- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bank Of Upper India, Ltd. v. Arif Husain
Case Summary — Judgment of Sen, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
On 1 March 1910 Syed Zafar Husain made a fixed deposit of Rs. 800 with the Bank of Upper India Limited, Meerut, for three months at 3% per annum. The fixed deposit receipt indicated interest "from 24th February 1910 payable on 1st January and 1st July of each year."
Syed Zafar Husain died on 10 June 1910, before the fixed deposit matured. His heirs under Mahomedan law included his widow Mt. Husain Bandi, a daughter Amtul Zainub (aged about 4 years) and a son Arif Husain (aged about 2 years). The widow later left the country and died in 1917 (exact date not ascertainable from the record); the daughter died on 14 October 1921.
The present suit for recovery of the fixed deposit was instituted on 18 March 1926 by Arif Husain (a minor) through a next friend. The plaintiff claimed to be the sole entitled person because his mother and sister had predeceased him.
The Bank of Upper India Ltd. closed and went into voluntary liquidation on 8 October 1914. A composition scheme drawn up by creditors was sanctioned by the High Court under Section 153, Companies Act on 2 June 1915. Under the scheme creditors were given an option (to be exercised on or before 5 January 1917) either to accept fully paid preference shares or to take debentures carrying interest at 4½% per annum according to the face value of their deposits.
The heirs of Syed Zafar Husain received no notice of those proceedings. They did not exercise the option by 5 January 1917 and therefore, under the scheme, became entitled to debentures. Trustees for debenture-holders were appointed and a deed of trust dated 18 December 1915 (creating a floating charge) was executed. A meeting on or about 31 January 1917 passed resolutions modifying the original deed; a supplementary trust deed dated 18 June 1917 (sanctioned by the High Court) sought effectively to transfer liability from the Bank of Upper India Ltd. to the Trust of India Ltd. and the Alliance Bank of Simla Ltd.
The heirs of Syed Zafar Husain were not represented at the meeting that adopted the supplementary deed. No debentures appear to have been issued to those heirs after 5 January 1917. The plaintiff's claim was resisted by the bank (which required a succession certificate, later repudiated the claim, disputed the genuineness of the deposit receipt and, in its written statement, contended inter alia that liability had been transferred to other companies and that the suit was time-barred).
The trial Court decreed the plaintiff's claim (for Rs. 1,333-11-0 of a claimed Rs. 1,373-11-0). The lower appellate Court affirmed the decision. The present appeal by the bank was dismissed by the court below (Sen, J.) with costs.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, having been bound by the High Court-sanctioned composition scheme of 2 June 1915, the heirs' rights were replaced by debentures and whether those rights remained enforceable against the Bank of Upper India Ltd.
- Whether the supplementary trust deed and the modifications effected by resolutions (circa 31 January 1917 and the deed of 18 June 1917) validly transferred liability to the Trust of India Ltd. and the Alliance Bank of Simla Ltd., thereby extinguishing any cause of action against the Bank of Upper India Ltd.
- Whether the doctrine of part performance can validate or cure the transfer/release where statutory requirements (including registration and the Companies Act provisions) were not complied with.
- Whether the plaintiff's claim was barred by limitation (including the applicability of Article 60 of the Limitation Act and the effect of minority and the debentures' maturation period under the composition scheme).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (Bank of Upper India Ltd.)
- That the liability of the Bank had been validly transferred to the Trust of India Ltd. and the Alliance Bank of Simla Ltd., and therefore there was no subsisting cause of action against the Bank.
- That the plaintiff's claim was time-barred (that is, barred by limitation).
- The Bank also raised factual/contentionary points: it required a succession certificate and repudiated the plaintiff's claim; and, on production of the original fixed deposit receipt, contested its genuineness and put the plaintiff to proof.
Plaintiff (Arif Husain, by next friend)
- That his rights under the fixed deposit had been replaced by rights under the composition scheme sanctioned on 2 June 1915, making him (and co-heirs) debenture-holders whose rights remained unimpaired.
- That there was no valid novation or fresh contract by which those rights were surrendered to a third party, and therefore the supplementary deed and any attempted transfer could not extinguish his claim.
