- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mayar Traders Ltd. v. Akhil Services Ltd.
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Ms. Usha Mehra, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
M/s. Mayar Traders Ltd. (petitioner) filed an application seeking the winding up of M/s. Akhil Services Ltd. (respondent) on the ground that the respondent was unable to pay its debts. The parties entered into an agreement for printing lottery tickets, the terms of which were contained in the petitioner's letter dated 15.1.91. Under the arrangement the petitioner printed tickets for various draws (Jeewan Shakti, Jeewan Mothi, Jeewan Shree, Jeewan Sagar, Jeewan Akshay, Jeewan Jyothi and Jeewan Dhara) and despatched them to the respondent.
The petitioner raised bills for the printed tickets. Some payments were made but an amount of Rs. 1,72,000/- remained outstanding according to the petitioner. The respondent raised objections about deliveries and the schedule, lodged a protest regarding payments and later claimed damages of Rs. 1,35,780/-. After discussions, the respondent communicated by letter dated 29.1.92 that it would pay Rs. 1,02,721.03P (after adjustments). That amount was not paid despite reminders and a statutory notice dated 20.4.92. The respondent filed a reply to the show cause notice denying liability and asserting breach due to late delivery; the petitioner filed rejoinder asserting the settlement and admission of liability by the respondent.
The Court heard counsel for both parties, examined documents (including letters dated 15.1.91, the respondent's earlier letters complaining of delay in 1991, and the respondent's letter dated 29.1.92), and proceeded to consider whether the petition should be admitted.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondent company is unable to pay its debts within the meaning of the Companies Act, thereby justifying a winding up petition.
- Whether the respondent's letter dated 29.1.92, in which it communicated an admitted amount of Rs. 1,02,721.03P after discussions, constitutes an admission of liability under Section 433(e) of the Companies Act and establishes a present debt recoverable by the petitioner.
- Whether the respondent has raised a bona fide and substantial dispute (for example, by alleging breach and claiming damages) that would defeat the winding up petition.
- Whether the respondent has established that the alleged admission (letter dated 29.1.92) was procured or issued by a person without authority such that it should not be treated as an admission of liability.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (M/s. Mayar Traders Ltd.)
- The parties entered into the agreement as per letter dated 15.1.91 and the petitioner performed by printing and despatching tickets as agreed.
- The respondent admitted, in a letter dated 29.1.92, that a sum of Rs. 1,02,721.03P was due and payable; that amount remains unpaid despite statutory notice.
- Time for delivery was not the essence of the contract and there was no contractual provision that late delivery would give rise to a right to claim damages or to reject supply; therefore the respondent's counterclaim is not substantive.
- Under Section 433(e) of the Companies Act, the admission in 29.1.92 establishes a debt and the respondent is unable to prove discharge of that debt.
Respondent's Arguments (M/s. Akhil Services Ltd.)
- The petitioner breached the agreement by failing to supply lottery tickets as per the schedule (the agreement provided a delivery period of 21 days prior to the date of draw), causing the respondent loss and damages; respondent claimed Rs. 1,35,780/- as damages (letter dated 4.5.92).
- The letter dated 29.1.92 cannot be treated as an acknowledgement of liability because it was procured by the petitioner and was issued by a person allegedly without jurisdiction.
- Mere acknowledgement of debt does not operate as a new contract nor can it be the basis for the suit (relying on Hasti Mal v. Shanker Dan).
