Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jagan Nath and others ;State v. State of J&K ;Jagan Nath and others; Amar Nath

Jammu and Kashmir High Court
Dec 14, 2005
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Per Gandhi, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This criminal appeal challenges the judgment and order dated 31.01.2002 of the Sessions Judge, Udhampur, by which several appellants were convicted and sentenced (sentences described as "imprisonment already undergone" with a fine of Rs. 5,000 each and, on realization of fine, Rs. 30,000 was directed to be paid as compensation to the complainant Bashir Ahmad).

The prosecution's case arises from an incident on 04.11.1984: while members of the complainant's party were constructing a Kotha on disputed land (survey No. 300, 37 kanals 18 marlas) in village Badola, a group of persons including the accused allegedly trespassed, attacked the complainant party with lathies and other implements; Roshan Din succumbed to his injuries and others were injured. The FIR (No. 287 of 1984) was registered on the same date at 10:15 p.m. Investigations included recording injured persons, recovery of lathies and one rifle, and collection of evidence about possession of the disputed land; a challan was presented for offences under sections 302/396/307/447/148 and 149 CrPC.

Defendants pleaded not guilty. The trial court convicted and sentenced the accused (except Amar Nath, who was acquitted by the trial court on the ground of being on duty at Leh on the date of occurrence). The State filed two separate acquittal appeals: Acquittal Appeal No. 14/2002 against the acquittal of Amar Nath, and Acquittal Appeal No. 3-D/2002 seeking conviction under section 302 instead of section 304 part II IPC as ordered by the trial court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court's conviction of the accused (other than Amar Nath) was sustainable on the evidence presented, or whether the appellants should be acquitted.
  2. Whether the prosecution suppressed the genesis (origin and circumstances) of the occurrence and thereby prejudiced the accused's defence.
  3. Whether the acquittal of Amar Nath (on the basis that he was on duty at Leh) should be disturbed by the State's acquittal appeal.
  4. Whether the acquittal appeals seeking to alter the conviction or sentence (including seeking conviction under section 302 IPC instead of section 304 part II IPC) should be allowed.

Arguments of the Parties

Prosecution's Case (as presented at trial)

  • The complainant party was constructing a Kotha on land they claimed; the accused trespassed with a pre-planned common intention, attacked with lathies and other weapons, caused fatal injuries to Roshan Din and injuries to others, and looted household goods (including two rifles and various items).
  • Investigative steps included recording statements of injured witnesses, seizure and recovery of lathies and a rifle, and documentary evidence of possession and custodian orders; a charge sheet was presented for multiple offences including murder.

Defence / Appellants' Arguments

  • The investigation was not properly conducted and the genesis of the occurrence was suppressed by the prosecution.
  • The complainant party had firearms and numerous household implements (axes, draties, etc.) and were in possession of implements that could be used as weapons—suggesting they may have been prepared for conflict.
  • The construction (Kotha) being raised by the complainant party was defective and fell down during hurried construction, causing injuries to the complainant party (including the deceased) rather than the accused having inflicted injuries by assault.
  • Accused Amar Nath was not present at the scene and proved his non-involvement by showing he was on duty at Leh on the date of occurrence (supported by defence witnesses and documents).
  • Some recovered "lathis" were in fact large construction logs; medical fractures could result from collapse of the roof/structure rather than intentional assault.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kashi Ram and others v. State of M.P., AIR 2001 SC 2902 Suppression of the genesis of the occurrence by the prosecution is fatal; investigation must consider injuries on accused and record their statements to avoid a one-sided investigation. The court relied on this authority to emphasize that the prosecution had suppressed genesis and had not adequately investigated or explained circumstances that would identify the real aggressor; this supported giving benefit of doubt to the accused and led to acquittal.
State of M.P. v. Sardar, (2001) 6 SCC 433 Non-explanation of injuries on the accused permits inferences: (1) prosecution suppressed genesis; (2) witnesses denying accused's injuries may be unreliable; (3) a defence version explaining accused's injuries becomes plausible — but if prosecution evidence is clear and cogent these inferences may be outweighed. The court applied these principles to conclude that because the prosecution did not explain the genesis and did not satisfactorily account for injuries and other material circumstances, inferences favourable to the accused should be drawn and the benefit of doubt extended.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by close appraisal of the prosecution and defence evidence, documentary material and medical reports, and by applying the legal principles set out in the precedents cited.

