Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Pendyala Venkatakrishnarao v. Dr. B. Seetharam .

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Jul 20, 1989
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision petition arises from a landlord's challenge to the order of the Rent Controller, Rajahmundry, as confirmed by the appellate authority on 21-3-1983, which dismissed the landlord's eviction petition. The petitioner landlord, after a family partition, sought possession of a building at Danavaipeta, Rajahmundry, which fell to his share. The building had been let out to the respondent tenant, who operated a nursing home there. The landlord filed for eviction on the ground of bona fide requirement for residence, having issued a prior notice to vacate on 13-1-1976. The tenant resisted, contending that the landlord's requirement was not bona fide, that the landlord owned other properties, and that the building was non-residential and let out for ulterior motives. Both sides produced oral and documentary evidence. The Rent Controller and the appellate authority dismissed the eviction petition, finding the landlord's requirement not bona fide. The petitioner challenged these orders in this revision petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a building let out for a non-residential purpose (such as a nursing home) retains its character as a residential building under the relevant Rent Control Act.
  2. Whether the landlord's requirement for the building for residential use is bona fide.
  3. The legal effect of letting a residential building for a non-residential purpose on the landlord's right to recover possession for residential use.
  4. Whether estoppel can arise against the landlord in claiming residential use after letting the building for a non-residential purpose.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner (Landlord)

  • The building is a residential building by structure and nature, capable of residential use despite being let out for a nursing home.
  • The landlord requires the building bona fide for residence after partition and attaining majority, especially since he had no other residence in Rajahmundry.
  • The building has not been converted into a non-residential building by any order of the rent controller as required under section 18 of the Act.
  • There is no estoppel against the landlord in claiming residential use since letting for non-residential purposes does not amount to a representation that the building will never be claimed for residence.
  • The landlord's requirement is reasonable and bona fide, supported by evidence including his marriage shortly after filing the petition and his business interests nearby.

Respondent (Tenant)

  • The building is non-residential because it was let out for a non-residential purpose, i.e., running a nursing home.
  • The landlord owns other buildings in Rajahmundry, negating bona fide requirement.
  • The eviction petition is motivated by ulterior motives to extract higher rent.
  • The building's character as non-residential is supported by its current use and alleged structure.
  • Relied on a full bench decision of the Madras High Court suggesting that a residential building may become non-residential by force of letting terms.
  • Asserted estoppel against the landlord for claiming residential use after letting the building for non-residential purposes.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
p. Vardarajam vs. State of A.P. Determination of whether a building retains its residential character despite being let out for non-residential purpose; requirement of controller's order under section 18 for conversion. Followed to hold that the building remains residential absent an order converting it; tenant's reliance on building use alone is insufficient.
Busching Schmitz vs. Menghani (Supreme Court) Purpose of lease is not decisive of the character of accommodation; suitability for residential use governs classification. Applied to reject the tenant's argument that non-residential use changes the building's character.
Vinod Kumar vs. Surjit Kaur (Supreme Court) Conversion of residential premises into non-residential requires written consent of rent controller; use without consent does not change character. Applied to reinforce that the building remains residential in absence of controller's permission.
Kamal Arora vs. Amar Singh (Supreme Court) Even mutual consent between landlord and tenant to convert residential building into non-residential violates statutory provisions. Referenced to support the statutory prohibition against conversion without controller's permission.
Dakshinamoorty vs. Thulja Bai (Madras High Court Full Bench) Suggested that residential buildings may become non-residential by force of letting terms, but did not consider statutory conversion provisions fully. Distinguished and held not good law in light of statutory provisions and later decisions.
M/s Variety Emporium vs. V. R. M. Mohd Ibrahim Concurrent findings of fact can be interfered with if manifestly unjust; subsequent events relevant to bona fide requirement. Applied to justify interference with lower courts' findings on bona fide requirement.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by examining the definition and character of a "residential building" under the applicable Rent Control Act, noting that the Act does not explicitly define the term but refers to it in sections 10, 12, and 18. The court rejected the tenant's contention that the building's use alone (as a nursing home) converts it into a non-residential building. Instead, it emphasized that the building's structure, nature, and capability for residential use are determinative.

