- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S Idea Cellular Ltd. v. Cce, Meerut - I .
Per. Rakesh Kumar :- The appellant are providing the taxable service of mobile tele communication. 1.1 In appeal No. ST/641/2009 (SM) there are two issues involved with regard to Cenvat credit in respect of input services. (a) whether insurance of the appellants vehicles, laptop and insurance for cash during its transit from the cash collection centres to the bank can be treated as input service. The service tax denied in respect of this service is Rs. 11,401/- ; (b) whether the service of catering received by the appellant for serving tea and snacks to the staff through an outdoor caterer can be treated as input service. The Cenvat credit denied in respect of this service is Rs. 4,163/-. 1.2 In the appeal No. ST/642/2009 (SM), the following three issues in respect of Cenvat credit are involved :- (a) whether the service of customer care and attending to the customers complaints received from M/s Sanchay, a call centre, can be treated as input service. The service provider has paid the service tax on this service under heading business auxiliary service. According to the department this service cannot be treated as input service and service tax credit denied is Rs. 1,11,935/-; (b) whether the service of mandap keeper availed by hiring of conference room of the hotels for training of the staff can be treated as input service. The Cenvat credit denied in respect of this service Rs. 290/- ; (c) whether the service tax paid on supply of audio-video equipment for employee welfare purposes is eligible for Cenvat credit. The service tax credit denied in respect of this issue is Rs. 5,214/-. 1.3 In both the appeals, the Commissioner (Appeals) has also uphold the penalty of Rs. 2,500/- each imposed on the appellant under Rule 15 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004.
2. Heard both the sides. 2.1 Shri Hemant Bajaj, Advocate, the learned Counsel for the appellant, pleaded that all the five services mentioned above are covered by the definitions of input service, that the same are the services in relation to the business of the appellant, that in respect of service of insurance for transit of cash from the collection centres to the bank, he relies upon the judgments of the Tribunal in the cases of CCE, Raipur vs. Raipur Rotocast Ltd. reported in 2010 (18) S.T.R. 466 (Tri. Del.) and Monnet Ispat & Energy Ltd. vs. CCE, Raipur reported in 2010 (19) S.T.R. 417 (Tri. Del.), that the insurance of cash during transit and other valuable goods would be done by any prudent businessman and, therefore, this service is the service in relation to business of the appellant, that as regards the catering service, the same is also eligible for Cenvat credit and in this regard he relies upon the judgment of Honble Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench) in the case of The CCE, Nagpur vs. Ultratech Cement Ltd. and ors. reported in 2010 TIOL 745 HC MUM ST and also the judgment of Honble High Court of Judicature at Bombay in the case of Coca Cola India Pvt. Ltd. vs. CCE, Pune III reported in 2009 (242) E.L.T. 168 (Bom.), that tea and snacks are served to the staff through an outdoor caterer so that staff does not waste time in going out for the same and thus, this service has to be treated as activity connected with the business of the appellant, that the ground in the impugned order for denying credit in respect of this service, that the invoices are not in the name of the appellant was not there in the show cause notice, that even this ground is not correct as the earlier name of the appellant company was M/s Escotel Mobile Communication Ltd., the name in which the invoices have been issued by the service providers, that the customer care service on which the service provider had paid the service tax as business auxiliary service is an essential service for any tele communication service provider as the customers grievance and complaints have to be attended to, that the audio video equipment had been hired for the employee welfare which is also the service in relation to the business of the appellant, that Mandap keeper service had been availed in course of hiring of a conference room in hotels for arranging training for their staff, that the Cenvat credit of these service has, therefore, been correctly availed and the impugned order upholding the denial of Cenvat credit in respect of the same and also upholding the penalty is not correct. 2.2 Shri R.K. Gupta, the learned Departmental Representative defended the impugned order by reiterating the findings of the Commissioner (Appeals) and emphasized that :- (a) so far as the service called employee welfare is concerned in respect of which the Cenvat credit of Rs. 5,214/- has been taken, the invoices show that this service tax had been paid on the supply of audio video equipment which does not appear to be a service and that in any case the receiving audio video equipment from a supplier has nothing to do with the provider of tele communication service by the appellant ; (b) the customer care service received from a call centre cannot be said to be an input service for the appellant ; and (c) with regard to the outdoor catering service in respect of which Cenvat credit amount involved is Rs. 4,163/- the invoices issued by M/s Gulati Tiffin Centre do not even show the service tax and for this reason also no credit would be available.
