Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. Jaya Hydro Power Pvt. Ltd. v. Jai Prakash Hydro Power Ltd. & Another

Appellate Tribunal For Electricity
Jul 23, 2007
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an application under Rule 55(3) of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (Procedure, Form, Fee and Record of Proceedings) Rules, 2007, seeking waiver of the fee for filing an appeal. The Schedule to Rule 55 prescribes a fee of Rs.1,00,000 for filing an appeal under sub‑section (2) of Section 111 of the Electricity Act, 2003 where respondents are four or fewer, with an additional Rs.10,000 for each respondent beyond four. Sub‑rule (3) permits the Tribunal to waive payment of fee in suitable cases, taking into account economic condition or indigence of the petitioner, or whether waiver will advance the cause of justice, among other reasons.

The applicant, a generating company, sought waiver of the Rs.1,00,000 fee in connection with an appeal challenging a tariff order dated 24 February 2007 of the Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission, issued on a tariff petition filed by Jay Prakash Hydro Pvt. Ltd. The applicant provided an audited balance sheet showing net current assets of Rs.102,052 and argued that it lacked financial capacity to pay the fee and that waiver would advance the cause of justice for consumers of Himachal Pradesh.

The Tribunal examined whether the applicant demonstrated indigence or other factors justifying waiver, whether waiver would advance the cause of justice, and whether this was a suitable case for inquiry. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant failed to show how it was aggrieved by the impugned tariff order and declined to waive the fee. The application for waiver was rejected, and the Tribunal observed that issues about retrospective application of the amended fee schedule need not be decided for disposing of the instant application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal should waive the fee for filing an appeal under Rule 55(3) of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity Rules, 2007, taking into account the applicant's economic condition or indigent circumstances, whether waiver would advance the cause of justice, and whether it is a suitable case for waiver.
  2. Whether the applicant has demonstrated sufficient locus or how it is aggrieved by the impugned tariff order to justify waiver under Rule 55(3).
  3. The applicant raised a contention based on State of Bombay Vs. Supreme General Films Exchange Ltd. (AIR 1960 SC 980) that amended court fees cannot be applied retrospectively to proceedings initiated before amendment; the Tribunal noted this contention but did not decide it because the waiver application was rejected.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applicant asserted it lacked financial capacity to pay the prescribed fee of Rs.1,00,000 and submitted an audited balance sheet showing net current assets of Rs.102,052.
  • The applicant contended that unless the impugned tariff order of 24 February 2007 is set aside, consumers of Himachal Pradesh would face impermissibly higher tariff and that waiving the fee would advance the cause of justice.
  • The applicant described itself as engaged in hydro power activities, providing consultancy services, and acting as a watchdog on public interest issues in the power sector, implying a public‑interest basis for waiver; however, the Memorandum of Association did not show an objective of acting as a watchdog for consumers.
  • The applicant relied on the Supreme Court decision in State of Bombay Vs. Supreme General Films Exchange Ltd. (AIR 1960 SC 980) to argue that the amended fee schedule could not be applied retrospectively to proceedings initiated before the amendment, and that the fee payable should be the lower fee applicable when the original proceedings began.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any respondent arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Bombay Vs. Supreme General Films Exchange Ltd. AIR 1960 SC 980 Principle that amended court fees cannot be applied to suits/ proceedings if the suit was filed before such amendment (argument against retrospective application of increased fee). The Tribunal noted the applicant's reliance on this precedent but held that deciding the retrospective‑effect argument was unnecessary to dispose of the present waiver application and therefore did not adjudicate on that point; the Tribunal suggested the applicant may challenge the validity of the amendments before the appropriate forum.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal began with the text of Rule 55(3), which authorizes waiver "to advance the cause of justice and in suitable cases," taking into consideration the economic condition or indigent circumstances of the petitioner or such other reasons. The Tribunal identified three relevant considerations explicitly: (1) the economic condition or indigence of the appellant; (2) whether waiver would advance the cause of justice; and (3) whether it is a suitable case for waiver.

The Tribunal evaluated the applicant's financial evidence (audited balance sheet showing net current assets of Rs.102,052) and observed that the financial position could be inquired into; however, such inquiry would be warranted only if the case were otherwise suitable and waiver would advance the cause of justice.

The Tribunal then examined whether the applicant had demonstrated how it was aggrieved by the impugned tariff order. It found that the Memorandum of Appeal did not disclose how the applicant, a generating company and provider of consultancy services, had been adversely affected by the tariff fixed on Jay Prakash Hydro Pvt. Ltd.'s petition. The applicant's claim of acting as a "watch dog" for consumers was not supported by the Memorandum of Association, which listed objectives such as generation, sale and consultancy relating to power projects but did not include representing or protecting ultimate consumers. Because the applicant failed to show that it was directly aggrieved, the Tribunal concluded this was not a suitable case for fee waiver and that waiving the fee would not advance the cause of justice.

Regarding the retrospective‑effect argument based on the Supreme Court precedent, the Tribunal noted the contention but declined to decide it because the dismissal of the waiver application made that issue unnecessary for the present disposal. The Tribunal expressly refrained from commenting on the merits of that argument and left open the possibility for the applicant to challenge the amendment before an appropriate forum.

Holding and Implications

APPLICATION FOR WAIVER OF FEE REJECTED.

