Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

B.L. Grover v. Union Of India

Delhi High Court
Sep 20, 1979
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff and the defendants entered into a contract (Agreement No. SEDS/64 of 1956-57) for the execution of the work described as "Construction of Delhi Side approach on Mai Mathura Road near Bhogal." The contract contained an arbitration clause (clause 25) providing for reference to the Chief Engineer, Central Public Works Department, or, if he were unable or unwilling, to a person appointed by him as sole arbitrator.

Disputes arose and the plaintiff invoked the arbitration clause by letter dated 14 June 1961, seeking adjudication of thirteen disputes (Annexure-B). The Chief Engineer, by letter dated 26 October 1961, appointed an arbitrator for some disputes but excluded items Nos. 10, 11, 12(a), 12(b), 12(c) and 13 of Annexure-B. Subsequently there was a prosecution involving the plaintiff and some departmental officers; the plaintiff was finally acquitted by this Court on or about 30 May 1975 (judgement of V.D. Misra J.). The appointed arbitrator had resigned and proceedings could not continue because records were with the police.

After his acquittal, the plaintiff sought appointment of an arbitrator and, by letter dated 24 August 1976 (Annexure-L), submitted 19 disputes (including previously submitted disputes). The Chief Engineer, by letter dated 29 October 1977 (Annexure-N), appointed Kumari K.P. Sarojini as sole arbitrator but limited the reference to nine claims only.

The plaintiff filed the present petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act seeking (a) that the arbitration agreement be filed in court and (b) that the Chief Engineer be directed to refer all 19 disputes detailed in the plaintiff's letter dated 24 August 1976 to an arbitrator, thereby superseding the limited reference made by the Chief Engineer on 29 October 1977.

The defendants replied that an arbitrator had already entered on the reference (making the Section 20 application not maintainable) and that additional disputes raised by the plaintiff were time-barred. On 6 November 1978 two issues were framed (set out below). The plaintiff also filed an interlocutory application (I.A. No. 805 of 1979) under Section 5 of the Limitation Act seeking condonation of delay in filing the Section 20 petition; the defendants opposed condonation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the disputes mentioned in the Annexure to the plaintiff's letter dated 24 August 1976 to the Chief Engineer, P.W.D., New Delhi, are not referable to the arbitrator Miss K.P. Sarojini, already appointed by the defendants?
  2. What relief should be granted?

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff sought filing of the arbitration agreement and referral of all 19 disputes listed in his letter dated 24 August 1976 (Annexure-L), asserting that some disputes previously submitted were not referred by the Chief Engineer.
  • By I.A. No. 805 of 1979 under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, the plaintiff argued for condonation of delay in filing the Section 20 petition, on the ground that he had been under a bona fide impression that no limitation period governed a Section 20 application until later authoritative decisions clarified the law.

Defendants' Arguments

  • The defendants contended that an arbitrator had already entered on the reference and therefore the plaintiff's application under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act was not maintainable.
  • They also pleaded that the additional disputes raised by the plaintiff were barred by time and hence not referable to arbitration.
  • In opposition to condonation of delay, the defendants argued that the plaintiff had not shown sufficient cause under Section 5 of the Limitation Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mohd Usman v. Union of India, AIR 1969 SC 474 Held that an application under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act was not covered by Article 181 of the Limitation Act, 1908; Article 181 was restricted to applications under the Code of Civil Procedure. The court noted this decision as part of the body of authorities that had led the plaintiff to believe there was no period of limitation for Section 20 applications.
Town Municipal Council, Athani v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Hubli, AIR 1969 SC 1335 Held that Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963 was confined to applications under the Code of Civil Procedure. The court recorded that this earlier view contributed to the plaintiff's bona fide impression that no limitation applied to Section 20 petitions.
Kerala State Electricity Board, Trivandrum v. T.P. Kunhaliumma, AIR 1977 SC 282 Held that Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963 applies to any petition or application filed under any Act (i.e., not confined to CPC applications); it overruled the confined view in Town Municipal Council, Athani. The court relied on this Supreme Court authority as a turning point showing Article 137 applies to Section 20 petitions, affecting the assessment of whether there was sufficient cause for delay.
Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Shah Construction Co., Suit No. 160A of 1976 (order dated 22 Dec 1978) Held by this court that an application under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act is governed by Article 137 of the Limitation Act, which prescribes a period of three years from the date when the right to apply accrues. The court treated this decision as binding precedent in the local context and as the decisive development that made the plaintiff aware that Article 137 applied; this formed the basis for condoning delay under Section 5.
Raw Venkata Surya Rao v. Ravu Venkata Rao, AIR 1963 Andh Pra 286 Authority where arbitrator had been appointed outside court and disputes had already been referred to that arbitrator; addressed a second appointment application. The court held this authority inapplicable to the present facts because, in those cases, the disputes had already been referred to an arbitrator; here the disputes now sought to be referred had not been referred to the arbitrator.
Mangal Prasad… v. Lachhman Prasad…, AIR 1964 All 108 (FB) Similar authority involving a previously appointed arbitrator and a prior reference of the disputes. The court found the facts of this authority not applicable for the same reason: in that case disputes were already referred, unlike the present matter.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court addressed two principal strands of analysis: (A) whether the plaintiff's Section 20 petition could be admitted despite delay, and (B) whether the disputes now pressed by the plaintiff were referable under Section 20 given that an arbitrator (K.P. Sarojini) had been appointed for certain claims.

