Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rahmat Bee And Others v. Maqbool Banu And Another

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Jul 4, 1989
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This Civil Revision Petition challenges the order of the learned Subordinate Judge, Adoni, Kurnool District, in I.A No. 328 of 1983 in O.S No. 8 of 1961. The original suit was filed by the sole plaintiff seeking partition of the plaint schedule properties and separate possession of her one-third share. The trial Court decreed the suit with a preliminary decree after overruling the defendants' objections. On appeal, the Appellate Court modified the decree, specifying the shares of the plaintiff and each defendant, including the 10th defendant (the present petitioner), who was allotted a 4/384th share in certain schedule properties.

The 10th defendant filed I.A No. 328 of 1983 seeking appointment of a Commissioner to divide the properties and allot his share as per the decree. The Legal Representatives of Defendant No. 1 opposed the petition, arguing it was not maintainable as the preliminary decree did not direct allotment or separate possession for the defendants. The trial Court rejected this plea and appointed a Commissioner accordingly. The Legal Representatives of Defendant No. 1 then filed this revision petition against that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a petition for appointment of a Commissioner to divide and allot shares as per a preliminary decree is maintainable in the absence of a specific direction in the preliminary decree regarding allotment and separate possession of defendants' shares.
  2. Whether defendants need to get the preliminary decree modified before seeking partition or separate possession of their shares when their shares have already been specified in the preliminary decree.

Arguments of the Parties

Legal Representatives of Defendant No. 1

  • The petition filed by the 10th defendant for appointment of a Commissioner is not maintainable.
  • There is no direction in the preliminary decree about allotment and separate possession in favour of the defendants.
  • Unless the preliminary decree is modified, defendants cannot seek partition or separate possession of their shares.
  • Relied on the decision in K. Rangayya Naidu v. K. Venkataswami Naidu 1986 (1) A.P.L.J 272 to support this contention.

Court's Counter-Arguments (as per judgment)

  • The preliminary decree specifies the shares of the plaintiff as well as the defendants unmistakably.
  • The absence of a direction for separate possession in the preliminary decree does not bar defendants from seeking a Commissioner’s appointment for partition and allotment.
  • It is not necessary to get the preliminary decree modified when shares are already declared.
  • Multiplicity of proceedings should be avoided; defendants are entitled to have a final decree passed in accordance with the preliminary decree.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K. Rangayya Naidu v. K. Venkataswami Naidu 1986 (1) A.P.L.J 272 Petition for partition or separate possession not maintainable without specific direction in preliminary decree unless decree is modified. The Court disagreed with this view and held that where shares are specified, defendants can seek partition without decree modification.
Bittan Devi v. Rudra Sen A.I.R 1966 Allahabad 601 Preliminary decree should declare defendants' shares; if not declared, defendants must get decree modified before partition; if declared, defendants can seek partition post-decree. The Court relied on this precedent to support that defendants can seek partition once shares are declared in preliminary decree.
Lachmi Narayan Marvary v. Balmukunda Marwary A.I.R 1924 P.C 198 No legal bar to any party initiating supplementary proceedings after passing of decree if rights and interests are declared. Supported the principle that any party can move for partition once rights are declared.
Sarbeswar v. Bibhabasu A.I.R 1977 Calcutta 288 Commissioner cannot partition or allot shares unless rights of parties are declared in preliminary decree or decree is modified. The Court referred to this precedent but distinguished it on facts, noting the preliminary decree here declared all shares.
Muthu v. Veerammal 1981 (1) M.L.J 502 Partition application is not maintainable without declaration of defendants' rights in preliminary decree unless decree is modified. The Court cited this to affirm that once shares are declared in preliminary decree, defendants can seek partition without modification.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the provisions of Order 20 Rule 18 and Order 26 Rule 13 of the Civil Procedure Code. Order 20 Rule 18 allows a Court to pass a preliminary decree declaring the rights of all parties interested in the property and to give further directions as necessary. Order 26 Rule 13 empowers the Court to appoint a Commissioner to partition the property according to the rights declared in the preliminary decree.

In the instant case, the preliminary decree clearly specifies the shares of the plaintiff and all defendants, including the 10th defendant. Although the decree does not explicitly direct allotment or separate possession to the defendants, the Court held this omission does not bar the defendants from seeking a Commissioner’s appointment to partition and allot shares as per the decree. The Court reasoned that requiring modification of the preliminary decree in such circumstances would lead to unnecessary multiplicity of proceedings.