The court relied on prior authoritative decisions, including the division bench judgment in p. Vardarajam vs. State and the Supreme Court's ruling in Busching Schmitz vs. Menghani, which held that the purpose of lease is not conclusive and that a building constructed for residence retains that character absent statutory conversion.

Further, the court noted the statutory requirement under section 18 that no residential building can be converted into a non-residential building without the rent controller's written permission. Since no such order existed, the building remained residential despite its non-residential use.

The court also analyzed the bona fide requirement of the landlord. It found that the petitioner, having attained majority and married shortly after filing the petition, had a genuine and reasonable need to reside separately in the building allotted to him after family partition. The landlord's connection to the locality via business interests further supported bona fide requirement.

The court rejected the tenant’s estoppel argument, explaining that letting for non-residential purposes does not constitute a representation barring future residential claims. Estoppel cannot override statutory provisions that preserve the building's residential character.

Finally, the court found that the lower authorities' dismissal of the eviction petition was based on conjectures and failed to consider relevant facts and evidence, including subsequent events supporting bona fide requirement. The court held that the landlord is entitled to possession for residential use.

Holding and Implications

The civil revision petition is allowed. The orders of the Rent Controller and the appellate authority dismissing the eviction petition are set aside. The eviction petition filed by the landlord is allowed, and the tenant is directed to vacate the premises within six months from the date of the order. No costs were awarded.

The decision directly affects the parties by allowing the landlord to recover possession of the building for bona fide residential use despite its prior non-residential use. The court reaffirmed the principle that a building’s character as residential is not lost by non-residential use without statutory conversion, and that bona fide requirement must be assessed on the totality of facts including subsequent events. No new legal precedent was established beyond the application of existing statutory provisions and case law.

Show all summary ...

Armareswari:-

(1) This is a landlord's revision againsi the order of the rent controller, rajahmundry as confirmed by the order of the appellate authority dated 21 - 3 - 1983 dismissing the petition for eviction.

(2) The petitioner was living along with the members of the jointfamily in their ancestral house in dommeru village, kovvuru taluk, west godavari district. The family owns another building bearing door no. 330 (36 - 7 - 39) situate at danavaipeta, rajahmundry. The building at rajahmundry was let out to the respondent - tenant by the maternal uncle of the petitioner, acting as the guardian. The tenant was running a nursing home in the said building. There was a partition between the members of the family and the building at rajahmundry fell to the share of the petitioner.

(3) As the petitioner wanted to live separately after the partition, hefiled a petition for eviction stating that as he grew of age, he wants to live separately and that he dees not own any other building either in rajahmundry or elsewhere. The petitioner also issued a notice on 13 - 1 - 1976 asking the tenant to vacate the premises, prior to the filing of the eviction petition.

(4) The respondent - tenant resisted the petition contending inter aliathat the lequirement of the landlord for residence is not bona fide, that the petititioner owns several other buildings in rajahmundry, that the suit premises is a non - residential building and that the eviction petition is prompted by ulterior motives and is a ruse to get more rent.

(5) Both sides adduced oral and documentary evidence and on aconsideration of the same, the rent controller as well as the appellate authority found that the requirement of the landlord is not bona fide and dismissed the petition. Challenging the validity of these orders, the petitioner filed the revision petition.