A. Condonation of Delay (Section 5, Limitation Act)

  • The plaintiff had filed the petition belatedly and sought condonation under Section 5 of the Limitation Act. The court examined the evolution of authority about which Limitation Act article applied to Section 20 petitions.
  • Earlier decisions (Mohd Usman and Town Municipal Council, Athani) had led to an impression that Article 181 or Article 137 was confined or inapplicable to Section 20 petitions, causing the plaintiff to believe no limitation period applied.
  • The Supreme Court's decision in Kerala State Electricity Board v. T.P. Kunhaliumma clarified that Article 137 applies to any petition or application filed under any Act, thereby changing the legal position.
  • This court's own order in Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Shah Construction Co. (22 Dec 1978) held explicitly that Section 20 is governed by Article 137, which prescribes a three-year period. That decision clarified the law for the plaintiff only on 22 December 1978.
  • The court concluded that the plaintiff's bona fide misapprehension about the existence of a limitation period, dispelled only after the court's 22 December 1978 order, constituted sufficient cause under Section 5 of the Limitation Act to condone the delay. Accordingly, the Section 20 petition was admitted despite being beyond the Article 137 period.

B. Maintainability of Section 20 Petition and Referability of Disputes

  • The defendants argued that an arbitrator had already entered on the reference, making the Section 20 application not maintainable. The court examined whether proceedings under Chapter II of the Arbitration Act had been started (i.e., whether an arbitrator had been appointed without court intervention for the same disputes).
  • The court set out the statutory conditions necessary to invoke Section 20: (i) existence of an arbitration agreement entered into before any suit regarding the subject-matter, (ii) a difference has arisen to which the agreement applies and is sought to be referred, and (iii) proceedings under Chapter II have not been started (no arbitrator appointed without court intervention for adjudication of such disputes).
  • It was admitted that the disputes now sought to be referred had not been referred to any arbitrator by the Chief Engineer. Although Kumari K.P. Sarojini had been appointed for nine claims by letter dated 29 October 1977, the disputes the plaintiff sought to refer (per Annexure-L) were not among those referred.
  • The court concluded that Chapter II proceedings had not been commenced in respect of the disputes now sought to be referred and therefore Section 20 remained available to the plaintiff. The question of whether individual claims are time-barred was held to be a matter for the arbitrator to decide in the first instance, not for the court at this stage.
  • Accordingly, the court ordered that all disputes set out in the plaintiff's letter dated 24 August 1976 (Annexure-L), excluding those already referred to the arbitrator as per Annexure-N, be referred by the Chief Engineer to an arbitrator. Because Kumari K.P. Sarojini was said not to be acting as arbitrator, the Chief Engineer was directed to appoint a new arbitrator within two months from the date of the order.

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • The petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act was admitted despite being filed beyond the period of limitation prescribed by Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963, on the ground of sufficient cause under Section 5 of the Limitation Act.
  • All disputes listed in the plaintiff's letter dated 24 August 1976 (Annexure-L), excluding those already referred to the arbitrator under the Chief Engineer's letter dated 29 October 1977 (Annexure-N), are to be referred to an arbitrator by the Chief Engineer (defendant No. 4).
  • The Chief Engineer is directed to appoint an arbitrator within two months from the date of the order to refer the said disputes (excluding those already referred).

Direct consequences for the parties: the defendant Chief Engineer must appoint an arbitrator within two months and refer the listed disputes (except those already pending before the arbitrator). The arbitrator (once appointed) will decide the referability and the timeliness of individual claims (the court explicitly left the question of time-bar to the arbitrator). The parties were ordered to bear their own costs, and copies of the order and annexures were to be sent to the Chief Engineer.