Key factual and evidentiary findings relied upon by the court:

  • There was long-standing litigation over possession of the disputed land. While the Custodian had made Bashir Ahmad superdar, the Patwari's record and evidence showed that physical cultivating possession of the land by Amar Nath, Kaku and Jagtu had been established and noted in official records.
  • The principal prosecution witnesses were relatives of the complainant and their evidence had to be approached with caution, though not automatically rejected.
  • Inconsistencies existed in witness accounts as to whether the deceased was inside the Kulli/Kotha or outside on a cot when assaulted; some witnesses asserted the deceased was inside and that the roof might have fallen on him.
  • Medical evidence (post mortem) recorded fractures of ribs, rupture of left lung and fractures of forearm bones; the doctor opined the deceased might have survived with timely medical aid and that such injuries could be possible if the deceased was inside the house and the roof had fallen on him.
  • Recovered "lathis" were large logs (dimensions given) consistent with construction materials; the court observed that fractures could have been caused by these logs falling as part of a collapsed roof rather than from deliberate assault.
  • The complainant party possessed a large number of implements and two guns and had stored many household items in the Kulli; the court found no satisfactory explanation for why these items were kept in the Kulli, which suggested the complainant party may have been prepared for a violent encounter.
  • The FIR was filed late (occurrence at about noon; FIR at 10:15 p.m.), which the court regarded as casting doubt on the prosecution's account of immediate events.
  • The prosecution named eleven persons allegedly involved but ultimately charged only eight after investigation; three persons were not implicated in the challan, indicating investigative gaps.
  • Accused Amar Nath successfully proved his absence from the scene by producing duty records corroborated by defence witnesses, which led the trial court (and was affirmed) to acquit him.

On legal assessment, the court found material shortcomings in the prosecution case: suppression of the genesis of the occurrence, inadequate investigation (including not exploring injuries on accused or sending seized guns for expert examination), inconsistent witness statements and factual possibilities consistent with an accidental collapse of the structure during hurried construction. Applying the cited precedents, the court held that where the genesis is suppressed and a plausible defence version raises a preponderance of probability in favour of the accused, the accused deserve benefit of doubt.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

APPEAL ALLOWED — THE APPELLANTS ARE ACQUITTED OF THE CHARGES. The court allowed Criminal Appeal No. 4-A/2002 and acquitted the appellants of the charges. The State's acquittal appeals (including the appeal against the acquittal of Amar Nath and the appeal seeking conviction under section 302 IPC instead of section 304 Part II IPC) were dismissed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The convicted appellants were acquitted by the appellate court; the State's efforts to disturb the acquittal(s) were unsuccessful.
  • The court's decision turned on evaluation of evidence and application of settled principles regarding suppression of genesis and non-explanation of injuries. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new principle of law but applies established Supreme Court authority to the facts at hand.
  • No broader novel precedent was created by this decision; the court applied existing authorities (Kashi Ram and State v. Sardar) to conclude that the prosecution's failures entitled the accused to acquittal.

End of summary based solely on the provided opinion.

Show all summary ...

Per Gandhi. J:

1. This Criminal Appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 31.1.2002 passed by learned Sessions Judge, Udhampur, whereby appellants have been convicted and sentenced to imprisonment already undergone with fine of Rs. 5000/- each, in default whereof to undergo imprisonment for six months. However, on real­ization of the fine amount, Rs. 30,0007- has been directed to be paid as compensation to complain­ant Bashir Ahmad.

2. State has also filed-two separate acquit­tal appeals. Acquittal Appeal No. 14/2002 has been filed against the acquittal of the accused Amar Nath, whereas Acquittal Appeal No. 3-D/ 2002 has been filed to other convict and sen­tence the accused for commission of offence under section 302 rfc instead of section 304 part ii r.p.c. as ordered by the trial court.

