- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State of Madhya Pradesh v. Hariram
Summary of Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners challenged two orders: Annexure P-1 dated November 16, 2007 (Industrial Court, Gwalior) and Annexure P-2 dated August 17, 2007 (Labour Court, Gwalior). The respondent-employee originally applied to the Labour Court under the Madhya Pradesh Industrial Relations Act seeking classification as a Chowkidar and challenging his termination notice dated July 4, 1995. The Labour Court, by order dated February 10, 2000, allowed the application, quashed the termination notice and ordered classification of the employee as Chowkidar with payment of salary from July 24, 1993.
The petitioners' appeal to the Industrial Court was dismissed on April 23, 2002. A subsequent writ petition (W.P. No. 2140/2003) was dismissed on July 18, 2003. The Executive Engineer issued an order on October 12, 2004 classifying the respondent as a permanent labourer and fixing minimum pay as per the Labour Commissioner. The respondent then filed an application under Section 108-A of the Madhya Pradesh Industrial Relations Act before the Labour Court for recovery of Rs. 2,66,551/-, seeking payment in accordance with the Labour Court's earlier direction. The Labour Court ordered payment of Rs. 2,66,551/- and issued a Revenue Recovery Certificate (RRC). The Industrial Court dismissed the petitioners' appeal against that order by its order dated November 16, 2007. The petitioners then filed the present writ petition which is the subject of this opinion.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondent-employee, already classified as a permanent Chowkidar by the Labour Court and whose classification was affirmed on appeal, is entitled to the regular pay scale of the post of Chowkidar and to the sums ordered by the Labour Court (Rs. 2,66,551/-) and the RRC issued in his favour.
- Whether the Labour Court and Industrial Court committed any error of law in ordering payment of the regular pay scale and issuing the RRC, particularly in light of the Madhya Pradesh Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Rules, 1963 and the Annexures to the Standard Standing Orders.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The respondent-employee is not entitled to the regular pay scale of Chowkidar; the Labour Court erred in granting the pay scale and issuing the RRC.
- Under the provisions of the Madhya Pradesh Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Rules, 1963 and the Annexures to the Standard Standing Orders, the respondent is only entitled to benefits accrued in relation to those Standard Standing Orders and not necessarily to the regular pay scale prescribed for regularly recruited employees.
- The learned Deputy Advocate General relied on Mahendra L. Jain and Others v. Indore Development Authority and Others (AIR 2005 SC 1252 : (2005) 1 SCC 639 : 2005-I-LLJ-578) and MP. State Agro Industries Development Corporation Ltd. and Another v. S.C. Pandey ((2006) 2 SCC 716 : 2006-II-LLJ-215) in support of this contention.
Respondent-Employee's Arguments
- The respondent has already been classified as permanent (Chowkidar) by the Labour Court and the Labour Court directed payment of the pay scale with effect from July 24, 1993; that order has been affirmed up to the High Court, and hence the Labour Court rightly ordered issuance of RRC.
