Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

S.V. Matha Prasad v. Renuka Devi

Madras High Court
Nov 11, 2014
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Sanjay Kishan Kaul, C.J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

Late Thiru S.V. Ramakrishnan (the Testator) is alleged to have executed a Will dated 15.7.1970. The First Respondent (Original Plaintiff) filed a petition on 18.12.2006 for grant of Letters of Administration in respect of that Will, 26 years after the Testator's death on 31.12.1980.

The Testator had been married to Rajalakshmi (mother of the Appellant/Original Second Defendant), who predeceased in March 1952. Two children were born of that marriage: the Appellant (Original Second Defendant) and Respondent No. 2 (First Defendant). The Testator later lived with Rajalakshmi's sister, Smt. Saroja, and produced further offspring; Respondent No. 1 is one of those daughters.

The petition for Letters of Administration was opposed by the Appellant/Second Defendant and Respondent No. 2/First Defendant.

Procedurally, the First Respondent (Plaintiff) was examined as PW1 before the Additional Master-I on 26.8.2010. Cross-examination of PW1 by the Appellant's counsel was repeatedly adjourned across multiple dates despite cautions by the Master that cross-examination rights would close and further evidence of the Plaintiff would be recorded. Thereafter, additional witnesses (PWs 2 to 5) were examined for the Plaintiff, with their evidence concluded on 13.6.2011. The Appellant later appeared as DW2 and was cross-examined, during which 32 documents were exhibited and admitted. The Plaintiff applied for recall of the Appellant for further cross-examination; the Single Judge allowed recall on 21.11.2013, and the Division Bench dismissed appeals against that order on 6.2.2014. One additional document (exhibited as P78) was confronted upon recall and the defendants' evidence concluded.

On 9.4.2014 the Appellant filed two applications (Nos. 2565 & 2566 of 2014) seeking recall/re-opening of the Plaintiff's evidence to enable further cross-examination in respect of the documents produced during the Appellant's cross-examination; these applications were dismissed by the learned Single Judge by the impugned order dated 15.4.2014. The Appellant challenged that order by filing the present appeals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Appellant/Second Defendant should be permitted to recall or re-open the evidence of the First Respondent/Plaintiff (PW1) for further cross-examination in respect of documents exhibited during the Appellant's cross-examination, after the Appellant had repeatedly failed to cross-examine earlier and after the defendants' evidence was concluded.
  2. The proper scope and application of Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—specifically whether it permits a party to recall a witness for the purpose of filling omissions in evidence or for further party-driven cross-examination, versus recall limited to clarification by the Court (and whether Section 151 CPC is the correct recourse for reopening).
  3. Whether parity should be accorded to the Appellant because the Plaintiff was earlier permitted further cross-examination of the Appellant (i.e., whether the Appellant should be allowed the same benefit after completion of the defendants' evidence).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Appellant contended that vital documents with material bearing were exhibited during the cross-examination of the Appellant (32 documents, including an Assignment Deed), and therefore the First Respondent/Plaintiff should be recalled for further cross-examination on those documents.
  • The Appellant relied on S.S.S Durai Pandian v. S.A. Samuthira Pandian (AIR 1988 Mad. 323) to argue that the Trial Court has power under Order 18, Rule 17 CPC to recall the Plaintiff for re-cross-examination on an application filed by a Defendant, independent of Section 151 CPC; that the power is wide and discretionary.
  • The Appellant pleaded parity: if the Plaintiff had been permitted further cross-examination of the Appellant, the Appellant should similarly be permitted to cross-examine the Plaintiff on the documents.
  • The Appellant also sought an order that an outstanding application seeking dismissal of the Plaintiff's petition on the ground of limitation be decided first, before denying the Appellant's request for further cross-examination.

