- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
R.K. Roy v. East Central Railway
CIC/OP/A/2009/000292-AD Dated January 4, 2010 Name of the Applicant : Shri R.K.Roy Name of the Public Authority : East Central Railway, Danapur Background
1. The Applicant filed an RTI application dt.16.3.09 with the PIO, ECR, Danapur requesting for a certified copy of letter dt.5.4.91 which according to ADRM, Danapur is the offer of appointment issued by SPO(Con) and duly accepted by the Applicant. He also sought clarifications against other points in his RTI application. The PIO replied on 1.4.09 enclosing the letter dt.30.3.09 received from by DPO, Danapur furnishing point wise information. Not satisfied with the reply, the Applicant filed an appeal dt.9.4.09 with the Appellate Authority stating that reply is incomplete, misleading and irrelevant as he had not sought information on schedule of power on Establishment Matters. Shri Radhey Raman, Appellate Authority replied on 14.5.09 stating that the Applicant had asked information in connection with his DAR case and that the PIO vide letter dt.1.4.09 had sent the relevant reply to him from the concerned department. He added that he had gone through the appeal and it was found that reply from concerned department enclosing copy of letter dt.5.4.91 as demanded by the Applicant has already been sent by the PIO. The Applicant in his RTI application has sought the explanation/opinion of the officials on various points related to order passed by Appellate Authority while disposing his appeal in a DA&R case. He added that he is of the view that giving of opinion of the officials on the matter i.e giving answer to questions raised by Applicant does not come in the ambit of RTI Act. Therefore, opinion of officials against queries raised by the Applicant cannot be given to the Applicant. Being aggrieved with the reply, the Applicant filed a second appeal dt.26.5.09 before CIC stating that it is unbecoming of a Govt./Railway Servant to say that offer of acceptance is the appointment letter and not the real appointment letter dt.21.9.92. He also added that before 21.9.92, he did not hold any civil post in Railways nor was he a railway-man and hence any order passed before that date does not attract the provisions of article 311 of the Constitution of India. He also questioned the reason for the Appellate Authority not taking into account the appointment letter dated 21.9.92 according to which the Chief Engineer is the Appointing Authority and only thereafter provisions of article 311 of the Constitution apply to the case of the Appellant.
2. The Bench of Mrs. Annapurna Dixit, Information Commissioner, scheduled the hearing for January 4, 2010.
3. Shri Manoj Kumar, Sr.DPO & PIO represented the Public Authority.
4. The Appellant was heard through audio conferencing. Decision
5. The PIO, Shri Manoj Kumar submitted that the Appellant as per rules was removed from service by a Sr. Scale Officer and that the Appointing Authority for the Appellant was accordingly also of the same rank . He further added that a Sr. Scale Officer is eligible for appointing and removing officials of the rank of the Appellant and that a senior officer of the rank of a Chief Engineer is not required to take the decision.
6. The Commission after hearing the submission made by both sides directs the PIO to provide an affidavit to the Appellant stating that the reply given by the PIO on 1.4.09 based on the information provided by DPO dt.30.3.09 is complete and as per rules and as available on record. The affidavit should reach the Appellant by 11.2.2010 and the Appellant is directed to submit a compliance report by 18.2.2010.
7. The appeal is accordingly disposed of. (Annapurna Dixit) Information Commissioner Authenticated true copy: (G.Subramanian) Deputy Registrar
1. Shri R.K.Roy Jr. Engineer/P-Way Janaki Niwas Road No.2 Dwarika Puri Hanuman Nagar Patna 800 020
2. The PIO East Central Railway Divisional Railway Managers Office Danapur Division Danapur
3. The Appellate Authority East Central Railway Divisional Railway Managers Office Danapur Division Danapur
4. Officer incharge, NIC
5. Press E Group, CIC
Alert