- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Government Of A.P And Others v. Bala Musalaiah And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
In 1967, the Government of Andhra Pradesh issued an ad hoc rule under Article 309 of the Constitution prescribing the order in which temporary and probationary employees would be retrenched. The order (“the GO”) deferred the retrenchment of Scheduled Caste (SC) and Scheduled Tribe (ST) employees until after the retrenchment of even approved probationers belonging to the general category. The GO was challenged before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh, which struck it down as violative of Article 16(1) after relying, inter alia, on T. Devadasan v. Union of India. The State of Andhra Pradesh filed the present appeal to the Supreme Court. During the pendency of the appeal, the Supreme Court’s nine-Judge decision in Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992) clarified the constitutional parameters of reservation.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the 1967 Government Order prescribing the sequence of retrenchment, which privileged SC/ST temporary employees over even approved probationers of the general category, violates Article 16(1) of the Constitution.
- Whether the High Court’s reliance on T. Devadasan remains valid in light of the majority judgment in Indra Sawhney.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (State of Andhra Pradesh)
- Contended that, after the majority judgment in Indra Sawhney, the High Court’s reasoning—particularly its reliance on T. Devadasan—was no longer sustainable and therefore the GO should be upheld.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| T. Devadasan v. Union of India, AIR 1964 SC 179; (1965) 2 LLJ 560 | Invalidated an “unlimited carry-forward rule” that upset the balance mandated by Article 16(1). | The High Court relied on this case to hold that the GO introduced an impermissible form of carry-forward, violating Article 16(1). |
| Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217; (1992) 22 ATC 385 | Comprehensive exposition of the constitutional limits on reservation and affirmative action; reservation measures must not contravene the equality guarantee of Article 14. | The Supreme Court used the principles laid down in this case to test the GO’s validity and to emphasise that affirmative action cannot operate in a manner arbitrary under Article 14. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
Justice B. L. Hansaria observed that the GO is prima facie arbitrary because it mandates retrenchment of approved probationers from the general category before temporary SC/ST employees. Article 16(1) embodies equality principles under Article 14 and does permit affirmative action, but such measures cannot be unreasonable or arbitrary.
The Court proposed an alternative consistent with constitutional requirements: when retrenchment becomes necessary, the appointing roster used at the time of recruitment should be “recycled” backwards. Under this method, a reserved-category employee would be retrenched only when the recycled roster reaches a reserved point; thus, the percentage representation of SC/ST employees in the cadre remains intact without unfairly displacing more senior general-category probationers. The existing rule, by contrast, prefers junior temporary SC/ST employees over senior approved probationers solely on the ground of community status, a preference the Court found constitutionally unacceptable.
The Court emphasised that the mere fact that SC/ST candidates acquire a degree of seniority by virtue of roster-based appointments already offers some protection because retrenchment generally follows the “last-in, first-out” principle. The GO therefore bestowed an additional, excessive advantage unsupported by the constitutional scheme.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Dismissed; Government Order declared unsustainable and rendered inoperative prospectively.
Although the GO is struck down, retrenchments already effected under it over nearly three decades are left undisturbed. The State Government may, if it chooses, issue a fresh order consistent with the constitutional principles outlined by the Court. No costs were awarded, and no new legal precedent was set beyond clarifying permissible methods for protecting reservation interests during retrenchment.
B.L Hansaria, J.— The present is an unusual case despite it being related to the usual demand of reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. The peculiarity lies in the fact that the demand for reservation herein is not related to appointment, but is relatable to termination.
2. The Government of Andhra Pradesh issued an order (hereinafter referred to as the GO) on 3-8-1967 by which an ad hoc rule was framed in exercise of powers conferred by Article 309 of the Constitution prohibiting termination of reserved category candidates following normal rule applicable in such cases. The GO spells out in what order retrenchment of temporary employees has to take place. The order set out is as below:
“First — Persons, other than those belonging to the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, appointed temporarily, in the order of juniority;
Second — Probationers, other than those belonging to the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, in the order of juniority;
Third — Approved probationers, other than those belonging to the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, appointed temporarily in the order of juniority;
Fourth — Persons belonging to the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, appointed temporarily in the order of juniority;
Fifth — Probationers belonging to the Scheduled Castes, and the Scheduled Tribes, in the order of juniority;
Sixth — Approved probationers belonging to the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, in the order of juniority.”
