- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Suneel Sodhi v. M.L. Sodhi
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiffs filed a suit for partition and mesne profits concerning property No. B-3/4, Vasant Vihar, New Delhi, which they claim to be ancestral Joint Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) property. The defendants included late Mr. M.L. Sodhi (in whose name the lease stood), his wife late Smt. Raj Sodhi, Col. V.K. Sodhi, and Mr. A.K. Sodhi, all of whom have since expired. The plaintiffs are legal representatives of defendant No. 4. The legal representatives of defendant No. 3 moved applications under Order VI, Rule 17, CPC and Section 151, CPC to amend the plaint to propound two Wills executed by late Mr. M.L. Sodhi and late Smt. Raj Sodhi, discovered only after the death of defendant No. 2. The plaintiffs opposed these applications, alleging delay, fabrication, and mala fide intent to deprive them of their share in the HUF property. The matter involves consideration of the propriety of allowing amendment and admission of the Wills at the stage just before trial.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the legal representatives of defendant No. 3 can be permitted to amend the plaint to propound Wills discovered after the death of defendant No. 2.
- Whether the applications to amend the plaint and to take the Wills on record are barred by the amended Order VI, Rule 17, CPC, which prohibits amendments after the commencement of trial.
- Whether the delay and alleged mala fide in not earlier propounding the Wills justifies rejection of the amendment applications.
- The extent to which the plaintiffs should be allowed to challenge the genuineness of the Wills.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicants (Legal Representatives of Defendant No. 3)
- Moved applications under Order VI, Rule 17, CPC and Section 151, CPC to amend the plaint to propound two Wills executed by late Mr. M.L. Sodhi (dated 18th September 1989) and late Smt. Raj Sodhi (dated 1st May 1996).
- Claimed the Wills were discovered only after the death of defendant No. 2 (7th January 2002) and hence the applications were timely.
- Asserted that the Will of Smt. Raj Sodhi is a registered Will, raising a presumption of due execution.
Plaintiffs
- Opposed the applications as a delay tactic to prolong the suit.
- Pointed out that the joint written statement by defendants 1 to 4 made no mention of these Wills.
- Alleged the Wills are fabricated and intended to deprive plaintiffs of their legitimate share in the ancestral HUF property.
- Argued that under the amended Order VI, Rule 17, CPC, amendments after the commencement of trial are prohibited, barring the application.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court first determined the date of commencement of trial as 22nd October 2002 based on prior orders fixing trial dates and directions for filing evidence. Since the application to amend the plaint was moved on 8th October 2002, it did not fall within the prohibition against amendments after trial commencement under the amended Order VI, Rule 17, CPC. The court accepted the explanation that the Wills were discovered only after the death of defendant No. 2, noting the registered nature of the Will of Smt. Raj Sodhi, which raises a presumption of proper execution. The court emphasized that the defendants should not be precluded from propounding the Wills and that the plaintiffs would have full opportunity to challenge their genuineness. It was observed that the amendment plea was not inconsistent with the property being self-acquired by late Mr. M.L. Sodhi and that the effect of the Wills—depriving plaintiffs of their share—required full adjudication on merits. The court allowed the applications subject to costs, clarifying that the observations were prima facie and would not affect the substantive merits.
Holding and Implications
Applications IA 9628/2002 and IA 9629/2003 are allowed.
The court permitted the amendment of the plaint to propound the discovered Wills and allowed the Wills to be taken on record, subject to payment of costs of Rs. 5,000 each by the defendants. The decision enables the defendants to rely on the Wills in the suit, while preserving the plaintiffs' right to challenge their validity. No new precedent was established; the ruling primarily affects the procedural posture of this particular suit by allowing evidence newly discovered before trial commencement to be admitted, ensuring a fair opportunity for both parties to present their cases.