- That the supplementary deed and any release intended to transfer assets were ineffective (for reasons including lack of authority, lack of requisite creditor consent and non-registration), and therefore his cause of action against the Bank remained intact.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Muhammad Musa v. Aqhore Kumar Gangoli, A.I.R. 1914 P.C. | The limits of the doctrine of part performance: equity may support a transaction clothed imperfectly in legal forms where parties have acted on it, but the doctrine cannot create or annul title where statutory conditions are mandatory. | The court relied on this to hold that part performance cannot supply mandatory statutory requirements and thus cannot validate the purported transfer where statute requires particular formalities. |
| Ram Gopal v. Tulsi Ram, A.I.R. 1928 All. 641 (Full Bench) | That the doctrine of part performance cannot override the positive rules of law in the Transfer of Property Act (i.e., part performance cannot be used to circumvent statutory registration requirements). | The court treated this Full Bench decision as authoritative in rejecting any part-performance argument that would attempt to circumvent the statutory transfer/registration requirements in respect of the bank's assets. |
| re Hunter v. Damodar, A.I.R. 1924 All. 772 | (Referenced in context) An earlier decision on part performance which, according to the court, was inconsistent with later Full Bench authority. | The court indicated that the decision of one of the judges in that case must be taken to have been overruled by the Full Bench decision in Ram Gopal's case. |
| John H. Arseculeratne v. B.M. Perera, A.I.R. 1928 P.C. 273 (at p. 275) | The Privy Council held that the doctrine of part performance has no application where non-observance of a statutory provision makes the transaction ineffective. | The court relied on this pronouncement to reinforce its conclusion that part performance cannot cure a transaction rendered ineffective by non-compliance with statutory provisions (such as those requiring registration or prescribed creditor consent). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by applying statutory and equitable principles strictly as set out in the record.
- The composition scheme sanctioned by the High Court under Section 153, Companies Act on 2 June 1915 operated to replace the original fixed-deposit rights with rights under the sanctioned scheme. The heirs thereby became debenture-holders under that scheme.
- Because no notice was given to the heirs and they did not exercise the option for preference shares by 5 January 1917, they were entitled to debentures carrying interest at 4½% per annum according to the face value of the deposit.
- Trustees for the debenture-holders executed a deed of trust (18 December 1915) creating a floating charge, but the recorded material does not show the trustees had authority to assent to a modification that substituted the Bank's liability with that of third parties (Trust of India Ltd. and Alliance Bank of Simla Ltd.). The heirs were not represented at the meeting that adopted the supplementary deed.
- The attempted substitution of liability and purported transfer of assets were deficient in several material respects: no evidence of necessary authority for trustees to bind those heirs, no indication that the requisite creditor consent (three-fourths in number and value) under Section 212, Companies Act had been obtained, and the deed of release was unregistered (bearing an eight annas stamp) and therefore ineffective to transfer assets that included immovable property.
- Section 212 requires that an arrangement between a company in voluntary winding up and its creditors be sanctioned and acceded to by three-fourths in number and value of creditors to be binding. The resolution dated 31 January 1917 was not acceded to by the requisite three-fourths, and therefore the supplementary arrangement could not be binding on the creditors (including the plaintiff and his co-heirs).
- The court considered and rejected reliance on the doctrine of part performance as a cure for statutory non-compliance. Citing authorities (Muhammad Musa; Ram Gopal; Privy Council in John H. Arseculeratne v. Perera), the court held that where statute prescribes mandatory conditions (including registration or prescribed creditor consent), the doctrine of part performance cannot create or annul title or validate a transaction which is ineffective by reason of statutory non-compliance.
- On these bases the court concluded that the plaintiff's cause of action against the Bank of Upper India Ltd. remained unimpaired; the "so-called deed of release was a mere waste paper" and no novation had occurred to extinguish the debenture-holder rights created by the High Court's order of 2 June 1915.