First Respondent/Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The Plaintiff contended that the Appellant had been given numerous opportunities to cross-examine PW1 and other Plaintiff witnesses but failed to do so; the Appellant's counsel repeatedly adjourned and ultimately did not cross-examine, leading to closure of that right.
  • The Plaintiff argued that the documents produced related to legal proceedings, affidavits, etc., which the Appellant (not the Plaintiff) was party to, and therefore the Appellant could not claim surprise when confronted with them.
  • The Plaintiff relied on the Supreme Court authority in K.K. Velusamy v. N. Palanisamy and Bagai Construction thr. its Proprietor v. Gupta Building, Material Store (cited in the opinion) to submit that Order 18, Rule 17 is intended to permit the Court to recall witnesses for clarification and not to enable parties to fill lacunae in their evidence or to produce additional material after the evidence stage; recording of evidence should be continuous and lacuna-filling applications should generally not be entertained.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S.S.S. Durai Pandian v. S.A. Samuthira Pandian, AIR 1988 Mad. 323 Authority for the Trial Court's powers to recall a party/witness under Order 18, Rule 17 CPC; submitted by the Appellant to show recall power independent of Section 151 CPC and broadly discretionary. The Appellant relied on this decision to request recall. The Court noted the reliance but analysed the issue in light of higher authority (Supreme Court decisions) to limit the permissible use of Order 18, Rule 17 as one for clarification rather than filling evidentiary omissions.
K.K. Velusamy v. N. Palanisamy, 2011 (3) CTC 422 (SC) : 2011 (4) Scale 61 Elucidation of Order 18, Rule 17 CPC: the provision enables the Court to recall any witness to clarify doubts; it may be exercised suo motu or on application, but it is not intended to enable parties to recall witnesses to fill omissions or to place additional material after evidence has concluded. For reopening, Section 151 CPC is the proper recourse. The Court relied on this Supreme Court authority as decisive guidance: Order 18, Rule 17 is primarily for judicial clarification and not for party-driven reopening to fill lacunae. This principle was applied to reject the Appellant's entitlement to reopen PW1's evidence.
Bagai Construction thr. its Proprietor v. Gupta Building, Material Store, 2013 (1) MWN (Civil) 573 (SC) : 2013 (2) Scale 769 Reinforces that recording of evidence should be continuous and followed promptly by arguments and decision; applications to cure lacunae in pleadings or evidence should generally not be entertained. Refers to K.K. Velusamy. The Court invoked this authority to support the view that the trial process should not be used to fill gaps in evidence belatedly and to justify refusing the Appellant's request to re-open the Plaintiff's evidence at a late stage.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying and applying the legal position set out by the Supreme Court in K.K. Velusamy and the subsequent reference in Bagai Construction. It emphasized that Order 18, Rule 17 CPC permits recall of a witness primarily for the purpose of clarification by the Court (suo motu or on an application) and is not intended as a mechanism for parties to fill omissions in a witness's evidence or to introduce additional material after evidence has been recorded. For reopening of a case or recall of witnesses for further party-driven cross-examination, Section 151 CPC is the appropriate recourse.

Applying those principles to the facts, the Court observed that the Appellant had been repeatedly given opportunities to cross-examine the Plaintiff's witnesses, including PW1, and had either failed to do so or had repeatedly sought adjournments. The Master had cautioned the Appellant's counsel that the right to cross-examine would close and further evidence for the Plaintiff would be recorded. Despite that, the Appellant did not cross-examine the Plaintiff and did not cross-examine other Plaintiff witnesses; only the counsel for Respondent No. 2/First Defendant conducted cross-examination that the Appellant later adopted.

When the Appellant himself was examined as DW2, he was confronted with 32 documents and admitted them. The Plaintiff thereafter sought recall of the Appellant for further cross-examination, which was allowed by the Single Judge and that allowance was upheld by the Division Bench. After recall, one additional document (P78) was exhibited. The Appellant then sought to re-open the Plaintiff's evidence post factum to cross-examine PW1 about the documents; the Appellant argued parity on the basis that the Plaintiff had been permitted further cross-examination.

The Court rejected the parity argument: each party must present and prove its own case and lead its own defence; the fact that the Court permitted the Plaintiff to recall the Appellant for clarification did not automatically entitle the Appellant to a belated opportunity to re-open the Plaintiff's evidence to fill lacunae. The documents produced during DW2's cross-examination pertained to the Appellant and matters of legal proceedings to which the Appellant was a party; the Appellant could not claim surprise.

The Court also noted that the discretion exercised by the Single Judge in permitting recall of the Appellant had already been upheld by the Division Bench, and therefore that exercise was not open for re-litigation here. As to the Appellant's separate application seeking dismissal of the petition on the ground of limitation, the Court declined to direct the Single Judge to decide that application first, observing that the sequencing and manner of hearing was within the Single Judge's discretion.

