- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Subhash Chandra v. State of Uttar Pradesh
Factual and Procedural Background
The litigation stems from two incidents between the petitioner and respondents 3–6 in March 1998. On 10 March 1998 the respondents allegedly removed 350 bags of potatoes worth over one lakh rupees from the petitioner's field and physically assaulted him when he attempted to report the matter. A second incident occurred on 29 March 1998 when the respondents allegedly assaulted the petitioner again, took ₹500 from him, and abused him in the presence of two witnesses.
The petitioner initially lodged a complaint regarding the 29 March incident before the Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM), Farrukhabad, on 2 April 1998. Believing that the Special Judge (D.A.A.) had jurisdiction, he later filed an application under section 156(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) on 24 June 1998 before that court. Acting on this application, the Special Judge directed registration of an FIR on 6 July 1998 under sections 394, 504 and 506 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) against respondents 3–6.
The respondents challenged the Special Judge’s order by a petition under section 482 CrPC before the Allahabad High Court, which on 23 July 1998 stayed the 6 July order temporarily and allowed the respondents to file objections before the Special Judge. On 17 November 1998 the Special Judge recalled the 6 July order and issued a notice to the petitioner for concealing the earlier CJM complaint. On 14–15 January 1999 he initiated proceedings against the petitioner for an alleged offence under section 182 IPC (giving false information).
The petitioner approached the High Court through Criminal Misc. Writ Petition No. 2123/99. By order dated 21 April 1999 the High Court confirmed initiation of proceedings and directed the Special Judge to file a complaint under section 340 CrPC read with section 195 CrPC against the petitioner. The present opinion reviews the legality of those directions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Special Judge (D.A.A.) and the High Court were justified, at the preliminary stage, in initiating proceedings under section 340 CrPC read with section 195 CrPC for an alleged offence under section 182 IPC solely because the petitioner did not mention an earlier complaint filed before the CJM.
- Whether non-disclosure of the earlier complaint, without proof of the remaining statutory ingredients of section 182 IPC, is sufficient to prosecute the petitioner.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- The High Court lacked authority to order lodging of a complaint under sections 340/195 CrPC while the complaint under section 156(3) CrPC was still pending before the Special Judge and the CJM complaint had not been finally disposed.
- The initiation of proceedings under section 182 IPC was premature because the truthfulness of the allegations in the section 156(3) application had not yet been adjudicated.
Respondents’ Arguments
- The petitioner admittedly failed to disclose the earlier CJM complaint in the later section 156(3) application, thereby concealing a material fact from the Special Judge.
- Such concealment constitutes sufficient grounds to prosecute the petitioner under section 182 IPC; therefore, the High Court’s directions were proper.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court observed that both the Special Judge and the High Court “acted hastily.” Mere non-mention of a prior complaint is, by itself, insufficient to establish an offence under section 182 IPC. That provision requires proof of several statutory ingredients, including that the information furnished was false and given with the intention or knowledge required to cause a public authority to act to the detriment of another.
The Court stressed that the petitioner had only invoked section 156(3) CrPC, and the veracity of his allegations had not yet been investigated. Until the Special Judge examines the complaint and determines whether it is false and made with the requisite mens rea, prosecution under section 182 IPC is premature. The directions issued under sections 340/195 CrPC therefore lacked a factual and legal foundation.
Holding and Implications
Orders dated 15 January 1999 of the Special Judge (D.A.A.), Farrukhabad, and 21 April 1999 of the High Court are SET ASIDE.
The Special Judge must first adjudicate the petitioner’s application under section 156(3) CrPC. Only if that complaint is found to be false and lodged with the intent or knowledge specified in section 182 IPC may proceedings under sections 340/195 CrPC be initiated. The decision affects only the parties by restoring the matter to the Special Judge for proper inquiry; no broader precedent is expressly created.
