- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ex. Sub. G.P. Sharma v. Union Of India
Structured Summary of the Opinion — TA 383/2010 (Armed Forces Tribunal, Principal Bench)
Factual and Procedural Background
This petition challenges the conviction and sentence of the petitioner by a Summary General Court Martial (SCM) dated 05.11.2004. The SCM convicted the petitioner under Section 34(c) of the Army Act and awarded the punishments of dismissal from service and rigorous imprisonment for three years. The petitioner’s post-confirmation petition under section 164(2) of the Army Act was dismissed by the Chief of the Army Staff on 30.04.2005. The matter was brought before the Armed Forces Tribunal (Principal Bench, New Delhi) and the judgment in the Tribunal proceedings is dated 16.02.2016 (Coram: Justice Sunil Hali and Air Marshal J.N. Burma).
The underlying incident occurred while the petitioner was posted to 620 EME Battalion at Jammu & Kashmir and was detailed as in-charge of a Quick Reaction Team (QRT) for the night of 21–22 July 2003. On 22.07.2003 at about 05:45 hours three terrorists entered the unit area through the main gate, killing the orderly NCO and another soldier. Terrorists split in different directions; one entered the workshop area where two QRTs were stationed, and a number of personnel were killed in the resulting attack. The petitioner was charged under Section 34(c) of the Army Act alleging cowardice/misbehaviour in the presence of the enemy.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the petitioner committed an act constituting an offence under Section 34(c) of the Army Act (i.e., shamefully casting away arms, ammunition, tools or equipment or misbehaving so as to show cowardice in the presence of the enemy).
- Whether the factual record (witness statements and circumstances of the incident) supports the SCM's conclusions that the petitioner had shown cowardice or otherwise failed in his duty to such an extent as to warrant conviction and the punishments imposed.
- What relief (if any) should follow if the Tribunal finds that the prosecution failed to prove the charge — specifically, the consequences for service status, pension and other consequential benefits.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal proceeded methodically: it first identified the statutory provision under which the petitioner was charged and then set out the essential elements the prosecution must establish to make out the offence under Section 34(c) of the Army Act.
Statutory/elemental analysis:
- The Tribunal described Section 34(c) as applying to a person who, "in the presence of the enemy, shamefully casts away his arms, ammunition, tools or equipment or misbehaves in such manner so as to show cowardice."
- The Tribunal distilled three essential components required to prove cowardice under Section 34(c): (a) the accused committed an act of cowardice; (b) the conduct occurred in the presence of the enemy; and (c) the conduct resulted from fear.
- The Tribunal emphasised that the prosecution must show that the accused surrendered out of fear in the presence of the enemy — i.e., a "total surrender" or behaviour that would be considered shameful because it discloses surrender before the enemy.
Evaluation of the evidence:
- The Tribunal examined witness statements (summarised in the opinion) from multiple QRT members and others, noting differences in proximity to and direct observation of the accused during the incident.
- Several witnesses who were members of the QRT described being sent by the accused to check or take positions, engaging the terrorist(s), being fired upon, suffering injuries or being killed, and that they did not receive support fire from other QRT members at certain moments.
- The Tribunal noted that many witnesses did not state that the accused had run away, surrendered his arms or otherwise displayed the kind of behaviour constituting "total surrender" in the presence of the enemy. Witnesses placed the accused either in the QRT room or at positions near the QRT verandah, and some described orders given by him to take positions and instructions about where he would take up position to give supporting fire.
- The Tribunal found no direct evidence that the accused "ran away" or "surrendered his arms and ammunition." Instead, the evidence showed that he remained in or near the QRT location, gave directions, and was seen by witnesses during or immediately after engagement.
- The Tribunal also considered operational shortcomings in the unit: the QRT had not carried out rehearsals or drills to meet such contingencies; communication (telephone) in the QRT room was non-functional on the date; the Quarter Guard siren was not working; some arms supplied were defective; and overall the unit showed complacency and lack of adequate supervision and training.
- On these facts, the Tribunal concluded that the finding of the SCM — that the accused did not deploy QRT members effectively and thereby caused avoidable casualties — was based on surmise and was not supported by evidence sufficient to prove cowardice under Section 34(c).
Bridge to conclusion:
- The Tribunal emphasised that lapses in preparedness and supervision pointed to systemic failures for which the Commanding Officer bore responsibility; those lapses undermined any conclusion that the accused alone had committed the offence of cowardice.