The Court reviewed relevant precedents and distinguished the decision in K. Rangayya Naidu v. K. Venkataswami Naidu, rejecting the view that the absence of an explicit direction in the preliminary decree precludes partition applications by defendants. The Court emphasized that once the shares are declared, defendants have the right to proceed for partition and separate possession without decree modification.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED the Civil Revision Petition, thereby affirming the trial Court's order appointing a Commissioner to divide the properties and allot shares as per the preliminary decree.

The implication of this decision is that where a preliminary decree in a partition suit specifies the shares of all parties, defendants are entitled to seek partition and separate possession of their shares without the necessity of modifying the decree. This avoids multiplicity of proceedings and facilitates the final settlement of rights. No new precedent contrary to existing law was established; rather, the Court clarified the application of procedural provisions to the facts at hand.

Show all summary ...

Amareswari, J.:— This Civil Revision Petition is filed against the order of the learned Subordinate Judge, Adoni, Kurnool District in I.A No. 328 of 1983 in O.S No. 8 of 1961.

2. The suit was filed by the sole plaintiff for partition of the plaint schedule properties and for separate possession of her ⅓rd share. The trial Court decreed the suit after overruling the objections of the defendants and passed a preliminary decree. The defendants carried the matter in appeal. By Judgment dated 26-9-1967 the Appellate Court modified the decree and declared the shares of the plaintiffs as well as the defendants. The plaintiff was held to be entitled to 64/384th share Similarly, the share of each of the defendants was specified. The present petitioner who is the 10th defendant in the suit was gives 4/384th share in ‘B’ schedule business and in the properties of ‘C’ and ‘F’ schedules other than the properties of ‘C’ in Ex. B25 and Ex. B26 of ‘F’ schedule. The 10th defendant thereafter filed I.A No. 328 of 1983 for appointing a Commissioner to divide the properties and allot his share as per the decree. The petition was resisted by the Legal Representatives of Defendant No. 1 that such a petition is not maintainable in as much as there was no direction in the preliminary decree about the allotment and separate possession of the defendants.

3. The trial Court rejected the plea of the first defendant and allowed the petition and appointed a Commissioner to divide the properties by metes and bounds and for allotment 4/384th share as specified in the preliminary decree. Aggrieved thereby, the Legal Representatives of the 1st defendant have preferred this revision.

4. When the matter came up before our learned brother Ramaswamy, J. it was argued that the petition was not maintainable. The learned counsel relied upon a decision of Single Judge of this Court in K. Rangayya Naidu v. K. Venkataswami Naidu 1986 (1) A.P.L.J Page 272 in support of his contention that in the absence of a direction in the preliminary decree regarding allotment and separate possession in favour of the defendants, the petition is not maintainable unless and until the defendants get the preliminary decree modified. The learned single Judge was not inclined to agree with this view and referred it to the Division Bench us otherwise it would lead to conflict of Judicial opinion. In order to appreciate the controversy, it is necessary to refer to Order 20 Rule 18 and Order 26 Rule 13 of Civil Procedure Code Order 20 Rule 18 is as follows:

“Where the Court passes a decree for the partition of property or for the separate possession of a share therein, then

1.) ..……

2.) if and in so far as such decree relates to any other immovable property or to movable property, the Court may, if the partition or separate cannot be conveniently made without further inquiry, pass a preliminary decree declaring the rights of the several parties interested in the property and giving such further directions as may be required.”

5. From the aforementioned provision, it is seen that the preliminary decree can specify not only the share of the plaintiff, but also the shares of all the parties interested in the property and it also enables the Court which passes the decree to give such further directions as may be required.

6. Order 26 Rule 13 enables the Court which passes the preliminary decree to appoint a Commissioner to make the partition according to the rights as declared in such decree. Where the rights of the parties are declared in the preliminary decree a Commissioner can be appointed to partition the properties as per the rights declared in the decree. In the instant case, the preliminary decree in no unmistaken terms specifies the rights of the plaintiff as well as each of the defendants. No doubt the preliminary decree does not say that the defendant should be put in possession of their shares, but that in our opinion does not make any difference. When once the shares are specified in the preliminary decree, it is open to the defendants to have a Commissioner appointed for allotment and separate possession of the properties as per the preliminary decree. In such a case, it is not necessary to get the preliminary decree modified. It is true that any Dumber of final decrees can be passed. But in this case, it is not necessary as the rights of each of the parties have been specified, in the preliminary decree.

