- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Suleman v. State Of U.P And Ors.
Judicial Opinion Summary — Allahabad High Court (Arun Tandon, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The State of Uttar Pradesh acquired land in village Loni, Ghaziabad under the Land Acquisition Act, 1984 and transferred it to the U.P. State Industrial Development Corporation (UPSIDC). UPSIDC allotted 87.10 acres of undeveloped land to M/s Ansal Housing Construction Ltd. (Ansal) by letter dated 6.5.1997 and executed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with Ansal. The allotment contemplated development (roads, drains, sewers, water supply, parks, community centres, schools, etc.) and provided for leases for 90 years and for Ansal to sell developed plots / built-up premises to prospective buyers.
Tripartite lease deeds were subsequently executed between UPSIDC, Ansal and purchasers (petitioners). The tripartite deeds contained endorsements and recitals treating those deeds as the "first transfer" entitling the purchasers to a concessional rate of stamp duty. When these tripartite lease deeds were presented for registration, Stamp Authorities initiated proceedings under section 47A of the Indian Stamp Act and, by order dated 11.5.2010, held that the tripartite deeds were not the first transfer and that full stamp duty (with interest) was payable. An appeal under section 56-A of the Indian Stamp Act was dismissed on 28.7.2010. The purchasers filed writ petitions challenging the impugned orders; this opinion records the Court's consideration and final decision (dictated in open Court on 16.8.2011).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the tripartite lease deed executed between UPSIDC, Ansal and the purchasers constituted the "first transfer" of the land for the purposes of claiming concessional stamp duty under the Indian Stamp Act and relevant Government order.
- Whether the allotment letter and Memorandum of Understanding (between UPSIDC and Ansal) amounted in substance to a lease (a first transfer) or merely to a license, despite using the term "license" in certain clauses.
- Whether purchasers who were led to believe by UPSIDC and Ansal that the tripartite deed was a first transfer can avoid the demand for full stamp duty, or whether the Revenue's demand is valid.
- Whether persons (purchasers) misled by state instrumentality and the developer should bear the full financial consequences alone, or whether UPSIDC and Ansal should also be made to share the burden and face appropriate action.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' (Purchasers') Arguments
- The petitioners relied on written assurances/recitals in the allotment letter, memorandum of understanding and the tripartite deeds (including an endorsement affixed by UPSIDC) that the tripartite deed recorded the "first transfer," and therefore they paid stamp duty at the concessional rate in good faith.
- They contended that an instrumentality of the State (UPSIDC) had assured that the tripartite deed was the first transfer and that purchasers should not be saddled with the financial liability resulting from that assurance.
Respondents' (UPSIDC and Ansal) Arguments
- Counsel for Ansal and UPSIDC contended that the arrangement between UPSIDC and Ansal created a license in favour of the developer/builder (Ansal) and that the allotment letter and MOU could not be treated as leases. They emphasized Clause 13 of the allotment letter which described the developer as a "licensee" till completion of development work.
- They argued that UPSIDC continued to be the owner of the land and only the right to develop the undeveloped plots was conferred on Ansal; hence the tripartite lease deed recorded the first transfer and the recitals were justified. (They relied on precedents including NOIDA v. State of U.P. and ICICI v. State of Maharashtra.)