Plaintiffs have filed this suit for partition and mesne profits. The suit primarily concerns property bearing No. B-3/4, Vasant Vihar, New Delhi. It is the case of the plaintiffs that the property in question was a Joint Hindu Undivided Family acquired from ancestral funds. The defendant Nos. 1 and 2 were late Mr. M.L Sodhi, in whose name the lease of the property stood and his wife late Smt. Raj Sodhi. Defendant No. 3 was Col. V.K Sodhi and defendant No. 4 was Mr. A.K Sodhi. Defendants 1 to 4 have all expired. Mr. M.L Sodhi died on 18th January, 1989. Defendant No. 2 expired on 7th January, 2002 and defendant No. 3 expired on 29th January, 2003. Defendant No. 4 expired on 4th January, 1996. Plaintiffs are the legal representatives of defendant No. 4.
2. By the present applications moved under Order VI, Rule 17, CPC and under Section 151, CPC, the LRs of defendant No. 3 seek to amend the plaint to propound Will dated 18th Sept. 1989 and another registered Will dated 1st May, 1996, said to be executed by late Shri M.L Sodhi and Smt. Raj Sodhi. By the application under Section 151, CPC, the wills are prayed for being taken on record. The effect of these Wills briefly stated is that Mr. M.L Sodhi bequeathed the property to his wife Smt. Raj Sodhi. Vide a Will dated 1st May, 1996 she bequeathed her properties and assets to defendant No. 3, to the exclusion of defendant No. 4. It is claimed that it was only after 7th January, 2002 that the applicants LRs of defendant No. 3 have discovered the two Wills namely Will of late Sh. M.L Sodhi dated 18th Sept. 1989 and of Smt. Raj Sodhi, dated 1st May, 1996 and moved the present applications.
3. The said applications are vehemently opposed by Mr. J.P Senth, counsel for plaintiffs, who submits that this is yet another manifestation of the defendants efforts to delay the suit. It is stated that a joint written statement had been filed by the defendants 1 to 4 in which no mention was made of the said Wills. It may be noted that defendant No. 4 happens to be the estranged husband of plaintiff No. 1. It is stated that the Wills now sought to be propounded are fabricated and set up with the ulterior motive of somehow depriving the plaintiffs of their legitimate share in the property which was a HUF property. Another objection raised is that the present amendment application cannot be allowed in view of the amended Order VI, Rule 17, CPC which prohibits amendments sought after the commencement of trial.
4. The controversy on this aspect may be taken up first. It is seen that vide orders dated 22nd July, 2002 dates of trial were fixed from 22nd to 25th Oct. 2002 and parties were directed to take steps for filing the evidence by way of affidavit etc. In this view of the matter, it can be safely concluded that the actual trial commenced from 22nd Oct. to 25th Oct. 2002. The present application was made on 8th Oct. 2002 and hence would not fall, within the prohibition of amended Order VI, Rule 17, CPC. Regarding objection as to the application being highly belated and a mala fide one, without any sufficient cause being shown not propounding the Wills earlier, the explanation given is that it was Col. V.K Sodhi, the erstwhile defendant No. 3 while searching through the old papers of Smt. Raj Sodhi found the Wills. The Will of Smt. Raj Sodhi, which is sought to be propounded is a registered Will which would raise a presumption as to its due execution. The applications had been moved by Col. V.K Sodhi prior to his demise.
5. Considering the aforesaid facts, I am of the view that the defendants cannot be shut out from propounding the Wills which are claimed to have been discovered upon the death of defendant No. 2. Even though the plea was not raised earlier during the life time of defendant No. 2, the onus of proving the said Wills rest on the defendants. Plaintiffs shall have the opportunity of questioning the Wills and raising objections as to their genuineness. The case being at the stage when the trial is yet to be commence, the parties should be given the fullest opportunity to prove their case. Besides thePage: 101 present plea being set up is not inconsistent with the plea of the property being self-acquired property of Shri M.L Sodhi. The effect of the Wills is that it seeks to deprive the plaintiff i.e LRs of defendant No. 4 of their share, which will have to be fully adjudicated upon. Accordingly. IA. 9628/2002 is allowed subject to costs of Rs. 5000/- to be paid by defendants. Let the amended plaint be taken on record.
6. IA 9629/2003 is the application to place the two Wills on record is allowed subject to payment of Rs. 5000/- as costs. Any observation made in the above order is only on a prima facie view of the matter and it shall have no bearing on merits of the matter. Both IAs stand allowed in above terms.
Applications allowed.
Alert