- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Daya Sugar v. Commissioner, Central Excise
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant is a manufacturing unit of M/s. Daya Engineering (Sleeper) Ltd., engaged in the manufacture of sugar and molasses. The unit availed MODVAT (MODVAT credit) on capital goods under the erstwhile rule 57‑q of the Central Excise Rules and filed a declaration under rule 57‑t. On scrutiny for the period March 2000 to November 2000 it was observed that the appellant had taken MODVAT credit on various items (plates, sections, columns, staging material, sheets, checkered plates, steel castings, etc.). The Department alleged that such items were not capital goods (or components, spares or accessories) within the meaning of rule 57‑q and that the credit (stated in the opinion at different points as Rs. 9,63,016/- and later as Rs. 9,84,066/-) had been wrongly availed.
Procedural history: The Deputy Commissioner issued a show cause notice and thereafter passed an order dated 20.9.2002 accepting the appellant's contention and dropping the proceedings. The Department appealed to the Commissioner (Appeals), which partly allowed the appeal and agreed that MODVAT credit was available. The Department then filed a second appeal to the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), which by order dated 25.7.2005 allowed the Department's appeal holding the appellant was not entitled to MODVAT credit. The appellant filed the present appeal under section 35G of the Central Excise Act.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the items such as plates, sections, sheets, staging material, checkered plates and similar fabricated parts purchased and used by the appellant qualify as "capital goods" (plants, machinery, components, spares or accessories) within the meaning of rule 57‑q of the Central Excise Rules, 1944, entitling the appellant to MODVAT credit.
- Whether the classification/descriptions supplied in suppliers' invoices (classification under Chapter 84 as sugar mill machinery parts) determine entitlement to MODVAT credit when the actual use by the purchaser is for civil erection/ platform construction (items arguably classifiable under Chapters 72 or 73).
- Whether the scope of the table annexed to rule 57‑q and the rule's text restricts credit only to items listed in the table (or components of specified chapters) and how the "user" test and prior precedents apply to the facts of this case.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The goods received (plates, sections, sheets, steel castings, staging materials, checkered plates, etc.) are capital goods and fall within the term "plant and machinery", so MODVAT credit under rule 57‑q was properly availed.
- The supplier had described and classified the items under Chapter 84 in the invoices (as sugar mill machinery parts), and that classification was not challenged; the authority to classify lies with the officer having jurisdiction over the manufacturer (supplier), not the officer over the user (appellant). Consequently, where goods are classifiable under Chapter 84, they should be treated as capital goods for MODVAT purposes.
- Relied upon Supreme Court authority (Rajasthan Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd.) and Jawahar Mills Ltd. to support a broad/user‑based approach to the definition of capital goods.
- Also relied upon Sarvesh Refractories and Mohan Breweries decisions to support the proposition that the classification made by the supplier/manufacturer should be respected and not changed by the recipient.
Department's Arguments
- Rule 57‑q allows credit only for capital goods as specified in the table annexed to the rule; the benefit cannot be extended to items not found in that table.
- The table indicates that items under Chapters 82, 84, 85 and 90 (and their specified components/spares/accessories) may be capital goods, but items falling under Chapters 72 or 73 (such as plates, sections, staging material) are not covered.