3. The prosecution story is that on 4.11.1984 at about 9 a.m. when the complainant party, who had already constructed a Kulli (a room having straw roof), was raising construction of a Kotha (kacha room with clay and timber roof) in the land measuring 3 7 kanals and 18 marlas bear­ing survey No.300 situated at village Badola, on which land both the parties claim their posses­sion, appellants committed trespass in the land of the complainant, attacked the complainant party, inflicted injuries to Roshan Din with lathies, as a result thereof he succumbed to the injuries whereas Bashir Ahmad, Shamas Din and Ghulam Rasool also received injuries in the same inci­dent. Police registered FIR No. 287 of 1984 at 10.15 p.m. and started investigation. Bashir Ahmad, injured was admitted in hospital at Udhampur and the dead body was taken to hos­pital for postmortem. Statement of complainant Bashir Ahmad was recorded on 5.11.1984, who stated that land measuring 37 kanals and 18 marlas under survey No. 3 00,3002/1 and 306 situ­ated at village Badola is the property of his grand father who has migrated to Pakistan.The disputed land has been kept on his superdari by the Cus­todian Evacuee Property (hereafter "the Custo­dian") vide his order dated 8.11.1980. He also stated that he is in cultivating possession of the land and paying Rs.27/- as annual cess to the Custodian. Before his possession over the land, accused Amar Nath and Kaku sons of Jagtu were in possession. The Evacuee Property Department evicted them and he, being heir of his grand­father, possession of land has been handed over to him on Superdari. Dispute with regard to pos­session is going on between him and Amar Nath and others in the court since 8 to 10 years. On 4.11.1984 at about 12 noon/1 p.m., while he and his father Roshan Din, his wife Nasima, Shamas Din S/o Ghulam Rasool and Ghulam Rasool S/o Sain residents of Rakwal and Mushtaq Ahmad, Shah Mohd. sons of Taj Din, were constructing a Kotha in the land, 11 person, including the ac­cused, with pre-planed common criminal inten­tion to kill the complainant, trespassed into the land and attacked them. Complainant Bashir Ahmad, Roshan Din, Shamas Din and Ghulam Rasool who were present on spot, were assaulted with Tabar and lathies. His wife Nasima raised noise, on which some residents of the village came on spot and in the meantime the accused ran away. While running away the accused de­molished the Kulli and committed theft by taking away 2 rifles (one double barrel and one single barrel) which the complainant had kept in it. They also took away 20 blankets, two bed covers, 4 cults, three pillows, 2 Sabbals (iron rods), one shawal, on ghenti (instrument of digging clay), one kudal, three draties of sharpe edge, 4 axes, one hammer, one cheni, on hand saw, one steel pot, one lamp, one radio set 2 band sanio make, one silver kadai. 2 thalies, 4 kolies, 2 glass silver, one Huka (nubble bubble) 4 baskets, one tin, one torch, one packet cartridges, 250 grm gun pow­der and six live cartridges. After recording his statement investigation commenced.

4. During investigating, statements of in­jured were recorded and on the disclosure state­ment of accused Mani Ram and Suram Chand, lathies were recovered. One riffle (Amar -709-76) one riffle cap type-2044-LDR was also recovered from accused Jagat Ram from his house, besides recovery of other stolen articles. Evidence with regard to the possession of land bearing survey No.300 was also collected. Statements of wit­nesses under section 161 cr.p.c. were recorded. After observing other formalities, challan was presented against the appellants for alleged com­mission of offences under sections 302/396/307/ 447/148 and 149 rfc.

5. The accused were charged sheeted on 30.1.1985, except accused Amar Nath, who was charge sheeted on21.10.1999. They pleaded not guilty and were put to trial.

6. Prosecution examined PWs Bashir Ahmad, Shamas Din, Ghulam Rasool, Mst. Nasima, Mushtaq Ahmad, Shah Mohd. Mohd. Din, Abdul Gani, Paras Ram, Joginder Singh, Mohd. Saleem, Assistant Custodian, Ab. Rashid Field Officer, AH Mohd. Patwari, Shri Nawas Gupta Addl. Tehsildar, Dr. Jai Ram Gupta, Dr. Jatinder Sharma, Mohd. Saleem and Shamsher Singh SI, to prove the charges against the appellants.

