- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Om Prakash And Anr. Petitioners v. Delhi Jal Board
Case Summary: W.P.(C) 1132/2011 — OM PRAKASH & ANR. v. DELHI JAL BOARD
Factual and Procedural Background
The petition challenges an Industrial Tribunal-II award dated 22 February 2010 (ID No. 114/2008). Petitioner No.1 (Om Prakash) joined Delhi Jal Board on 1 June 1989 as a chowkidar and Petitioner No.2 (Bhagwati Prasad) joined on 10 November 1989 as a beldar. Their services were terminated with effect from 1 October 1991. The terminations were challenged before the Labour Court/Industrial Adjudicator, which, by an award dated 31 May 2001, held the terminations illegal and ordered reinstatement with 50% back wages. Despite reinstatement and payment of back wages, petitioners asserted that Delhi Jal Board did not regularize their services.
The Municipal Employees Union served a legal demand notice (22 November 2005) and, on failure of conciliation, the Government of NCT of Delhi referred the dispute to the Industrial Tribunal. The reference framed the question whether the petitioners' demand for regularization on their respective posts from the initial date of joining was legal and/or justified. The Industrial Tribunal held that petitioners could be considered for regularization under the management's regularization policy if they met its criteria, but they were not entitled to be regularized from their initial date of engagement (1989). This writ petition assails that Tribunal award.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether reinstatement "with immediate effect" (especially where back wages are awarded) necessarily entails continuity of service for all purposes such as computation of seniority and qualification for regularization.
- Whether the workmen are entitled to regularization on their respective posts from the initial date of joining (1989) as claimed by them.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- Reinstatement with 50% back wages implies that the workmen are deemed to be employed from the date of their initial appointment (1989) and thus continuity of service must be counted from that date for purposes such as regularization and seniority.
- Reliance on precedents (Vasantika R. Dalia and Gurpreet Singh) for the proposition that continuity of service follows reinstatement even if the award does not expressly use the phrase "continuity of service".
- Back wages up to 2 May 2005 have been paid pursuant to the prior award, indicating the practical effect of reinstatement; nowhere did the management plead there was a break in service or that pre-reinstatement service should be disregarded for regularization.
- Evidence (cross-examination of respondent's witness K.K. Sharma) admitted that the petitioners rendered continuous and uninterrupted service from initial appointment until termination on 1 October 1991.
- Information obtained under Right to Information indicated that persons engaged as beldar/chowkidar in 1989 who satisfied criteria were regularized w.e.f. 1 April 1995, suggesting differential treatment and supporting petitioners' claim for consideration from initial engagement.
- The Industrial Adjudicator adopted an overly technical approach by inferring denial of continuity from the phrase "with immediate effect" despite absence of any pleading to that effect by the respondent.
Respondent's Arguments
- The Industrial Tribunal's award contains no infirmity: the earlier award directing reinstatement did not direct reinstatement with continuity of service, and therefore no interference is warranted.