- The invoices show a deliberate or collusive mis‑classification by suppliers to obtain MODVAT; the appellant bought items that actually fall under Chapter 72/73 and used them for civil platforms/erected structures, not as plant/machinery components eligible for credit.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Commissioner of Central Excise, Jaipur vs. Rajasthan Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd., 2010 (255) ELT 481 (S.C.) | Recognition of the "user test" — whether items (e.g., steel plates, MS channels) used in fabrication (e.g., a chimney integral to DG set) can be treated as capital goods/accessories under rule 57‑q. | The court distinguished this decision: in Rajasthan Spinning the steel plates and channels were used to fabricate a chimney which was integral to the diesel generating set and mandatory for pollution control, so user‑test supported classification as an accessory/capital good. In the present case the items were used to construct platforms/civil structures and not integral parts of machinery, so Rajasthan Spinning is not applicable. |
| Commissioner of Central Excise, Coimbatore & ors. vs. Jawahar Mills Ltd. & ors., (2001) 6 SCC 274 | The definition of "capital goods" is wide; whether an item is a capital good depends on the user and the purpose for which it is used. | The court cited the Jawahar Mills principle (user test) but applied it to the facts and found that the items in question were not used in manufacture or as inputs; they were used for civil/platform construction and therefore did not qualify as capital goods under rule 57‑q on the facts of the case. |
| Sarvesh Refractories (P) Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Central Excise & Customs, 2007 (218) E.L.T. 488 (S.C.) | Principle that classification made by the manufacturer/supplier should not be altered by the recipient/assessee; the supplier's classification has weight. | The court held this precedent inapplicable on the facts because there was a specific finding that the supplier had wrongly classified the goods under Chapter 84. Here the goods were actually used for platform construction and not as parts of machinery, so Sarvesh Refractories does not assist the appellant. |
| Commissioner of Central Excise Pondicherry vs. Mohan Breweries & Distilleries Ltd., 2010 (259) E.L.T. 176 (Mad.) | Similar to Sarvesh Refractories: the supplier's/manufacturer's classification cannot be altered by the recipient. | The court recorded that Mohan Breweries is not applicable for the same reasons as Sarvesh Refractories: there was a factual finding of wrongful classification by supplier and the goods were used for civil construction not as machinery parts. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court undertook a textual and factual analysis guided by the provisions of rule 57‑q of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 (the text of the rule was fully set out in the opinion). The key analytical steps were:
- Textual interpretation of rule 57‑q: The rule permits credit of excise duty paid on "capital goods" used by the manufacturer in the manufacture of specified final products. Although "capital goods" is not itself defined in the rule text reproduced, capital goods eligible for credit are enumerated in the Table annexed to rule 57‑q, and therefore entitlement must be determined with reference to that Table.
- Examination of the Table and chapter headings: The court observed that the Table permits items under certain chapters (notably Chapters 82, 84, 85 and 90) to be treated as capital goods (including components/spares/accessories), sometimes even if the particular component is classified under another chapter; however, benefit under the rule is limited to those items which properly fall within the Table's scope.
- Factual scrutiny of invoices and use: The invoices showed supplier descriptions classifying the items as Chapter 84 (sugar mill machinery parts). The court examined the actual descriptions (e.g., "boiler house internal staging", "fabricated parts of plants for sugar miller", "fabricated parts of boiler house", "fabricated parts of caustic soda tank") and the admitted use by the appellant. The court concluded that these items are appropriately classifiable under Chapter 72 (checkered plates, sections) or Chapter 73 (staging material/erected structures) and were in fact used to construct platforms and civil structures in the factory (for running/checking machinery or supporting equipment).
- Application of the user test and precedents: The court applied the "user" principle from precedents but distinguished Rajasthan Spinning (where user test led to a finding of capital good because the fabricated chimney was integral to DG set and pollution control) on the ground that the present items were used only for civil/platform construction and not as machinery or its accessories. Jawahar Mills' broad user‑based approach was acknowledged but applied against the appellant because the user here was not manufacture/input use. Sarvesh Refractories and Mohan Breweries were considered in light of supplier classification principles but found inapplicable because there was a specific finding of wrongful classification by the supplier in the present case.
- Conclusion from fact + law: Given the factual finding that the materials were used for constructing platforms (civil works) and not as parts/accessories/components of sugar mill machinery listed in the Table annexed to rule 57‑q, the items did not qualify as capital goods under rule 57‑q and MODVAT credit was therefore not allowable.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is DISMISSED.
Direct effect on the parties: The court held that the appellant had wrongly availed MODVAT credit in respect of the disputed items and explicitly concluded that those items could not be specified as capital goods under rule 57‑q. The opinion states the amount of wrongly availed credit as Rs. 9,84,066/- in the court's concluding finding (the record also contains an earlier figure of Rs. 9,63,016/- noted during scrutiny). The appellant's claim to MODVAT credit on those items is disallowed.
Broader implications: The court distinguished prior Supreme Court and High Court decisions relied upon by the appellant and the Department, applying the established "user" test and the textual limits of rule 57‑q. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new broader legal principle beyond applying existing authorities to the facts and does not treat the decision as creating a new precedent; rather it applies and distinguishes earlier authorities on the facts before it.
