Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bhagwan Kaushik v. State of U.P.& Ors.

Allahabad High Court
Jan 1, 2006
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, claiming to be a life member of the General Body of a Society, filed a writ petition challenging an order dated 24-4-2004 passed by the District Inspector of Schools. The order attested the signature of Respondent No. 5 as Manager of the Committee of Management, following the approval of the Regional Committee on 19-4-2004, which recognized the elections held on 19-10-2003 where Respondent No. 5 was elected as Manager. The petitioner contested the recognition of the election and the attestation of the signature, despite no dispute between rival committees regarding the election. The petition was disposed of at the admission stage with consent of the parties after exchange of affidavits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an individual member of the General Body of the Society has locus standi to challenge the recognition of the election and attestation of the Manager's signature by the authorities.
  2. Whether the petitioner’s writ petition is maintainable in the absence of a dispute between rival committees.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner claims locus as a life member of the General Body to challenge the order recognizing the election and attestation of Respondent No. 5's signature.
  • The petitioner relies on the decision in Yogendra Nath Singh v. State of U.P. to support locus standi to question administrative orders related to the institution.

Respondent No. 5's Arguments

  • Respondent No. 5, through counsel, raised a preliminary objection that the petitioner, being merely an individual member of the General Body, has no locus standi to maintain the writ petition.
  • It was contended that only the Committee of Management as a whole can challenge such orders, not individual members.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Committee of Management Janta Inter College v. Joint Director of Education, 1999(1) LBESR 467 (All) Individual members cannot prolong disputes over elections as it may paralyze administration. The court relied on this to emphasize that allowing individual members to challenge election recognition would lead to administrative chaos.
Dr. P.P. Rastogi v. Meerut University, Meerut, (1997) 1 UPLBEC 415 Individual members of a Committee of Management lack locus standi; only the Committee can appear as a party. The court applied this principle to hold that the petitioner, as an individual member, cannot maintain the writ petition.
Yogendra Nath Singh v. State of U.P., 1997(2) E.S.C. 851 A teacher has locus standi to question an order declaring an institution as a minority institution. The court distinguished this precedent, holding it inapplicable as the present case concerns election approval, where individual members do not have locus standi.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the petitioner's locus standi, noting that the petitioner is merely an individual life member of the General Body of the Society. It referred to authoritative precedents establishing that individual members do not have the right to challenge decisions related to the Committee of Management elections, as such challenges must be brought by the Committee itself to avoid administrative paralysis and multiplicity of litigation. The court distinguished the petitioner’s reliance on the Yogendra Nath Singh case, clarifying that the locus standi recognized there was for a teacher contesting minority status of an institution, which is materially different from the present case concerning election approval. The absence of any dispute between rival committees further undermined the petitioner's standing. Consequently, the court concluded that the writ petition was not maintainable on the ground of lack of locus standi.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is dismissed as not maintainable due to lack of locus standi of the petitioner.

The direct effect of this decision is the rejection of the petitioner's challenge to the recognition of the election and attestation of the Manager's signature. The court clarified that this dismissal does not preclude the petitioner from pursuing any other legal remedies available under the law. No new precedent was established; rather, the court reaffirmed existing principles limiting individual members' rights to litigate election-related matters of the Committee of Management.

Show all summary ...

Vineet Saran, J.:-

The petitioner claims himself to be a life member of the General Body of the Society in question. By means of this writ petition, the petitioner has challenged an order dated 24-4-2004 passed by the District Inspector of Schools, whereby the signature of the Respondent No. 5 has been attested as Manager of the Committee of Management in pursuance of the approval accorded by the Regional Committee on 19-4-2004 whereby the elections dated 19-10-2003, in which Respondent No. 5 was elected as Manager, had been recognized.

2. A preliminary objection has been raised by Sri G.K. Singh, learned Counsel for the contesting Respondent No. 5, that the petitioner, who is merely a life member of the General Body of the Society, would have no locus to maintain this writ petition.

3. I have heard Sri S.D. Shukla, learned Counsel for the petitioner as well as learned Standing Counsel appearing the State-respondents and Sri G.K. Singh, learned Counsel appearing for the Respondent No. 5. Counter and rejoinder affidavits have been exchanged between the contesting parties and with the consent of the learned Counsel for the parties, this writ petition is being disposed of at the admission stage itself.

4. In pursuance of the Government Order dated 19-12-2000, the District Inspector of Schools had forwarded the papers with regard to the election of the Committee of Management held on 19- 10-2003 to the Regional Committee headed by the Regional Joint Director of Education, Respondent No. 2. By order dated 19-4-2004 the Regional Committee recognized the election and consequently the District Inspector of Schools attested the signature of the Respondent No. 5. It is not the case that there was any dispute between two rival committees with regard to the said elections. The petitioner is merely an individual member of the General Body of the Society who has challenged the orders recognizing the elections and attestation of signature of Respondent No. 5 as Manager.

5. A learned Single Judge of this Court in the case of Committee of Management Janta Inter College v. Joint Director of Education, 1999(1) LBESR 467 (All) : 1999(1) UPLBEC 170, has, while considering a case under section 16-a (7) of the u.p. intermediate education act, 1921, observed that "In case such dispute is stretched or extended to the right of each individual member, in that event, if any member raised such dispute then the whole administration is expected to collapse since the Joint Director would remain busy and pre-occupied with deciding such disputes which may be raised by any individual."

6. A Division Bench of this Court in the case of Dr. P.P. Rastogi v. Meerut University, Meerut, (1997) 1 UPLBEC 415, has, in a case filed by an individual member of the Committee of Management, held that "an individual member of the Committee of Management has no locus standi in such cases and it is only the Committee of Management alone which can appear as a party in the case. To permit individual members of the Committee of Management to appear before us would create a lot of problems because any individual member or several members may file applications at any time through his/their own separate Counsel, resulting in confusion......."

7. In the present case, the petitioner is also an individual member of the General Body of the Society and has challenged the decision of the District Inspector of Schools whereby the signature of Respondent No. 5 has been attested, after the approval has been granted by the Regional Committee. In such facts, this writ petition would not be maintainable on the ground that the petitioner does not have the locus standi to file this writ petition. In my view, if each individual member of the General Body is allowed to file writ petitions, without the law recognizing their right to raise such dispute, the same would open a flood gate of litigation, adding further confusion to the already existing situation where very often separate petitions are filed by different parties relating to the same election of the Committee of Management.

8. The decision of the Division Bench in the case of Yogendra Nath Singh v. State of U.P., 1997(2) E.S.C. 851, relied upon by the learned Counsel for the petitioner would not be applicable to the facts of the present case. In the said case, this Court has held that a teacher of the institution would have locus standi to question the order declaring the institution as minority institution, which is not so here. In the case in hand the approval to the election of the Committee of Management is involved, in which individual members of the Society cannot be permitted to raise disputes and file writ petitions.

9. Accordingly, this writ petition is dismissed as not maintainable. However, this order shall not debar the petitioner from availing such other remedy which may be available to him in law.

Petition dismissed.