Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Union Of India & Anr. v. Jagdish Kaur

Allahabad High Court
Nov 10, 2006
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners challenged the validity and correctness of two judgments and orders dated 11-08-2005 and 13-02-2006 (Annexures 7 and 9 to the writ petition) passed by the Judge, Small Causes Court, Meerut and the Additional District Judge, Court No. 5, Meerut respectively.

The factual matrix, as narrated in the writ petition, is that a registered rent lease/agreement (the text refers to both a deed dated 20-01-2000 and repeatedly to an agreement dated 01-07-1999) concerning premises No. 212 Arvindpuri, Meerut, was executed between the petitioners and the predecessor-in-interest of the respondent-landlady for a period of five years commencing 01-07-1999 and on a monthly rent of Rs. 1,250/-. Clauses 2, 14 and 15 of the agreement provided for continuation after the initial five-year term on a yearly basis (subject to terms) and contained an arbitration clause.

On 21-04-2004 the petitioners were served with a notice demanding vacant possession and arrears of rent up to 30-06-2004 and warning of a suit for ejectment and mesne profits. Subsequently, J.S.C.C. Suit No. 56 of 2004 was filed by the landlady in the Small Causes Court, Meerut for ejectment and recovery of arrears of rent. The petitioners contested the suit by filing a written statement raising multiple defenses (including illegality of the notice, offer/deposit of rent, applicability of Section 15 of the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupant) Act, 1971 and jurisdictional objections based on the arbitration clause).

The trial Court framed four issues, decreed the suit by judgment and decree dated 11-08-2005 directing delivery of vacant possession and payment of arrears and mesne profits. The petitioners preferred a revision (S.C.C. Revision No. 64 of 2005) which was dismissed by the revisional Court on 13-02-2006. The petitioners then invoked writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution challenging the concurrent judgments below.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit filed by the landlady was invalid for want of notice under Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act?
  2. Whether the suit was barred in view of the arbitration clause contained in Clause 15 of the agreement dated 01-07-1999?
  3. Whether the tenants were entitled to retain possession of the accommodation-in-dispute by invoking Clause 14 of the agreement dated 01-07-1999 for a further period of one year?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The notice dated 21-04-2004 was wholly illegal and unwarranted because there was no condition permitting re-entry by the landlord; the lease included a renewal clause permitting continuation.
  • Service of a notice under Section 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure does not define rights and cannot be the basis for suit; the suit could not be founded on that notice.
  • The three-month notice before expiry applies only where the landlady desires to grant a new lease and is not applicable to continued possession by tenants on the same terms for a further year; the Courts below misread the lease terms.
  • The landlady was motivated by a desire to enhance rent and did not personally appear before the Courts to prove ejectment grounds.
  • Additional factual contentions in the written statement: the notice was illegal; rent for June 2004 was offered/refused and sent by money order which was refused; rent for June–August 2004 plus interest was deposited on the first hearing date; the suit was barred by Section 15 of the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupant) Act, 1971; and the arbitration clause (clause 15) deprived the Court of jurisdiction.