After recording the prosecution evi­dence, statements of the accused were recorded under section 342 cr.p.c. Accused Amar Nath pleaded that on the day of occurrence he was on his duty at Leh. Other accused denied the allega­tions of the prosecution as false and fictitious. They stated that they have not committed the murder of Roshan Din or inflicted injuries to the prosecution witnesses cited by the prosecution. They further stated that they were in possession of land bearing survey No.300 since the time im­memorial. The complainant party intended to forc­ibly disposses them. They approached the com­plainant party and requested them not to inter­fere or raise any construction in the land in their possession. The complainant party threatened them of dire consequences and started quarrel­ling with them and fired gun shots. While the complainant party was assaulting the accused persons, the construction being raised by them fell down and as a consequence thereof, Roshan Din, Bashir Ahmad, Shamas Din and Ghulam Rasool received injuries. Roshan Din, who was not immediately looked after, succumbed to the injuries due to the fault of the complainant party. They also started that complainant party bears enmity with them over the possession of the land.

7. After hearing learned counsel for the parties, appreciating the evidence led by the pros­ecution and the defence and considering the other documentary evidence, the trial court con­victed and sentenced the accused, except ac­cused Amar Nath, who has been acquitted on the ground of being on duty at Leh on the day of occurrence.

8. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

Learned counsel for the appellants-ac­cused has drawn our attention to the statements of the prosecution witnesses and urged that the prosecution has not conducted the investiga­tion of the case properly, rather the genesis of the occurrence has been suppressed. It is sub­mitted that the complainant party has fired from their guns and that the presence of accused Amar Nath shown on spot itself demolishes the pros­ecution story as it has been proved by the de­fence that he was on duty at Leh on the day of occurrence, which evidence has been accepted by the trial court and accused Amar Nath has been acquitted. His submission is that the com­plainant-party has received injuries because of felling down on them the construction of Kotha which was being raised by them. The Kotha fell down while they were laying clay on the roof thereof. Deceased Roshan Din died because of the injuries sustained on account of felling down of the Kotha on him while he was inside the Kotha.

9. On appreciation of evidence, we find that PW Bashir Ahmad has stated that on 4.11.1984 when he was constructing Kotha in his land, his wife Nasima, father Roshan Din, nephew Shamas Din, son Mushtaq Ahmad and Ghulam Rasool, Shah Mohd. Badri Nath were also present on spot. At about 12 or 1 p.m. the accused ap­peared on sport, equipped with lathies started assaulting them. Roshan Din was lying on a cot near the Kulli and all the accused attached him with lathies and inflicted multiple injuries to him as a result of which he died on spot. PWs Ghulam Rasool and Shamas Din and other witnesses tried to rescue the deceased but the accused at­tached them also and inflicted injuries to them. They raised hue and cry on spot on which ac­cused escaped from the scene of occurrence but before leaving the place of occurrence they de­molished the Kulli and also took away house­hold goods, including two guns and other house­hold items. Report was lodged by one of his rela­tives with the police, who recorded his statement EXPWBA. He further stated that he is in posses­sion of land since 1980. In cross examination he stated that khasra No.300 measuring 37 kanals and 18 marlas belong to his maternal grand fa­ther, who migrated to Pakistan in 1947. About II 8 years prior to 1980, the land was in illegal pos­session of Amar Nath and Kaku. He has also filed appeal before District Judge, Udhampur. The guns were kept by them inside the Kulli. He has further stated that PW Ghulam Rasool received injuries on his arms and legs whereas PW Shamas Din sustained injuries on his head and leg. He also stated that litigation with regard to the land is going on.

