Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shalimar Chemical Works Limited v. Usha Holding & Enclave Private Limited & Anr.

Calcutta High Court
Feb 29, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit for eviction filed by Usha Holding & Enclave Private Limited & Others against Krishna Gopal Mondal, the tenant, on multiple grounds including failure to vacate after giving notice, default in rent payment, unauthorized sub-letting, acts of waste, and the plaintiffs' requirement of the premises for building purposes. The tenant filed an application expressing willingness to vacate but did not contest the suit by filing a written statement. The hearing concluded before the tenant's death, and an ex parte eviction decree was passed thereafter. The appellant, claiming to be a sub-tenant under the deceased tenant, challenged the executability of the decree on grounds of nullity and fraud. The executing court and the first appellate court rejected the objection, leading to this second miscellaneous appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appeal involves any substantial question of law warranting admission under Order XLI Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  2. Whether the ex parte eviction decree passed against the deceased tenant is a nullity for lack of judicial satisfaction on grounds under Section 6 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997.
  3. Whether the appellant, as a non-notified sub-tenant, has locus to challenge the legality and executability of the eviction decree under Section 47 read with Order 21 Rule 101 of the Civil Procedure Code.
  4. Whether the appellant is entitled to challenge the rejection of its application for addition as a party in the eviction suit under Section 105 of the Civil Procedure Code.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The ex parte eviction decree is a nullity as the court did not record satisfaction regarding the existence of any grounds under Section 6 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997.
  • The appellant, as a sub-tenant, is directly affected by the decree and thus has the right to challenge its executability.
  • The appellant's application for addition as a party in the eviction suit was wrongly rejected; under Section 105 of the Civil Procedure Code, the appellant is entitled to challenge this rejection.
  • Relied on the Supreme Court decision in Ishwar Dass Jain (Dead) Through LRS. v. Sohan Lal (Dead) By LRS (2000) 1 SCC 434 to support the right to challenge the order of rejection for addition of party.

Respondent's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ishwar Dass Jain (Dead) Through LRS. v. Sohan Lal (Dead) By LRS (2000) 1 SCC 434 Right to challenge rejection of application for addition of party under Section 105 of the Civil Procedure Code. The court noted the precedent but ultimately held that the appellant, being a non-notified sub-tenant, had no locus to challenge the decree or the rejection of party addition in this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first examined whether any substantial question of law arises under Order XLI Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure to admit the appeal. It noted that the eviction suit was based on valid grounds, including the tenant's failure to vacate after giving notice to quit, which was duly proved. The tenant appeared but did not contest, and filed an application expressing intent to vacate. The court found that the decree passed after hearing was not a nullity, even though it was ex parte, as the tenant died only after the hearing but before the decree was passed, which is protected under Order 22 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Code.

Regarding the appellant's locus, the court held that the appellant does not claim to be a notified sub-tenant and under the Tenancy Act scheme, a non-notified sub-tenant lacks the right to contest the eviction suit. Consequently, the decree against the tenant binds the sub-tenant, and the appellant has no locus to challenge the decree's legality or executability.

The court also considered the appellant's contention about the rejection of its application for addition as a party but found no ground to admit the appeal on this basis.

Accordingly, the court endorsed the findings of the lower courts and declined to admit the appeal for hearing.

Holding and Implications

The court dismissed the appeal and declined to admit it for hearing under the provision of Order XLI Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

The direct effect of this decision is the affirmation of the executability of the eviction decree against the deceased tenant, thereby denying the appellant, a non-notified sub-tenant, the right to challenge it. No new precedent was set, and the decision confirms the binding nature of eviction decrees on sub-tenants who are not formally notified under the Tenancy Act.

Show all summary ...

Jyotirmay Bhattacharya, J.:— Leave is granted to the learned advocate-on-record of the appellant to rectify the defects in terms of the report of the Stamp Reporter.

2. This second miscellaneous appeal is directed against the judgement and order dated 8th June, 2015 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Alipore, South 24-Parganas in Miscellaneous Appeal No. 544 of 2013 by affirming the judgement and order being No. 145 dated 3rd December, 2013 passed by the learned 2nd Civil Judge (Junior Division) at Alipore in Miscellaneous Case No. 849 of 2008 at the instance of the objector/appellant.

3. Let us now consider the merit of the appeal to find out as to whether any substantial question of law is involved in this appeal for which the appeal is required to be admitted for hearing under the provision of Order XLI Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure or not.

4. Usha Holding & Enclave Private Limited & Others being plaintiffs filed a suit for eviction against Krishna Gopal Mondal on various grounds viz. -

(i) The tenant after giving six months notice dated 30 June, 2006 intimating his landlords to vacate and/or give up possession of the tenanted premises i.e suit premises in favour of the plaintiffs, failed and neglected to deliver up possession of the suit property in terms of the said notice.

(ii) Default in payment of rent.

(iii) The defendant/tenant is guilty of sub-letting and/or inducting unauthorised persons in the tenanted premises without the consent of the plaintiffs.

(iv) The defendant/tenant committed various acts of waste.