- Generally, if a company denies liability on a substantial ground then it cannot be said to have neglected to pay debts (relying on British India General Insurance Co. Ltd.).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Hasti Mal v. Shanker Dan, AIR 1952 Rajasthan, page 7 | Held that a mere acknowledgement of debt does not operate as a new contract and cannot be the basis of a suit; it keeps alive the original cause of action but does not create a new one. | The Court acknowledged the principle but distinguished the facts: here the respondent did not merely acknowledge; it settled the bills after discussion and admitted a specific sum (Rs. 1,02,721.03P), so the Court treated that admission as establishing present liability under Section 433(e). |
| M.V. Paulose v. City Hospital, (1992) 73 Company Cases, p.362 (Kerala High Court) | Referenced in support of the proposition that once a company admits it owes an amount, the onus is on the company to establish that the liability has been discharged. | The Court relied on this authority to support the view that the respondent, having admitted the debt, must show discharge; since no discharge was shown and statutory notice was ignored, the petitioner's claim stands. |
| British India General Insurance Co. Ltd., AIR 1971 Bombay Page 102 | Holds that if a company denies liability on a substantial ground then it cannot be said the company has neglected to pay debts (i.e., a bona fide substantial defence can defeat a winding up petition). | The Court considered this principle but found it inapplicable because the respondent's denial was not supported by a substantial or bona fide defence in view of the admission dated 29.1.92; thus the Bombay decision did not help the respondent. |
| J.N. Roy Chowdhury (Traders) Pvt. Ltd. v. Jainti Enterprises, (1987) Vol. 61 Company Cases p.504 (Calcutta High Court) | On the particular facts of that case the Court found the dispute to be bona fide and therefore refused to pass a winding up order. | The present Court distinguished that case on the facts: because of the respondent's admission on 29.1.92, the Court held that no substantial or bona fide dispute had been raised here and the Calcutta decision did not bar admission of the petition. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by examining the terms of the agreement (letter dated 15.1.91) and the subsequent correspondence between the parties. The letter of 15.1.91 prescribed delivery periods (21 days prior to draw for certain tickets) but did not specify contractual consequences for failure to adhere to the schedule.
The Court noted that the respondent had sent letters in 1991 (Annexures R1, R2 and R3) complaining of delay and warning of loss, and the petitioner had demanded payment (letter dated 4.6.91). Following discussions, the respondent's Manager (Operation) communicated to the petitioner by letter dated 29.1.1992 a settlement admitting an amount of Rs. 1,02,721.03P as due.
The central analytic question was whether the respondent could now raise a dispute about deliveries and damages despite that January 1992 settlement. The Court held that the settlement letter was of decisive importance because it was made after the 1991 complaints and after taking those complaints into account. The Court treated the 29.1.92 communication as more than a mere acknowledgement: it was a final admission of liability arrived at after discussion.
The respondent's contention that the 29.1.92 letter was procured or issued by an unauthorized person was considered but not proved: there was no resignation or other record to show that Mr. R.N. Bhagat (who had authored earlier letters R1–R3) lacked authority on 29.1.92. In the absence of evidence of lack of authority or of coercion, the Court was unwilling to disregard the admission.
The Court examined the respondent's reliance on authorities. It accepted the legal proposition from Hasti Mal that a mere acknowledgement does not create a new contract, but found that the facts here showed a final settlement rather than a mere acknowledgement. The Court also found the Bombay decision (British India) inapplicable because the respondent had not shown a bona fide substantial defence — the 29.1.92 admission negated such a defence. The Calcutta case (J.N. Roy Chowdhury) was likewise distinguished on facts; the present record did not disclose a bonafide dispute capable of defeating the petition.
The Court further observed that the respondent had failed to forward Annexure-IV (statement of account) when replying to the statutory notice, denying the petitioner an opportunity to scrutinize the claimed counterclaim. Statutory notice was duly received by the respondent and there was no adequate justification shown for non-payment of the admitted amount.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court admitted the petition for hearing.
Immediate implications and direct effects:
- The winding up petition by M/s. Mayar Traders Ltd. against M/s. Akhil Services Ltd. was admitted for hearing.
- The Court ordered publication of the citation in specified newspapers: "Statesman" (English), "Veer Arjun" (Hindi) and the Delhi Gazette for 20th January, 1994.
Broader implications: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent; it resolves the application on the particular facts before the Court, notably treating the respondent's post‑dispute settlement letter (29.1.92) as amounting to an admission of present liability under Section 433(e) of the Companies Act. The Court expressly distinguished earlier authorities relied upon by the respondent on the basis of factual differences and the absence of a bona fide defence in the present record.
Petition admitted for hearing.
This summary is confined strictly to the content of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond the text of that opinion.