(6) When the matter came up before the learned single judge, it wascontended by the tenant that the suit building is a non - residential building and as such it cannot be required for a residential purpose and that the building having been let out for a con - residential purpose must be deemed to be a non - residential building. The learned single judge referred the (b) any furniture supplied or any fittings affixed by the landlord for use in such house or hul or part of a house or hut, but does not include a room in a hotel or boarding house ;" "residential building" is not defined under the act. We find the words 'residential building' and 'non - residential building' only in section 10 of the act. While the tenant contends that the building is a non - residential building in as much as it is let out for a non - residential purpose viz. , to establish a nursing home, the landlord contends that the purpose for which the building is let out is not the criteria and other factors such as the structure and nature of the building whether it is intended or capable of being used for a residential purpose must also be taken into account. It is common knowledge that some buildings can be used both for residential and non - residential purposes. For instance, a mulgi, a shop or an office room without other amenities such as kitchen etc. , are undoubtedly non - residential buildings. On the other hand, houses with facilities such as kitchen, lavatories, bath rooms are essentially residential buildings. They are some times let out for non - residential use such as office accommodation, schools, clinics or nursing homes. There is no difficulty in regard to the first category. The problem presents only when a residential building is let out tor a non - residential purpose. Several instances where houses which are constructed for residence are let out for office purposes depending upon the exigencies of the situation. This question had come up before courts several times.

(7) In c. R. P. No. 1754 of 1984 a similar question arose namely, whether a building let out for a non - residential purpose can be required for residential use. A division bench of this court, of which one of us is a member (amareswari, j.) held that in determining the question whether the building is a residential or non - residential one, it is necessary to consider the nature and structure of the building; the purpose for which it was intended and whether the building is capable of being used and in fact used for residence. The argument that since the building was let out for a non - residenlial purpose, it is a non - residential building was rejected observing that the user of the building alone is not the deteiminate factor. The provision of a kitchen, toilets, bath - rooms, bed - rooms etc. , are the essential features of a residential building as distinct from shops or mulgies, which are undoubtedly non - residential buildings. The division bench relied upon section 18 of the act and held that the building continues to be a residential building unless it is converted as a non - residential building by an order of the rent controller and in the absence of such an order, a residential building cannot be construed as a non - residential building notwithstanding the fact that the building was let out for a non - residential purpose.

(8) We may now refer to a decision of the supreme court in busching schmitz vs. Menghani (3). This is a case which arose under the delhi rent control act the landlord sought eviction of the premises which was let out for a residential - cum - commercial purpose. The tenant resisted contending that the building was let out for a commercial purpose. The supreme court held that the purpose of lease is not decisive of character of accommodation, that use or put pose of the letting is no conclusive test and whatever is suitable or adaptable for residential uses, even by making some changes, can be designated "'residential premises".

(9) In p. Vardarajam vs. State of a. P. (1 supra) the question that arose was whether a building constructed as a residential one, but let out for a non - residential purpose can be claimed for a residential purpose. The facts of this case are 'a' constructed a building as a residential building. He let out the same to the government for locating its office. The building was sold by 'a' to 'b' who had no other building, 'b' filed a petition for eviction under sec. 10 (3) (a) (i) on the ground of bona fide requirement for his own residence. On the question whether the building had lost its character as "residential" the division bench held that the building did not lose its original character of a residential one in the absence of an order of the controller convening the residential building into a non - residential building under section 18 ot the act.

(10) In vinor kumar vs. Surjit kaur (4) the supreme court held that where the parties have not obtained the consent in writing of the rent controller for converting the residential building into a clinic the tenant cannot get over the embargo placed by section 11 by pleading that the landlord was well aware of his running a clinic in the hall and that she has not raised objection at any time to the running of the clinic. Section 11 of the east punjab urban rent restriction act requires the written consent of the rent controller for conversion of residential premises into non - residentiat premises. This provision corresponds to section 18 of the andhra pradesh rent act. In construing the said provision, the supreme court held that in the absence of the order of the controller, a residential premises cannot be converted into a non - residential premises and even if it is put to non - residential use to the knowledge of the landlord the building does not lose its character and it continues to be a residential building.

(11) In kamal arora vs. Amar singh (5) the supreme court declined to interfere with an order of eviction passed in favour of the landlord as the court was of the view that even if the landlord and the tenant had converted a residential building into a non - residential one by mutual consent, it would still be violative of section 11 of the east punjab rent restriction act and, therefore, the landlord cannot be barred from seeking recovery of possession of the leased building for his residential needs.