- On limitation, the court held Article 60 of the Limitation Act (three years from demand) did not apply because the money under the fixed deposit was not payable on demand but payable at a specified time (three months after deposit). Nevertheless, the plaintiff's claim was saved from the operation of limitation by several reasons recorded in the judgment: the cause of action accrued during the plaintiff's minority and the disability had not ceased; and under the composition scheme ten years were allowed for debentures to mature (the opinion records that the period of debentures expired on 1 April 1925 and that the suit instituted on 18 March 1926 was within time as concluded by the court).
Holding and Implications
Final Disposition: The appeal is dismissed with costs.
Direct Effect: The court held that the plaintiff (Arif Husain) had a subsisting cause of action against the Bank of Upper India Ltd.; the rights created by the High Court-sanctioned composition scheme (2 June 1915) remained unimpaired and the plaintiff's decree below was sustained (the trial Court's decree for Rs. 1,333-11-0 was affirmed by the lower appellate Court and this appeal was dismissed).
Broader Implications: The opinion applied established principles limiting the doctrine of part performance where statutory formalities (Companies Act provisions and registration requirements under the Transfer of Property Act) are not complied with. The opinion does not purport to set a new legal precedent beyond its application of existing authorities and statutory rules.
Note: This summary has been prepared strictly from the content of the provided opinion and does not add or infer factual or legal material not present in the original text.
Sen, J.
1. Syed Zafar Husain made a fixed deposit of Rs. 800 in the Bank of Upper India Limited at Meerut on 1st March 1910. The deposit was for a period of three months only and the stipulated rate of interest was 3 per cent per annum.
2. The fixed deposit receipt which has been exhibited in this case as No. 4 is worded as follows:
Received from Syed Zaffar Hussain village Dholri, District Meerut, the sum of Rs. 800 only as a deposit subject to three months' notice of withdrawal bearing interest at 3 per cent per annum from 24th February 1910 payable on 1st January and 1st July of each year.
3. Syed Zaffar Hussain died on 10th June 1910. He left a widow Mt. Husain Bandi, a daughter Amtul Zainub, aged about 4 years and a son Arif Husain aged about 2 years. These were his heirs under the Mahomedan law and were entitled to the amount of the deposit together with interest.
4. It ought to be noticed that Syed Zaffar Husain died before the fixed deposit had matured for payment.
5. Mt. Husain Bandi the widow had left this country and lived in Iraq from 1913 to 1917. She died in 1917, the exact date of her death cannot be ascertained from the record. Mt. Amtul Zainub died on 14th October 1921.
6. The present suit was commenced by Arif Husain for recovery of the amount of the fixed deposit on 18th March 1926. Plaintiff was a minor at the date of the suit and the suit was instituted by one Syed Mohammad Raza as the next friend of the plaintiff.
7. The plaintiff alleged that at the date of the suit he was the only person who was entitled to the money his mother and his sister having predeceased him.
8. The Bank of Upper India, Limited closed its doors and went into voluntary liquidation on 8th October 1914. A meeting of the creditors was held which drew up a composition scheme This scheme was sanctioned by this Court under section 153, companies act' on 2nd June 1915. In pursuance of this scheme an option was given to the creditors either to accept fully paid up preference shares in the bank or to take debentures of the bank carrying interest at the rate of 41/2 per cent per annum according to the face value of their deposits. The High Court directed that this option was to be exercised on or before 5th January 1917. If the depositors did not exercise the option on or before that date they were to forfeit their rights to preference shares in the bank and were entitled to debentures only.
9. No notice of these proceedings were given to the heirs of Syed Zaffar Husain. But the composition scheme appears to have been sanctioned by this Court in due process of law under Section 153, Companies Act. It was therefore binding upon the heirs of Syed Zaffar Husain. Not having exercised the option to accept preference shares on or before 5th January 1917 they became entitled to hold debentures from the bank carrying interest at the rate of 4i per cent per annum according to the face value of their deposits.
10. The debenture-holders appear to have appointed three trustees to act for and look after their interests. A formal deed of trust was executed on 18th December 1915. The effect of this document was that a floating charge was created in favour of the debenture-holders on all the assets belonging to the Bank of Upper India. We do not know what the powers of the trustees were under this deed of trust.