Ms. Usha Mehra, J.— M/s. Mayar Traders Ltd., by this application has sought the winding up of M/s. Akhil Service Ltd. on the ground that the said Company is unable to pay its debts. M/s. Akhil Services Ltd., respondent herein, placed order on the petitioner company for the printing of lottery tickets for its various draws namely Jeewan Shakti, Jeewan Mothi, Jeewan Shree, Jeewan Sagar, Jeewan Akshay, Jeewan Jyothi and Jeewan Dhara. The agreement was arrived at between the parties, the terms of which are contained in petitioner's letter dated 15.191 Pursuance to that agreement, the petitioner was to print the tickets of the first four lotteries from the third draw onwards and those of the last three lotteries from the fourth draw onwards. These tickets were to be despatched by the petitioner to the respondent. Petitioner raised bill with regard to the lottery tickets printed by the petitioner for the respondent. Some payments were made by the respondent but an amount of Rs. 1,72,000/- was still due and outstanding against the respondent. Respondent raised objections regarding the delivery of ticket, schedule followed by the petitioner and hence lodged protest regarding payments. However, after discussion a settlement was arrived at pursuance to which the respondent agreed to pay to the petitioner a sum of Rs. 1,02,721.03P i.e after making certain adjustments. This was so communicated by the respondent to the petitioner vide letter dated 29.1.92 This admitted amount has not been paid inspite of the repeated reminders issued by the petitioner. Ultimately the petitioner issued a statutory notice on 20.4.92 In response to this notice, the respondent raised a counter claim to the tune of Rs. 1.35,780/- which according to the petitioner is after thought and not bonafide.
2. On application being filed a show cause notice was issued to the respondent in response to which a reply has been filed raising a dispute that neither any amount is payable nor due. On the contrary according to the respondent the petitioner committed breach by not supplying the lottery tickets as per the terms of the agreement dated 15.1.91 According to this agreement the delivery period was 21 days prior to the date of the draw of the lottery. This schedule was not adhered hence the respondent suffered loss and damages. Hence the respondent claimed a sum of Rs. 1.35.780/- on account of damages as mentioned in its letter dated 4th May, 1992. As regards letter dated 29.1.92, it was procured by the petitioner. The said letter cannot amount to acknowledgement of liability. It was issued by a person without jurisdiction. The tickets were received from 1 to 5 days before the date of draw, some of the tickets were from 6 to 10 days before the date of draw, others were received from 11 to 13 days before the date of draw and then 14 to 21 days before the date of draw. This delay in delivery led to the loss in the business of the respondent.
3. In rejoinder the petitioner took the plea that the time was not the essence of the contract nor it was agreed that in case the tickets were not supplied within 21 days the respondent would claim damages or reserved the right to reject the supply of the lottery tickets. In fact after discussion a settlement was arrived at thereby the respondent admitted the liability to pay to the petitioner a sum of Rs. 1,02,72103 P. After this settlement there remains nothing for the respondent to raise any dispute.
4. I have heard Mr. S.K Kaul, Counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Jayant Nath, Counsel for the respondent and have perused the documents placed on record. Admittedly as per the letter dated 15.1.91 the delivery of the lottery tickets was to be made 21 days from the date of 5th draw on wards and delivery of 3rd and 4th draw were as agreed. The reading of this letter does not indicate as to what would have happened if the delivery schedule was not adhered. Be that as it may, the respondent vide Annexure-R1 letter dated 15.3.91, Annexure-R 2 letter dated 25.3.91 and Annexure-R3 letter dated 25.4.91 did intimate to the petitioner that there was delay in the supply of lottery tickets on account of which respondent will suffer losses. It is also a fact that vide these letters the respondent pointed out to the petitioner that lottery tickets should be despatched in time and as per the delivery period mentioned in the agreement. All these letters are of the year 1991. Similarly the letter written by the petitioner making a demand of Rs. 1,75,000/- is dated 4th June, 1991. Thereafter, it appears, discussion took place pursuance to which the Manager (Operation) of the respondent company vide letter dated 29.1.1992 intimated to the petitioner a sum of Rs. 1,02,721.03P. The question that arises for consideration is; in view of this letter thereby settling the dispute between the parties does it lie now for the respondent to raise any dispute on the same account. Admittedly the complaint of the respondent that the lottery tickets were not supplied in time or as per the schedule or the delivery period, were of the year 1991, whereas this settlement after discussion was arrived at in Jan., 1992. Therefore, this letter assumes importance for the determination of this petition.