- Given the absence of evidence of total surrender or conduct motivated by fear in the presence of the enemy, the prosecution had not established essential ingredients of Section 34(c).
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Tribunal held that the prosecution failed to prove the charge under Section 34(c) of the Army Act and therefore allowed the petition and set aside the order of conviction recorded by the Summary Court Martial.
Immediate consequences for the parties:
- The petitioner shall not be reinstated in service.
- The petitioner shall be entitled to post-retirement benefits including pension, gratuity and consequential benefits.
- If there is any deficiency in the petitioner’s qualifying service for pension purposes, he shall be notionally reinstated solely for the purpose of granting pension.
- The petitioner is not entitled to back wages.
- No order as to costs was made.
Broader implications: The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel precedent; it reverses the specific conviction on the basis that the required elements of Section 34(c) were not proved on the evidence and stresses the relevance of unit preparedness and supervisory responsibility. The decision's effect is the direct relief granted to the petitioner (set aside conviction and pensionary consequences) rather than the establishment of a new legal principle.
Judgment delivered: 16 February 2016 — Members: Justice Sunil Hali (Member, Judicial) and Air Marshal J.N. Burma (Member, Administrative).
TA 383/2010 1 COURT NO. 2, ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI TA 383/2010 Writ Petition (C) No.9232 of 2007 Ex. Sub G.P Sharma Applicant VERSUS Union of India & Ors Respondents For petitioner : Mr. S.R. Kalkal, Advocate For Respondents : Mr. J.S.Yadav Advocate CORAM: HONBLE MR. JUSTICE SUNIL HALI, MEMBER HONBLE AIR MARSHAL J.N. BURMA, MEMBER Judgment 16.02.2016 Justice Sunil Hali The petitioner stands convicted by the Summary General Court Martial vide its order dated 05.11.2004. He was awarded the following punishments:
a) To be dismissed from service.
b) To suffer rigorous imprisonment for three years. His post confirmation petition u/s 164 (2) of the Army Act was dismissed by the Chief of the Army Staff on 30.04.2005. These are the subject matter of challenge before this court.
2. While posted to 620 EME Bn at J & K, he was detailed on duty as in charge Quick Reaction Team for the period 21/22 July,2003 in the unit. At about 05.45 hours on 22.07.2003 three terrorists entered in the Unit area through main gate of 620 EME Bn by killing the orderly NCO and one more jawan. The three terrorists who had entered in the unit went on three different directions.. One of the terrorists went in the direction of
810 Field Workshop area. In this area two QRT were stationed. As a TA 383/2010 2 consequence of the terrorist attack in the unit, the terrorist who had approached the workshop area managed to kill a number of people. The SCM found the accused guilty u/s 34 ( C) of the Army Act and awarded three years RI and dismissal from the service.
3. In order to appreciate the controversy, it is necessary to examine the statement of the witnesses who have appeared in the case.
4. PW-1 Lt. Col. Ramesh Kumar Pullabhatla was performing the duties of Second in Command of 610 Electronics and Mechanical Engineers Battalion at that time. In order to boost the security of the unit, the Commanding Officer had divided the guards of QRT into two different teams. The team under the JCO was placed near the workshop area of
809 Field Workshop Company and the second under an NCO was placed at the Technical Library area approximately 100 meters North East of unit kote. The witness produced five copies of the Topographical sketch of the incident site. The charter of duties of the QRT was laid down in the concerned Army Training Instructions/Memorandum. He further states that at the unit level all the personnel were briefed and adequately activated to operate as a QRT to meet any contigency arising out of any security breach. The QRT commander is required to prevent the intruder from passing through his area of responsibility and neutralize him. The QRT is to be led to the site where the intruder or the terrorist is present and the QRT is to take necessary steps to prevent him from causing further damages. On the relevant date the QRT was equipped with the arms and ammunition. A land telephone line existed from the QRT to the main exchange located at the battalion area. He further stated that he heard the sounds of small arms firing and grenade blast from the general area of their Battalion Headquarters main gate. At that time he was at his residence. Within minutes, he reached the main gate of the Battalion and TA 383/2010 3 found three wounded soldiers lying there. One of them was dead and the other two were alive. He states that he evacuated the two wounded soldiers one by one through the main gate to the hospital.