11. On or about 31st January 1917 a meeting of the debenture-holders wag held and resolutions were passed modifying the terms of the original deed of trust dated 18th December 1915. The Original trust deed was modified by a supplementary trust deed which was executed on 18th June 1917 and which was sanctioned by the High Court. The terms of the supplementary deed were rather drastic. The object was to transfer the liability from the Bank of Upper India Limited to two other bodies, namely, the Trust of India, Limited and the Alliance Bank of Simla, Limited. The supplementary trust deed provided that each debenture holder of Rs. 100 was to get Rs. 40 per cent cumulative preference shares of the Trust of India Limited and Rs. 60 per cent fixed deposit receipt in the Alliance Bank of Simla, Ltd.
12. The heirs of Syed Zaffar Husain do not appear to have been represented at the general meeting in which the terms of the supplementary deed were mooted and ultimately adopted. It does not appear that the trustees of the debenture-holders were within their authority in assenting to a modification of the original deed of trust and to a substitution of the liability of the Bank of Upper India Ltd. by that of the Trust of India Ltd., and the Alliance Bank of Simla, Ltd. No debentures, appear to have been issued to the heirs of Syed Zaffar Husain as ought to have been issued after 5th January 1917. The plaintiff contends that his right against the Bank of Upper India Ltd. remains unaltered by the supplementary trust deed which is not binding upon him.
13. The tactics adopted by the Bank of Upper India Ltd., were dilatory and obstructive. Upon the plaintiff claiming the money, the Bank insisted upon the plaintiff producing a succession certificate. A succession certificate was produced in due course. The Bank then repudiated the plaintiff's claim.
14. Upon the original fixed deposit receipt being produced in support of the plaintiff's claim, the defendant Bank refused to admit its genuineness and put the plaintiff to its proof.
15. A written statement attested by Mr. H. Hunter, liquidator, has been produced in this case which consists of 26 paragraphs. Various pleas were taken in defence but it is necessary to notice only two of the pleas which are material for the purpose of this appeal. The defendant contended that the liability of the Bank having been transferred to the Trust of India Ltd. and the Alliance Bank of Simla Ltd. there was no subsisting cause of action against the defendant. It was also contended that the plaintiff's claim was time barred.
16. These contentions were overruled by the trial Court which substantially decreed the plaintiff's claim. The plaintiff had claimed a sum of Rs. 1,373-11-0. The trial Court decreed the claim for Rs. 1,333-11-0. On appeal by the Bank, the lower appellate Court has affirmed the decision.
17. Holders of fixed deposits who did not surrender their receipts were treated as unconverted depositors.
18. Ten lakhs of rupees were set apart in the Upper India Bank accounts to meet the claims of the unconverted depositors.
19. Syed Zaffar Husain's deposit formed part of this sum of ten lakhs of rupees.
20. Syed Zaffar Husain was not represent-ed at the meeting of the debenture-holders dated 31st January 1917. It does -not appear that the trustees of the debenture-holders had any authority to represent the heirs of Syed Zaffar Husain or to negotiate about their securities with a third party. The assets of the Bank of Upper India do not appear to have been transferred in due course of law to either the Trust of India or the Alliance Bank Ltd. A deed of release bearing an eight annas stamp appears to have been executed with the set design of conveying the assets of the Bank of Upper India to the Trust of India Ltd. This document was unregistered and therefore could not effectively operate to transfer the assets to the Trust of India Ltd. We are clearly of opinion that the plaintiff's cause of action as a holder of debentures in pursuance of the composition scheme sanctioned by the High Court on 2nd June 1915 under Section 153, Companies Act, remains unimpaired. The original rights of the parties under the fixed deposit dated 1st March 1910, became replaced by the rights which came into existence under the aforesaid order of the High Court. The plaintiff and the other coheirs became therefore the debenture-holders of the defendant company. They could not lose those rights except either by a fresh contract between the parties or by operation of law. The plaintiff or his other coheirs did mot surrender their rights to a third party under a fresh contract. Indeed, there was no novation of contract. The original tights as secured by the order of the High Court dated 2nd June 1915 did not cease to exist by operation of law. The so-called deed of release was a mere waste paper. The supplementary deed of trust was clearly in the teeth of section 212, companies act, which provides that:
Any arrangement entered into between a company about to be, or in the course of being wound up voluntarily, and its creditors shall, subject to any right of appeal under this section be binding on the company if sanctioned by an extraordinary resolution and on the creditors, if acceded to by 3/4ths in number and value of the creditors.
