. The Court allowed the writ petition and directed respondent No. 4 to accept and register the documents presented by the petitioners, while leaving the respondents free to assert their claims in a competent court.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is allowed.
Respondent No. 4 is directed to receive and register the documents presented by the petitioners. Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 retain the right to assert their claim to the land before a competent court of law. The decision directly affects the parties by permitting registration of the documents but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond reaffirming the principle that revenue record entries alone do not conclusively determine land ownership.
1. Despite granting of time, respondents have neither filed counter-affidavit nor reported instructions.
2. The petitioners filed the present writ petition feeling aggrieved by the action of respondent No. 4 in not receiving the documents sought to be presented by them for registration in respect of land admeasuring Acs. 2-40 cents, comprised in Sy. No. 15/1 of Bodumalluvaripalle Revenue Village, Piler Mandal, Chittoor District. The petitioners have traced their title to registered sale deed dated 11.2.1947 under which their grandfather Khasim Saheb purchased the property. It is the pleaded case of the petitioners that the name of his grandfather was mutated in the revenue records, that after his death his son, Shaik Modin Saheb succeeded to the properties and pattadar passbooks were also issued in favour of the said Shaik Modin Saheb. The petitioners are claiming through the said Modin Saheb as his lineal descendents.
3. When the petitioners have approached respondent No. 4 for issuing a certificate of market value, he declined to Page: 49issue the same stating that the land is classified as Assessed Waste DRY (D.K.T) as per M.R.O's. List. In support of the above pleas raised by the petitioners, they have filed a photo copy of the registered sale deed dated 11.2.1947 standing in the name of the petitioners' grandfather and copies of pattadar passbooks and title deeds issued in the name of the petitioners' father Modin Saheb.
4. Under Section 22-A of the Registration Act, 1908, the category of documents mentioned therein cannot be registered. The lands belonging to the Government falls in one of the categories mentioned in the said provision.
5. This Court in P. Suresh v. A.P. State, 2009 (3) ALD 802, K.M Kamulla Basha v. District Collector, Chittoor, WP Nos. 27249 and 28393/2007, dated 16.2.2009, reported in 2009 (3) ALD 385, Meda Subbarayudu v. Sub-Registrar, Rayachoty, WP No. 11675/2008, dated 30.7.2008 and S. Zakhir v. District Collector, Anantapur, WP No. 19419/2008, dated 16.2.2009 held that mere entries in R.S.R do not constitute conclusive proof of title. In a recent judgment in Shaik Dudekula Pyari Jan @ Lal Bi v. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Madanapalli, WP No. 6016/2010, dated 2.7.2010, this Court reiterated this position following the above mentioned judgments of this Court.
6. From the facts noted above, while there is overwhelming evidence in respect of the petitioners' plea that the lands are treated as private lands and registered transaction has taken place as far back as 1947 and revenue records such as pattadar passbooks and title deeds were issued in favour of the petitioners' father, the stand of the respondents treating the property as Government land, cannot prima facie be appreciated. As held by this Court as noted above, mere entries in R.S.R or A-Register will not offer conclusive proof of ownership of the land. Therefore, I do not find any justification for respondent No. 4 to refuse to receive the documents and register the same.
7. For the above mentioned reasons, the writ petition is allowed. Respondent No. 4 is directed to receive the documents that may be presented by the petitioners and register the same. Respondent Nos. 1 to 3, are however, free to assert their title before competent Court of law, if according to their case, the land in question belongs to the Government.
Alert