In sum, the Court concluded that the Appellant had had adequate opportunity to cross-examine the Plaintiff's witnesses but failed to do so, and that the legal authorities did not support permitting the Appellant to re-open the Plaintiff's evidence at that late stage as a means of filling evidentiary gaps.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeals are dismissed and the impugned order of the learned Single Judge (dismissing the Appellant's applications to recall/re-open the Plaintiff's evidence for further cross-examination) is upheld as unexceptional. The Appellant is ordered to pay costs of Rs. 10,000/- (Rupees ten thousand only) to the First Respondent/Plaintiff within fifteen days from the date of the order.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the Appellant's applications seeking reopening/recall of the Plaintiff's evidence for further cross-examination were refused; the Plaintiff's petition proceeds without the further cross-examination sought by the Appellant; the Appellant must pay costs as directed.
  • The Court applied existing Supreme Court authorities to limit the use of Order 18, Rule 17 CPC to judicial clarification and to discourage late attempts to fill lacunae in evidence. The decision enforces the principle that parties must exercise their opportunity to cross-examine when provided and cannot belatedly seek re-opening merely to cure omissions.
  • This opinion does not purport to announce a new legal principle; it applies established precedents to the facts and upholds the trial court's discretion. (The opinion does not discuss any broader novel precedent being set beyond the application of the cited authorities.)

This summary is limited to the information explicitly contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts not present in that text.

Show all summary ...

Sanjay Kishan Kaul, C.J:— Late Thiru. S.V Ramakrishnan (Testator) is alleged to have executed a Will dated 15.7.1970 and the First Respondent before us (Original Plaintiff) filed a Petition on 18.12.2006 for grant of Letters of Administration in respect of the said Will, 26 years after the death of the Testator, who passed away on 31.12.1980 The Testator was married to one Rajalakshmi, the mother of the Appellant (Original Second Defendant), who passed away in March, 1952. There were two children born from their marriage, the Appellant/Second Defendant and Respondent No. 2.First Defendant. It appears that the Testator started living with the sister of Rajalakshmi, Smt. Saroja and the Union produced three daughters and a son. Respondent No. 1 is one of the daughters. The Petition was opposed by Appellant/Second Defendant and Respondent No. 2.First Defendant.

2. Respondent No. 1.Plaintiff, who is staying in Mysore, entered the witness box as PW1 and was examined before the Additional Master-I on 26.8.2010 The Counsel for the Second Respondent/First Defendant concluded the cross-examination on 2.12.2010, whereafter the Counsel for the Appellant/Second Defendant took adjournment for cross-examination of Respondent No. 1.Plaintiff. It appears that thereafter there was only a saga of adjournments, though the First Respondent/Plaintiff appeared for cross-examination on 13.12.2010, 14.12.2010, 16.12.2010, 21.12.2010 and 5.1.2011 The matter was adjourned to 18.1.2011 by the learned Master cautioning that if cross-examination was not carried out on the next date, further testimony of other witnesses on behalf of the First Respondent/Plaintiff would be recorded. On 18.1.2011 also, the Counsel for the Appellant/Second Defendant is stated to have refused to cross-examine the First Respondent/Plaintiff, where after four more Witnesses were examined on behalf of First Respondent/Plaintiff, being PWs. 2 to 5. Their evidence was concluded on 13.6.2011 and it has been stated that the cross-examination was carried out only by the Counsel for the Second Respondent/First Defendant, while the Counsel for the Appellant/Second Defendant only adopted that cross-examination.

3. It appears that the cross-examination on behalf of the First Respondent/Plaintiff of the Appellant/Second Defendant, who appeared in the Witness box as DW2, was completed on 11.2.2013 and 32 documents were exhibited during that cross-examination by confronting DW2, who admitted those documents. However, the First Respondent/Plaintiff filed Applications for recall of the Appellant/Second Defendant for further cross-examination, which were contested by the Appellant/Second Defendant. The Applications were, however, allowed on 21.11.2013 by the learned Single Judge and the Appeals against the same were dismissed by the Division Bench on 6.2.2014 The Page: 85sequitur was that the Appellant again appeared for cross-examination and was confronted with one more document, which was exhibited as P78. The evidence of Defendants, thus, stood concluded on that date.