(12) The learned counsel for the tenant, however, relied on a full bench decision of the madras high court in dakshinamoorty vs. Thulja bai (2 supra). The full bench in a general way held that : "what is at the inception a residential building may well become a non - residential one by force of the terms of a letting, and that any conversion, after the letting of a residential building into a non - residential one may well take place within and only within the limits which the statute prescribes. That if prior to a letting, a building happens to have been of one character it must for ever keep that character irrespective of what the effect of the letting or of the acts of parties subsequent to the letting may be, seems to our minds to be a difficult, if not impossible position having regard to the considerations above set forth. " though rajamannar, c. J. , speaking for the division bench in his order of reference observed : "reliance was placed on section 11 (1) of the act, but we were inclined to hold that what was contemplated by that section was structural alteration which converted a residential building in to a non - residential building". Yet, in the actual full bench opinion, there was no consideration of this aspect at all. Justice raghava rao, who rendered the opinion of the full bench merely noticed section 11 (1) of the madras act which corresponds to section 18 of the a. p. act, but no opinion was expressed nor any consideration of the scope of that section is seen from the judgment. Thus the full bench of the madras high court had not considered the effect of section 11 corresponding to section 18 of the present act and the observations of the full bench have been correctly explained by the division bench of this court in p. Vardarajam vs. State (1 supra). That apart, in view of the judgment of the supreme court in bunching schmitz vs. Menghani (3 supra) the view expressed by the full bench of the madras high court is no longer good law.

(13) In the instant case, no doubt the building was let out for a non - residential purpose. The evidence shows that it is being used as a 20 bedded nursing home. The building is situate in danavaipet, in rajamandry, which is essentially a residential area.

(14) A feeble attempt is made by the learned counsel for the tenant, that the building even by its structure is a non - residential building. We are unable to accept this having regard to the pleadings of the parties. When the landlord sought for possession on the ground that he requires it for his residence, the tenant never raised a plea that the building is structurally not suitable for residence. His contention as noticed from the counter is that the bulding is a non - residential one as it was let out for a non - residential purpose. If really the building cannot be used for residence purposes or that it was constructed as shops or mulgies and incapable of being used tor residence, the simple answer of the tenant would have been that the building can never be used as a residence. The bone of contention between the parties is that the building should be construed as a non - residential building as it was let out for a non - residential purpose and was used as a nursing home for long. We have carefully gone through the pleadings and nowhere it is the case of the tenant that the building is located not in a residential area, but in a commercial area and that structurally it is designed for a non - residential purpose or that it has never been used for residence. We have, therefore, to start on the premise that the building is constructed for residential purpose, ft is capable of being used as a residence. Not only those buildings which are let out for residential purposes, but also all other structures which are capable of being used as residential houses must be considered as residential buildings. If a bungalow is let out to locate an office or to run a show room by the landlord, who had necessarily to move to another place on account of his service conditions or otherwise, can it be said that he cannot recover it for a residential purpose when he wants to reside in his own house after his retirement or when he is posted at the same place where the bungalow is situate. In our opinion, the building continues to be a residential building and the landlord can recover possession. Otherwise, a premises may be residential for some time and non - residential for another time. Use or purpose for which the building is let out is not the conclusive test. Similarly, if a person sleeps on the verandah of a shop, it cannot make the shop a residential building. The advancement in designing and engineering skills may make multi - purpose buildings to serve as residential, commercial or for other uses. The character of a house can be both and not "either or". A rich home can be a good business house. Some small scale industries are run in living quarters. Whatever premises are suitable for residential use can therefore be designated as residential buildings. This is a common sense test which we apply and the modern engineering supports this construction. A shop in abid road or any structure which is patently a non - residential or a tea shop are obvious instances of non - residential buildings. The house with which we are dealing is situate in danavaipet, rajahmundry which is essentially a residential area nothing stated in the counter puts the building out of the pale of residential premises. This construction of ours is more effective by reference to section 18 of the act. Section 18 says that no residential building can be converted into a non - residential building except with the permission of the controller in writing. Admittedly there is no order passed by the controller much less in writing permitting the conversion. It is significant to note that there is no corresponding requirement for conversion of non - residential buildings into residential buildings. The reason is obvious. Residential building should be sllowed to retain its nature and character. Otherwise, there could have been a converse requirement for conversion of non - residential buildings into residential buildings and the emphasis that, the permission should be in writing strengthens this understanding of the intendment of the legislature. The intention appears to be to avoid conversion of residential buildings into non - residential buildings unless the circumstances require it and the controller gives his permission in writing. This intention is also evident from section 12 which deals with recovery ot possession by landlord for repairs, alterations or additions or for reconstruction. subsection (4) of section 12 reads : "nothing in this section shall entitle the landlord, who has recovered possession of the building for repairs, alterations or additions or for reconstruction to convert a residential building into a non - residential building or a non - residential building into a residential building unless such conversion is permitted by the controller at the time of passing an order under sub - section (1) ". So it is also in the case of directing possession for repairs, the controller is empowered to convert a residential building into a non - residential one and non - residential into a residential building. Since it is reconstruction, the legislature thought it fit to confer power on the controller to permit such conversion if he is satisfied about it. At the same time, section 12 (4) emphasises the need for a permission from the controller to convert a residential building into a non - residential building. Thus, section 12 also supports our conclusion based on section 18 of the act.