5. In cross examination he stated that he was getting ready for the morning physical training which used to commence at 06.00 hours. The battalion PT parade used to consist of approximately 50-80 personnel and the PT ground was approximately 150 to 200 meters from the unit kote. The personnel standing in the PT ground could not be seen from the main gate of the unit. If anyone was hiding in the thick vegetation area he could not be seen from outside with naked eyes. The two QRT were provided rooms at respective locations i.e. at the Technical Library location and 809 Field Workshop Area. He admits that the QRT was basically responsible to react to any incidence occurring inside the unit area such as a terrorist/intruder entering the unit area. He further states that to be best of his knowledge no cordon or engagement procedure/practice was followed by the QRT in the unit for neutralizing the terrorist.
6. PW-2, Hav. Gursaran Singh states that on 22.07.2003, he had come to the unit physical training ground for physical training. When he was about to sit on the culvert he heard the sound of firing. By then Hav. BP Bhopte had also arrived there after blowing the whistle for physical training. He asked Hav. BP Bhopte as to what further action had to be taken. He suggested him to go to the JCO Mess building and climb on top of it. He asked Hav. Bhopte to handover the rifle to him. After taking the rifle from him, he went to the top of JCO Mess building. From there he killed the terrorist. TA 383/2010 4
7. PW-3 Hav. Mohammad Haresuddin Sarkar states that the accused was the guard commander of the QRT and he was a member of the QRT. He heard the sound of firing from the Quarter Guard area of the unit on 22.07,.2003, He cocked his rifle and went to the accused. Accused at that time was inside the QRT room. He was sitting on a cot. The accused instructed him to take position in the nallah situated there. The sound of firing increased and simultaneously the loud sound of Bhajan from the speaker was also coming. He was unable to make out as to from where the sound of firing was coming. He saw the terrorist moving towards East and fired upon him. The terrorist went to the dense bushes. He stated that the main entrance of the QRT room was not visible from the place where he ws told to take position by the accused. He states that no specific briefing was given on that day. However, general briefing was given by the accused being the in-charge of the QRT. The briefing was that one will not leave the place till relieved. He would be told to take position and follow the orders. He states that in front of the verandah of the QRT room a Tata Shakitman 3 Ton vehicle was also parked. No question was put to him in the cross examination.
8. PW-4 Naik Tara Chandra states that he was a member of the QRT located in 809 Field Workshop which was commanded by the accused. The unit was attacked by terrorists on 22.07.2003 at about 0550 hours. When the firing sound increased including LMG firing and grenade blasts, the accused told him that they should move towards the main gate of the unit and also check as to where the firing was coming from. He states that he along with Sep. S.K. Singh after getting ready started moving towards the gate. The witness states that they had just moved approximately 20-25 meters and were near the crossing when they saw that a man in combat dress with stars was hiding behind the R& I store, When he saw him firing towards them, he cocked his rifle . Sepoy SK Singh told him to take lying position. When he was about to take lying TA 383/2010 5 position he found that a bullet had hit his right shoulder. The terrorist was continuously firing at him. Sepoy S.K. Singh fired few rounds but his rifle also stopped firing due to some defect. Sepoy SK Singh lied down on the ground pretending to be dead. The terrorist crossed him and moved towards him. He kept crawling behind, When the terrorist came close to him while firing and was approximately 25-30 feet away, he picked up a stone which was lying nearby and threw it at him. He took lying position. Thereafter he got up and ran towards QRT verandah crossing a parked vehicle on his right side. Subsequently he was shifted to military hospital.
9. On a question being put by the court, he states that when he and SK Singh fired upon the terrorist, they did not receive any support from the balance of the QRT. When he came back running towards QRT he did not find the accused or any of the member of the QRT in that area However, subsequently he came to know that one of the QRT members Craftsman Indra Prakash was also killed in the terrorist attack.