10. PW Shamas Din has stated that Roshan Din was his maternal grand-father. He had gone to his house along with his father Ghulam Rasool PW Shah Mohd, his counsin, had also gone to the house of Roshan Din. They were construct­ing their house. At about 12 O'clock on 4.11.1984 the accused, who were having lathies with them, attacked Roshan Din, who died on spot. Bashir Ahmad, Shah Mohd. Ghulam Rasool and Badri Nath tried to rescue Roshan Din but the accused attached them also. The accused demolished the house and while running away took away vari­ous house-hold items, including two guns and plundered the Kulli constructed by PW Bashir Ahmad. Complainant party took the deceased to the hospital. In cross examination, he stated that the guns and other articles were kept by them in the Khulli. He has also stated that complainant party has not fired any shot. When he was con­fronted by the defence that he has stated in his statement under section 161 cr.p.c. that he was beaten by Bansi Lal and Hari Krishan, he stated that he has not made such statement before the police. PW Ghulam Rasool has also supported the statement of PW Bashir Ahmad in the same tune. PW Nasima has stated that Roshan Din was residing in the Kulli since about 10 months prior to occurrence. She stated that complainant party was constructing the house in the land and Roshan Din was sitting inside the Kulli and the accused, who were having lathies in their hands, came on spot and rushed towards Kulli. Roshan Din was brought out of the Kulli and beaten by the accused, who died on spot. Her husband Bashir Ahmad, Shamas Din and Ghulam Rasool came on spot to rescue but they were also at­tached by the accused persons. She also stated that the accused looted house-hold goods from the Kulli and escaped from the occurrence. In cross examination she stated that their residen­tial house is situated at a distance of 6 jareebs from the disputed land. Kulli was constructed by them one and a half month prior to the date of occurrence which had not walls but only gross roof. Guns and other articles were kept in side the Kulli. Roshan Din used to stay in the Kulli. The accused has demolished the Kulli. None from the village came on spot at the time of occur­rence. PW Badri Nath had been called for con­struction of the roof. Shah Mohd. is resident of Nagrota. PW Ghulam Rasool is also resident of Nagrota. They had come to assist them in the construction. The complainant party has not fired any gun shot. The accused person have not sus­tained any injury in the incident. PW Mushtaq has also supported the statement of PW Bashir Ahmad, but in his cross-examination he stated that Kulli was constructed a month earlier to the occurrence installed on Bamboo poles; PW Shah Mohd has also supported the statement of PW Bashir Ahmad. In his statement he stated that he had come to the house of PW Bashir Ahmad a day earlier to the occurrence. Deceased Roshan Din was sitting inside the room. The occurrence lasted for about half an hour. PW Mohd. Din is a witness to the seizure memo of lathi recovered from accused Mani Ram.

11. PW Abdul Gani has stated that he does not know any of the accused persons. He stated that 2 guns were recovered from the house of Jagat Ram accused, who was not present in the house at that time. PW Bashir Ahmad is his ma­ternal uncle. PW Paras Ram is witness to the sei­zure memo of the dead body whereas PW Joginder Singh is a witness to the seal which was kept on his superdari.

12. PW Abdul Rashid is the field inspector of the Evacuee department. He has stated that he evicted Madan Lal superdar and put Bashir Ahmad in possession on 4.11.1980. In cross-ex­amination he stated that Custodian General vide his order dated 21.11.1980 has ordered that Thakur Dass and others be allowed to harvest the crop.

13. PW Ali Mohd. Patwari has proved the khasra girdawari, EXPWAM and EXPWAM/1. He stated that he has prepared the site plan, EXPWAM/3 and EXPWAM/4. On 22.3.1982, sta­tus quo was directed to be maintained on spot by Custodian General with respect to the dis­puted land. The land was taken over from Madan lal superdar and possession was handed over to Badri Nath and Kaku sons of Jagtu, and Chuni. This change of possession has been made in the record. He stated that there is no mention of any Kotha in khasra No.300. In cross-examination he has stated that Khasra No.300 is recorded in pos­session of Amar Nath, Kaku and Chuni since long time. They have not been evicted from the land.

14. Dr. Jai Ram Gupta has also been exam­ined who has medically examined injured Ghulam Rasool and found 5 injuries on his person caused by blunt object. He also examined Shamas Din and Bashir Ahmad. As per this witness all the injuries were simple in nature, except injury No.4 which was of grievous nature, inflicted on Shamas Din. Dr. Jatinder Gupta has conducted the post mortem on the dead body of deceased Roshan Din and noticed injuries on his person, which are fracture of 4th, 5th and 6th rib on the left side of his chest. Rupture on back of left lung, fracture of upper end of left radious and fracture of upper end of right ulna respectively and the cause of death is shock as a result of chest injuries. In his cross-examination, he opined that deceased could have survived for few hours if timely medical aid would have been provided to him. As per the doctor, injuries found inflicted on the deceased could be possible if the deceased was inside the house and roof of the house had fallen on him. He has not noticed any blood on the sticks shown to him.