- Reliance was placed upon this Court's judgments: Engineer-in-Chief PHED and Others v. Budha Rao Magarde and Others (2002-II-LLJ-353 (MP)) and Vandna Singh (Smt.) v. Steel Authority of India Ltd. and Another (1992-I-LLJ-64(MP)) to support entitlement to pay scale upon classification as permanent.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Engineer-in-Chief, PHED and Others v. Budha Rao Magarde and Others, 2002-II-LLJ-353 (MP) | Confirms principle that once an employee acquires permanent status under the Standing Orders, he is entitled to the salary/pay scale of the post. | The court relied on this decision to hold that classification as permanent entitles the respondent to the pay scale of Chowkidar. |
| Vandna Singh (Smt.) v. Steel Authority of India Ltd. and Another, 1992-I-LLJ-64 (MP) | Illustrates entitlement to pay scale and ancillary benefits upon declaration as a regular and permanent employee (example given in the opinion). | Used to support the principle that upon classification a person is entitled to pay in the regular pay scale and related benefits; the court cited it as authority for awarding pay scale. |
| Mahendra L. Jain and Others v. Indore Development Authority and Others, AIR 2005 SC 1252 : (2005) 1 SCC 639 : 2005-I-LLJ-578 | Relied upon by petitioners/Deputy Advocate General regarding the right to be classified under certified Standing Orders and the powers of the court in that context. | The court observed these authorities address the right of classification under Standing Orders and the powers of courts, but found they did not engage the specific point in issue here (entitlement to pay after classification that had become final). |
| MP. State Agro Industries Development Corporation Ltd. and Another v. S.C. Pandey, (2006) 2 SCC 716 : 2006-II-LLJ-215 | Also relied upon by the Deputy Advocate General regarding classification rights and court powers under Standing Orders. | The court noted this authority relates to classification questions and distinguished it from the present case where classification and entitlement to pay had already been determined and attained finality. |
| M.P.S.R.T.C. v. Harish (as cited within the quoted passage) | Cited in the quoted passage from the Engineer-in-Chief decision to show that conferal of a deeming status of permanent employee led to direction for payment of salary on the post. | Referenced (via the Engineer-in-Chief decision) to support the proposition that permanent status carries with it entitlement to salary of the post. |
| State of M.P. v. Ram Prakash (as cited in the quoted passage) | Cited in the quoted passage to support the view that a person endowed with permanent employee status is entitled to pay scale and increments applicable to the post. | Referenced (via the Engineer-in-Chief decision) to reinforce the legal proposition that classification as permanent confers entitlement to the pay scale and increments. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's reasoning proceeded by establishing the finality of the classification and related orders and then applying the Standing Orders and precedent to determine entitlement to pay:
- Finality of classification: The Labour Court had classified the respondent as permanent Chowkidar by order dated February 10, 2000 and ordered payment of the pay scale from July 24, 1993. Appeals against that order were dismissed (Industrial Court and the writ petition), and no further proceedings were taken by the petitioners; accordingly the order attained finality.
- Content of Standard Standing Orders: The Standard Standing Orders (Madhya Pradesh Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Rules, 1963 — Annexure) define categories of employees including 'permanent' and set out criteria for when a temporary employee becomes deemed permanent (e.g., after six months of continuous work). The Annexure itself did not prescribe a pay scale for permanent employees, although the pay scale for the post of Chowkidar was prescribed by the department.
- Legal principle on pay entitlement: The court adopted the principle, as stated in prior decisions of this Court (Engineer-in-Chief and Vandna Singh), that once an employee acquires permanent status under the Standing Orders, he is entitled to the salary/wages of the post and cannot be continued on the lower wages on which he had initially been employed. The court quoted and relied on the earlier reasoning that permanent status is not a mere 'tag' without the attendant benefit of pay.
- Application to the facts: Because the respondent had been classified as Chowkidar and the departmental pay scale for Chowkidar existed, the court concluded the respondent was entitled to the pay scale for that post. The Labour Court had already directed payment on that basis and that directive had attained finality.
- Distinguishing authorities relied by petitioners: The court observed that the precedents cited by the Deputy Advocate General (Mahendra L. Jain and MP State Agro) deal with the right to be classified under certified Standing Orders and the powers of courts in that context. The present case did not raise that question because classification and payment had already been adjudicated and finalized; the issue now was enforcement of an already final determination.
- Practical concern about correct computation: The Deputy Advocate General submitted that the department had not produced cogent evidence about the correct amount and pay scale to be paid. The court provided a remedial direction allowing the department to address any ambiguity by issuing appropriate orders after notice within four weeks; failing that, the respondent would be entitled to the amounts previously ordered by the Labour Court and Industrial Court.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The petition is disposed of and the orders Annexure P-1 (dated November 16, 2007) and Annexure P-2 (dated August 17, 2007) passed by the Industrial Court, Gwalior and the Labour Court, Gwalior are upheld.
Direct implications and consequential directions:
- The respondent-employee is to be paid the regular pay scale of the post of Chowkidar as ordered by the Labour Court effective from July 24, 1993; the Labour Court's computation (including the Rs. 2,66,551/- awarded) and the RRC issued in his favour stand, unless the department acts within the court-prescribed window.
