Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Akkode Jumayath Palli Paripalana Committee v. P.V Ibrahim Haji And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Jul 23, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant is a society registered under the Societies Registration Act, formed to manage and administer wakf property, including the mosque known as “Akkode Juyamath Palli” and an associated madarsa. Seeking protection from interference by the respondents, the society filed a suit for perpetual injunction before the Court of the Munsif, Manjeri. The matter was transferred to the Wakf Tribunal, Kozhikode as OS No. 53 of 2003.

After a contested hearing, the Wakf Tribunal on 28-9-2004 decreed in favour of the appellant, restraining the respondents from disturbing the administration, management, possession and enjoyment of the mosque, madarsa and all attached assets.

The respondents challenged that decree through Civil Revision Petition No. 1362 of 2004 before the Kerala High Court under Section 83(9) of the Wakf Act. Relying on this Court’s decision in Ramesh Gobindram v. Sugra Humayun Mirza Wakf (2010) 8 SCC 726, the High Court on 10-11-2010 held that a suit for injunction is not maintainable before a Wakf Tribunal, set aside the Tribunal’s decree and permitted the appellant to withdraw the plaint for presentation before the appropriate civil court. A review petition (RP No. 87 of 2011) was dismissed on 4-2-2011. The appellant then approached the Supreme Court, leading to the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Wakf Tribunal constituted under Section 83 of the Wakf Act, 1995 possesses jurisdiction to entertain a suit seeking an injunction to restrain interference with the administration, management and peaceful enjoyment of a mosque, its madarsa and related wakf assets.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramesh Gobindram v. Sugra Humayun Mirza Wakf (2010) 8 SCC 726 The Wakf Tribunal has no jurisdiction over eviction disputes because the Wakf Act does not provide for such proceedings; civil court jurisdiction is therefore not excluded for eviction suits. The Supreme Court explained that this precedent concerns tenant eviction matters and is not applicable to suits involving management and peaceful enjoyment of wakf property. Hence, the High Court’s reliance on this case was misplaced.
W.B. Wakf Board v. Anis Fatma Begum (2010) 14 SCC 588 Disputes relating to demarcation and management of wakf property fall within the jurisdiction of the Wakf Tribunal. The Supreme Court cited this case to distinguish Ramesh Gobindram and to affirm that management-related disputes, like the present one, are within the Tribunal’s purview.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court identified the nature of the dispute as one concerning the management and peaceful enjoyment of wakf property, specifically a mosque, madarsa and their assets. Applying the test articulated in Ramesh Gobindram itself—namely, whether the Wakf Act requires the Tribunal to deal with the matter—the Court observed that issues of administration and protection of wakf property are contemplated by the Act and therefore fall squarely within the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.

Because Ramesh Gobindram addressed eviction of tenants—a category of dispute for which the Act provides no Tribunal mechanism—the precedent did not govern the present injunction suit. Conversely, the principle affirmed in W.B. Wakf Board v. Anis Fatma Begum supported the Tribunal’s competence over management-related controversies. On this analytic basis, the Court held that the High Court erred in excluding the Tribunal’s jurisdiction and in setting aside the Tribunal’s decree without considering the revision on its merits.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Supreme Court set aside the Kerala High Court’s order in CRP No. 1362 of 2004 and remitted the matter to the High Court for consideration of the revision petition on its merits, thereby affirming that the Wakf Tribunal had jurisdiction to grant the injunction sought in OS No. 53 of 2003.

Implications: The decision clarifies that the jurisdictional exclusion recognized in Ramesh Gobindram is confined to eviction and tenant-related disputes, and that the Wakf Tribunal retains authority over suits concerning management, administration and protection of wakf property. While the ruling directly affects the parties by restoring the Tribunal’s decree, it also guides lower courts on the proper scope of Wakf Tribunal jurisdiction without creating a new legal test.

Show all summary ...

K.S.P Radhakrishnan, J.— Leave granted. The question that arises for consideration in this appeal is: whether the Wakf Tribunal has got jurisdiction to entertain a suit for injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with the administration, management and peaceful enjoyment of the mosque and madarsa run by it and all the assets attached to the mosque.

