Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Larry Lee Mccallister v. Pangea3 Legal Database Systems Pvt. Ltd.

Competition Commission Of India
Nov 6, 2013
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This information was filed under section 19(1)(a) of the Competition Act, 2002 by Mr. Larry Lee Mccallister ("the informant") against M/s Pangea3 Legal Database Systems Pvt. Ltd. and two senior employees of the company, alleging contravention of sections 3 and 4 of the Act. The informant, an American citizen, was employed as Assistant Vice-President, Litigation Solutions with OP1, a dominant player in the Indian Legal Process Outsourcing industry. The informant resigned on 12.07.2013, after which OP2 reminded him of a non-compete clause in his employment contract restricting him from joining any competitor for one year post-termination. The informant challenged this clause as a violation of the Competition Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the non-compete clause in the employment contract of the informant amounts to an abuse of dominance under the Competition Act, 2002.
  2. Whether the employment contract and its restrictive clause fall within the scope of the relevant service market for assessing dominance and competition issues.

Arguments of the Parties

Informant's Arguments

  • OP1 is a dominant player in the market for high quality outsourced legal solutions.
  • The non-compete clause in the employment contract constitutes an abuse of dominance under sections 3 and 4 of the Competition Act.

Commission's Observations

  • The employment contract is a contract between an individual and an enterprise, and does not involve a relevant service market as contemplated under the Act.
  • The position of strength of OP1 in the outsourced legal solutions market is unrelated to the terms of the employment contract.
  • The non-compete clause in an employment contract does not raise competition issues as the employee negotiates salary and terms accordingly.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Commission analyzed the nature of the contract between the informant and OP1, emphasizing that it is a personal employment contract rather than a contract involving a service market. The Commission held that the concept of dominance and relevant market applies to service providers offering services to a broad customer base, which is not the case here. The non-compete clause restricts the informant from joining competitors post-employment, but such clauses are negotiated at the time of employment and do not amount to anti-competitive conduct. The Commission concluded that no prima facie case of abuse of dominance or competition violation was made out.

Holding and Implications

The Commission closed the matter under section 26(2) of the Competition Act, 2002 for lack of any competition issues. The decision directly affects the parties by rejecting the informant's allegations and does not set any new legal precedent.

Show all summary ...

Case No.66 of 2013

Mr. Larry Lee Mccallister Informant And

M/s Pangea3 Legal Database Systems Pvt. Ltd. Opposite Party 1 Office 403, Shiv Tower , 14, Patto Plaza Panaji, Goa - 403001 Mr. Christopher Wheeler Opposite Party 2

Vice President, Litigation Solutions,

M/s Pangea3 Legal Database Systems Pvt. Ltd. Mr. UmairMuhajir Opposite Party 3

Vice President, Global Litigation Solutions M/s Pangea3 Legal Database Systems Pvt. Ltd.

CORAM:

Mr. Ashok Chawla Chairperson

Dr.Geeta Gouri Member

Mr.Anurag Goel Member

Mr. M. L. Tayal Member

Mr. Justice (Retd.) S. N. Dhingra Member

Mr. S.L. Bunker

Member

1

Order under Section 26 (2) of Competition Act 2002

The present information has been filed under section 19(1)(a) of the Competition Act, 2002 ('the Act') by Mr. Larry Lee Mccallister ('the informant') against M/s Pangea3 Legal Database Systems Pvt. Ltd. (OP1), Mr. Christopher Wheeler, Vice President, Litigation Solutions, M/s Pangea3 Legal Database Systems Pvt. Ltd. (OP2) and Mr. Umair Muhajir, Vice President, Global Litigation Solutions, M/s Pangea3 Legal Database Systems Pvt. Ltd. (OP3) alleging inter alia contravention of the provisions of sections 3 and 4 of the Act.

2. The informant an American citizen, wasworking as an expatriate with OP1, as Assistant Vice-President, Litigation Solutions. OP1 is stated to be a market leader in the Indian Legal Process Outsourcing industry having offices in Mumbai, Noida, Bangalore, and New York etc., and is owned and controlled by Thomson Reuters. OP 2and 3 are senior employees of OP1.

3. The informant sent his resignation notice to the OPs on 12.07.2013 through official email. However, while accepting the informant's resignation, OP No. 2 in his reply through email dated 12.073.2013 reminded the informant about his employment contract and particularly the non-compete clause according to which the Informant could not join any competitor firm of OP's for a period of one year following the date of termination of the agreement.

2

4. The informant aggrieved by the following clause in his Employment Agreement dated 10.01.2011, has presented this information alleging violation of the provisions of Competition Act.

5. The Commission had heard the informant and considered the material placed by informant before the Commission by way of information. The informant claimed OP-1 to be a dominant player in the market of high quality outsourced legal solutions. He claimed that OP-1 was providing outsourced legal solutions to most reputed companies and law firms and was a dominant player in the field. The informant alleged abuse of dominance by OP-1 because OP-1 entered into an employment contract with the informant with aforesaid clause. The employment contract has nothing to do with the market of providing outsourced legal solutions. Any service provider has to buy equipments and recruit people for providing services and this has nothing to do with his dominance in service market. The Commission, therefore, considers that the position of strength, if any, of OP-1 in the market of providing legal out sourced solutions has nothing to do with the employment contract which OP-1 entered into with the informant. The contract of providing service by an 'expert' to an employer is a contract of an individual with an enterprise or a firm. No relevant service market is involved in this. The issue of dominance in the relevant market thus would not arise. The issue of relevant service market arises only where there is a service provider who provides service to one and all who pay for the service. A person who seeks employment with an enterprise tends to seek maximum salary in lieu of his service to be provided to the

3

enterprise. Once he enters into contract of employment with the enterprise, he is not a service provider to one and all, nor can his service be purchased by other competitors of the enterprise, so long as he is in employment of that enterprise. All consultants/experts who seek employment negotiate the terms of employment in the very beginning. If an expert is unique kind of expert and is much sought after, he is able to dictate his terms at the time of employment and reverse is also possible where the kind of employee the company is seeking is easily available and there are lot many people seeking job, than the company is able to dictate its terms. In such contracts, no issue of competition arises. A clause in service contract restricting an employee from taking employment with the competitors, after he leaves the employment, for a particular period, raises no competition issue. The employee who enters into such contract negotiates his salary/pay package accordingly and takes into calculations even the period for which he would not be able to provide his expertise to competitors.

6. The case raised no competition issues. The Commission is of the view that no prima facie case was made out for intervention of the Commission. The matter deserves to be closed under section 26(2) of the Act.

4

7. The Secretary is directed to inform the parties accordingly. New Delhi Sd/-

Dated: 06/11/2013 (Ashok Chawla)

Chairperson

Sd/-

(Dr.Geeta Gouri)

Member

Sd/-

(Anurag Goel)

Member

Sd/-

(M.L. Tayal)

Member

Sd/-

Justice (Retd.) S. N. Dhingra

Member

Sd/-

(S.L. Bunker)

Member

5