Note: This summary is prepared strictly from the contents of the provided opinion. Where the opinion itself contains multiple numerical figures for the MODVAT credit in issue (see paragraphs noting Rs. 9,63,016/- and later Rs. 9,84,066/-), both figures are reflected above as they appear in the judgment text.
1. The appellant is a unit of M/s. Daya Engineering (Sleeper) Ltd. Naya Bans, Gagalheri, District Saharanpur and is engaged in the manufacture of sugar and molasses falling under Chapter sub-heading No. 1701.31, 1701.39 and 1703.10 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. The appellant was availing MODVAT credit on the capital goods under the erstwhile rule 57-q of the central excise rules and filed a declaration under rule 57-t of the rules for availing credit on various capital goods.
2. During the course of scrutiny, for the period March, 2000 to November, 2000, it was observed that the appellant had wrongly taken a credit of Rs. 9,63,016/- on various items under rule 57-q of the central excise rules, 1944 (hereinafter referred to as the "Rules"). It was found that the MODVAT credit was taken on various items such as plates, sections, columns, staging material etc. which were not used in the manufacture of specified goods. The appellant had availed MODVAT credit on the basis of suppliers invoices for the items under Chapter 84 which were duly mentioned in the invoices in respect of the supplies of parts used for capital goods. It was alleged that these goods were used in the manufacture of specified goods in the factory of the appellant. The goods so received such as plates, sections, sheets, staging material, etc. were used in the factory of the appellant for the purpose of constructing platforms for the use of running of machinery, for supporting equipments used in the factory.
3. Based on the scrutiny, the Deputy Commissioner, Central Excise, Saharanpur issued a show cause notice to the appellant to show cause as to why the MODVAT credit availed by the appellant on the items such as plates, sections, columns, staging material, etc. under rule 57-q of the rules should not be disallowed contending therein that these items cannot be termed as "components, spares or accessories in the light of the definition of "Capital Goods".
4. The appellant submitted a detailed reply. The Deputy Commissioner, after considering the reply, passed an order dated 20.9.2002 accepting the contention of the appellant holding that the appellant had correctly availed MODVAT and, accordingly, dropped the proceeding. The Department, being aggrieved by the order, filed an appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals), which was partly allowed. The appellate authority agreed with the contention of the appellant that the MODVAT credit was available on the purchase of plates, sections, columns, staging materials, etc. under rule 57-q of the rules as capital goods. Being aggrieved by the said order, the Department filed a Second Appeal before the Customs Excise and Service Appellate Tribunal. The Tribunal by its order dated 25.7.2005 allowed the appeal of the Department holding that the appellant was not entitled to avail MODVAT credit. The appellant, being aggrieved by the order of the Tribunal, has filed the present Appeal under section 35g of the central excise act.
5. We have heard Sri Nikhil Agarwal along with Sri Parv Agarwal, the learned counsel for the appellant and Sri. B.K.S. Raghuvanshi, the learned counsel for the Department.
6. The learned counsel contended, that the goods received by the appellant, namely, plates, sections, sheets, steel castings, staging material, checkered plates etc. were capital goods and would come under the term plants and machinery and, consequently, the appellant was entitled to avail MODVAT credit under the erstwhile rule 57-q of the rules. In support of his submission the learned counsel placed reliance upon a decision of the Supreme Court in Commissioner of Central Excise, Jaipur vs. Rajasthan Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd., 2010(255) ELT 481 as well as a decision of the Supreme Court in Commissioner of Central Excise, Coimbatore and others vs. Jawahar Mills Ltd. and others, (2001) 6 SCC 274.
7. The learned counsel further contended that the supplier of the goods had mentioned the description of the item, which had been classified under Chapter 84 and that these goods were eligible for capital goods being classified under Chapter 84. The learned counsel contended, that when the classification of the goods has not been challenged at the manufacturer's end and the authority to classify the goods is vested with the officer having the jurisdiction over the manufacturer and not with the officer having jurisdiction over the user of the goods, consequently, the goods classifiable under Chapter 84, being capital goods, the appellant was eligible to claim MODVAT under rule 57-q of the rules. In support of the submission, the learned counsel placed reliance upon a decision of the Supreme Court in Sarvesh Refractories (P) Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Central Excise & Customs, 2007 (218) E.L.T. 488 (S.C.) as well as a decision of the Madras High Court in Commissioner of Central Excise Pondicherry vs. Mohan Breweries & Distilleries Ltd., 2010 (259) E.L.T. 176 (Mad.).