- It was also submitted that earlier documents (the allotment letter and the MOU) had not been presented for registration and authorities should not take those unregistered documents into consideration for ascertaining stamp duty liability on the tripartite deed (relying on Somdutt Builders Ltd. v. State of U.P. and others).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Associated Hotels Of India Ltd v. R.N. Kapoor, AIR 1959 SC 1262 | Principle that substance of document prevails over its form; tests to determine whether a document creates a lease or a license (intention of parties, exclusive possession, whether document creates an interest in property). | The Court applied these principles to conclude that, on the true construction of the allotment letter and MOU, a lease interest in immovable property was created in favour of Ansal despite some clauses calling Ansal a "licensee." |
| State of Uttarakhand & Ors v. Harpal Singh Rawat, JT 2011(2) SC 481 | Clarification that the definition of "lease" in Section 2(16) of the Indian Stamp Act is wide and may include instruments that do not amount to a lease under Section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act. | The Court relied on this authority to hold that even if the transaction might not qualify strictly as a lease under the Transfer of Property Act, it could nonetheless be a lease for the purposes of the Stamp Act; this supported treating the MOU/allotment as a first transfer (lease) under the Stamp Act. |
| Residents Welfare Association, NOIDA v. State of Uttar Pradesh and others, (2009) 14 SCC 716 | Authority cited by respondents on questions of allotment/transaction characterization (as relied upon by counsel for Ansal/UPSIDC). | The Court found the facts of NOIDA distinguishable from the present case and therefore did not treat it as controlling; it recorded that the present facts differ materially. |
| ICICI v. State of Maharashtra, (1999) 5 SCC 708 | Authority cited by respondents (referred to in their submissions). | The Court observed that ICICI is distinguishable on facts and does not govern the present matter where an interest enabling development and sale at enhanced rates was conferred on the developer. |
| Somdutt Builders Ltd. v. State of U.P. and others, 2005 (2) AWC 1711 | Case relied upon to argue that unregistered allotment-letter/MOU cannot be considered for stamp duty determination. | The Court found Somdutt distinguishable on the terms and conditions of the documents in the present case and did not accept it as controlling; the Court examined the actual terms and concluded the MOU/allotment effected a first transfer. |
| Bhavnagar University v. Palitana Sugar Mills (Pvt.) Ltd. and Others, 2003 (2) SCC 111 | Principle that minor factual differences can significantly affect the precedential value of a decision. | The Court invoked this principle to justify distinguishing prior decisions and to stress that differing facts change their precedential application to the present case. |
| Dr. Rajbir Singh Dalal v. Chaudhari Devi Lal University, AIR 2008 SCW 5817 | Followed the above principle regarding the impact of factual differences on precedential value. | The Court noted that this authority follows the Bhavnagar principle and applied that approach in distinguishing prior cases relied upon by respondents. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court conducted a clause-by-clause analysis of the allotment letter (dated 6.5.1997) and the Memorandum of Understanding between UPSIDC and Ansal. Key elements informing the Court's analysis included:
- The allotment letter expressly granted land "on lease for 90 years" (Clause 18), required payment of 25% premium and execution of the MOU for possession, and required payment of a lump-sum lease rent of 10% of total land cost upon tripartite lease.
- The MOU and allotment letter contemplated that Ansal would perform comprehensive development work (internal roads, drains, sewers, utilities, parks, community centres, schools) within a specified period (three years, extendable in some circumstances) and could start booking and accept sale proceeds after possession and plan approval.
- The MOU and allotment letter contained clauses (Clause 6(b) of MOU and Clause 12(c) of allotment letter) reciting that a tripartite lease would be signed among the Corporation, developer and allottees and describing such tripartite lease as a "first sale" for which no transfer charges would be levied.
- Despite Clause 13 describing the developer as a "licensee" for the development period, the Court emphasized that labels used in the documents are not conclusive. The Court applied the tests laid down by the Supreme Court (Associated Hotels) — substance over form, intention of parties, whether the document creates an interest in property, and whether exclusive possession is conferred — to determine true character of the transaction.
- Applying these legal tests and considering the scheme (where Ansal was allotted land at a relatively low rate, developed it and sold developed plots at substantially higher rates, was authorized to accept sale proceeds and transfer built-up accommodation, and where lease terms were set out for 90 years), the Court concluded that the MOU/allotment letter granted an interest in the land amounting to a lease — i.e., the MOU/allotment constituted the first transfer.
- The Court relied on the Supreme Court's recent clarification in State of Uttarakhand v. Harpal Singh Rawat that the definition of "lease" under Section 2(16) of the Indian Stamp Act is wide and may cover instruments that might not amount to a lease under Section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act; this supported treating the MOU/allotment as a first transfer for stamp-duty purposes.