Respondent-Landlady's Arguments

  • The agreement specifically provided tenancy for a period of five years and on expiry the tenancy automatically ended; the petitioners remained as unauthorized occupants.
  • The petitioners illegally inducted another Post Office in the premises without the landlady's consent, breaching the agreement and contravening Section 108 of the Transfer of Property Act.
  • The petitioners were under legal obligation to vacate upon expiry; the landlady (though elderly and ailing) proved her case through the statement/affidavit of Sri Rajeev Singh (P.W.1).
  • The option under Clauses 2 and 14 was never exercised by the petitioners, so there was no occasion to extend those benefits; the Courts below recorded concurrent findings of fact which should not be disturbed in writ jurisdiction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt Shanti Devi v. Amal Kumar Banerjee, (1981) 2 SCC 199 : AIR 1981 SC 1550 Where a lease is for a definite term it expires by efflux of time by reason of Section 111(a) of the Transfer of Property Act; service of notice under Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act is not necessary for determination of such lease. The Court relied on this authority to hold that no notice under Section 106 was required where the lease expired by efflux of time and to treat the 21-04-2004 notice as not being a Section 106 notice but as a statutory notice under Section 80(1) CPC; consequently the notice served was valid and did not vitiate the suit.
Raptakos Brett & Co. Ltd. v. Ganesh Property, (1998) 7 SCC 184 : AIR 1998 SC 3085 Affirms that obligations to hand over possession arise after the period of lease is over; reinforces that lease determined by efflux of time gives rise to cause of action independent of a new lease notice. The Court cited this decision to support the position that the covenant to hand over possession remains effective after lease expiry and that a separate notice under Section 106 was not a precondition to the landlady's suit.
Union of India v. Roshan Lal Gupta … and Brothers, AIR 1959 SC 1362 Authority supporting the proposition that where a lease/agreement has expired the arbitration clause may not be operative thereafter (as applied by the Court in the opinion). The Court relied on this authority to conclude that after expiry of the five-year term the agreement was non-existent for purposes of invoking the arbitration clause, and therefore the arbitration clause did not bar the landlady's suit instituted after expiry.
Polymat India Pvt. Ltd. v. National Insurance Company Ltd., 2005 (1) AWC 36 : (2005 All LJ 206) Supports the proposition that a party cannot raise an issue or plea in writ proceedings which was not pleaded or raised before the trial court; issues not framed/pleaded in trial cannot be raised for the first time in writ petition. The Court applied this principle to hold that the petitioners could not raise the plea under Clause 14 (exercise of an option to continue tenancy) in the writ petition when they had not pleaded or framed this issue before the trial court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court systematically addressed the three points identified for consideration:

Point (A) — Notice under Section 106, Transfer of Property Act:

  • The Court observed the lease was for a fixed five-year term expiring on 30-06-2004 and Clause 14 contemplated extension by mutual agreement.
  • There was no material to show that petitioners sought the landlady's consent for continuation after expiry.
  • Relying on Smt Shanti Devi and Raptakos Brett the Court concluded that when a lease expires by efflux of time, Section 106 notice is not necessary. Consequently the notice dated 21-04-2004 was treated as a statutory notice under Section 80(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure and was held valid.
  • The Court found the concurrent findings of fact by the courts below on this point did not warrant interference in writ jurisdiction.

Point (B) — Arbitration clause (Clause 15):

  • The Court noted that Clause 15 provided for arbitration but the suit was instituted after the expiry of the agreement’s five-year term (1-7-2004 onward).
  • It held that once the five-year period expired the agreement was non-existent for the purpose of invoking the arbitration clause; the arbitration clause was not applicable to the post-expiry suit.
  • The Court cited Union of India v. Roshan Lal Gupta and Brothers to support that the arbitration clause does not apply after expiry in the circumstances before it.

Point (C) — Clause 14 option to continue possession for one year:

  • The Court recorded that the petitioners did not raise this objection before the courts below nor was any issue framed on the point by the trial court.
  • The landlady pleaded that the petitioners were required to exercise the option at least three months before expiry and that no such option was exercised.
  • The petitioners’ written statement did not assert that they had exercised the option under Clause 14; in the absence of such pleading they could not raise this ground for the first time in the writ petition.
  • Polymat India was cited to support refusing belated invocation of this plea.

The Court also noted as a matter of record that the landlady had pleaded a need for the premises for her son's personal use and that her son, Sri Rajeev Singh, appeared as P.W.1. Considering the pleadings, evidence and concurrent findings, the Court found no illegality or infirmity warranting interference in writ jurisdiction.

Holding and Implications

Final Holding: WRIT PETITION DISMISSED.

Direct consequences ordered by the Court:

  • The petitioners are directed to vacate and hand over peaceful possession of the accommodation-in-dispute to the landlady and to make payment of arrears of rent, if any, within two months from the date of the judgment.
  • Failing compliance within two months they shall be evicted by coercive process with the aid of local police in accordance with law and the arrears of rent shall be recoverable as arrears of land revenue.
  • No order as to costs was made.

