Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

B. Srikanta Murthy v. Director Of Public Instructions

Karnataka High Court
Jan 19, 2016

1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

DATED THIS THE 19THDAY OF JANUARY 2016

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE N.K.PATIL

AND

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP D. WAINGANKAR REVIEW PETITION No.415 of 2014

IN

WRIT APPEAL NO.4085/2011 (S-PRO) BETWEEN:-

SRI. B. SRIKANTA MURTHY

AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS

S/O SRI. BASAVANNA R/AT. NO.119, DAYA MARGA

I STAGE, SIDDARTHANAGAR

MYSORE-570 011.

... PETITIONER

(BY SRI: T.N. RAGHUPATHY, ADVOCATE)

AND:-

1. THE DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC

INSTRUCTIONS (HIGH SCHOOL)

OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PUBLIC OFFICES

K.R.CIRCLE, BANGALORE-560 001.

2. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS

MYSORE DIVISION, MYSORE.

3. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS

MYSORE DISTRICT, MYSORE.

4. THE SECRETARY

ASHOKA VIDYA SAMASTHE

106, 4THSTAGE

1

KUVEMPUNAGAR (KHB)

J.T.KOPPAL, MYSORE-570 023.

5. SRI. T.N. SRIKANTAMURTHY

MAJOR, FATHER'S NAME NOT

KNOWN TO THE APPELLANT

PRESENTLY WORKING AS

HEAD MASTER

SRI. SIDDESHWARA HIGH SCHOOL

GOKULAM, MYSORE.

... RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI: VASANTH V. FERNANDEZ, HCGP FOR R1 - R3

SRI: VIJAY V. BAJANTRI, ADVOCATE, FOR R5

NOTICE TO R-4 DISPENSED WITH V/O/DT:29.10.2015)

THIS REVIEW PETITION IS FILED UNDER ORDER 47

RULE 1 OF CPC, PRAYING TO REVIEW THE ORDER DATED

13/05/2014 PASSED IN WA No.4085/2011, ON THE FILE OF THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, BANGALORE.

THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND

RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT ON 17.12.2015 AND COMING ON

FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDER THIS DAY, PRADEEP D.

WAINGANKAR J., MADE THE FOLLOWING:

ORDER

This review petition is filed to review the judgment dated 13.05.2014 passed in W.A.No.4085/2011.

2. The petitioner-B. Srikantamurthy and respondent No.5-T.N. Srikantamurthy were appointed as Assistant Teachers in Siddeshwara High School, Mysore, run by Ashoka Vidya Samsthe, Mysore, a Private Educational Trust under the same order of appointment. Both of them joined the school as

2

Assistant Teachers on 02.06.1986 forenoon. The appointment of the petitioner was approved by the Government on 30.10.1990 and appointment of the respondent No.5 was approved on 17.09.1990. Both of them were granted Government salary on 23.07.1994. The date of birth of the petitioner is 28.11.1955, whereas that of respondent No.5 is 11.05.1960. When such being the case, the Management of the school passed a resolution for promotion on respondent No.5 to the post of the Head Master of the High School instead of petitioner and forwarded the resolution for approval of respondent No.1-the Director of Public Instructions (High School), who inturn accorded approval of promotion of respondent No.5 as Head Master by 25.09.2001. Petitioner being elder in age, aggrieved by the promotion of respondent No.5, preferred Writ Petition No.15821/2004 before the learned Single Judge. The Writ Petition came to be dismissed. Against the dismissal of the Writ Petition, the petitioner preferred Writ Appeal No.4085/2011. The Writ Appeal came to be dismissed by judgment dated 13.05.2014 on the ground

3

that the appointment of respondent No.5 was approved on 17.09.1990 earlier to the approval of the appointment of the petitioner on 30.10.1990. Therefore, the petitioner has filed this review petition seeking review of the judgment.

3. The grounds on which the review is filed is that though both of them were appointed on the same day, under the same order and joined the school on the same day and the services of respondent No.5 were approved by the Government earlier to the approval of the services of the petitioner, the approval will be effective from the date of the appointment.

4. It has been held in ILR 2000 KAR 4045 by the Division Bench of this Court in case of State of Karnataka and Others vs. B.R. Chowdappa and Others that once the appointment is approved, it will be effective from the date of appointment. If we go by this proposition of law, since both the petitioner and respondent No.5 were appointed on the same day, the approval of their appointment will be effective from the date of appointment. In that case, since the petitioner is elder in age than respondent No.5, as per the rules, the

4

petitioner ought to have been promoted to the post of Head Master. As such, the judgment dismissing the writ appeal requires to be recalled by allowing the review petition.

5. For the reasons stated above, the review petition is allowed. The judgment dated 13.05.2014 in W.A.No.4085/2011 is hereby recalled. The W.A.No.4085/2011 is allowed. The order passed by the learned Single Judge and respondent No.1-the competent authority promoting respondent No.5 as Head Master of the school are set aside directing the Management of the school to promote petitioner as the Head Master of the school. However, respondent No.1 shall not be entitled to recover the monetary benefit received by respondent No.5 in view of his promotion to the post of Head Master till the date of retirement of the petitioner. The management of the school is directed to pass a necessary resolution promoting the petitioner as Head Master of the school and forward the same to respondent No.1-competent authority for approval. The

5

petitioner shall only be entitled for retirement benefits based on the Head Master's scale for which he was entitled as on the date of his retirement.

Sd/-

JUDGE

Sd/-

JUDGE

PMR

6