2. The appellant, a society registered under the Societies Registration Act stated to be formed for the management and administration of wakf property including a mosque situated therein, filed a suit for an injunction before the Court of the Munsif, Manjeri, which was transferred to the Court of the Wakf Tribunal, Kozhikode and numbered as OS No. 53 of 2003. The suit was contested by the respondents on merits and ultimately it was decreed by the Wakf Tribunal on 28-9-2004 and the plaintiff was given a decree for a perpetual injunction restraining the respondent-defendants and their men from interfering in any manner in the administration, management and peaceful possession and enjoyment of the mosque, namely, Akkode Juyamath Palli, the madarsa run by it and all the assets attached to the mosque.

3. The respondents herein filed a civil revision petition as CRP No. 1362 of 2004 under Section 83(9) of the Wakf Act before the Kerala High Court. The High Court vide its judgment dated 10-11-2010 CRP No. 1362 of 2004 set aside the judgment and decree passed by the Wakf Tribunal holding that a suit for injunction is not maintainable before a Wakf Tribunal placing reliance on the judgment of this Court in Ramesh Gobindram v. Sugra Humayun Mirza Wakf (2010) 8 SCC 726. The Court also granted permission to the appellant to take back the plaint for presenting before the appropriate court. Later, the appellant preferred a review petition which was also dismissed by the High Court on 4-2-2011 Review Petition No. 87 of 2011. The legality of the orders is under challenge in this appeal.

4. We are of the view that the High Court has committed an error in holding that the reliefs sought for by the appellants in the suit could not be claimed before the Wakf Tribunal in view of the judgment of this Court in Ramesh Gobindram (2010) 8 SCC 726. In Ramesh Gobindram (2010) 8 SCC 726 the question that arose for consideration before this Court was whether the Wakf Tribunal constituted under Section 83 of the Wakf Act was competent to entertain and adjudicate upon disputes regarding eviction of the appellants who were occupying different items which were admittedly wakf properties. The Wakf Tribunal answered the question of jurisdiction in affirmative and decreed the suit which was affirmed by the High Court. This Court, after examining the various provisions of the Wakf Act and Section 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure held in paras 34 and 35 of the judgment as follows:

“34. The crucial question that shall have to be answered in every case where a plea regarding exclusion of the jurisdiction of the civil court is raised is whether the Tribunal is under the Act or the Rules required to deal with the matter sought to be brought before a civil court. If it is not, the jurisdiction of the civil court is not excluded. But if the Tribunal is required to decide the matter the jurisdiction of the civil court would stand excluded.
35. In the cases at hand, the Act does not provide for any proceedings before the Tribunal for determination of a dispute concerning the eviction of a tenant in occupation of a wakf property or the rights and obligations of the lessor and the lessees of such property. A suit seeking eviction of the tenants from what is admittedly wakf property could, therefore, be filed only before the civil court and not before the Tribunal.”

This Court allowed the appeals and the orders passed by the Wakf Tribunal were set aside and the suit filed by the respondents for eviction of the appellants before the Tribunal was held not maintainable.

5. The ratio laid down in the abovementioned judgment in Ramesh Gobindram case (2010) 8 SCC 726 later came up for consideration before this Court in W.B Wakf Board v. Anis Fatma Begum (2010) 14 SCC 588 and the judgment in Ramesh Gobindram case (2010) 8 SCC 726 was held distinguishable. That was a case where the dispute related to the wakf estate which was created by a registered deed of wakf dated 22-9-1936. The question raised was with regard to the demarcation of the wakf property, which this Court held is a matter which fell under the purview of the Wakf Act. The judgment of the Calcutta High Court which held otherwise was set aside and this Court held that the Wakf Tribunal has jurisdiction to decide those disputes.

6. We are of the view that the dispute that arises for consideration in this case is with regard to the management and peaceful enjoyment of the mosque and madarsa and the assets which relate to wakf. Nature of the relief clearly shows that the Wakf Tribunal has got jurisdiction to decide those disputes. We, therefore, find no error in the Wakf Tribunal entertaining OS No. 53 of 2003 filed by the appellant and the High Court has committed an error in holding otherwise. Consequently, the impugned order CRP No. 1362 of 2004 passed by the High Court is set aside and the matter is remitted to the High Court to consider the revision on merits. The appeals are disposed of as above, with no order as to costs.