- If there is any ambiguity about the correct pay scale or amount to be paid, the department is permitted to pass appropriate orders after giving notice to the employee within four weeks. If no such order is passed within that period, the respondent-employee will be entitled to the amounts already ordered by the Labour Court and Industrial Court.
- The order states that the respondent is to be paid the regular pay scale as per the Labour Court order. There is no order as to costs.
Note: The opinion does not discuss broader legal policy implications or purport to lay down a novel precedent beyond applying existing authority that a permanently classified employee is entitled to pay in the regular pay scale of the post.
1 Petitioners have filed the petition challenging the orders Annexure P-1, dated November 16, 2007 and Annexure P-2, dated August 17,2007 passed by the Industrial Court, Gwalior and Labour Court, Gwalior.
2 Initially the respondent-employee filed an application before the Labour Court under the provisions of madhya pradesh industrial relations act for his classification on the post of Chowkidar and also challenged the order of termination of service dated July 4, 1995. He pleaded that he had been working on daily wage basis as Chowkidar w.e.f. July 1, 1990. He completed six months satisfactory service and was entitled to be classified on the post of Chowkidar. Contrary to this the department issued a notice dated July 4, 1995 terminating his services which is illegal. The Labour Court vide order dated February 10,2000 allowed the application of the respondent-employee and quashed the notice dated July 4, 1995 and also ordered classification of the employee from July 24, 1993 on the post of Chowkidar with payment of salary for the post w. e.f. July 24, 1993.
3 Petitioners filed an appeal against the aforesaid order, which was also dismissed by the Industrial Court vide order dated April 23, 2002. Thereafter, petitioners further filed a, petition before this Court, which was registered as Writ Petition No. 2140/2003 and same was also dismissed vide order dated July 18, 2003. Thereafter, the Executive Engineer vide order dated October 12, 2004 classified the, respondent-employee as permanent Labourer and further ordered that respondent-employee shall be entitled minimum pay as fixed by the Labour Commissioner.
4 After the order of the Executive Engineer the respondent-employee filed an application under section 108-a of the madhya pradesh industrial relations act before the Labour Court for recovery of an amount of Rs. 2,66,551/-. He pleaded that the Labour Court ordered to pay the pay scale to him for the post of Chowkidar w.e.f. July 24, 1993, hence the respondent-employee was entitled to receive the aforesaid pay scale and salary accordingly. Along with the application he also filed a chart and stated that he was entitled to an amount of Rs. 2,66,551/-. Before the Labour Court the petitioners stated that the respondent-employee had already been classified as permanent but he is not entitled to the pay scale of Chowkidar. The Labour Court rejected the contention and ordered for payment of an amount of Rs. 2,66,551/- and also issued RRC (Revenue Recovery Certificate) to this effect. Against the aforesaid order petitioners filed an appeal before the Industrial Court. That appeal has also been dismissed vide order dated November 16,2007. Now, the petitioners filed present writ petition.
5 Learned counsel for petitioners has submitted that the. respondent-employee is not entitled to the regular pay scale of Chowkidar and Labour Court has committed an error of law in granting the pay scale and issuing RRC in favour of the respondent-employee. Learned counsel further submitted that in view of the provisions of Madhya Pradesh Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Rules, 1963 and Annexures to the Standard Standing Orders the respondent-employee is only entitled benefits accrued in relation with the aforesaid Standard Standing Orders. In support of her contention learned Deputy Advocate General relied upon Mahendra L. Jain and Others v. Indore Development A uthority and Others, AIR 2005 SC 1252 : (2005) 1 SCC 639 : 2005-I-LLJ-578 and MP. State Agro Industries Development Corporation Ltd. and Another v. S.C.Pandey, (2006) 2 SCC 716 : 2006-11-LLJ-215. Contrary to this, learned counsel for the respondent-employee has submitted that the respondent-employee has already been classified as permanent. There is order of Labour Court for payment of pay scale of Chowkidar and that has been affirmed up to the High Court. In such circumstances, the Labour Court has rightly ordered issuance of RRC. In support of his contentions learned counsel relied upon the judgments of this Court in Engineer-in-Chief PHED and Others v. Budha. Rao Magarde and Others, 2002-II-LLJ-353 (MP) and Vandna Singh (Smt.) v. Steel Authority of India Ltd. and Another, 1992-I-LLJ-64(MP).