(15) It is submitted by the learned counsel for the tenant that in any event, the petitioner is estopped from claiming the building for residential use, having let it out for a non - residential purpose. He sought to derive support for this contention from the following observations of the division bench in p. Vardarajam vs. State (1 supra). "that estoppel, if any, survives during his ownership or during his lifetime whichever is earlier. Now that the building has been sold to the present landlord in september, 1968, the estoppel which may be said as barring the then owner from recovering the possession of the building for his residential purposes, does not bar the present owner who is only his successor in title. " tbe words, the estoppel 'if any' is clearly indicative of the fact that the division bench has not laid down any such principle of law. Having held that the building continues to be a residential building, a passing observation is made that it dots not bind the successor. The division bench referred to the full bench decision in dukshina moorty vs. Thulja bai (2 supra) which itself had not put the case on estoppel. All that the full bench said was that "it would be unfair to permit the landlord to recover possession for residential purpose of a building let out by him for non - residential purpose. For "estoppel" to apply, there must be a representation or action on the part of one person which made the other person believe to act on that representation and the person making the representation cannot go back on the same causing detriment to the person who acted on the basis of the representation. When a building is let out for a non - residential purpose, the said act does not amount to a representation that it would never be claimed for a residential use. No question of estoppel arises then. If in law the building continues to be a residential building, notwithstanding the fact of its being let out for a non - residential purpose, it can be claimed for residential use subject to fulfilment of other conditions mentioned therein. There can be no estoppel against law.

(16) Further, in this case, the building was let out by p. W. 1 in 1959 on behalf of the petitioner who was a minor then and the same cannot opeiate as estoppel against the petitioner after he attains majority.

(17) Having regard to the ratio of the decisions aforementioned and the provisions of the act, we have no doubt in holding that the building in question is a residential building even though it was let out for a non - residential purpose viz. , for a nursing home and the landlord is entitled to seek possession subject to fulfilment of the other conditions