(1) The dispute between petitioner and respondent Nos. 3 to 6 dates back to 10th of March 1998, when respondents 3-6 are alleged to have forcibly taken away 350 bags of potatoes valued at more than Rupees one lakh, from the fields of the petitioner by loading the consignment in their tractor-trolley. In order to prevent the petitioner from lodging the First Information Report with the Police, respondents 3-6 took the petitioner to their residence and allegedly assaulted him. On the next day, namely, on 1 1/03/1998, the petitioner informed the Sr. Superintendent of Police, Farrukhabad, about the above incident through a fax message.
(2) In another incident, which is the incident involved in this case, respondent 3-6 assaulted the petitioner on 29/03/1998 at 11 A.M., Rs.500/-which the petitioner had with him at that time was taken-away by respondents 3-6 and they also badly abused the petitioner. The incident was allegedly witnessed by Ram Niwas and SiyaRam. Petitioner immediately went to the Police Station to lodge the report but no action was taken Consequently, the petitioner filed a complaint in the court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Farrukhabad, against respondents 3-6 on 2/04/1998 in respect of the incident of 29/03/1998. While the application was pending in the court, the petitioner was advised that in respect of the incident in question the court competent to take action was the court of Special Sessions Judge, (DAA), Farrukhabad, and not the court of Chief Judicial Magistrate. Consequently, on 24/06/1998, petitioner moved an application under section 156 (3) of the criminal procedure code in the court of Special Sessions Judge (DAA), Farrukhabad. On the direction of the Special Sessions Judge (DAA), Farrukhabad, on 6/7/1998, a case was registered under section 394/504/506 indian penal code at Police Station, Farrukhabad, against respondents 3-6 as crime case No. 541/98. The order dated 6/7/1998, by which the learned Special Sessions Judge (DAA), Farrukhabad, had directed Police Station House Officer to register a case against respondents 3-6, was challenged by the latter in the Allahabad High Court through a petition (Criminal Miscellaneous Application No. 2527 of 1998) under section 482 criminal procedure code. On this petition, the High court passed the following order dated 23/7/1998:
"Heard the applicants' counsel that in respect of the same incident a criminal complaint has already been filed against the applicants and the same is pending. During the pendency of the same complaint, complainant Subhash Chandra also filed application U/S 156(3) Criminal Procedure Code. before another court, i.e. the court of Special Judge (D.A.A), Farrukhabad, by concealing the fact that he has already moved an application before the court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Farrukhabad for necessary action by filing an application under Sec. 156(3) Criminal Procedure Code. and the C.J.M. refused to order investigation. It is further contended that the local police is inimical to the applicants. The applicants have filed writ petition against the police authorities as well as contempt petition. In short, the argument of the learned counsel is that the complainant by concealing material facts before the Special Judge (DAA), Farrukhabad has succeeded in procuring a favourable order on 6/7/1998. on his application moved under Sec. 156(3) Criminal Procedure Code. In the circumstances, this petition is disposed of finally with the observation that the applicants, if so advised, may move before the Special Judge (DAA) Farrukhabad inviting his attention to the aforestated objection and if such an objection is filed, the same shall be decided by Special Judge (DAA) Farrukhabad in accordance with law after getting opportunity of hearing to both the sides. The operation of the order dated 6/7/1998 passed by Special Judge (DAA) Farrukhabad shall remain stayed for a period of 10 days in order to enable the applicants to file suitable objection and if such objections are filed, the order shall remain stayed until the objection is disposed of. A certified copy of this order be given to the learned counsel for the petitioners on payment of usual charges within 48 hours."