- Having distinguished the prior authorities relied upon by respondents (NOIDA, ICICI, Somdutt) on the basis of differing facts and the particular terms of the documents in the present case, the Court held that the tripartite deed was not the first transfer; it was the second transfer of a developed plot at a much higher price.
- Consequently, the Court found the Stamp Authorities' orders holding the tripartite deeds not to be first transfers — and demanding the deficiency of stamp duty at full rates with interest — to be legally sustainable.
- Separately, the Court addressed equitable considerations: purchasers were misled by UPSIDC and Ansal into believing the tripartite deed was the first transfer. The Court found it unfair for purchasers alone to bear the financial consequences flowing from the authorities' demand and the misleading assurances, and therefore made remedial directions to allocate financial responsibility.
- The Court also sought and received a report from the Chief Secretary who concluded that civil and criminal action should be initiated against those involved in affixation of stamp and misleading the allottees. On that basis the Court did not consider it necessary to pass further directions for action against UPSIDC and Ansal beyond directing recovery of amounts and entrusting the Chief Secretary to ensure appropriate steps.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court held that the Memorandum of Understanding between Ansal and UPSIDC constituted the first transfer in the nature of a lease of immovable property and that the subsequent tripartite lease deeds executed between the petitioners, Ansal and UPSIDC were second transfers. Accordingly, the tripartite deeds were not eligible for concessional stamp duty under the Government order and full stamp duty (with interest) was payable; the challenge to the impugned orders was repelled. The writ petitions were disposed of subject to observations and directions.
Immediate Consequences (Direct Effect on Parties):
- The Stamp Authorities' demand for deficiency in stamp duty (full rate) along with interest on the tripartite deeds is upheld.
- Equitable allocation of liability: the Court ordered that the purchasers (petitioners) must pay one-third (1/3) of the total demanded amount within two months from the date of the order.
- The Chief Secretary was directed to ensure recovery of one-third of the amount each from Ansal and UPSIDC within the same period (effectively making UPSIDC and Ansal equally liable to bear two-thirds of the demand alongside purchasers paying their one-third share).
- The Chief Secretary's report recommending initiation of civil and criminal action against those involved in affixation of stamp or otherwise misleading allottees was noted by the Court; the Court did not pass further orders for action and expected the Chief Secretary to act on the report.
Broader implications: The Court distinguished earlier authorities on factual grounds and relied on established principles (substance over form; wide scope of "lease" under the Stamp Act). The opinion applies existing jurisprudence rather than announcing a new legal precedent.
Disposition: Writ petitions disposed of subject to the observations and directions recorded above (including the financial apportionment and the Chief Secretary's role).
Arun Tandon, J;-
This bunch of writ petitions has been filed by lessees of developed plots (for construction of residential houses)as per the separate tripartite deeds executed between the concerned petitioner, U.P. State Industrial Development Corporation (herein after referred to as UPSIDC) and M/s Ansal Housing Construction Ltd. New Delhi (hereinafter referred to Ansal).
2. These petitions are a classic example of the manner in which the UPSIDC in collusion with the construction Company Ansal has created a situation, (a) for defrauding the public exchequer and (b) for mis-leading common person like the petitioners to believe that the Tripartite deed was first transfer of the property and so they were entitled to the benefit of reduced rate of stamp duty under the relevant Government order. The mis-representation has lead to a situation where huge demand towards stamp duty penalty along with interest has been raised against the petitioners under the orders impugned passed by the Stamp authorities under the indian stamp act.
3. Brief facts of the case as on record of these petitions are as follows.
The State of Uttar Pradesh acquired land situate at village Loni district Ghaziabad under the Land Acquisition Act, 1984. This land was transferred by the State of Uttar Pradesh to the UPSIDC for development.