Broader implications: The Court treated the decision as an application of settled principles concerning expiry of fixed-term leases, the inapplicability of a contractual arbitration clause after expiry of the agreement in these circumstances, and the bar on raising new issues in writ jurisdiction that were not pleaded below. The opinion states there was "no illegality or infirmity" in the concurrent judgments that would warrant interference, and it does not purport to create any new legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities.


Note: This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond those contained in the text.

Show all summary ...

1. The petitioners have challenged the validity and correctness of judgments and orders dated 11-8-2005 and 13-2-2006 (appended as Annexures 7 and 9 respectively to the writ petition) passed by Judge, Small Causes Court, Meerut and Additional District Judge, Court No. 5 Meerut respectively.

2. Facts of the case, as have been disclosed in the writ petition, are that registered Rent lease/agreement dated 20-1-2000 regarding premises No. 212 Arvindpurl, Meerut was executed between the petitioners and the predecessor-in-interest of the respondent-landlady for a period of five years and onwards commencing from 1-7-1999 to run the Post Office on a monthly rent of Rs. 1250/-. As per clauses 2, 14 and 15 of the agreement dated 20-1-2000, tenancy of the petitioners was to continue even after expiry of initial period of five years for future period on yearly basis and in the event of any dispute concerning the subject-matter and agreement, the matter was to be referred to an Arbitrator appointed by Government of India for decision under the provisions of Arbitration Act, 1940.

3. It is claimed that the petitioners received notice dated 21-4-2004 from Smt. Jagdish Kaur, widow of late Sardar Gurdeep Singh through her counsel Sri Harcharan Singh Sarang on 22-4-2004 demanding vacant possession of the tenanted premises and arrears of rent up to 30-6-2004. It was also stipulated in the notice that in case of failure to comply with the terms of notice, landlady shall file a suit for ejectment and arrears of rent together with mesne profits/damages at the rate of Rs. 2500/- per month.

4. Thereafter, J.S.C.C Suit No. 56 of 2004 was filed by the landlady in the Court of Judge, Small Causes Court, Meerut for ejectment and recovery of arrears of rent on the grounds mentioned in the notice dated 21-4-2004.

5. The suit was contested by the petitioners by filing written statement denying the plaint allegations inter alia that the notice dated 21-4-2004 was illegal; that they offered rent for month of June 2004 to the landlady, who refused to accept, as such, it was sent through Money Order, which too was refused; that entire rent from June to August 2004 together with interest @ 9% per annum was deposited by the tenants on the first date of hearing before the trial Court, that the suit was based on false and frivolous grounds and it was barred by the provisions of Section 15 of the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupant) Act, 1971 and that in view of specific clause 15 of the rent lease deed, the Court had no jurisdiction to try the suit.

6. Landlady, in support of her case, filed affidavit of Sri Rajeev Singh under Order XVIII, Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, who was also cross-examined as P.W 1. He, in his cross-examination, admitted that he was not authorized by the landlady to submit any affidavit/statement but as she was suffering from knee pain, she was unable to appear before the Court and that the premises, in dispute, was needed by the landlady for members of her family. He also admitted that the building, in dispute was constructed in 1970.

7. The petitioners, in support of their case, filed affidavit of one Sri R.K Rana who proved the rent lease and stated that construction of the building, in dispute, was about 50 years old and that due rent was offered to the landlady, who refused to accept the same.

8. After hearing the parties and considering the materials available on record, the trial Court framed the following issues:—

(i) Whether the? defendant had not complied with the terms of lease deed due to which he is liable for ejectment from the disputed premises?

(ii) Whether the suit was barred under the provisions of Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupant) Act, 1971?

(iii) Whether the present suit is barred by provisions of Arbitration Act? and

(iv) Relief for which the plaintiff is entitled.

9. Trial Court decreed the suit vide impugned judgment and decree dated 11-8-2005 directing the petitioners to handover vacant possession of the premises, in dispute to the landlady within 30 days from the date of judgment and to pay Rs. 1250/- per month from 1-6-2004 till the delivery of possession as arrears of rent and mesne profit to the landlady.

