Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shamsher Singh and others v. State of Haryana

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Nov 24, 1981

M.R. Sharma and S.S. Kang, JJ. - The petitioner was acting as a Manager of the Panjokhra Credit and Service Society, Panjokhra, from September, 1976 onwards. Earlier he was acting as a Secretary of the Society. One Suraj Bhan was appointed by the Society as a Salesman. It is said that he committed some acts of embezzlement and when called upon to show cause he admitted his liability and prayed that he be given time to make good the loss of the Society. The case against him was referred by the Registrar to an Arbitrator for decision. In the meantime, the Society made an application before the Arbitrator that the petitioner should also be impleaded as a party to the dispute. The Arbitrator allowed this application and impleaded the petitioner as a party to its dispute and found him liable along with Suraj Bhan. The order passed by the Arbitrator is dated April 8, 1980. (Annexure P-9). This order is being challenged in the instant petition. 2. Under section 56 of the punjab co-operative societies act, 1961 (hereafter referred to as 'the act') an Arbitrator assumes jurisdiction to decide a dispute between a society and its constituent or a servant on the basis of a reference made by the Registrar. In the absence of a reference, he has no jurisdiction to implead any party to the arbitration proceedings. Prima facie, therefore, the procedure adopted by the Arbitrator was illegal. 3. On behalf of the respondent, it has been argued that the Arbitrator in this case was Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Societies, who could exercise the powers of a Registrar for making a reference either to an Arbitrator or to himself. It was also submitted that the Co-operative Society passed a resolution on the basis of which an application was made to the Arbitrator for impleading the petitioner. 4. The plea raised on behalf of respondent, appears to be untenable. Once an Arbitrator takes seisin of the dispute, he has to decide the matter qua the parties who are arrayed before him because while deciding this case he exercises the jurisdiction as an Arbitrator appointed by the Registrar. No order has been brought to our notice to indicate that a duly appointed person exercising powers of the Registrar, applied his mind to the facts of the case and decided that the dispute between the petitioner and the Co-operative Society should also be referred to and decided by the Arbitrator. We, therefore, allow this petition and quash the impugned order dated April 8, 1980 (Annexure P-9) and dated May 29, 1981 (Annexure P-10) qua the petitioner. It shall, however, be again open to the Society to make an application to the Registrar with the prayer that the dispute, if any, between the petitioner and the Co-operative Society be decided in accordance with section 56 of the Act. If such an application is made, the Registrar of Cooperative Societies, will make a reference by passing a speaking order discussing therein the admissions made by Suraj Bhan, Salesman of the Society, as already stated, who had admitted his liability. 5. The petition is allowed with no order as to costs. Petition allowed.