4. The Appellant, thereafter, filed two Applications bearing Nos. 2565 & 2566 of 2014 on 9.4.2014 for recall and re-opening of the evidence of the First Respondent/Plaintiff with further opportunity to cross-examine her in respect of the documents exhibited in the cross-examination of the Appellant/Second Defendant. It is the say of the Appellant/Second Defendant that before he could make the said Applications, the First Respondent/Plaintiff had moved the Applications, which were contested by the Appellant/Second Defendant. The Appellant/Second Defendant pleaded parity with the First Respondent/Plaintiff on the issue of further cross-examination. These applications were opposed by the First Respondent/Plaintiff.

5. The learned Single Judge, vide the impugned Order dated 15.4.2014, dismissed the Applications filed by the Appellant/Second Defendant, aggrieved by which, the present Appeals have been filed.

6. Learned Senior Counsel for the Appellant submitted that in the cross-examination of the Appellant/Second Defendant, vital documents having material bearing on the case were exhibited and thus, the further examination of the First Respondent/Plaintiff was necessary. The documents initially exhibited, amongst 32 documents, included an Assignment Deed executed by the First Respondent/Plaintiff, in which, there has been an admission that the Testator had died intestate with regard to the properties listed in Annexure-A at item Nos. 3 & 4 of the Affidavit of assets, despite having executed the Will and the cross-examination of First Respondent/Plaintiff on this issue was vital. In substance, the plea is that if the case could have been reopened for cross-examination of the Appellant/Second Defendant, why should the same treatment/benefit be not meted out qua cross-examination of First Respondent/Plaintiff.

7. Learned Senior Counsel for the Appellant relied upon a Judgment of this Court by a learned Single Judge in S.S.S Durai Pandian v. S.A Samuthira Pandian, AIR 1988 Mad. 323, to contend that the Trial Court has got powers to recall the Plaintiff for re-cross-examination under Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, (hereinafter referred to as ‘the said Code’) on the Application filed by the Defendant, independent of Section 151 of the said Code. The power of Court is very wide and discretionary, though the same has to be exercised with greatest care and in most peculiar circumstances. The right of the Court to act under this Rule was not restricted in case of its own motion.

8. The Court, in fact, pointed out to the learned Counsel for the parties the Judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in K.K Velusamy v. N. Palanisamy, 2011 (3) CTC 422 (SC) : 2011 (4) Scale 61, elucidating the Page: 86legal position qua an Application under Order 18, Rule 17 of the said Code. It has been held that the said provision enables the Court, at any stage of the Suit, to recall any Witness, who has been examined (subject to the law of evidence for the time being in force) and put such questions to him as it thinks fit. Such power can be exercised by the Court either on its own motion or on an Application filed by any of the parties to the Suit requesting the Court to clarify any doubts it may have in regard to the evidence led by the parties and such power is not intended to use to fill up omissions in the evidence of a Witness, who has already been examined. However, this is not a provision intended to enable the party to recall any Witnesses for their further cross-examination in chief or cross-examination or to place additional material or evidence, which could not be produced when the evidence was being recorded. It is primarily a provision enabling the Court to clarify any issue or doubt, by recalling any Witness either suo moto or at the request of any party, so that the Court itself can put questions and elicit answers. Once a Witness is recalled for the purpose of such clarification, it may, of course, permit the parties to assist it by putting some questions. For a case to be reopened and/or recall of Witnesses for cross-examination, the proper recourse would be to Section 151 of the said Code.

9. On this legal issue, the learned Counsel for the First Respondent/Plaintiff referred also to the Judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Bagai Construction thr. its Proprietor v. Gupta Building, Material Store, 2013 (1) MWN (Civil) 573 (SC) : 2013 (2) Scale 769, which, in turn, has referred to the aforesaid Judgment. The Court expressed with a view that it was desirable that the recording of evidence should be continuous and followed by arguments and decision thereon within a reasonable time. Applications to overcome lacuna in the Plaint, pleadings and the evidence ought not to be entertained.