10. On issue No. (i), the trial Court held that the rent lease was operative only for a period of five years w.e.f 1-7-1999 to 3-6-2004 and since the petitioners were continuing their possession even after expiry of lease period, their possession was illegal. On issue No. (ii), it was held that since the lease period of five years had already expired on 30-6-2004, tenancy should extinguished and suit of the landlady was not barred by Section 15 of the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupant) Act, 1971. On issue No. 3, it was held that after expiry of period of five years, clause 15 of the agreement dated 20-1-2000 was not available to be invoked.

11. Aggrieved by the impugned judgment and decree dated 11-8-2005 passed by the trial Court, the petitioners preferred S.C.C Revision No. 64 of 2005 in the Court of District Judge, Meerut on 9-9-2005 on the grounds, inter alia, that as the agreement dated 20-1-2000 was subsisting, the landlady having not invoked the arbitration clause, her suit was not legally maintainable, that the provisions of Section 15 of Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupant) Act, 1971 were fully applicable, as such, notice served upon them was illegal and that the landlord neither appeared before the trial Court nor authorized Sri Rajeev Singh to make any statement on her behalf nor was a witness of lease agreement, the judgment rendered by the trial Court was patently illegal and suffered from jurisdictional error. It was also claimed that the petitioners had deposited rent up to July 2005.

12. The revision filed by the petitioners was dismissed by the revisional Court vide judgment and order dated 13-2-2006.

13. Aggrieved by the impugned judgments passed by the Courts below, the petitioners have invoked the writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution by means of the instant writ petition.

14. Counsel for the petitioners vehemently urged that the impugned judgments cannot be sustained in law on the following grounds:—

(i) that there is no condition of re-entry of landlord in the disputed premises by terminating the lease agreement executed between the parties on 1-7-1999 for the initial period of five years including the renewal clause, as such, notice dated 21-4-2004 was wholly illegal and unwarranted;

(ii) that it is settled law that notice under Section 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure neither defines the rights of parties nor confers any legal right on parties. It only provides mode of procedure for getting the relief in respect of the cause of action, as such, the suit filed by the landlady against the petitioners for ejectment and recovery of damages etc., cannot be based on the said notice;

(iii) that notice of three months prior to expiry of term of the lease is applicable only in the matter of desire of grant of new lease by the landlady regarding the disputed premises and it is not applicable in the case of continuance of possession of the tenants on the same terms and conditions of the lease agreement for a further term of one year commencing from the date of expiry of the initial term of the lease agreements. The Courts below have misread the terms and conditions of the lease agreement and passed the impugned judgments;

(iv) that the landlady is interested only to enhance the rent as she did not appear before the Courts below to prove her case regarding relief of ejectment.

15. Per contra, it has been contended by counsel for the respondent-landlady that the agreement dated 1-7-1999 specifically provided the tenancy of the petitioners for a period of five years and on expiry of period of five years, it automatically came to an end. He submitted that the petitioners illegally inducted another Post Office in the name and style of ‘Patel Puri Post Office’ in the premises, in dispute without consent of the landlady, which was clear breach of the terms of agreement dated 1-7-1999 and in violation of the provisions of Section 108 of the Transfer of Property Act.

16. He urged that the petitioners were under legal obligation to vacate the accommodation, in dispute as their tenancy stood expired by efflux of time and their present status was that of unauthorized occupant. According to counsel for the respondent-landlady, the landlady being 80 years' old and ailing lady suffering from acute knee pain, was not able to attend the Court proceedings but she proved her case through the statement of Sri Rajeev Singh, P.W 1. As regards Clauses 2 and 14 of the rent agreement, he submitted that the option referred to in the said clauses was never exercised by the petitioners, as such, there was no occasion to extend the benefit of aforesaid clauses to the petitioners. It is vehemently urged that the Courts below have recorded concurrent findings of fact, which should not be interfered in the writ jurisdiction.

Conclusion

17. After hearing counsel for the parties and perusal of record, the following points emerge for consideration in this case:—

(A) Whether the suit filed by the landlady was bad for want of notice under Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act?

