- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Tipparam Prabhakar v. State Of Andhra Pradesh .
Factual and Procedural Background
On 20 March 2003, one Damera Shiva Kumar (“the deceased”) was found dead with multiple injuries near Anand Bagh crossroads, Andhra Pradesh. His mother (PW 1) lodged an FIR, leading to registration of Crime No. 90/2003 under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). Three individuals—Suresh Kumar Yadav (A-1), the present appellant (A-2), and Telukrishna (A-3)—were arrested and charged under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC.
The case rested on circumstantial evidence, principally that the accused were allegedly “last seen” with the deceased and that an identity card belonging to A-2 was found near the body. After trial, the Sessions Court acquitted A-3 but convicted A-1 and A-2. On appeal, the Andhra Pradesh High Court acquitted A-1 yet upheld A-2’s conviction. A-2 appealed to the Supreme Court, which rendered the present judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the circumstantial evidence—primarily the “last-seen” circumstance and discovery of A-2’s identity card near the body—was sufficient to sustain A-2’s conviction for murder under Section 302 IPC.
- Whether inconsistencies in the testimony of key prosecution witnesses (PW 1 and PW 2) undermined the prosecution’s case against A-2.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant’s Arguments
- The testimonies of PW 1 (mother) and PW 2 (sister-in-law) regarding the “last-seen” circumstance were materially inconsistent, rendering that circumstance unreliable.
- Only A-1’s fingerprints were recovered; none belonging to A-2 were found on the seized articles.
- The mere presence of A-2’s identity card near the body could not, by itself, establish guilt.
- Given the weak and contradictory evidence, conviction could not be sustained.
Respondent State’s Arguments
- Supported the High Court’s view that the chain of circumstantial evidence—including the “last-seen” circumstance and recovery of A-2’s identity card—proved A-2’s guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court observed that the prosecution case was entirely circumstantial and hinged on the “last-seen” theory. The Court reiterated that this theory is reliable only when the time gap between the accused being last seen with the deceased and the discovery of the body is so small that no other possibility exists. Here, the Court found:
- Inconsistency of Witnesses: PW 1 and PW 2 gave divergent accounts of when and how A-2 and A-3 allegedly took the deceased away, casting doubt on the “last-seen” circumstance.
- Fingerprint Evidence: Investigators recovered fingerprints only of A-1—who was later acquitted by the High Court—not of A-2, weakening the nexus between A-2 and the crime scene.
- Identity Card: The discovery of A-2’s identity card near the body, without corroborative evidence, was deemed insufficient for conviction.
- Gap in Time: Given the timeline discrepancies and lack of direct evidence, the possibility of another person committing the crime could not be excluded.
Applying these findings, the Court concluded that the circumstantial chain was incomplete and the prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The conviction of A-2 under Section 302 IPC is set aside, and the appellant is ordered to be released forthwith unless required in another case.
Implications: The decision underscores that, in cases resting solely on circumstantial evidence, courts must insist on an unbroken chain of circumstances. Mere recovery of personal articles or presence of an identity card, absent corroborating evidence and consistent “last-seen” testimony, is inadequate for conviction. While the judgment sets no new precedent, it reaffirms strict judicial scrutiny of the “last-seen” doctrine.
Dr. Arijit Pasayat, J.— Leave granted. The challenge in this appeal is to the judgment of a Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court upholding the conviction of the appellant for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”).
2. Three persons faced trial for alleged commission of death of one Damera Shiva Kumar (hereinafter referred to as “the deceased”) on 20-3-2003. The trial court directed acquittal of Telukrishna (A-3). The High Court by the impugned order dismissed the appeal filed by the present appellant A-2 while directing acquittal of A-1.
3. The prosecution version as unfolded during trial is as follows: A-1 is the maternal uncle's son of Damera Shiva Kumar (hereinafter referred to as “the deceased”). A-2 and A-3 are the friends of A-1. On 20-3-2003 at about 5.00 p.m, the mother of the deceased Smt Damera Lingamma (PW 1) and her daughter went to her younger sister's house at Malkajgiri to attend a betrothal ceremony. While leaving the house she gave Rs 10 to the deceased Shiva Kumar. The sister-in-law of the deceased Smt Lalitha (PW 2) and the deceased were alone in the house.
4. At about 7.00 p.m, A-2 and A-3 came to the house of the deceased. A-3 was standing outside the house. A-2 came inside the house. A-2 and A-3 took the deceased Shiva Kumar on his motorcycle. PW 1 and her daughter returned home at about 10.00 p.m, and enquired from PW 2 about the deceased Shiva Kumar. PW 2 informed PW 1 that A-2 and A-3 took the deceased Shiva Kumar on his motorcycle.
5. At about 10.30 p.m, A-2 and A-3 again came to the house of the deceased, along with the deceased. On hearing the sound of the motorcycle of the deceased, PW 2 came out of the house and asked the deceased to come inside the house, as PW 1 was calling him. Thereupon A-2 stated to PW 2 that he will send back the deceased within ten minutes.
6. At about 11.00 p.m, one Mallesh, Councillor of Malkajgiri came to the house of the deceased and informed PW 1 that one motorcycle with the inscription of Yadav was lying near Anand Bagh crossroads and that one dead body was also lying near the spot.
7. Thereupon, PW 1 and others went to the scene of offence. PW 1 found her son lying dead in a pool of blood with bleeding injuries at Anand Bagh crossroads. PW 1 gave Ext. P-1 complaint to PW 11, the Sub-Inspector of Police of Malkajgiri Police Station. PW 11 registered Ext. P-1 as Crime No. 90 of 2003 under Section 302 IPC and submitted a copy of the FIR to all concerned. After registration of the case, PW 15 took up investigation from PW 11.