4. Ansal vide letter dated 15.2.1997 made a request for allotment of 87.10 acres of said un-developed land to the UPSIDC for developing a housing colony in the housing Sector of Tronica City Loni district Ghaziabad. The request so made by Ansal was accepted by the UPSIDC as per their letter dated 6.5.1997. UPSIDC agreed to allot 87.10 acres of un-developed land to the Ansal @ Rs.397/= per sq.mt. on the terms and conditions mentioned in the letter of allotment. From Clause 18 of the allotment letter it is apparently clear that the period of the lease was 90 years. Clause 7 of the said letter of allotment provided that possession of land shall be delivered to Ansal only after payment of 25% of the total amount of premium and after execution of Memorandum of Understanding with the UPSIDC.
5. The letter of allotment was acted upon and an memorandum of understanding has been executed between the Regional Manager UPSIDC and the Vice President of Ansal. Copies whereof have been brought on record as Annsure-1 to the writ petition No.73277 of 2010 and as Annexure No. 3 to the counter affidavit filed by the Ansal respectively.
6. Paragraph 3 of the memorandum of understanding provides for the nature of work to be done for the purposes of development of the undeveloped land allotted to Ansal. It is mentioned that the development had to be undertaken as per the approved plan. The internal development work would includ laying of roads, drains, sewers, underground cable, water supply and facility of park, roads community centers, schools etc. The development work had to be completed within 3 years. From paragraph 6 of the memorandum of understanding it is apparently clear that at least 25% of the plots (in terms of number and area) were to be transferred as built up accommodation. For the purpose Ansal was permitted to start booking and to accept the sale proceeds in their name from prospective buyers of plots/buildings immediately after getting the possession and on approval of the layout plan.
7. Absolutely no price limit was fixed for Ansal on which it could let out the developed plots/residential house. Suffice to record that in the facts of the case the plot have been leased out to the petitioners approximately @ Rs.2400/= per sq.mt. It will be seen that the allotment has been made by Ansal after developing the plot at seven times the price on which they had obtained possession of the same land for development.
8. Clause 18 further stipulates that the persons obtaining plots from Ansal after development will further be required to pay 10% of the total cost of the land in lump sum at the time of tripartite lease to the UPSIDC as lease rent. After allotment of the developed plot or built up premises a tripartite lease deed be executed between UPSIDA, Ansal and the allottee for which no transfer charges would be payable.
9. A tripartite lease has been executed between the Ansal, UPSIDC and the petitioners who are the allottees of the developed plots by Ansal.
10. Clause 12 (c) of the letter of allotment and Clause 6(b) of the memorandum of understanding, contain a recital that the tripartite lease deed would be the first sale. Relevant portion of Clause 6 (b) of memorandum of understanding is reproduce here under :-
"That the lease of the plot or built up premises shall be executed by UPSIDC Limited with the allottees of Developer/Builder . For such lease, developer /builder shall inform the Corporation in writing. A tripartite lease shall be signed among Corporation, developer/builder and its allottees. No transfer charges shall be levied for such first sale."
11. Relevant portion of 12 (c) of the letter of allotment which contains same recital is reproduce here as under :-
"The lease of the plot or built up premises shall be executed by UPSIDC Limited with the allottees of Developer/Builder .For such lease, developer/builder shall inform Corporation in writing. A tripartite lease shall be signed by Corporation, developer/builder and its allottees. No transfer charges shall be levied for such first sale. However, for subsequent sale transfer levy as per policy of the Corporation prevailing at that time would be payable to the Corporation."
12. On the basis of the said clauses an endorsement was made on all the Tripartite Lease deeds executed by the Officer of the UPSIDC which reads as follows:-
"Lekhpatra duara iss sampatti ka antaran patta pratham baar pratham viyakti ke pakchh me kiya ja raha hai. Kreta/Pattagrahita mool abanti hai."
13. From the aforesaid three recitals in writing it is no more in doubt that the UPSIDC and Ansal held out a categorical assurance to the allottee that the tripartite deed recorded first transfer of the plot/flat. It is only because of such assurance having been held out to the allottees like the petitioners that they deposited the stamp duty treating the same to be the first transfer i.e. at concessional rate in terms of the Government order applicable.
14. In Writ Petition No. 73277 of 2010 copy of the tripartite lease deed dated 31.3.2009 has been enclosed as Annexure-3 to the writ petition. In connected writ petitions lease deeds are stated to be identical.