8. On the other hand, Sri B.K.S. Raghuvanshi, the learned counsel for the Department contended that rule 57-q of the rules only provides for taking credit of Central Excise Duty paid on capital goods, which are used by the manufacturer in the manufacture of specified goods. It was contended that the goods specified as capital goods has been annexed in the table annexed to the Rule and, therefore, the benefit of credit of duty could only be extended to those capital goods which found place in the said table. The learned counsel contended that from a perusal of the table annexed to rule 57-q of the rules, clearly showed that items falling under Chapters 82, 84, 85 and 90 excluding the Chapter Heading, which were not termed as a capital good and components, spares and accessories of the goods of chapter mentioned at Sl. Nos. 1 to 4, i.e., Chapters 82, 84, 85, and 90 could only be considered as capital goods, irrespective of the fact that the said components spares or accessory falls in another chapter heading. The learned counsel contended that the parties had purchased plates, sections, sheets staging material etc. are items which falls under Chapter 72 or 73 and, therefore, are not capital goods. The learned counsel contended that the appellant with the connivance of the suppliers had opted a modus operandi to get the benefit of MODVAT by way of classifying the items under Chapter 72, 73 into items of 84, in view of the fact, that the items covered under Chapter 72 or 73 are not covered under the purview of MODVAT scheme.
9. In the light of the contention raised by the learned counsel for the parties, it is necessary to consider the provision of rule 57-q of the rules as it existed then at the relevant moment of time under the Central Excise Rules, 1944. For facility, the said provision is extracted under under:
"57Q. Applicability.-(1) The provisions of this section shall apply to goods (hereafter in this section, referred to as the "final products") described in column (3) of the Table given below and to the goods (hereafter, in this section, referred to as "capital goods"), described in the corresponding entry in column (2) of the said Table, used in the factory of the manufacturer of final products.
(2)(i) The manufacturer of the final products shall be allowed credit of the duty of excise or the additional duty leviable under section 3 of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (5 of 1975) (hereinafter referred to as "specified duty") paid on the capital goods.
(ii) The manufacturer availing of the credit may utilise the same for payment of duty of excise payable on the final products manufactured in his factory.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1), the manufacturer of the final products shall be allowed credit of additional duty leviable under section 3 of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (51 of 1975) on goods falling under Chapter heading No. 98.01 of the first schedule to the said Customs Tariff Act, to the extent of 75% of the said additional duty paid on such goods.
(4) A manufacturer of the final products purchasing capital goods from a unit situated in a Free Trade Zone or from a hundred per cent export-oriented undertaking or from a unit in an Electronic Hardware Technology Park or Software Technology Parks and using them in the manufacture of final products, shall be allowed to take the credit of the specified duty paid on such capital goods only to the extent of duty which is equal to the additional duty leviable on like goods under section 3 of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (51 of 1975), equivalent to the duty of excise paid on such capital goods.
(5) The credit of the specified duty on capital goods (other than those capital goods in respect of which credit of duty was allowable under any other rule or notification prior to the 1st day of March, 1997) shall not be allowed if such capital goods were received in the factory before the 1st day of March, 1997.
(6) A manufacturer shall be allowed credit of specified duty paid on capital goods manufactured by him for the manufacture of final products in his factory.
(7) The credit of the specified duty on capital goods [other than those capital goods covered under S. No. 5, 7, 10, 11 and 12 of column (2) of the Table below sub-rule (1)] and received in the factory on or after the 1st day of January, 1996, shall not be taken on a date prior to the date on which such capital goods are installed or, as the case may be, used for manufacture of excisable goods, in the factory of the manufacturer as certified by such manufacturer or a person designated by him for this purpose.