7. We will now refer to some decisions relevant on the point.

8. In Bittan Devi v. Rudra Sen (1) A.I.R 1966, Allahabad, Page 601 it was held;

“It is true that the Courts of law generally lays down in the preliminary decree the plaintiffs' share or rights in the property, but where the defendants desire that their share or interest be also declared, the preliminary decree should contain such a declaration also. If, for some reason, the defendants, rights have not been declared in the preliminary decree, the aggrieved party can challenge the decree in an appeal or can apply for review. One thing is clear that after the passing of the preliminary decree also, the defendants can apply for and have their share partitioned on payment of court-fee etc., as may be necessary under the law.

The Courts of law cannot go behind the decree and have to take further stepson the basis of the decree already passed. Consequently if the preliminary decree passed in a partition suit does not contain any declaration as to the rights of the defendants, their application for the partition or separation of their share shall not be maintainable till they have the preliminary decree suitably modified, but once the preliminary decree contains a declaration as to the defendants' share, they can, even after the passing of the preliminary decree takes steps for the separation of their share.”

9. In Lachmi Narayan Marvary v. Balmukunda Marwary A.I.R 1924, P.C Page 198, the Privy Council held that it was the plaintiff who ordinarily moves the Court to initiate the supplimentary proceedings after the passing of a decree, but there Page: 223was not legal bar to any party to the suit taking such steps provided that his rights and interest had also been declared under the decree.

10. In Sarbeswar v. Bibhabasu A.I.R 1977, Calcutta Page 288 a Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court observed:

“Under the provisions of or 20 R-18 sub-rule (2) the Court though may pass a preliminary decree declaring the rights of the several parties in the suit property in a partition suit but generally the court declares the rights of the plaintiff and of those defendants who contest in the suit and desire their rights to be so declared. The rights and shares of the defendants being not declared in the preliminary decree, the Commissioner is not competent to partition and make separate allotment of the share in respect of the property-in-suit in favour of the petitioners unless the said preliminary decree is modified declaring the right anil share of the petitioners either on appeal or on review of the said preliminary decree.”

11. The Calcutta High Court approved the ratio of the decision in Bittan Devi v. Rudra Sen A.I.R 1966, Allahabad, Page 601.

12. A Single Judge of the Madras High Court in Muthu v. Veerammal 1981 (1) M.L.J Page 502 observed;

“If the preliminary decree already passed does not contain any declaration as to the rights of the defendants their application for partition or separation of their share shall not be maintainable till they have the preliminary decree suitably modified. But when once the preliminary decree contains a declaration as to the defendant's share they can even after passing of the preliminary decree take steps for the actual separation of their share.”

13. The learned Counsel for the petitioner draw our attention to a decision of a Single Judge of this Court in Kurella Rangayya Naidu… v. Kurella Venkataswamy Naidu…. 1986 (1) A.P.L.J Page 272 in which it is held that in the absence of a specific direction in the preliminary decree that the shares of defendants 1 and 2 shall also be separated, the petition is not maintainable till the decree is modified. We are unable to agree with this view.

14. In a partition suit, every party is in the position of a plaintiff and where a preliminary decree specifies the shares and rights of the plaintiffs as well as the defendants, the defendants can file an application after the passing of the preliminary decree to get their shares separated as per the decree and it is not necessary to get the decree modified. In fact, there is nothing to be modified since the shares are already specified. Multiplicity of proceedings have to be avoided. The defendants would be entitled to have a final decree passed in accordance with the preliminary decree. The Civil Revision Petition is accordingly dismissed. No costs.

15. C.M.P No. 606 of 1989. This is a petition to implead the 6th defendant in the suit as respondent No. 2 in this revision. The share of the 6th defendant is also specified in the preliminary decree in the suit. Hence there cannot be any objection for impleading this respondent. Petition to implead is ordered. The 6th defendant may also file an application that she may be put in possession of her share as per the preliminary decree and the Court shall pass orders accordingly.