The opinion does not state that it establishes any new legal precedent beyond applying and following existing Supreme Court and this Court's prior decisions; the decision effects the direct referral and condonation described above.

Orders accordingly.
Show all summary ...

This is a petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act for filing of arbitration agreement and appointment of an arbitrator. The Plaintiff entered into contract with the defendants for the execution of the work of “Construction of Delhi Side approach on Mai Mathura Road near Bhogal” and agreement No. SEDS/64 of 1956-57 was executed between the parties. The contract contained arbitration clause No. 25 under which it is provided that the disputes shall be referred to the Chief Engineer, Central Public Works Department and if he is unable or unwilling to act, to the sole arbitration of some other person to be appointed by him. Disputes arose between the parties and the plaintiff vide his letter dated 14th June, 1961 invoked the arbitration clause and required the defendants to appoint an arbitrator for adjudication of thirteen disputes detailed therein (Annexure-B) to the petition. The Chief Engineer, vide letter dated 26th October, 1961 (Annexure-C) appointed an arbitrator to decide the disputes mentioned by the plaintiff except the disputes at items Nos. 10, 11, 12(a), 12(b), 12(c) and 13 of Annexure-B, There was prosecution Page: 46of the plaintiff and some officers of the department, The plaintiff was acquitted finally by this court on or about 30th May, 1975 as per judgement of V.D Misra J. The arbitrator in the meantime had resigned, and no progress could be made in the proceeding before the arbitrator as all records of the case were lying with police. After his acquittal the plaintiff sought the appointment of an arbitrator and also the reference of other disputes which came to his light subsequently, He submitted 19 disputes as per his letter dated 24th August, 1976 (Annexure-L) including the disputes already submitted previously. The Chief Engineer, by letter dated 29th October, 1977 (Annexure-N) appointed Km. K.P Sarojini Arbitrator, Ministry of Works and Housing, New Delhi as sole arbitrator to decide and make award with respect to nine claims only. The plaintiff by this petition prays that the defendants be directed to file the arbitration agreement and that the Chief Engineer defendant No. 4 be directed to refer all the 19 disputes as detailed in the plaintiff's letter dated 24th August, 1976 (Annexure-L) to the petition superseding the statement which he has sent to the arbitrator with his letter dated 29th October, 1977 (Annexure-N).

2. The defendants in their reply plead that the arbitrator had already entered on the reference and, therefore, the application under Section 20 of the Arbitral Act is not maintainable, that additional disputes raised by the plaintiff are barred by time and that thus the disputes are not referable to the arbitrator.

The following issues were framed on 6th of November, 1978 :—

(1) Whether the disputes mentioned in Annexure to the plaintiff's letter dated 24th August, 1976 to the Chief Engineer, P.W.D, New Delhi, are not referable to the arbitrator Miss. K.P Sarojini, already appointed by the defendants ?

(2) Relief.

3. The plaintiff on 12-3-1979 filed an application (I.A No. 805 of 1979) under Section 5 of the Limitation Act for condonation of delay in filing the petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act. The allegations are that certain disputes were referred to the arbitrator while the others were not referred by the Chief Engineer, that prosecution of the plaintiff ended and after his acquittal on 30-5-75 the plaintiff on 30-5-75 requested the defendants to appoint an arbitrator. The plaintiff prays that delay in filing petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act be condoned. The defendants in their reply plead that there is no sufficient cause for condonation of delay in filing the petition.

4. The learned counsel for the plaintiff submits that there was no period of limitation prescribed for filing of a petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act within the meaning of Limitation Act, 1908. In Mohd Usman v. Union Of India., AIR 1969 SC 474, the Supreme Court held that an application under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act was not covered by Article 181 of the Limitation Act and that the said article was restricted to application under the Code of Civil Procedure, In Town Municipal Council, Athani v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Hubli, AIR 1969 SC 1335 it was again held that Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963 was confined to the applications under the Code of Civil Procedure.

5. In view of these authorities it was assumed and the plaintiff was tinder a bona fide impression that there was no period of limitation for filing an application under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act. In The Kerala State Electricity Board, Trivandrum v. T.P Kunhaliumma, AIR 1977 SC 282, it was however held that Article 137, Limitation Act, 1963 applies to any petition or application filed under any Act. The Supreme Court differed with the view taken by it in Town Municipal Council, Athani v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Hubli, AIR 1969 SC 1335 and held that Article 137 was not confined to applications contemplated by the Code of Civil Procedure only. It was also observed that the interpretation given to Article 181 of the Limitation Act, 1908 was not applicable with regard to Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963.