6 The respondent-workman on an application filed by him before the Labour Court has been classified as permanent on the post of Chowkidar vide order dated February 10, 2000. It has further been ordered by the Labour Court that the respondent-employee is entitled TO pay scale of permanent post of Chowkidar w.e.f. July 24, 1993. Against the aforesaid order an appeal was filed which was also dismissed and the writ petition filed was also dismissed. Thereafter, the petitioners did not file any further appeal or proceedings. Hence, the order has attained finality. It is clear from the order of the Labour Court that the Labour Court has clearly directed to pay the pay scale of Chowkidar to the respondent-employee w.e.f. July 24, 1993.
7 As per Annexure which is Standard Standing Orders under the Madhya Pradesh Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Rules, 1963 the Standing Order 2 prescribes classification of employees, which is as under:
"2. Classification of Employees. Employees shall be classified as (i) permanent, (ii) permanent seasonal, (iii) probationers, (iv) Badlies, (v) apprentices, and (vi) temporary: (i) A 'permanent' employee is one who has completed six months' satisfactory service in a clear vacancy in one or more posts whether as a probationer or otherwise, or a person whose name has been entered in the muster roll and who is given a ticket of permanent employee;
(ii) A 'permanent seasonal employee' is one who has completed service for a period equal to 2/3 of the duration or a season or three months whichever is less in a clear vacancy and shall be deemed to be a permanent employee for the purposes of these orders;
(iii) A 'probationer' means an employee who is provisionally employed to fill a clear vacancy, and who has not completed six months' satisfactory service in the aggregate;
(iv) A 'badli' employee means an employee who is employed on the post of a permanent employee, or a probationer or a permanent seasonal employee who is temporarily absent.
(v) An 'apprentice' means a learner, provided that no employee shall be classified as an apprentice if he has had training for an aggregate period of one year, provided further that a longer period of apprenticeship shall be required if prescribed by a law or an award, or by agreement with the representative of employees;
(vi) A 'temporary employee' means an employee who has been employed for work which is essentially of a temporary character, or who is temporarily employed as an additional employee in connection with the temporary increase in the work of a permanent nature; provided that in case such employee is required to work continuously for more than six months he shall be deemed to be a permanent employee, within the meaning of clause (i) above."
8 When an employee or worker has already been classified as permanent then he had got certain benefits. In the Standard Standing Orders the pay scale of permanent employee has not been prescribed. However, it is an admitted fact that in the department also there is no pay scale prescribed for (sic) the employee who has been classified as permanent by the Labour Court under the aforesaid Standing Orders. However, the pay scale of Chowkidar has been prescribed. When the respondent-employee has been classified as Chowkidar then certainly he is entitled to get the pay scale of the aforesaid post also. Apart from this, the Labour Court has also ordered for payment of salary of permanent post of Chowkidar to the respondent-employee and that order has attained finality. Hence, the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for petitioners that the respondent-employee is not-entitled to the pay scale of Chowkidar which has been prescribed for regularly recruited employees, cannot be accepted.