(B) Whether the suit was bad in view of the arbitration clause contained in Clause 15 of the agreement dated 1-7-1999? and

(C) Whether the tenants were entitled to retain possession of the accommodation-in-dispute, in view of Clause 14 of the agreement dated 1-7-1999 for a further period of one year?

18. On point (A), suffice it to say that a bare perusal of agreement dated 1-7-1999 shows that the lease was for a fixed term of five years which was to expire on 30-6-2004. Clause 14 of the agreement clearly stipulated that the extension of lease could be granted by mutual agreement between the parties. There is no material available on record indicating that the petitioners sought consent of the landlady for continuance of tenancy after expiry of period of five years. Hon'ble the Apex Court in Smt Shanti Devi v. Amal Kumar Banerjee , (1981) 2 SCC 199 : AIR 1981 SC 1550 has held that where a lease is for a definite term, it expires by efflux of time by reason of Section 111(a) of the Transfer of Property Act, as such, service of a notice under Section 106 of the said Act is not necessary for determination of lease. To the same effect is the decision of Hon'ble the Apex Court in Raptakos Brett & Co. Ltd. v. Ganesh Property, (1998) 7 SCC 184 : AIR 1998 SC 3085, wherein it has been held that (para 17):—

“It is easy to visualize that covenant mentioned in paragraph 2 of the plaint regarding the appellant's liability to hand over vacant and peaceful possession of the suit property to the plaintiff lessor would come into operation only after the period of lease is over. Therefore, it cannot be said that the said covenant would not remain effective and pending between the parties after the lease gets determined by efflux of time. To that extent the extreme contention of Dr. Singhvi that this part of the cause of action did not arise out of the contract of lease cannot be accepted.”

19. Thus, in view of settled position of law, no notice was required to be given to a tenant in case of expiry of lease by efflux of time. Notice dated 21-4-2004 served upon the petitioners by the landlady was statutory notice under Section 80(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure and it was not a notice under Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act. The notice dated 21-4-2004 was valid notice and concurrent finding of fact recorded by the Courts below call for no interference in the writ jurisdiction.

20. On point (B), it appears from clause 15 of the agreement that it provided for arbitration. The suit was instituted by the landlady on 1-7-2004 after expiry of term of agreement. Courts below have rightly held that after expiry of five years, the agreement was non-existent and the arbitration clause was not applicable. This view finds support from the law laid down by Hon'ble the Apex Court in Union Of India… v. Roshan Lal Gupta…. and Brothers, AIR 1959 SC 1362.

21. As regards point (C), from the record, it is evident that the petitioners never raised such objection before the Courts below nor any issue, in this regard, was framed by the trial Court. On the other hand, landlady had specifically stated in her plaint that the petitioners had to exercise their option at least three months before the expiry of period of lease and no such option having been exercised, they were estopped from raising this plea. The petitioners, in their written statement, have not stated that they exercised the option as per clause 14 of the lease agreement and in the absence of such pleading, they cannot raise the issue for the first time in the writ petition. This view is supported by the decision of Hon'ble the Supreme Court in Polymat India Pvt. Ltd. v. National Insurance Company Ltd. 2005 (1) AWC 36 : (2005 All LJ 206).

22. A perusal of plaint allegations clearly shows that in paragraph 14, the landlady had specifically stated that she required the accommodation, in dispute, for her son's personal use and occupation. Her son Sri Rajeev Singh, for whose need, the accommodation, in dispute, was needed, appeared before the trial Court as P.W 1.

23. There is no illegality or infirmity in the judgments impugned warranting interference in the writ jurisdiction.

24. For the reasons stated above, the writ petition is dismissed.

25. The petitioners shall vacate and handover peaceful possession of the accommodation, in dispute, to the landlady and also make payment of arrears of rent, if any, to the landlady within a period of two months from today failing which they shall be evicted by coercive process in accordance with law with the aid of local police and the arrears of rent shall be recoverable as arrests of land revenue. No order as to costs.

26. Petition dismissed.