10. PW-5 Sepoy (Driver) Shiv Kumar Singh states that accused was the in charge of the QRT. While sitting in the QRT room on 22.07.2003 along with the accused and other persons, he heard the sound of firing. The accused told two personnel should go towards the main gate of the Battalion to find out as to where the firing was coming from. He along with Naik Tara Chandra was sent by the accused towards the main gate. While running towards the main gate, suddenly they saw a terrorist in combat dress who fired upon them. He cocked his rifle and fired upon the terrorist. After firing about 3-4 rounds, his rifle stopped firing due to defect. Naik Tara Chandra told him that he has been hit by a bullet. He tried to clear the defect of his rifle. The terrorist was firing continuously and stopped firing when his magazine became empty. While he was changing the magazine he immediately got up and ran towards QRT TA 383/2010 6 room. He found the accused standing in front of the QRT room. He informed the accused that the terrorist was coming towards their room. Accused told him that he would take position behind the vehicle standing near the QRT room and he also told him to take position behind the building south of the QRT room. The accused also told him to engage the terrorist when in sight and he would give the supporting fire from his location. When he was clearing the stoppage of his rifle, he heard a sound of a long firing burst from the QRT room. After a few seconds, a single shot firing sound was also heard from the same direction. After sometime he saw Capt. Batra on the road coming from 809 Field Workshop main gate area. The witness narrated the incident to him and he took the witness to the unit Mandir area. They saw the dead body of Sepoy Manoj. Capt. Batra went inside the Mandir and came out and told him that the Panditji was also dead. He also states that he told the accused that the terrorist was coming towards QRT room but did not tell him from which direction the terrorist was approaching. The place where he and Naik Tara Chandra were fired upon by the terrorist was about 50-
60 meters from the QRT room. He further states that he covered the area in front of 809 Field Workshop building and the accused could cover the area behind 809 Workshop. They did not get any support from the other QRT when he and Naik Tara Chandra were being fired upon by the terrorist.. He remained behind the building where he was sent by the accused for about one and a half minute. On being asked a question by the court, the witness states that the accused was at a place E in front of the QRT room. The accused was holding his weapon i.e 5.56 mm INSAS rifle. He states that he saw the accused when he entered the verandah of
809 Field Workshop. The accused was facing towards South. When he saw the accused at place H no member of the QRT was with him.
11. PW-6 Major Sandeep Chaudhary states that he was detailed to record the summary of evidence in respect of the accused. In his TA 383/2010 7 statement the accused stated that he made all efforts possible to prevent the terrorist from causing destruction and neutralize him . In a reply to the question whether regular activities were carried out by the QRT in the unit to cater for any kind of contingency, the accused stated that no rehearsals were carried out in the unit to meet such a contingency. He further stated that the QRT room did not have direct communication with the main gate of the unit but it had a telephone through the battalion exchange. On the date of incident the telephone kept in the room was not functional. These are the evidence in a nutshell, which have come on record.
12. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties.
13. Before adverting to the evidence on record, it is necessary to mention Section 34(c) of the Army Act for which the petitioner has been charged.
14. Before resorting to the legal submissions made, it is necessary to examine Section 34(c) of the Army Act. section 34 (c) contemplates that it can be applied against any person who in the presence of the enemy, shamefully castes away his arms, ammunition, tools or equipment or misbehaves in such manner so as to show cowardice.
15. The import of section 34 (c) is that it would apply to any soldier who in the presence of the enemy, shamefully castes away his arms, ammunition, tools or equipment or misbehaves in such manner showing total surrender before the enemy. Cowardice is a misbehaviour motivated by fear. To prove cowardice, the evidence must show: TA 383/2010 8
a) That the accused committed an act of cowardice;
b) That the conduct of the person was in the presence of enemy;
c) That this conduct was a result of fear.
16. Therefore, the prosecution is required to show that the conduct of the accused while being confronted with the enemy was such that his behaviour would be considered shameful disclosing that he caste away his arms and ammunition and ran away. Therefore, the essential feature of an act of cowardice is that there should be total surrender shown by the soldier in the presence of an enemy.
17. In order to hold the petitioner guilty, it is necessary to show that in the presence of the terrorist the accused had shamefully caste away his arms, ammunition, tools or equipment or misbehaved in such a manner that it showed total cowardice. What is essential is to show that the accused had surrendered out of fear before the terrorist. In order to appreciate this controversy, it is important to discuss the version of the witnesses.