9 The aforesaid point has already been answered by the learned single Judge of this Court in Engineer-in-Chief, PHED and Others v. Budha Rao Magarde and Others (supra), where learned single Judge has held as under at p.358 of 2002-II-LLJ-353:
"72. The next contention of the learned Government advocate is that clauses (i) and (vi) of SSO 2 merely confer a status without any corresponding obligation to pay them wages or salary in the regular pay scale of the posts. Learned Government advocate has proceeded further to submit that by acquiring a status, a person gets apprised of the nature of the duties that he is required to discharge as employee engaged on daily wages can, without such status, be employed in different Sections. It is difficult to comprehend that a person acquires permanent status only as a 'tag' without attendant benefit of salary of the posts; relating to the nature of the work carried out by such an employee. In the present case, each of the employees has specifically referred to the work of the service rendered by him in connection with a post. To illustrate, in W.P. No. 3510/2000 the claim of the employee was that he was working as a Lab Assistant while in W.P. No. 3056/2000 the claim was that the employee was working on the post of Sweeper. Thus, specific duties performed relating to specific posts were duly pleaded and not specifically denied. Such a status acquired by an employee does not give him any other advantage except the advantage of pay. In M.P.S.R.T.C. v. Harish (supra), itself on conferal of the deeming status of permanent employee, direction for payment of salary on the post was made which indicates that it goes without saying that when a person acquires a permanent status, he automatically becomes entitled to the salary of the said post. In State of M.P. v. Ram Prakash (supra), the observations of the Division Bench which are relevant in this context read as extracted below: "12. For all the foregoing reasons, we have no hesitation to hold that our interference with the order or award passed by the Labour Court on June 25, 1987 (Annexure P-3) is not warranted, the claim of the respondent being legally as also constitutionally justified, whether in Surendra Kumar Saxena or Brij Kishore Sharma (supra) would not, in terms, apply to respondents case for that reason. His entitlement would also be so determined (under the "Annexure" of 1963 Rules) in respect of his claim for being treated as permanent employee. Therefore, he would be entitled to be paid not only the minimum of salary in the pay scale applicable to Lower Division Clerks/Typist appointed on regular basis; he would rather be entitled to be paid salary in the pay scale applicable to them. In other words, he would also be entitled to increments envisaged under that pay scale because we have held that he is entitled to be endowed with the status of a "permanent employee" in terms of the statutory provisions aforesaid."
From the above decision it is clear that once an employee acquires the status of permanent employee he is required to be paid the salary/wages of the post and he cannot be continued on the wages on which he had initially been appointed or continued till he had become permanent." Learned Division Bench of this Court in Vandna Singh (Smt) v. Steel Authority of India Ltd. and Another (supra), has held as under with regard to entitlement of pay scale:
"In the result, the petition is allowed with costs. The petitioner is declared as a regular and permanent employee, who shall be entitled to the pay scale of Rs. 1425-2205 from February 20, 1990 with regular increments and all ancillary benefits attached to the post. The difference of salary shall be payable to petitioner only from February 20, 1990. Respondents to pay the costs of petitioner in this petition. Counsel's fee Rs. 1000/- if already certified."
10 On the basis of above principle of law laid down in the aforementioned decisions of this Court it is clear that upon classification an employee is entitled to get the pay scale of the post on which he has been classified as permanent.
11 The judgments relied upon by the learned Deputy advocate General are with regard to the right of an employee to be classified under the provisions of certified Standing Orders and the powers of the Court. That point is not involved in the present case. The point involved in the present case is that the respondent has already been classified and ordered for payment of regular pay scale of the post.
12 In my opinion, the Labour Court has not committed any error of law in computing the salary of the respondent-employee on the basis of regular pay scale of the post of Chowkidar. However, the learned Deputy advocate General has submitted that the department has not submitted cogent evidence before the Court with regard to correct amount and pay scale which has to be paid to the respondent-employee.
13 Looking to the above facts of the case, the petition of the petitioner is disposed of with the following directions: (1) That, the orders Annexure P-1, dated November 16, 2007 and Annexure P-2 dated August 17,2007 passed by the Industrial Court, Gwalior and Labour Court, Gwalior are upheld. However, if there is any ambiguity with regard to entitlement of the pay scale to the respondent-employee, the department is free to pass appropriate orders after giving notice in this regard to the employee within a period of four weeks. If within the aforesaid period no order be passed then the respondent-employee will be entitled the amount which has been ordered by the Labour Court and the Industrial Court. It has further been ordered that the respondent-employee be also paid regular pay scale as per the order of the Labour Court. No order as to costs.
Alert