15. These tripartite lease deed were presented for registration resulting in initiation of proceedings under section 47 a of the indian stamp act. The Deputy Commissioner, Stamps vide order dated 11.5.2010 held that the lease deeds were not the first transfer of the land and the petitioners were therefore not entitled to the concessional rate of duty. The petitioners have therefore been called upon to pay difference of the stamp duty along with interest.
16. Not being satisfied the petitioner filed an appeal under section 56 -a of the indian stamp act which has also been dismissed under the order dated 28.7.2010. Hence this writ petition.
17. Counsel for the petitioner contends that an instrumentality of the State like UPSIDC which is run and managed by the State Officer had assuranced that the Tripartite lease deed is the first transfer of the land leading the petitioners to believe in good faith that he is entitled to concessional rate of stamp duty. It cannot be insisted upon by the Revenue authorities of the State that stamp duty at full rate is payable on the tripartite deed as it was not the first transfer.
18. He submits that purchaser like the petitioners cannot be made to suffer because of the Officers of the UPSIDC in collusion with the Ansal so as to be saddled with financial liability at the hands of the district authorities who are now demanding full stamp duty on the tripartite deed executed.
19. Sri Manu Khare, Advocate counsel for the Ansal and Sri V.K.Birla counsel for the UPSIDC with reference to paragraph 4 (d) of the short Counter affidavit read with Clause 13 of the letter of allotment in reply contend that only license was granted in favour of the developer/builder i.e. Ansal and the documents i.e. Letter of allotment and Memorandum of Understanding cannot be treated to be a lease. Similarly in paragraph 6 and 7 of the short counter affidavit it is stated that no lease was granted in respect of the undeveloped plots under the allotment letter or under the memorandum of understanding. The UPSIDC continued to be the owner of the land and right to develop the undeveloped plot alone was conferred upon Ansal. It therefore, submitted that in the facts of the case recital in the letter of allotment, memorandum of understanding, and the affixation made on the tripartite deed to the effect that it was the first transfer is factually correct and justified. In support of the contentions raised reliance has been placed upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Residents Welfare Association, NOIDA v. State of Uttar Pradesh and others reported in (2009) 14 SCC 716 and ICICI v. State of Maharashtra reported in 1999 (5) SCC 708. Counsel for the respondents then contended that in view of the judgment of High Court in the case of Somdutt Builders Ltd. v. State of U.P. and others reported 2005 (2) AWC 1711 since the documents i.e. memorandum of understanding and Letter of allotment have not been presented for registration the same cannot be taken into consideration for ascertaining the liability of stamp duty on the tripartite deed.
20. In order to examine the correctness or otherwise of the stand so taken by the UPSIDC and the Ansal it would be worthwhile to refer to various clauses of the letter of allotment and the memo of understanding executed between the UPSIDC and Ansal.
21. Under the allotment letter dated 6.5.97 undeveloped land measuring 87.10 acres was allotted to Ansal for developing a Housing Colony in industrial area of Tronica City Loni district Ghaziabad @ Rs.397 per sq.mt. Clause 7 provides that possession of the land would be delivered on payment of 25% of the premium amount and after execution of the memorandum of understanding. Clause 8 and 9 provide that the development work shall be undertaken as per the approved lay out plan. The conditions of Alltment letter have been made part of the memorandum of understanding.
22. The development work to be done by Ansal will include laying of internal roads, drains, sewers, underground cables, watter supply, facilities like park, community center and schools etc. inside the allotted area.
23. Clause 12 of the allotment letter further provides that the developer/builder shall sell at least 25% of the plots (no. and areawise) as built up accommodation and the remaining would be allotted as plot or built up premises according to rules and regulations approved by the corporation.
24. Clause 18 of the letter of allotment categorically records as follows:-
"The land of the plot is being allotted on lease for 90 years . Lease rent shall also be payable by the various allottees/your nominees @ 10% of the total cost of the land in lump sum as per prevalent rates of the corporation at the time of lease".