(v) Plaintiffs reasonably require the tenanted premises for building and rebuilding.

5. The defendant/tenant appeared in the said suit and filed an application on 11 July, 2007 mentioning therein that the defendant being the tenant under the plaintiffs is interested in giving up his possession in the tenancy in favour of the plaintiffs. He did not file any written statement to contest the said suit. As such, the suit proceeded with for the ex parte hearing. Hearing of the said suit was concluded on 27 July, 2007 and 3 August, 2007 was fixed for passing judgement in the said suit.

6. The defendant viz. Krishna Gopal Mondal died on 21st August, 2007 after conclusion of the hearing of the suit. The ex parte decree was passed on 30 May, 2008. The decree for eviction was passed by the learned Trial Judge on the ground that the tenant having given notice to quit and vacate his tenancy, failed to vacate the suit premises and as such, the plaintiffs are entitled to get a decree for eviction. The learned Trial Judge also held that service of notice by the tenant upon his landlords intimating his intention to vacate the suit premises has also been proved.

7. The appellant herein filed an application under Section 47 read with Order 21 Rule 101 of the Civil Procedure Code challenging the executability of the said decree on the ground of nullity. According to the appellant, the said decree is vitiated by fraud. The appellant claimed itself as sub-tenant under the defendant/tenant. The appellant claimed that its sub-tenancy was created in 1946 i.e prior to the commencement of West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1956.

8. The learned Executing Court rejected the objector's said objection against executability of the said decree. Hence, it filed a first miscellaneous appeal before the learned Appeal Court. The said appeal having been dismissed by the learned Appeal Court, the instant second miscellaneous appeal has been filed.

9. Though the objector/appellant contended that the decree having been passed against a dead person is a nullity and such challenge was rejected by the learned Executing Court which was also affirmed in appeal, but in course of hearing of this appeal, Mr. Roy Chowdhury, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant in his usual fairness submits that he will not press the said ground of challenge as it is apparent from the record that the original tenant died after conclusion of hearing of the eviction proceeding, but before passing of the decree. As such, the landlord is protected under the provision of Order 22 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Code.

10. Mr. Roy Chowdhury strenuously argues before us that the ex parte decree which was passed in the said suit is a nullity as, such a decree for eviction was passed by the court without recording its satisfaction as to existence of any of the grounds as mentioned in Section 6 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997. He further contends that his client being a sub-tenant has every right to challenge the executability of the said decree as it is his client who is only affected by the said ex parte decree.

11. Mr. Roy Chowdhury further submits that even though his client's application for addition of party in the suit was rejected by the learned Trial Judge and the same was affirmed by this Court in its revisional jurisdiction, but still then in view of the provision contained in Section 105 of the Civil Procedure Code, his client is entitled to challenge the legality of the said order of rejection of his client's application for addition of party in the suit passed by the learned Trial Judge. In this regard, he has also referred to a decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Ishwar Dass Jain (Dead) Through LRS. v. Sohan Lal (Dead) By LRS. reported in (2000) 1 SCC 434. He thus invites us to admit this appeal for hearing under the provision of Order 41 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

12. Let us now consider the acceptability of such contention of Mr. Roy Chowdhury, learned senior counsel in the facts of the present case.

13. Here is the case where we find that an eviction suit was filed by the landlords against their tenant on several grounds including a ground that the tenant after giving notice to quit the suit premises to the landlords, has failed to vacate the suit premises. For maintaining a suit on this ground, no further notice of suit was required to be served. The learned Trial Judge found that the notice to quit was duly served by the tenant upon his landlords. The tenant appeared in the said suit, but did not file any written statement to contest the same. On the contrary, the tenant filed an application in the said suit mentioning his intention to vacate the suit premises in favour of his landlords viz. the plaintiffs. Such being the position, we hold that the decree which was passed by the learned Trial Judge after recording satisfaction about the said ground cannot be held to be a nullity.

14. Let us now consider the locus of the objector/appellant to maintain the said proceeding under Section 47 read with Order 21 Rule 101 of the Civil Procedure Code.

15. Admittedly the objector/appellant does not claim itself to be a notified sub-tenant. A non-notified sub-tenant has not been given any right to contest the suit under the Scheme of the Tenancy Act. It is well settled that the decree which is passed against a tenant is binding upon the sub-tenant. As such, a non-notified sub-tenant, in our view, has no locus to challenge the legality and/or executability of the decree passed in the said eviction suit. We, thus, fully endorse the views of the learned courts below and hold that the courts below rightly rejected the objector's application and/or first miscellaneous appeal as mentioned above.

16. Accordingly, we do not find involvement of any substantial question of law in this appeal for which the appeal is required to be admitted. We thus decline to admit this appeal for hearing under the provision of Order XLI Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

17. The appeal thus stands dismissed.

Re: CAN 9808 of 2015 (Stay)

18. Since we have not admitted the appeal under the provision of Order XLI Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, no further order need be passed on the interim application for stay. The said application being CAN 9808 of 2015 is thus deemed to be disposed of.

19. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be given to the parties as expeditiously as possible.