- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Akhil Bharat Goseva Sangh v. State of A.P.
Factual and Procedural Background
The opinion concerns court monitoring of the State of Andhra Pradesh's obligation to prepare a livestock census. The State had not prepared the census and, according to the court, it appeared not to have commenced the process. Multiple prior opportunities had been granted to the State (at its own request) to complete the census. An affidavit filed in court by Shri Syed Riazuddin, Assistant Secretary to the Government, indicated that the matter remained at the stage of sanctioning funds for preliminary expenditure connected with conducting the census. The court expressed surprise and doubt about the State's sincerity in completing the census expeditiously. The State's counsel represented that, now that the amount had been sanctioned, the census would be undertaken on a priority basis.
Legal Issues Presented
The opinion addresses a procedural matter and does not frame distinct legal issues.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court noted that the livestock census had not been prepared and that repeated extensions had already been granted at the State's request. Based on the affidavit, the court observed that the State was still at a preliminary funding-sanction stage, which the court found surprising and indicative of possible lack of sincerity in expediting the census. Nonetheless, in light of the submission by the State's counsel that funds had now been sanctioned and work would be taken up on a priority basis, the court granted additional time. The court also specified a consequence for non-compliance: if the State failed to complete the census and, in any event, to file an interim/final report by the next date, parties would be permitted to request the court to draw an adverse presumption against the State.
Holding and Implications
TIME EXTENDED / DIRECTIONS ISSUED: The court granted further time to the State of Andhra Pradesh until the end of December 1999 to complete the livestock census and, in any event, to file an interim/final report by the next date.
The matter was directed to be listed in January 2000 for further directions. If the State does not comply, the parties may request the court to raise an adverse presumption against the State. The opinion does not indicate that any broader legal principle or new precedent was established beyond these case-management directions.
(1) Census of livestock has not been prepared by the State of A.P. and it appears that it has not even commenced so far. Number of opportunities have already been granted to the State of A.P., at its request, for time to complete the census. From the affidavit filed today in court by Shri Syed Riazuddin, Assistant secretary to the government, it transpires that the matter is still at the stage of sanctioning of amounts for the purpose of incurring expenditure in connection with the preliminaries to be undertaken for conducting census. We are really surprised. The cause manner in which the State of A. P. has been acting in this matter, creates a doubt in our mind about its sincerity in carrying out the census expeditiously. It is stated by learned counsel for the State that now that the amount has been sanctioned, census work would be taken up on priority basis.
(2) At the request of learned counsel for the State of A.P., we grant further time, till the end of December, 1999 to complete the census and in any event to file an interim/final report, by the next date. In case the needful is not done, it shall be open to the parties to submit to the court to raise an adverse presumption against the State.
(3) List in January, 2000, for directions, as requested.
_____________________
Alert