6. In Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Shah Construction Co., Suit No. 160A of 1976 by order dated 22nd December, 1978 it was held by this court that an application under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act is governed by Article 137 of the Limitation Act, which article prescribes a period of three years from the date when the right to apply accrues. In view of this state of authorities the plaintiff was justified in holding the bona fide impression that there was no period of limitation for the petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act. It was, therefore, only after the decision of this Page: 47court announced on 22nd December, 1978 that the plaintiff realised that Article 137 of the Limitation Act would apply to a petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act. This state of affairs is a sufficient cause within the meaning of Section 5 of the Limitation Act and, therefore, I hold that there was sufficient cause for the plaintiff for not filing the petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act earlier. The petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act is, therefore, admitted beyond the period of limitation prescribed in Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963.

7. The contention of the learned counsel for the defendants is that the claims raised by the plaintiff are barred by time. The question whether the claims are within time is a matter for decision by the arbitrator and not by the court. The next contention of the learned counsel for the defendant is that the present petition under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act is not maintainable because the plaintiff has already taken proceedings under chapter II of the Arbitration Act meaning thereby that an arbitrator has already been appointed without intervention of the court and, therefore, no arbitrator can be appointed. It is correct that Km. K.P Sarojini has already been appointed as an arbitrator by the Chief Engineer, Central Public Works Department but the disputes now sought to be referred were never referred to the said arbitrator at all. It cannot, therefore, be said that the plaintiff has taken any proceedings within the meaning of Chapter II of the Arbitration Act. The differences that have arisen between the parties have not already been referred to the arbitrator. S.20 (1) of the Arbitration Act reads as under :—

“Where any persons have entered into an arbitration agreement before the institution of any suit with respect to the subject matter of the agreement or any part of it, and where a difference has arisen to which the agreement applies, they or any of them, instead of proceeding under Chapter II, may apply to a Court having jurisdiction in the matter to which the agreement relates, that the agreement be filed in court.”

8. In order to attract the provisions of Section 20 of the Arbitration Act the following conditions are necessary :—

(i) That the arbitration agreement must have been entered into before the institution of any suit, with respect to the subject-matter of the agreement or any of, it.

(ii) That a difference has arisen to which the agreement applies, and it sought to be referred.

(iii) That proceedings under Chapter II of the Act have not been started i.e arbitrator has not been appointed without intervention of court for adjudication of such disputes.

9. It is admitted that the disputes which are now sought to be referred by the plaintiff have not been referred so far by the Chief Engineer, to any arbitrator and therefore, it cannot be said that proceedings under Chapter II of the Arbitration Act have been taken. The learned counsel for the defendants has cited Raw Venkata Surya Rao v. Ravu Venkata Rao, AIR 1963 Andh Pra 286 and Mangal Prasad… v. Lachhman Prasad…., AIR 1964 All 108 (FB). The facts of these two authorities are not at all applicable to the facts of the present case. In both these authorities arbitrator had already been appointed outside court and the disputes were already referred to the arbitrator who for one reason or the other could not proceed with the arbitration and the aggrieved party sought appointment of arbitrator for reference of the same disputes for the second time.

10. Disputes which have been detailed in Annexure-L are the disputes relating to the contract and the work in question. They are all, it is admitted covered with in the meaning of clause 25 of the Arbitration Clause. I, therefore, hold that all the disputes raised by the plaintiff are referable to arbitration. The disputes detailed in the reference letter dated 29th October, 1977 (Annexure-N) are already pending before the arbitrator. I, therefore, order that all the disputes mentioned in the plaintiff's letter dated 24th August, 1976 (Annexure-L) excluding the disputes already pending before the arbitrator as detailed in (Annexure-N) shall be referred by the Chief Engineer defendant No. 4 to an arbitrator. The plaintiff's counsel states that Kumari K.P Sarojini arbitrator is not acting at present as such and, therefore, a new arbitrator is to be appointed. The Chief Engineer defendant No. 4 is, therefore, directed to appoint an arbitrator within two months from the date of this order referring all the disputes detailed in the plaintiff's letter dated 24th August, 1976 (Annexure-L) to the petition but excluding the disputes which have already been referred by him as per his reference letter Page: 48dated 29th October, 1977 (Annexure-N to the petition). Parties are left to bear their own costs. A copy of this order with copies of Annexure ‘L’ including ‘X’ and Annexure ‘N’ be sent to the Chief Engineer, defendant No. 4.

Orders accordingly.