25. Similarly the memorandum of understanding in opening recitals contains following statements:- " whereas the rate of 397/= per sq.mtr. for allotment of land is on lease hold basis."
26. Under the letter of allotment and the memorandum of understanding there is a specific stipulation that after development the allotment shall be made by the Ansal to prospective buyers for which it can start accepting applications even before such development. The allottees shall not only pay money asked for by the Ansal they shall also be required to pay UPSIDC rent @ 10% of the total premium of the plot as lump sum as per the prevalent rate of the Corporation at the time of lease.
27. It is, further specifically provided in the said document that a tripartite lease shall be executed duly signed by the Corporation (UPSIDC), developer/builder (Ansal) and the allottees.
28. In the facts of the case the allotment of land by Ansal in favour of the petitioner is at a rate, which is nearly 7 times the rate paid for the undeveloped land by Ansal to the Corporation.
29. The Court may now reproduce Clause 13 of the allotment letter which has been heavily relied upon by the learned counsel for the Ansal and the Corporation.
"Clause 13 : Developer/builder shall work as the licensee of the Corporation till the completion of the development work."
30. The term for completion of the development work has been provided under Clause 9 as three years from the date of allotment which in certain circumstances could be extended to a period of five years.
31. From a simple reading of the aforesaid clause it is apparently clear that for development work and that to only for three years the Ansal has been declared to be the licensee. For the entire lease period of 90 years the terms clearly indicate that lease of the land has been granted.
32. It has been settled by the Supreme Court of India that the use of particular words like 'license' or 'lease' in a deed will not be conclusive qua the exact nature of the transaction. The following have to be taken into consideration for examining the exact nature/intent of the document;
(a) substance of the document must be preferred to the form;
(b) the real test is the intention of the parties- whether they intended to create a lease or a license;
(c) if the document creates an interest in the property, it is a lease; but if it only permits another to make use of the property, of which the legal possession continues with the owner, it is a license; and
(d) if under the document a party gets exclusive possession of the property, prima facie, he is considered to be a tenant; but circumstances may be established which negative the intention to create a lease.
33. The legal principle so enunciated by the Supreme Court in the case of Associated Hotels Of India Ltd v. R.N Kapoor; AIR 1959 SC 1262 hold the field on the subject even today.
34. Judged in the legal background as explained by the Supreme Court in Associate Hotels (supra) it is seen that lease of immovable property has been granted by the Corporation in favour of the Ansal which is the first transfer of the property and recital to the contrary in the letter of allotment and memorandum of understanding and the tripartite deed by affixation of the stamp is factually false and misleading.
35. The legal position with regard to a document being lease or not within the definition of the term under the provision section 2(16) of the indian stamp act viz-a-viz the provision of section 105 of the transfer of property act has been a subject matter of consideration in a recent judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of State of Uttarakhand and others v. Harpal Singh Rawat; JT 2011(2) SC 481. The Supreme Court, after noticing the definition of lease as contained in section 2(16) of the indian stamp act in para 8 of its judgment has laid down as follows:
"The definition of 'lease' contained in Section 2(16) consists of two parts. The first part is applicable to any lease with respect to immovable property. The second part, which is inclusive, applies to various kinds of instruments by which a title, or other rights may be conferred upon the lessee for a specified period in respect of immovable property or otherwise. The use of the words "includes also" implies that the definition of lease contained in section 2(16) (c) is very wide and even if the transaction does not amount to a lease under section 105 of the transfer of property act, the same may nonetheless be a lease for the purpose of the Act."
36. So far as the judgment relied upon by learned counsel for the respondent are concerned this Court may record that the issue for consideration in the facts of the present case is as to whether the recital in the tripartite deed to the effect that it was the first transfer so as to avail the benefit of the concessional rate of stamp duty is true or not.
37. The petitioner have not disputed applicability of section 47 A in the facts of the present case.
38. The facts of the case in hand are clearly distinguishable viz-a-viz those of Residents Welfare Association , NOIDA v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Others (supra).