21. The resolution mooted in the meeting of the trustees dated 31st January 1917 was not acceded to by 3/4ths in number and value of the creditors. This was therefore not an arrangement which could be binding upon the creditors. It therefore could not take away the right of the plaintiff and his other coheirs, Reliance has been placed upon the doctrine of part performance as an answer to the objection that the directions of the statute as contained in Section 212 have not been complied with. The doctrine of part performance cannot create or annul a title. Where there is a legal defect in an agreement between the parties by reason of its not being registered but the parties have acted on the terms of the agreement and in arrangement of their rights in accordance with the said terms equity steps in. In such cases equity will support a transaction clothed imperfectly in those legal forms to which finality attaches after the bargain has been acted upon: Muhammad Musa v. Aqhore Kumar Gangoli A.I.R. 1914 P.C. 27. Where the statute makes it imperative that certain conditions must be fulfilled, the non-fulfilment of these conditions cannot be supplied by invoking the doctrine of part performance.
22. The assets of the Bank of Upper India Ltd., consisted of moveable and immovable property of the value of more than Rs. 100. There could be no transfer or release in favour of the Trust of India Ltd., or the Alliance Bank of Simla, Ltd, without an instrument in writing duly registered. It has been held by a -Full Bench of this Court in Ram Gopal v. Tulsi Ram A.I.R. 1928 All. 641 (F.B)., that the doctrince of part performance cannot override the positive rules of law embodied in the Transfer of Property Act. This principle does not appear to have been kept in view in re Hunter v. Damodar A.I.R. 1924 All. 772. The decision of one of the Judges in that case must be taken to have been overruled by the Full Bench decision in Ram Gopal's case A.I.R. 1928 All. 641 (F.B).; and also by a recent pronouncement of the Privy Council in John H. Arseculeratre v. B.M. Perera, A.I.R. 1928 P.C. 273 at p. 275, it has been held by their Lordships of the Judicial Committee that the doctrine of part performance has no application when non-observance of a statutory provision makes the transaction ineffective. We are clearly of opinion that the plaintiff has a subsisting cause of action against the defendant-appellant.
23. Syed Zaffar Husain died before the fixed deposit became mature for payment. Of his heirs only one, namely, Mt. Husain Bandi, the widow, was entitled to recover a share of the deposit because she was a major. She was away from the country when the Bank of Upper India Ltd. went into liquidation and she died in a foreign land. Mt. Amtul Zainub died a minor. Plaintiff was a minor at the death of his father and continued to be a minor at the date of the present suit.
24. The lower appellate Court has relied upon Article 60, Lim. Act; and held that the suit was within limitation as being within three years from the time when the demand was made by the plaintiff for his money. The demand was made in 1925. Article 60, Lim. Act prescribes a period of three years from the date when he demand is made in a suit:
for money deposited under an agreement that it shall be payable on demand, including money of a customer in the hands of his banker so payable.
25. The money payable under the' fixed deposit was not subject to an agreement that it was payable on demand. It was not money of a customer in the hands of the banker " so payable," that is payable on demand. On the other hand, it was money payable by the Bank at a specified time, namely, upon the expiry of three months from the date of the deposit. Article 60, Lim. Act, is therefore not applicable to a suit of this description. The plaintiff's claim however is saved from the operation of limitation by a variety of reasons. The cause of action accrued to the plaintiff during his minority and the disability has not ceased. Under the composition scheme sanctioned by the High Court ten years' time was allowed for the debentures to mature for payment. The period of debentures expired on 1st April 1925. The suit was instituted on 18th March 1926. It is clearly within time. This appeal is without force and is dismissed with costs.
Alert