(18) The next question for consideration is whether the requirement of the petitioner landlord is bona fide the suit building was leased out by p. W. 1 in 1959 when the petitioner was a minor. The petitioner was living with his brother p. W. 3 at dommeru village, kovvur taluk, west godavan district. In the partition between the brothers, the suit building at rajahmundry fell to the share of the petitioner while the building at dommeru fell to the share of the other members of the family. The eviction petition was filed in 1976 and the petitioner was 23 years old as seen from the description in the petition. He stated in the petition that he requires the building for his residence. Though the petitioner was not married by the date of the petition 31 - 5 - 76, the evidence shows that he got married in july, 1976 i e. , two months after the petition. The evidence also establishes that he has no other house in rajahmundry. There is absolutely no reason why his requirement cannot be considered to be bona fide. Merely because he had been living in the family house at dommeru along with his brother and his family, he cannot be asked to live in the same house which fell to the share of his brother when he wants to live in his own house. He has become of marriageable age and in fact, he got married 2 months after the filing of the petition. Rajahmundry is just on the other side of the bridge of kovvur, where the petitioner has a pharmaceutical industry. At present, he is attending to the business at kovvur, living at dommeru village. The petitioner belongs to a rich family and it is not unreasonable to expect of him to live in his own house in the town instead of living with his brother who has a family of his own especially after the petitioner had attained majority and was intending to marry. Both the rent controller as well as the appellate authority merely proceeded on the ground that the petitioner was not married by the date of the petition i. E. , 31 - 5 - 1976. But the evidence of p. W. 1 the maternal uncle of the petitioner shows that the petitioner was married in july, 1976, two months later. All the witnesses say that the petitioner wanted to reside at rajahmundry to manage his industries at kovvur. He is one of the directors of the andhra pharmacy chemicals corporation, kovvur. P. W. 1 is a very respectable man and he spoke to the faot that the petitioner genuinely intends to live in rajahmundry which is very near to kovvur. There are absolutely no grounds to reject his testimony. The requirement is also reasonable. Unless it: is established that the petition is motivated or intended to harass the tenant to extract more rent or to let out. The building to some other person, the requirement cannot be said to be not bona fide.

(19) Bonafide requirement is purely a question of fact, which has to be decided on the facts of each case. The petitioner does not have any other building in rajabmundry and he is residing in the family house at dommeru which fell to the share of his brother in the partition. He is a business - man having an industry at kovvur which is very near to rajahmundry. The evidence shows that he got married just two months after the filing of the petition and this fact lends support to the conclusion that his requirement is bonafide. The finding of the rent controller and the appellate authority that no reasons are given why the petitioner requires a big building for his residential occupation at rajahmundry is perverse. Rajahmundry is as near to kovvur as dommeru. It is equally convenient for him to attend to his business at kovvur by residing at rajahmundry. P. Ws. 1 to 3 say that the petitioner requires the premises for his residence so that he can conveniently pursue his business avocation at kovvur. The finding of the lower court that he can attend to his business bv residing at dommeru and that it is not difficult for him to do so by living at dommeru is wholly unreasonable. He cannot be expected to live with his brother, who has a family of his own in these circumstances, to say that the requirement is neither reasonable nor bona fide is unsustainable and to say the least is perverse.

(20) In vinor kumar vs. Surjit kaur (4 supra) it was held that the high court has the power to interfere in revision even with concurrent findings of fact when such findings suffer from inherent defects and are based on irrelevant material and baseless assumptions.

(21) In m/s. Variety emporium vs. V. R. M. Mohd ibrahim it was held that when concurrent findings are shown to be manifestly unjust or based on irrelevant assumptions, they can be set aside and the injustice cannot be perpetuated because it has been done 2 or 3 times in a case. It is further held that in a suit for eviction on the ground of bona fide requirement of the premises by the landlord, the subsequent events are to be taken into account for the purpose of finding out whether the landlord requires the premises in possession of the tenant, and in appropriate cases, the court must have regard to events as they present themselves at the time when it is hearing the proceeding before it.

(22) Both the courts have ignored the material facts. The finding regarding the bona fide requirement is based on conjectures and surmises without taking ihe relevant circumstances into account. Having regard to the evidence on record, we find that the requirement of the landlord is bona fide and he is entitled to recover possession of the building in question for his residential use.

(23) It is also worthy of notice in this context that the tenant owns a building in rajahmundry and realising rents from the same.

(24) For the reasons given above, the civil revision petition is allowed. The orders of the rent controller and the appellate authority are set aside and the eviction petition is allowed. The tenant to vacate the premises within 6 months from today. No costs.