5. Mr. Jayant Nath, appearing for the respondent contended that this letter can at best be treated as an acknowledgement of debt. But mere acknowledgement would not fasten any liability on the respondent, nor does it operate as a new contract nor it can be made basis for the filing of this winding up petition. In order to strengthen his arguments he placed reliance on the decision of the Rajasthan High Court in the case of Hasti Mal v. Shanker Dan, AIR 1952, Rajasthan, page 7, where it was held that a mere acknowledgement of debt does not operate as a new contract and cannot be made basis of the suit. It only keeps alive the original cause of action but the suit must be founded on the original cause of action. There is no quarrel with the propostion of law laid down in this case, but the facts of that case are distinguishable. In the case in hand the respondent has not only acknowledged the liability, but settled the bills finally after discussion and admitted the amount due and payable to the tune of Rs. 1,02,721.03P. Therefore, as per Section 433(e) of the Companies Act, the amount due and payable in this case comes to Rs. 1.02,721.03P. This is the present liability of the respondent. It is not a mere acknowledgement of the debt. It is infact the admission of the liability after discussion. The bill raised be the petitioner were to the tune of Rs. 1.75 lacs whereas the respondent settled the dues to Rs. 1,22,160/- out of which further deductions were made on account of cost of sheets of printing papers and flap papers lying with the petitioner, thereby reducing the amount to Rs. 1,02,721.03. For the petitioner to invoke the provision of section 433, it was to prove that a debt exists and secondly the company is unable to pay it. In this case the petitioner by his own admission made in the letter dated 29.1.92, has established the debt due and payable to Rs. 1,02.721.03P and the same has not been paid by the respondent inspite of statutory notice. When once the company admits that it owes an amount, it is for the company to establish that the liability has been discharged. In this regard reference can be had to the decision of Kerala High Court in the case of M.V Paulose v. City Hospital, (1992) 73 Company Cases, page 362.
6. The contention of Counsel for the respondent that letter dated 29.1.92 was procured has not been prima facie proved on record nor any letter of resignation of Mr. R.N Bhagat has been placed on record. On the contrary on behalf of respondent Annexure-R1, R2 and R3 were all written by Mr. R.N Bhagat, Manager (Operation). This shows that Mr. Bhagat was competent to settle the amount due to the petitioner on behalf of the respondent Company. If he had resigned and left the company by or before 29.1.92 then his resignation ought to have been placed on record. But no such resignation or any document proving that on 29.1.92 Mr. Bhagat, was not in the service of the respondent Company has been placed on record. Therefor, it cannot be said that the letter dated 29.1.92 was issued by an unauthorised person. Mr. Nath, placed reliance on the decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of British India General Insurance Co. Ltd., AIR 1971 Bombay Page 102, where it has been held that if the Company denies its liability on a substantial ground then it cannot be said that the company has neglected to pay debts. But the question still remains as to whether any substantial ground or defence has been raised by the respondent Company? In fact no bonafide dispute exists about in view of its letter dated 29.1.92 in which respondent admitted the debt due. Regarding this letter there is no explanation except that the same was procured. This can neither be called substantial defence nor a bonafide dispute. Mere denial of liability is no defence what to talk of boanfide defence. Therefore, the ratio of the Bombay High Court decision has no applicability to the facts of this case. Counsel for the respondent than placed reliance on the decision of Calcutta High Court in the case of J.N Roy Chowdhury (Traders) Pvt. Ltd. v. Jainti Enterprises, (1987) Vol. 61 Company Cases page 504. In that case on the facts disclosed Court came to the conclusion that the dispute was bonafide and hence winding up order was not passed. But in the case in hand in view of the acknowledgement of debt vide letter dated 29.1.92 it cannot be said that any substantial or bonafide dispute has been raised by the respondent Company by merely denying now its liability. Mr. Jayant Nath's contention that this letter dated 29.1.92 has to be read with respondent's letters annexures R1 to R3, to my mind, is without force. As pointed out above, all these letters had been written by the respondent upto April, 1991, whereas the settlement of dues took place and communicated on 29.1.92 which clearly indicates that this amount was settled after discussions. In June 1992, when respondent wrote letter dated 29.1.92, it must be having before it Annexures R1 to R3 and must have also taken these into consideration i.e the losses or damages suffered by it and only thereafter accepted the liability to the tune of Rs. 1,02,721.03P. As regards the statement of account of the respondent Company mentioned in Annexure-IV the same was never forwarded to the petitioner at any stage.
7. Statutory notice was duly received by the respondent and in response the only defence taken was that the petitioner owed a sum of Rs. 1,35,780/-. With this reply dated 4.5.92, Annexure-IV was not forwarded to the petitioner, hence the petitioner had no opportunity to know how the respondent had raised counter claim. To my mind, in view of settlement of debt after discussion it cannot be said that the respondent has raised a substantial or a bonafide dispute. The admitted liability presently due has not been discharged by the respondent. Therefore, the petitioner is within its right to file this petition.
8. In view of the above discussions, I am of the considered view that the petition be admitted for bearing. Let the citation be published in the daily newspaper “Statesman” (English), “Veer Arjun” (Hindi) and Delhi Gazette for 20th January, 1994.
Petition admitted for hearing.
Alert