10. In the conspectus of the aforesaid legal position, the learned Counsel for the First Respondent/Plaintiff sought to contend that the Appellant/Second Defendant had never cross-examined any Witness of the First Respondent/Plaintiff including the First Respondent/Plaintiff, who appeared as PW1. He was given numerous opportunities, which were followed by the caution that the right for cross-examination would stand closed and further evidence on behalf of the First Respondent/Plaintiff would be recorded, the dates of which have already been set out aforesaid. Despite this, there was no cross-examination and even the other Witnesses produced by the First Respondent/Plaintiff were never cross-examined by the learned Counsel for the Appellant/Second Defendant. The only cross-examination was by the Counsel for the Second Respondent/First Defendant and the Counsel for the Appellant/Second Defendant only adopted the said cross-examination. It is submitted that the documents, which have been produced, relate to legal proceedings, Affidavits, etc., to which the First Respondent/Plaintiff was not a party, but the Appellant/Second Defendant was.

11. We have given a thought to the matter and are of the view that the Appeals are meritless. If the legal principles enunciated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the aforesaid Judgments are applied to the facts of the present case, it would be quite apparent that despite repeated opportunities, the Counsel for the Appellant/Second Defendant never cross-examined any of the Witnesses of the First Respondent/Plaintiff. The Appellant/Second Defendant, thus, had adequate opportunity, but to no avail. The Counsel for Respondent No. 1.Plaintiff was well within his right to confront the Appellant as DW2 with documents, which were within his knowledge and thus, proved those documents in cross-examination. The Appellant/Second Defendant cannot be said to have been taken by surprise on being confronted with those documents.

12. The First Respondent/Plaintiff, did seek further cross-examination and one more document was produced in that process. Whether such permission ought to have been granted or not is a issue no more open, as the exercise of discretion by the learned Single Judge was upheld even by the Division Bench. We, however, fail to appreciate the plea of parity on this account, i.e, because the First Respondent/Plaintiff was permitted to further cross-examination of the Appellant/Second Defendant, in which process, one more document was exhibited, the Appellant/Second Defendant should be given an opportunity to cross-examine the First Respondent/Plaintiff as PW1 qua all the documents produced by the First Respondent/Plaintiff during the cross-examination of the Appellant/Second Defendant. Each party has to prove his own case or leads his own defence. As observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the aforesaid two Judgments of K.K Velusamy v. N. Palanisamy, 2011 (3) CTC 422 (SC); and Bagai Construction thr. its Proprietor v. Gupta Building, Material Store, 2013 (1) MWN (Civil) 573 (SC), supra, the objective cannot be to fill in the lacunae and gaps in the evidence, by this exercise. It is not a case where the Court has felt handicapped and needs any elucidation. These documents pertain to the Appellant/Second Defendant. They are matters of legal proceedings. The Appellant/Second Defendant has not been caught by surprise. Thus, the Appellant/Second Defendant, at this stage, cannot be permitted to cross-examine the First Respondent/Plaintiff as PW1. It is on completion of trial that belatedly the prayer was made by the Appellant/Second Defendant. It is at a stage where even the evidence of the Defendants is over and in fact, the Applications were filed post adjournment of the Suit for final hearing on a date agreed to by the Counsel for the parties.

13. The Appeals are, thus, completely meritless and the impugned Order of the learned Single Judge is unexceptional.

14. We may note another aspect to the matter arising from the plea of the learned Senior Counsel for the Appellant that the Appellant had also moved an Application seeking dismissal of the Petition for grant of Letters of Administration on the ground of bar of limitation, but, no order has been Page: 88passed on that Application. What is prayed for is a direction that the said Application must be decided first.

15. We are unable to make such directions as prayed for on behalf of the Appellant/Second Defendant. The learned Single Judge, who is seized of the issue, has the Application before him. Whether he considers it appropriate to first hear the Application pleading bar of limitation at a belated stage or would like to hear all aspects simultaneously is a matter of complete discretion of the learned Single Judge.

16. The endeavour of the Appellant, especially keeping in mind, his conduct as reflected from the Order-sheets, somehow to delay the conclusion of the Suit, must be repelled and the Appeals are dismissed with costs, quantified at Rs. 10,000/- (Rupees ten thousand only) payable to the First Respondent/Plaintiff, within fifteen days from today.