18. PW-1 is not a witness to the occurrence. He came on the spot only after the firing started. At that time he was at his residence which was away from the unit. When specifically asked to define the role of QRT and on the reaction of the accused at the time the terrorist had attacked, he has stated that he was not aware of it. PW-2 Hav. Gursaran Singh was also not a witness to the fact as to what was the conduct of the accused when the terrorist attacked. He is stated to have killed the terrorist. PW-3. Hav. Mohammad Haresuddin Sarkar is a witness who was one of the members of the QRT. He states that when he heard the firing he cocked his rifle and went to the accused. The accused got up from the cot and told him to go towards East and take position in a nallah situated there. TA 383/2010 9 He is supposed to have seen the terrorist. On seeing the witness, the terrorist went into the dense bushes. He admits that a 3 ton vehicle was parked in front of the verandah. PW- 4,Naik Tara Chand admits that he was a part of the QRT. On hearing the firing the accused told them to go towards the main gate of the unit and check from where the firing was coming from . He saw the terrorist coming towards them and he took up the firing position. He was hit by a bullet on his right shoulder. The only statement he makes is that there was no support fire from other members of the QRT when he was confronted by the terrorist along with S.K. Singh. He states that while he was coming towards QRT he did not find the accused or anyone except S.K. Singh. All that he states is that the accused was not present in the QRT room. PW-5 Sepoy Shiv Kumar Singh has stated that he along with PW-4 were asked by the accused to proceed towards the main gate to find out as to from where the firing was coming from. Both the witnesses and PW-4 confronted the terrorist. He fired 4-5 rounds. Thereafter, his rifle did not function as a result of which he went towards the QRT room. He found the accused in front of the QRT room and told him that terrorist was coming towards that direction. The accused is stated to have told him that he was taking position behind the vehicle standing behind the QRT room and told him to take position behind the building south of the QRT room.
19. From the statement of the witnesses it has no where come out that the accused had run away from the place of duty. At the time of firing he was in the QRT room and had directed his team to take position at different locations. PW-5 Sepoy Shiv Kumar Singh states that when he came back to check the rifle, he found the accused in the QRT room. The accused informed him that he would take position at the back of the vehicle. Therefore, there is no evidence to suggest that the accused had run away or surrendered his arms and ammunitions. TA 383/2010 10
20. The question arises as to whether the accused has committed an offence u/s 34(c) of the Army Act. Cowardice is a misbehavior motivated by fear. Cowardice is defined in Blacks Law Dictionary as misbehaviour through fear in relation to duty to be performed. Admittedly, the charge against the petitioner is that he showed cowardice in not confronting the terrorist. Therefore, he did not perform his duty. Most important ingredient of the offence is the element of fear created by the enemy as a result of which the person required to perform a specific duty runs away. It is the element of fear which prevents a person to perform his duty in the event of an attack.
21. In the present case, there is no evidence to suggest that the accused had run away or surrendered himself. All that, that has been stated by the witnesses is that there was no support firing from the accused. It is admitted by the witnesses Sepoy SK Singh that the accused was in front of the QRT room when the terrorist was engaged in firing. The reaction taken was hardly one minute. Therefore, it was not possible for the other members of the QRT to react or provide support to the members of the QRT under fire. Admittedly the petitioner has not shown any cowardice as stated by the witnesses. The finding of the Court Martial is that the accused did not deploy the QRT members effectively, as a result of which, a number of causalities had been suffered which could have been avoided. The finding of the court martial is merely on surmises and not supported by evidence. We find no evidence to suggest that the accused had shown Cowardice in confronting the terrorist. There can be lapses in his part in dealing with the situation but for this he alone cannot be blamed. What we have observed in this case is that the unit was not fully prepared. Siren in the Quarter Guard was not working. The arms supplied to the personnel were found to be defective. No drill was conducted by the QRT. The unit was in a state of complacency that it is apparent that there was a lack of adequate supervision and training in the TA 383/2010 11 unit. The reasons for the complacency, which were displayed by the unit was admittedly on account of lack of preparedness for which the commanding officer would be largely responsible. To keep the unit in an optimum, state of preparedness is the duty of the Commanding Officer. It seems that he had not exercised his authority adequately. The unit was located in the area near the border and could have been affected by the terrorist attacks. Therefore, there was every reason to keep the soldiers in constant alert. Unfortunately this was found missing during the incident.
22. In view of this we find that the prosecution has failed to prove the case against the accused. We allow the petition and set aside the order of conviction recorded by the SCM. However, the petitioner shall not be reinstated in service. He shall, however, be entitled to post retirement benefits including pension, gratuity and consequential benefits. In case there is any deficiency in the qualifying service of the petitioner, he shall be notionally reinstated for the purpose of granting pension. However, he is not entitled to back wages. No order as to costs. (J.N. BURMA ) (SUNIL HALI) MEMBER (A) MEMBER (J) New Delhi 16.02.2016
Alert