15. PW Shamasher Singh, SI, is the investi­gating officer. He has proved the seizure memos and recovery memos. He has not seen any roof on the Kotha. None of the prosecution witnesses has named Hari Krishan, Madan Lal or Bansi Lal's involvement in the occurrence.

16. Defence has examined DWs Surinder Kumar, Madan Lal, Hari Krishan and Makori Ram. DW Surinder Kumar has stated that accused Amar Nath was posted at Leh on the date of occurrence. He produced the original register which proved that Amar Nath was present on duty. DW Madan Lal has stated that on the date of occurrence, after hearing gun shot, he went on spot. He stated that Roshan Din was sitting inside the Kotha and 10/12 persons were engaged in the construction process of Kotha. Land was in possession of Amar Nath, Kaka Ram Jagat Ram and others. The construction was being raised in haste, due to which the roof of the Kotha fell down and the prosecution witnesses, including Roshan Din deceased, sustained inju­ries. The accused persons have not beaten any prosecution witnesses. DW Hari Krishan stated that he was on spot. The roof of the house fell down and Roshan Din and other prosecution witnesses sustained injuries because of fall of roof of the Kotha on them. DW Makori Ram has stated that complainant party was construtcing Kotha in the land of the accused Jagat Ram. Om Parkash, Bal Krishan and Sham. The roof of the Kotha fell down, as a consequence of which Roshan Din and other prosecution witnesses sustained injuries. The complainant party was laying clay on the roof of the Kotha when it fell down. The accused party did not attack or as­sault the complainant party. The accused were not carrying lathies with them.

17. On appreciation of evidence, it is seen that there is long drawn litigation between the parties. PW Bashir Ahmad was made superdar of the land by the Custodian. However, physical cultivating possession over the land of Amar Nath, Kaku and Jagtu has been established by the Patwari which have its bearing in the record also. PW Ali Mohd, Patwari has further estab­lished that the accused party has not committed tresspass over the land in dispute. All the pros­ecution witnesses are relations. Their evidence has to be taken into consideration with care, though it cannot be brushed aside. PW Nasima and Shah Mohd. have stated that Roshan Din was sitting inside the house whereas other pros­ecution witnesses have stated that he was sit­ting outside the house on a cot and some have stated that deceased was dragged out from in­side the Kulli and beaten. It has also come in the prosecution evidence that only Roshan Din was living in the Kulli. The prosecution has failed to point out as to why Roshan Din was living in the Kulli in the winter months of November while the Kulli was having no walls and only straw roof and why he had kept with him so much utensils and house-hold goods including 4 axes, two guns, Ara (Handsaw), 20 blankets, Gyanti, Shawals, Kai, draties, ammunition and live cartridges. All this shows that the complainant party was fully prepared to attack the accused, if they come on spot. The prosecution named eleven persons' involvement in the occurrence, whereas during investigation, nothing was found or said against three persons and challan was presented only against eight persons. Moreover, Amar Nath accused has also proved his non-involvement, being on duty at Leh on the date of occurrence.

18. From the circumstances, it is established that the occurrence has not taken place in the manner it has been projected by the prosecu­tion.. It appears that when the complainant party started raising construction in the land, the ac­cused persons have stopped them and a scuffle might have taken place where in the Kotha col­lapsed and Roshan Din and other prosecution witnesses sustained injuries. Roshan Din could not be provided immediate treatment and suc­cumbed to the injuries, as opined by Dr. Jatinder Gupta.

19. There are other circumstances against the prosecution, such as, the lathi recovered from accused Mani Ram is of the size 3'. 9" in length and 4" in width. It is not a lathi but it is a log used in construction of roof. The fracture of ribs and rapture of back of the left lung, could be by this log, it had fallen on Roshan Din because of fell­ing down of the construction of Kotha. The lathi recovered from accused Suram Chand is also of the size of 3'.2" in length and 3" in width. This also cannot be termed as a lathi. Some injuries are such in size that these are possibly caused by these logs.