3. I have carefully considered the submissions from both the sides and perused the records.
4. As regards the service of insurance for the valuables and the transit of cash from the collection centres to the bank, I am of the view that any prudent businessman will arrange the insurance for the same and hence this service has to be treated as activity relating to business and earlier the Tribunal in the case of Monnet Ispat & Energy Ltd. vs. CCE, Raipur (supra) and CCE, Raipur vs. Raipur Rotocast Ltd. (supra) has also taken the same view holding that the service of insurance of machinery, capital goods and cash in transit is covered by the definition of input service. In view of this, I hold that the Commissioner (Appeals)s order denying the Cenvat credit in respect of insurance service is not correct and the same is liable to be set aside.
5. As regards the service of customer care and attending to customers complaints, the same is also essential for any telecom service provider and the Commissioner (Appeals)s findings that the same is not covered by the definition of input service are not correct. In my view, this service is squarely covered the term activities related to business. Therefore, the Commissioner (Appeals)s order denying the service tax credit in respect of this service is not correct and the same is liable to be set aside.
6. As regards the service tax credit of Rs. 5,214/- in respect of employee welfare expenses, I find that this credit has been taken on the basis of the invoice of M/s Chitra Pal Audio Private Ltd. and the invoice indicates supply of audio visual equipment. Invoice does not indicate whether the invoice is for service or is for sale of the goods. In view of this, I agree with the findings of the Commissioner (Appeals) that the Cenvat credit is not available on the basis of this invoice.
7. As regards the Cenvat credit of Rs. 290/- denied in respect of hotel expenses, the appellants contention is that the same had been paid on the charges for hiring of conference room of hotel for the staff training. The service received is in the nature of mandap keeper service and according to the appellant, the conference room of the hotel has been used for conducting training courses for the staff and business development. There is no finding in the impugned order as to how this service cannot be treated as activity related to the business and hence the Commissioner (Appeals)s order denying this credit is not correct and the same is liable to be set aside.
8. As regards, the service of outdoor catering i.e. supply of tea and snacks for the staff in respect of which service tax denied is Rs. 4,163/-, while Bombay High Court in the case of The CCE, Nagpur vs. Ultratech Cement Ltd. and ors. (supra) has held that the service of outdoor caterer is integrally connected with the business of the manufacturing of final product, on going through the invoices of the service provider it is seen that the invoices do not even indicate the payment of any service tax and the invoices appear to be just for supply of food and drinks. In view of this, I uphold the Commissioner (Appeals)s finding regarding denial of credit in respect of this item.
9. In view of the above discussion, while the Commissioner (Appeals)s order denying (a) Cenvat credit of Rs. 290/- in respect of hiring of conference room of the hotels, (b) Cenvat credit of Rs. 1,11,935/- in respect of service of customer care and attending to the customers grievances received from M/s Sanchay, and (c) the Cenvat credit of Rs. 11,401/- in respect of insurance charges for valuables and cash in transit is set aside, the Commissioner (Appeals)s order in respect of the remaining services is upheld. As regards, the penalty, the same is attracted whenever any wrong Cenvat credit has been taken and as such, the penalty of Rs. 2,500/- each is moderate and hence the same is upheld. The appeal stands disposed of, as above. (Dictated and pronounced in open court.) (Rakesh Kumar) Member (Technical)
Alert