(8) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (7), a manufacturer intending to remove the capital goods from his factory for home consumption or for export, prior to their being installed or used, as the case may be, shall be allowed to take credit on the date on which such capital goods are so removed by him from his factory on payment of the appropriate duty of excise leviable thereon as provided in rule 57S."
10. A perusal of the aforesaid rule 57-q of the rules indicates, that it provides for taking a credit of Central Excise Duty paid on capital goods used by a manufacturer in the manufacture of specified goods. Even though capital goods have not been defined, the goods specified as capital goods have been given in the table annexed to rule 57-q of the rules. Therefore, the benefit of credit of duty could only be extended to those capital goods, which finds place in the said table.
11. A perusal of the table annexed to rule 57-q of the rules indicates that items falling under Chapters 82, 84, 85 and 90 can also be considered as capital goods irrespective of the fact that the said components, spares or accessories falls in another Chapter Heading and benefit of credit of duty on the same could be extended under rule 57-q of the rules.
12. The invoices reveal that the appellant had purchased checkered plates, packing plates, sheets, sections, staging materials, which were classified by the supplier as items falling under Chapter 84 as sugar mill machinery parts. To be more precise, the description of the items mentioned by the supplier was "boiler house internal staging " "fabricated parts of plants for sugar milter", "fabricated parts for modification of Donnelley Chute", "fabricated parts of boiler house", " fabricated parts of caustic soda tank". These items are appropriately classifiable either under Chapter 72 as checkered plates, sections, etc. or under Chapter 73 as staging material, if subjected to various processes, which go to the erection of shed and erected structures. The appellant admits that these plates, sheets, sections, etc. were used in the factory for the purpose of constructing platform for use of the running of machinery. By no stretch of imagination these items could be considered as sugar mill machinery or its components, spares or accessories classifiable under Chapter Heading 84. These items are not capital goods given against Sl. Nos. 1 to 4 nor are components, spares and accessories, which are used as capital goods of Sl. Nos. 1 to 4 of the table annexed to rule 57-q of the rules. It is quite evident that the goods received by the appellant was used for construction of a platform which are used by mechanics for checking the running of the machines or used for supporting the equipments. The goods in question that has been used is only for the purpose of raising civil structures and, consequently, cannot be termed as capital goods under rule 57-q of the rules. The decision of the Supreme Court in Rajasthan Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd. (supra) is distinguishable as in that case the Supreme Court after applying the user test found that the steel plates and MS channels was used for the fabrication of Chimney which would fall within the ambit of capital goods, under rule 57-q of the rules for the reason that the Chimney was an integral part of the diesel generating set particularly when the Pollution Control Laws made it mandatory that all plants which emits effluents has to be equipped with an apparatus that could reduce or get rid of the effluent gasses. The Supreme Court held, that the Chimney constructed for the purpose of reducing the effluent gases was to be treated as an accessory under rule 57-q of the rules. Similarly, in Jawahar Mills Ltd. (supra) the Supreme Court held that the definition of capital goods was very wide and in view of the liberal language of the provision it was required to be found out as to whether an item falls within the definition of capital goods would depend upon the user which is put to. If the goods are not used for manufacture of a final product or is not used as an input, then it would not come under the purview of capital goods.
13. In the light of the aforesaid, we are of the opinion, that the goods used by the appellant was for manufacture of a platform, which was used for raising a civil structure and by no stretch of imagination, could it be considered as a sugar mill machinery or a plant or component, spares or accessories classifiable under Chapter Heading 84. We are of the opinion, that these items cannot be specified as capital goods under rule 57-q of the rules and, consequently, we hold that the appellant had wrongly availed the credit of Rs. 9,84,066/-.
14. The decision of the Supreme Court in Sarvesh Refractories and Mohan Breweries are not at all applicable. In these decisions, the classification of the item was changed, and in that context, the Court held, that once an item, which had been classified by the manufacturer supplying the material, the said classification cannot be changed by the assessee receiving the goods. In the instant case a specific finding has been given that the supplier of these items had wrongly classified them under Chapter 84 as sugar mills machinery parts, whereas the goods so received by the appellant were used for construction of a platform and were not used anywhere as a part of the machinery. Consequently, the said decisions are not applicable.
15. For the reasons stated aforesaid, the appeal fails and is dismissed.
_______________
Alert