- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ram Raj Singh And Others v. State Of M.P .
Factual and Procedural Background
On March 13, 1977 at about 6:00 p.m., an altercation led to PW 1 Netraprakash Sharma and his father PW 4 Goverdhan Lal Sharma sustaining simple injuries. The prosecution alleged that appellant Ram Raj Singh attacked with a dharia, appellants Sarat Singh, Tej Bahadur and Mulchand wielded lathis, and appellant Diwan Singh threatened witnesses with a pistol while the assailants withdrew. The prosecution relied chiefly on the testimony of the two injured witnesses (PW 1 and PW 4) and three additional eyewitnesses (PW 5, PW 6 and PW 10).
The trial court convicted Ram Raj Singh and Diwan Singh under Section 148 IPC and the remaining appellants under Section 147 IPC, with further convictions under Sections 455 and 324 IPC (or those sections read with Section 149 IPC). Sentences ranged from nine months to eighteen months in prison and included monetary fines.
The High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Jabalpur affirmed the convictions and sentences. The appellants then obtained special-leave to appeal. By the time the Supreme Court heard the matter, appellants Ram Raj Singh and Diwan Singh had completed their sentences and paid their fines, while appellants Sarat Singh, Tej Bahadur and Mulchand had served two months’ imprisonment and also remitted their fines.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether any interference with the concurrent findings of guilt recorded by the Sessions Court and the High Court was warranted.
- Whether, considering that appellant Ram Raj Singh alone initiated the incident and only simple injuries were caused, the sentences imposed on appellants Sarat Singh, Tej Bahadur and Mulchand should be reduced to the period already undergone.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court agreed with the lower courts that the prosecution proved the culpable acts of all appellants and therefore found no basis to disturb the convictions.
- It noted that the initiative for the occurrence came solely from appellant Ram Raj Singh.
- All injuries suffered by the victims were simple in nature.
- Appellants Sarat Singh, Tej Bahadur and Mulchand had already served two months in custody and paid their fines.
Balancing these factors, the Court concluded that justice would be served by deeming the sentences of Sarat Singh, Tej Bahadur and Mulchand satisfied by the period of imprisonment already undergone, leaving the fines intact.
The Court further observed that appellant Tej Bahadur was employed as a manager in a co-operative society, had played only a minor role, and therefore his conviction should not prejudice his continued employment.
Holding and Implications
APPEALS DISMISSED WITH MODIFICATION OF SENTENCE
The convictions of all appellants were affirmed. The substantive sentences of appellants Sarat Singh, Tej Bahadur and Mulchand were reduced to the period already served; their fines remain payable. Appellants Ram Raj Singh and Diwan Singh had already served their full sentences and paid their fines, rendering their appeals academic. The Court clarified that the conviction of Tej Bahadur shall not affect his employment. No wider legal precedent was set.
Order
1. Both these appeals arise out of a common judgment rendered by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Jabalpur in Criminal Appeal Nos. 411 and 478 of 1978. It is beyond dispute that an occurrence which took place at about 6.00 p.m on March 13, 1977 resulted in PW 1, Netraprakash Sharma and his father, PW 4 Goverdhan Lal Sharma sustaining injuries on their person. According to the prosecution, the appellant Ram Raj Singh used a dharia and the appellants Sarat Singh, Tej Bahadur and Mulchand used lathis to cause injuries to the victims and the appellant Diwan Singh threatened the witnesses with a pistol when the assailants withdrew from the scene after the incident was over. The prosecution rested its case upon the testimony of the injured witnesses PW 1, Netraprakash Sharma and PW 4, Goverdhan Lal Sharma, besides that of PW 6 Pawan Kumar, PW 5 Deoraj and PW 10 Baldeo Singh. As a result of the attack, PW 1 Netraprakash Sharma sustained a simple injury and PW 4, Goverdhanlal Sharma sustained four simple injuries. The trial court accepted the prosecution evidence and convicted the appellants Ram Raj Singh and Diwan Singh under Section 148 IPC and the other appellants under Section 147 IPC. Besides, the appellant Ram Raj Singh was convicted under Sections 455 and 324 IPC while the other appellants were convicted under Sections 455 and 324 read with Section 149 IPC. While the appellant Ram Raj Singh was awarded a sentence of one year RI under two counts and eighteen months RI under one count besides a fine of Rs 200, Rs 200 and Rs 100 for his convictions, the other accused were sentenced to imprisonment for nine months under two counts and one year under one count besides fine of Rs 100 on each count for their convictions. The High Court declined to interfere with the convictions and sentences and hence these appeals by special leave.
2. The appeals of Ram Raj Singh and Diwan Singh have now become academic because they have served out their sentences and also remitted the fines imposed on them. Insofar as the other three appellants are concerned, they have undergone sentence for two months and they have remitted the fine amounts imposed on them.
3. Having heard learned counsel for the appellants and the learned counsel for the State, we do not see any ground to differ from the view taken by the Sessions Judge and the High Court as regards the occurrence and culpable acts of the accused resulting in injuries being caused to PW 1, Netraprakash Sharma and PW 4, Goverdhan Lal Sharma. However, we are of the view that since the initiative for the occurrence was taken solely by the appellant Ram Raj Singh and that the injured witnesses had sustained only simple injuries, the ends of justice would be met by modifying the sentences awarded to the appellants Surat Singh, Tej Bhadur and Mulchand to the period of imprisonment already undergone by them besides the sentence of fine imposed upon them under the three counts.
4. It is represented that appellant Tej Bahadur is employed as a Manager in a Cooperative Society. Because of the minor role played by him in the occurrence, we do not think the conviction awarded to him should stand in the way of his continuing in service. We, therefore, make it clear that his conviction in this case should not affect his continuance in employment in any manner.
5. With the modification in the substantive sentence awarded to the appellants Surjit Singh, Tej Bahadur and Mulchand and the observations made regarding the continuance in service of the appellant Tej Bahadur, the appeals will stand dismissed.
Alert