- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sanjiv Seth v. North Eastern Railway
***** No.CIC/OK/A/2006/00323 Dated: 3 January 2007 Name of the Complainant Shri Sanjiv Seth Railway Banglow No.-120 Opposite Loco Ground Dairy Railway Colony Gorakhpur (U.P.)-273012 Name of the Public Authority : North Eastern Railway Background: The Appellant Sh. Sanjiv Seth requested the PIO, North Eastern Railway, Gorakhpur vide his application dated 3.3.06 for photocopies of certain documents regarding the selection proceedings held on 15.4.98 for the post of CAN Group B. The main information desired was the letter issued by the Railway Administration, Chief Personnel Office to Sh. Tarun Verma, Railway Advocate. The appellant filed an appeal before the First Appellate Authority on 3.5.06, as there was no response from the PIO. The Appellate Authority declined to furnish the information in view of Section 8(vi) vide order dated 7.6.06.
2. The Appellant, therefore, filed an appeal before the Central Information Commission on 12.7.06. The Commission vide letter dated 12.9.06 invited comments of the PIO and the Appellant was also requested to file his rejoinder. The PIO vide his letter no. S.No./RTI/IR-2006/39/loose 12.10.06 reiterated their stand that the information could not be furnished under section 8(vi) of the rti act. It was further stated that Sh. Rajiv Seth, younger brother of the Appellant has filed a case in the High Court and the documents requested for were confidential in nature. If the information was furnished, there was an apprehension of attack on the concerned officers.
3. The hearing of the aforesaid was fixed on 4th January, 2007 before the Bench of Dr. O.P. Kejariwal, Information Commissioner. Decision:
4. Since neither the Appellant nor the Respondent turn up for the hearing, the Commission decided to close the case and dispose of the application.
5. The Commission ordered accordingly. Sd/- (O.P. Kejariwal) Information Commissioner Authenticated true copy: Sd/- (Pankaj K.P. Shreyaskar) Assistant Registrar
1. Shri Sanjeev Seth, Railway Banglow No.129, Opposite Loco Ground Dairy, Railway Colony, Gorakhpur-273012
2. Shri Suresh Majhi, Dy Chief Personnel Officer IR & PIO, North Eastern Railway, Gorakhpur (UP)
3. Officer Incharge, NIC
4. Press E Group, CIC
Alert