8. PW 15 rushed to the scene of offence, got the scene of offence photographed, prepared rough sketch under Ext. P-5 for the scene of offence, conducted scene observation panchnama on 21-3-2003 at about 01:50 hours under Ext. P-4 in the presence of PW 7 and Panduri Ravi. He found MO 4 knife in the stomach of the deceased and MO 5 lying beside the deceased. He also found MOs 1 to 3 and 6 to 11 at the scene of offence. He seized MOs 1 to 13 under Ext. P-4 in the presence of PW 7 and Panduri Ravi. He held inquest over the dead body of the deceased in Gandhi Hospital mortuary on 21-3-2003 from 10.00 a.m to 12.30 noon. After the inquest, the dead body was sent for post-mortem examination.
9. On the requisition given by PW 11 under Ext. P-9, the fingerprints expert Shri Md. Khursheed (PW 13) visited Malkajgiri Police Station and examined the material objects seized by PW 15 in this case for developing the chance prints. He found one fingerprint on MO 6 and he lifted the chance print and got photographed the chance print. He compared the fingerprint sent by the police with the chance print marked as “A”, and found it as identical with the left fingerprints marked as “S-1”, which belongs to Suresh Kumar Yadav (A-1). The fingerprints expert gave his opinion under Ext. P-11.
10. On 22-3-2003 at 9.00 a.m A-1 to A-3 were arrested by ID party and were produced before PW 15, who interrogated A-1 to A-3 separately and individually in the presence of PWs 9 and 10. A-1 to A-3 confessed the offence leading to recovery. The admissible portions of the confessional statements of A-1 to A-3 are marked as Exts. P-23 to P-25 respectively.
11. In pursuance of his confession, A-1 led the police and panchayatdars to the house of A-2, went inside the house of A-2 and produced MO 14. He also produced his bloodstained clothes MOs 15 and 16. MOs 17 and 18 were seized at the instance of A-2 from his house. MOs 19 and 20 were seized at the instance of A-3 from the house of A-2.
12. PW 12, the doctor who conducted autopsy over the dead body of the deceased opined that Injuries 4 to 6, 11 and 12 are fatal injuries and they are sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature either cumulatively or individually. After the receipt of the post-mortem certificate and FSL report, charge-sheet was filed and the accused persons faced trial for commission of the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC. As the accused persons pleaded innocence trial was held.
13. To substantiate the accusations, 15 witnesses were examined. The case rested on circumstantial evidence. It was the prosecution version that the accused and the deceased were last seen together and the dead body of the deceased was identified. MO 1 was found at the scene of occurrence. The trial court as noted above, found the evidence to be inadequate and acquitted A-3, but convicted A-1 and A-2. The appeal was filed by A-1 and A-2. The conviction was confirmed so far as the appellant is concerned.
14. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the prosecution version is clearly unsupportable. PWs 1, 2 and 6 are stated to have highlighted the last seen aspect. The evidence of PWs 1 and 2 i.e the mother and sister-in-law is at great variance. Merely because the identity card of the accused was found near the dead body, that cannot be a ground to hold the appellant guilty. Additionally, fingerprint of the appellant-accused was not found on the articles seized. Only the fingerprints of A-1 were collected. As noted above A-1 has been acquitted by the High Court. Learned counsel for the respondent State supported the judgment of the High Court.
15. As per the version of PW 1 she was told by PW 2 that A-2 and A-3 came to the house at about 7.30 p.m and took the deceased on the motorcycle at 11.00 p.m Thereafter Councillor Mallesh came to his house and informed that the deceased was lying at Anand Bagh crossroads and his motorcycle was lying near the dead body. Contrary to what she stated, PW 2 stated that the appellant and PW 1 and her daughter had gone to attend a function. She and the deceased were alone in the house. A-2 and A-3 came into the house. A-3 was outside the house and A-2 was inside the house. A-2 and A-3 took the deceased on his motorcycle. PW 1 and her sister-in-law returned at about 10.00 p.m PW 1 enquired about the deceased. She was informed that A-2 and A-3 had taken the deceased on his motorcycle. After a few minutes she left. They took the deceased at about 10.30 p.m After hearing the sound of the motorcycle she came out of the house and noticed A-2 and the deceased on the motorcycle. She asked the deceased to come inside the house stating that PW 1 was calling him. Thereupon A-2 stated that he will send back the deceased within a short time. The deceased also stated that he will come within a short time. She claimed to have seen A-2 entering into the toddy shop which is located near their house. At about 11.00 p.m the Councillor came and informed that the motorcycle was lying near Anand Bagh crossroads and that the deceased was lying there. On hearing this PW 1 went out. PW 2 went to the scene of offence. In her cross-examination she accepted that she had not stated during investigation that A-2 and A-3 had come to their house and had taken the deceased. Interestingly, in the first information report the name of the accused was stated as unknown person and PW 1 had not stated that after she came back, again the deceased and A-2 went together.
16. “31. The last-seen theory comes into play where the time gap between the point of time when the accused and the deceased were last seen alive and when the deceased is found dead is so small that possibility of any person other than the accused being the author of the crime becomes impossible. It would be difficult in some cases to positively establish that the deceased was last seen with the accused when there is a long gap and possibility of other persons coming in between exists. In the absence of any other positive evidence to conclude that the accused and the deceased were last seen together, it would be hazardous to come to a conclusion of guilt in those cases.”
17. Above being the position, the evidence of PWs 1 and 2 did not establish the accusations so far as the appellant is concerned. Merely because his identity card was found near the dead body of the deceased, that cannot be a determinative factor to find the accused guilty.
18. The conviction is set aside. The appellant be set at liberty forthwith unless required to be in custody in any other case. The appeal is allowed.
Alert