Implications:

  • The immediate and direct effect is that the applicant's request to waive the Rs.1,00,000 fee (plus any additional respondent fees as applicable) was denied; the appellant may pay the required fees if it wishes to proceed with the appeal.
  • The Tribunal did not decide the separate legal question on retrospective application of the amended fee schedule; it left that issue open for challenge before an appropriate forum. No new precedent on the retrospective application of fee amendments was established by this decision.
Show all summary ...

This is an application under Rule 55 (3) of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (Procedure, Form, fee and record of proceedings) Rules 2007 praying for waiver of fee. Rule 55 prescribes inter alia that fee for filing an appeal shall be as prescribed in the Schedule. The Schedule prescribes a fee of Rs.1 Lac for filing an appeal under Sub section 2 of Section 111 of The Electricity Act 2003 in case the number of respondents is four or less. If the number of respondents exceeds four, an additional fee of Rs.10,000/- is payable for each respondent. Sub rule 3 of Rule 55 provides that the Tribunal may waive the payment of fee. The specific rule is as under : ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ICS/NP Page 2 of 5 55(3) The Tribunal may, to advance the cause of justice and in suitable cases, waive payment of such fee or portion thereof, taking into consideration the economic condition or indigent circumstances of the petitioner or appellant or applicant or such other reason, as the case may be.

2. The applicant prays for waiver of fee contending that it does not have financial capacity to pay the fee of Rs.1 Lac. It further contends that unless the Impugned Order namely the tariff order dated 24th February, 2007 of the Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission is set aside, the consumers of the State of Himachal Pradesh will have to pay impermissible higher tariff and that the application should be allowed in order to advance the cause of justice. The rule quoted above clearly shows that the economic condition or indigence of the appellant is not the only consideration which the Tribunal has to take into account for waiving the cost. Apart from the indigent condition other factors for waiving the court fees are (1) whether it will advance the cause of justice and (2) whether it is a suitable case.

3. The applicant has submitted its audited balance sheet to show that its net current asset is only worth Rs.102052/-. The financial position of the appellant can be a subject matter of inquiry and we could have proceeded to initiate the enquiry by giving notice to respondents had we found it a suitable case for waiving fees and the waiver would advance the cause of justice. ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ICS/NP Page 3 of 5

4. The appellant/applicant challenges the order of the Regulatory Commission dated 24.02.2007 passed on the tariff petition filed by Jay Prakash Hydro Pvt. Ltd. (JPHL), a generating company. The applicant is also a generating company. The applicant does not disclose in the Memorandum of Appeal as to how the applicant is aggrieved by the tariff fixed by the Commission on the tariff application of JPHL. It is contended in the appeal that the appellant has been engaged in the field of Hydro power activities and is providing consultancy services besides working as a watch dog on various issues of public interest, affecting electricity consumers in general in the power sector. The Memorandum of Association, however, does not show that the applicant company was formed with objectives of working as a watch dog as claimed. The first objective, as per this Memorandum, is to carry on the business to generate, receive, produce, improve, buy, sell, re-sale, acquire, use, transmit, accumulate, employ, distribute, develop, handle, protect, supply and act as agent, broker, representative, consultant, collaborator or otherwise to deal in electric power and steam in all its branches of such places or places as may be permitted by appropriate authorities. One of the objectives is to carry out work of consultancy relating to power projects. The applicant company, however, does not have, as one of its objectives, to take care of ultimate consumers of electricity or to act as a watch dog for such consumers in the matters of fixation of tariff by the appropriate Commission. The applicant nowhere discloses as to how the applicant itself as a generating company ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ICS/NP Page 4 of 5 or as a company engaged in the activities mentioned above has been adversely affected by the Impugned Order of the Commission. This being the situation we do not feel that this is an appropriate case in which the fees for filing the appeal should be waived. Nor do we think that waiving the fees in this matter will advance the cause of justice.

5. It is vehemently argued before us, on the basis of the judgment of Supreme Court in the case of State of Bombay Vs. Supreme General Films Exchange Ltd. AIR 1960 SC 980 that amended court fees cannot be applied for appeals if the suit was filed before such amendment. According to the applicant the present appeal is continuation of proceedings before the Commission and the fees payable for the present appeal should be the same as was applicable on the day the proceedings before the Commission were initiated and that since on such date the fee payable for appeal before this Tribunal was only Rs.10,000/-, charging Rs.1 Lac for this appeal would give retrospective effect to the amendments. It may be mentioned here that the amendment was notified on 22nd January, 2007. The rule bringing about the amendments says they shall come into force on the date of publication in the official gazette. Apparently, therefore, the amended rule comes into effect on 22nd January, 2007. The application under consideration is only for the waiving of fees and we have found that this is not an appropriate case in which the fees should be waived. The other submissions regarding retrospective effect or the legitimacy of the ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ICS/NP Page 5 of 5 amendments for that reason is not required to be gone into for the disposal of the application made before us. Nor do we want to pass any comments on the arguments made by the counsel for the applicant. If the applicant wants to challenge the validity of the amendments he may do so before the appropriate forum.

6. The application for waiver of fee is accordingly rejected. The appellant may pay the fees for the appeal in case it wants to proceed with the matter. (Mrs. Justice Manju Goel) ( Mr. H.L. Bajaj ) Judicial Member Technical Member