(3) When the matter was taken up by the Special Sessions Judge, Farrukhabad, on 17/11/1998, he recalled his earlier order dated 6/7/1998 and issued a notice requiring the petitioner to show cause why action be not taken against him for concealing the fact that he had earlier filed a complaint in the court of Chief Judicial Magistrate which was not mentioned by him in his complaint under section 156(3) criminal procedure code. Petitioner filed his objections to the show cause notice, but the Special Sessions Judge (DAA), Farrukhabad, by order dated 14/ 15/01/1999, initiated proceedings against the petitioner for an offence under section 182 of the indian penal code, allegedly on the ground that the petitioner had concealed the material facts from the court and had not mentioned that he had earlier filed an application in respect of the same incident before the Chief Judicial Magistrate Farrukhabad. This order was challenged by the petitioner before the High court in Criminal Misc, Writ Petition No. 2123/99 which has been disposed of by the impugned judgment dated 21/4/1999. The High court disposed of the writ petition with the following operative order:
"This writ petition is disposed of with the direction that a complaint shall be drafted and lodged against the petitioner in accordance with section 340 criminal procedure code and other formalities of law under section 340 criminal procedure code. read with section 195cr.p.c. shall be complied with. Orders passed on merits u/s 340 Criminal Procedure Code. is confirmed. With these directions, the writ petition is disposed of. Petitioner shall appear before the special Judge (D.A.A). Farrukhabad on 10/05/1999."
(4) Learned counsel for the petitioner has contended that the High court could not have directed the Special Sessions Judge, Farrukhabad, to lodge a complaint under section 340 criminal procedure code. read with section 195 criminal procedure code. at that stage as the complaint was stilt pending before the Chief Judicial Magistrate while the complaint filed by the petitioner in the court of special Session Judge (DAA), Farrukhabad, under section 156(3) cr.p.c had also not been disposed of finally on merits.
(5) Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents, on the other hand, has contended that there was no dispute with regard to the fact that the fact that the petitioner had earlier filed a complaint in the court of Chief Judicial Magistrate was not mentioned in the complaint filed under section 156(3) criminal procedure code in court of Special Sessions Judge (DAA), Farrukhabad, and that this vital fact had been concealed from that court. That being so, it is contended by learned counsel for the respondents, that the petitioner could be legally proceeded against in terms of the directions issued by the High Court. It is contended that in these circumstances the learned Special Sessions Judge (DAA), Farrukhabad, would be fully justified in lodging the complaint under section 340 criminal procedure code. read with section 195 criminal procedure code.
(6) After having heard learned counsel for the parties, we are of the view that the Special Sessions Judge (DAA), Farrukhabad, as also the High court have acted hastily in the matter. Mere non-mention of the complaint already filed in the court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, in the petition filed under section 156(3) cr.p.c. before the Special Sessions Judge (DAA). Farrukhabad, would not be enough.
(7) There are many ingredients set out in section 182 indian penal code. Unless all the ingredients are established by evidence, the offence cannot be treated to have been committed. In order to ascertain whether the petitioner had committed any offence under section 182 Indian Penal Code, it is necessary to find out whether all the ingredients constituting an offence under that Section have been proved or not. The petitioner had only filed a complaint under section 156(3) criminal procedure code., before the court of Special Sessions Judge (DAA), Farrukhabad. It is still to be investigated and found out by that court whether the complaint lodged before that court was false and had been made with the necessary intention or knowledge to induce the court to exercise its lawful power so as to cause injury to respondents 3-6. Once those ingredients are established and the charge is found to have been proved, then alone the court can take cognizance of that offence and proceed in the manner directed by the High court by the impugned judgment. But the stage at which such directions have been issued is, in our opinion, premature.
(8) Consequently, this petition is disposed of and the order dated 15/1/1999 passed by Special Sessions Judge (DAA) Farrukhabad, as also order dated 21/4/1999 passed by the High court are set aside, with the observation that the Special Sessions Judge (DAA), Farrukhabad, shall proceed to dispose of the complaint under section 156(3) cr.p.c. in accordance with law and if it is found that the complaint was false and has been filed with the knowledge and intention set out in section 182 Indian Penal Code, the court wilt proceed further in the manner by the High court.
_______________________
Alert