20. The prosecution has not justified for what purpose the complainant party was in pos­session of guns, axes and draties, Kehis etc. which can be safely used as weapons in the fight. It appears that the complainant party being fully prepared started the construction of the Kotha, believing that the accused party will not be si­lent spectator to their illegal construction. The accused party might have come on spot and re­sisted the action of the complainant party and in that process the Kulli and Kotha were demolished and as a result of this demolition complain­ant party received injuries. Moreover some of the witnesses appear to be chance witnesses, being residents of distant places, who have been shown by the prosecution to be the eye wit­nesses. The occurrence has taken place on 4.11.1984 at 12 O'clock and the FIR was lodged at 22.15 p.m., which also casts clouds on the pros­ecution story. It has come in the defence evi­dence that the complainant party has dried on the accused party at the time of incident. It ap­pears that the complainant party has not beaten the accused party in the manner it has been pro­jected by the prosecution. The guns recovered were not sent to the expert to find out as to whether the guns were used in the incident or not.

21. From the totality of the circumstances, we are of the view that the genesis of the occur­rence has been suppressed by the prosecution. It is not forth coming from the evidence as to which party was the aggressor so that the cheff can be separated from the grain to pin point the culpability. Suppression of the genesis of the occurrence is fatal to the prosecution case as held by Supreme Court in case titled Kashi Ram and others Vs. State of M.P. AIR 2001 SC 2902. Relevant portion of the judgment is reproduced as under:-

"A few relevant factual and legal as­pects overlooked by the High Court may now be noticed. The investigation suffers from a serious infirmity, which has to some extent prejudiced the ac­cused in their defence. The investigat­ing officer having found one of the ac­cused having sustained injuries in the course of the same incident in -which those belonging to the prosecution party sustained injuries, the investigat­ing officer should have at least made an effort at investigating the cause of, and the circumstances resulting in, in­juries on the person of accused Prabhu. Not only the investigating officer did not do so, he did not even make an attempt at recording the statement of ac­cused Prabhu. If only this would have been done, the defence version of the incident would have been before the investigating officer and the investiga­tion would not have been one-sided.

section 105 of the evidence act, 1872 provides that the burden of proving the existence of circumstances which would bring the act of the ac­cused alleged to be an offence within the exercise of right of private defence is on him and the court shall presume the absence of such circumstances. However, it must be borne in mind that the burden on the accused is not so heavy as it is on the prosecution. While the prosecution must prove the guilt of the accused to its hilt that is, beyond any reasonable doubt, the accused has to satisfy the standard of prudent man. If one of the material available on record a preponderance of probabili­ties is raised which renders the plea taken by the accused plausible then the same should be accepted and in any case a benefit of doubt should deserve to be extended to the accused.........."

The Supreme Court in case titled State of M.P. Vs. Sardar, (2001) 6 SCC 433, has further held as under:-

What is the effect of non-explanation of injuries sustained by the accused at about the time of occurrence? It is settled law that in case of non-expla­nation of injuries to the accused, the court can draw the following infer­ences:

(1) That the prosecution has suppressed the genesis and the origin of the occur­rence and has thus not presented the true version.

(2) That the witnesses who have denied the presence of the injuries on the person of the accused are lying on a most material point and therefore their evi­dence is unreliable. (3) That in case there is a defence ver­sion which explains the injuries on the person of the accused, it is rendered probable so as to throw doubt on the prosecution case.

But, non-explanation of injuries may lose its importance where the evidence is clear, cogent and creditworthy and where the court can distinguish the truth from falsehood without much dif­ficulty. It is also true that the reason­able inference which could be drawn in such cases is that the accused per­sons received the injuries during the course of occurrence and that some members of the prosecution party in­flicted such injuries. On that basis again, the question would be whether the accused caused the injuries to the prosecution witnesses and the deceased by exercising right of private defence. If the prosecution establishes that the accused were the aggressors and went at the residence of the deceased or that prosecution witness and inflicted inju­ries on the deceased and witnesses, there is no question of right of private defence to the accused. On the contrary in such situation the prosecution party would have the right of private de­fence. "

For the aforesaid reasons, the criminal appeal No. 4-A/2002 is allowed and the appel­lants are acquitted of the charges. The acquittal appeals are dismissed.

Jammu Sd/- Hon'ble Sd/- Hon'ble 1412.2005 (J.P.Singh)-J (R. C. Gandhi)-J