(Explanation not relevant)
3. It came to be assailed before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh to meet its Waterloo. The High Court, after taking note of various decisions of this Court dealing with different facets of reservation, held that the GO did not strike a reasonable balance between the claims of different communities and has sought to introduce by the back door an unlimited form of carry-forward rule which it regarded as invalid because of what was held in T. Devadasan v. Union of India AIR 1964 SC 179, (1965) 2 LLJ 560. The Court further stated that the GO does not merely postpone the retrenchment of temporary employees belonging to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes to temporary employees of other communities, but postpones the retrenchment of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes employees to probationers also and, what is worse, even approved probationers of other communities. Because of all these the GO was held to be violative of Article 16(1) of the Constitution and was, therefore, declared as invalid. The State of Andhra Pradesh has preferred this appeal by special leave.
4. A nine-Judge Bench of this Court in Indra Sawhney v. Union of India 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385 (commonly known as Mandal Commission case) reviewed the entire law on reservation; and as such, no effort is necessary on our part to find out the parameters within which reservation has to operate.
5. The GO being of the year 1967 and the law relating to reservation having come to be crystallised by the decision in Indra Sawhney case 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385 delivered in 1992, we stated to Shri Raghubir appearing for the appellants that if the State Government were to undertake passing of fresh GO on the subject keeping in mind the view expressed in Indra Sawhney case 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385, we could dispose of the appeal by allowing the stay order to continue for a period of three months within which the State could pass fresh GO. For want of instructions, Shri Raghubir could not give the undertaking and so we proceeded to hear the appeal instead adjourning the same as prayed for — the appeal being of the year 1977.
6. The High Court, as already noted, struck down the GO, inter alia, because of what has been stated in Devadasan case AIR 1964 SC 179, (1965) 2 LLJ 560. In view of the judgment of the majority in Indra Sawhney case 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385 Shri Raghubir contends that the judgment of the High Court merits to be set aside. But this is not all that the High Court had said, as would appear from what we have noted above.
7. The first observation we propose to make regarding the GO is that on the face of it the same is arbitrary inasmuch as it requires retrenchment even of approved probationers of general category before even temporary incumbents belonging to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes could be retrenched. Such a provision cannot be in tune even with Article 16(1) of the Constitution inasmuch as this sub-article is a facet of Article 14 and though permits affirmative action, as pointed out in Indra Sawhney case 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385, the same cannot fly in the face of Article 14. This would, however, be so if the GO were to allow to stand as it is, because giving of preference to temporary employees belonging to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes as against approved probationers of general category is definitely an unreasonable provision.
8. According to us, the principle and policy behind the reservation would be adequately met and would receive constitutional approval, if, while retrenching the employees, the roster followed while making appointments is adhered to. To elucidate, if the roster is operated backwards (which we shall call recycled) and if the employee to be retrenched as per normal principle be on a non-reserved point, a reserved category candidate would not be retrenched, even if as per general rule of “last in, first out” he would have been required to be retrenched. To state it differently, a reserved category candidate would be retrenched only when on the recycled path the reserved point is reached. This mode of following roster would adequately protect the reserved category candidates inasmuch as their percentage in the service or cadre would remain as it came to be when appointments were made. To explain further, if in the cadre or service reserved category candidates were holding, say seven posts and seven persons are required to be retrenched, the reserved category employees would not be retrenched even when they be the last seven as per the seniority list, which would have otherwise happened on following the normal principle. Instead of the seven reserved category candidates being retrenched as per the normal principle, the reserved category candidate on the recycled roster point alone would be retrenched, because of which the percentage of representation of such candidates in the service, as it got reflected in appointments made following the roster, would remain unaffected.
9. May we mention that the reservation in appointment, to effectuate which roster is prepared, makes an incumbent of the reserved category senior to the general category incumbent, as, though lower in merit the former gets appointed earlier as per the roster point. This in itself protects to some extent the interest of the listed category candidates, as under the normal rule, the retrenchment starts from the juniormost employee and it travels back step by step.
10. We, therefore, hold that the GO as framed is not sustainable. It would, however, be open to State Government to recast the GO in the light of what has been stated by us, if deemed necessary by it. As, however, the GO has been in operation for about three decades by now, we do not propose to upset the retrenchments which have already taken place pursuant to what has been provided in the GO. The GO would, therefore, become non-operative from today.
11. For the aforesaid reasons, the appeal is dismissed subject to the observation regarding prospectivity. No order as to costs.
Alert