39. Moreover the legal position with regard to the meaning of 'lease' under indian stamp act has been explained by the Apex Court in the case of State of Uttarakhand and others (supra). It has been laid down that the definition of lease under the indian stamp act is much wider than that under the Transfers of Properties Act.
40. Similarly this Court finds that the facts in the case of ICICI v. State of Maharashtra and others , reported in (1999) 5 SCC 708 are also clearly distinguishable. In the case in hand interest in the property has been transferred a right has been conferred for developing the plots and for drawing monetary benefit after such development by selecting the prospective allottees and offering the developed plots as well as the flats to be so constructed at the rates so desired by the Ansal.
41. The Apex Court in the case of Bhavnagar University v. Palitana Sugar Mills (Pvt.) Ltd. and Others , reported in 2003 (2) SCC 111, has held as follows:
"It is well settled that a little difference in facts or additional facts may make a lot of difference in the precedential value of a decision."
42. The said judgment has been followed in the recent judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Dr. Rajbir Singh Dalal v. Chaudhari Devi Lal University, Sirsa and Another, reported in AIR 2008 SCW 5817.
43. So far as the judgment of Somdutt Builders Ltd. v. State of U.P. And others reported in 2005(2) AWC 1711 is concerned the same is clearly distinguishable in view of the terms and conditions of the documents under consideration in the case.
44. In view of the above this Court holds that the memorandum of understanding between the Ansal and UPSIDC was the first transfer in the nature of lease of immovable property and the subsequent tripartite lease executed between the petitioners, Ansal and UPSIDC subject matter of dispute in the writ petition is the second transfer of developed plot at a much higher rate.
45. This Court therefore, has no hesitation to hold that the authorities under the indian stamp act are illegally justified in recording a finding that the tripartite deed executed between the Ansal, UPSIDC and the petitioner is not the first transfer of the land therefore Government Order dated 9.7.2008 shall have no application. Full rate of stamp duty was payable and the demand of deficiency in stamp duty cannot be faulted with. The challenge to the impugned order has to be repelled.
46. The question now arises as to whether the petitioners who have been misled by the Officers of the UPSIDC and Ansal be permitted to bear the consequences of the order impugned alone.
47. In my opinion persons like the petitioner who are bonafide purchasers and have been misled by the authorities of the UPSIDC and Ansal should not be made to suffer alone. The Officers of the UPSIDC and the Ansal must also be made to bear the consequences of the false assurance held out by them at the time of execution of the tripartite deed.
48. At this stage the Court deemed it fit and proper to afford can opportunity to the Chief Secretary, to examine the facts on record and inform the Court as to what action is proposed against the UPSIDC and Ansal.
Dictated in open Court on 16.8.2011
49. Sri Mahesh Chaturvedi, Chief Standing Counsel has filed an affidavit on behalf of the Chief Secretary of the State of U.P. today. It has been stated that an enquiry had been conducted in compliance to the order of this Court dated 28.7.2011. In the enquiry report, the Chief Secretary has opined that criminal as well as civil action is required to be initiated in the matter against all involved in the affixation of stamp on the deed as well as otherwise for misleading the allottee to believe that tripartite deed was first transfer of land and that concessional rate of stamp duty would be applicable.
50. In view of the said report of the Chief Secretary of the State, this Court is not required to pass any further orders for action being taken against the Officers of the UPSIDC and the construction company namely Ansal. This Court hopes and trust that the Chief Secretary shall act and shall not permit evasion of stamp duty to go unnoticed and persons involved in such acts, scot free.
51. In the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court finds that since purchasers of the plot have been misled by the officers of the UPSIDC and the Developers namely Ansal the demand of deficiency in the stamp duty payable on tripartite deed of transfer along with interest under the impugned orders must be equally borne by the petitioner UPSIDC and Ansal together. Petitioner must pay his 1/3 of the total demand within two months from today. The Chief Secretary is directed to ensure recovery of 1/3 the amount each from Ansal and UPSIDC within the same period.
52. Writ petition is disposed of subject to the observations made.
Alert