- The respondent's policy requires completion of prescribed attendance thresholds (240 days in a calendar year or 720 days in four years) for regularization; petitioners did not satisfy those thresholds prior to termination, so they are not entitled to regularization from their initial dates.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Secretary, State of Karnataka vs. Uma Devi and Ors., AIR 2006 SC 1806 | The opinion states the ratio of Uma Devi was "fully attracted" to the facts of the case (as noted by the Industrial Tribunal). | The Industrial Tribunal had relied on Uma Devi to conclude workmen could be considered for regularization under management policy if they met criteria, but not entitled to regularization from their initial dates. The High Court records that the Tribunal considered this precedent relevant to the dispute. |
| Vasantika R. Dalia vs. Baroda Municipal Corporation, (1997) 5 SLR 752 | Cited by petitioners for the proposition that continuity of service follows reinstatement and the absence of the word "continuity" in an award does not necessarily deny that relief. | The Court considered Vasantika R. Dalia in support of petitioners' contention that reinstatement inherently carries continuity unless continuity is specifically denied; the Court treated this precedent as persuasive on the point that continuity is a direct consequence of reinstatement in appropriate circumstances. |
| Gurpreet Singh vs. State of Punjab and Ors., (2002) 9 SCC 492 | Used to show that when reinstatement is directed after finding termination illegal, continuity of service cannot be denied as a matter of law (Supreme Court held continuity should follow reinstatement in that case). | The Court reproduced the Supreme Court's reasoning from Gurpreet Singh and relied on it to conclude that denial of continuity by implication is not warranted where reinstatement (with back wages) was ordered and there was no contrary pleading. |
| J.K. Synthetics Ltd. v. K.P. Agrawal and Anr., (2007) 2 SCC 433 | The two-judge bench statement referenced: it held there is a misconception that reinstatement automatically carries continuity of service and consequential benefits; courts must apply judicial mind before granting such consequences. | The Court noted J.K. Synthetics but observed that part of its observation (that continuity is not an automatic right on reinstatement) was contrary to ratios of certain three-judge bench decisions. The Court therefore treated the restrictive proposition in J.K. Synthetics as not good law in that respect. |
| Hindustan Tin Works (P) Ltd. vs. The Employees of Hindustan Tin Works (three-judge bench) [as cited] | The opinion quotes the three-judge bench to the effect that in industrial jurisprudence a declaration that termination is bad leads to the workman continuing in service; common law doctrines limiting specific enforcement do not apply the same way in this field. | The Court invoked this three-judge bench authority to support the proposition that reinstatement and continuity are consistent with industrial jurisprudence and that continuity may follow reinstatement where termination is held void. |
| Deepali GunduSurwase vs. Kranti Junior Adhyapak Mahavidyalaya (D.Ed.) and Ors., (2013) 10 SCC 324 | Considered for observations on entitlement to back wages and the legal consequences of reinstatement; discussed interaction of J.K. Synthetics and three-judge bench precedents. | The Court relied on observations in Deepali GunduSurwase to reconcile prior authorities and to justify that continuity of service may follow reinstatement; it used the case to support rejecting the narrow reading from J.K. Synthetics. |
| Rameshwar Singh & Anr. vs. Delhi Jal Board, 2014 SCC online Del 7335 | Recent single-judge and appellate consideration where muster-roll workers reinstated and later found entitled to regularization given long service; cited for analogous facts. | The Court observed that Rameshwar Singh was a stronger precedent for petitioners' position (muster roll workers reinstated and later regularized) and found the present case to be on an even better footing because of the record and absence of contrary pleading. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by identifying the core question: whether reinstatement "with immediate effect" equates to continuity of service (para 10). Noting that "reinstatement" is not defined in the Act or Rules, the Court examined dictionary definitions (Shorter Oxford, Law Lexicon, Merriam-Webster, Black's) to establish the ordinary meaning of "reinstate" and "reinstatement" as restoration to a former position or condition (paras 11–13).
The Court reviewed relevant authorities. It summarized the Supreme Court's decision in Gurpreet Singh, which held that continuity of service could not be denied where reinstatement was directed on setting aside termination, and reproduced the Supreme Court's reasoning to that effect (paras 13). The Court also considered Vasantika R. Dalia where a Division Bench held continuity of service to be a direct consequence of reinstatement where termination was void and continuity was not specifically denied (paras 14, 35).
The Court engaged with the tension in precedents: a two-judge bench in J.K. Synthetics had cautioned against automatically granting continuity/consequential benefits on reinstatement, but the Court observed (relying on Deepali GunduSurwase and three-judge bench authority such as Hindustan Tin Works) that the restrictive proposition in J.K. Synthetics is inconsistent with three-judge bench ratios and with the broader concept of reinstatement in industrial jurisprudence (paras 15–17, 36–44).
Applying those legal principles to the facts, the Court noted several key factual and procedural points:
- The Labour Court had ordered reinstatement "with immediate effect" and 50% back wages, and back wages had been paid (para 9, 18).
- The respondent had a departmental policy for regularization requiring specified attendance thresholds (240 days in a calendar year or 720 days in four years) (paras 3, 24, 51).
- The respondent did not plead any break in service or that the pre-reinstatement period should be excluded for purposes of regularization (para 19).
- RTI information produced by petitioners indicated that persons engaged as beldar/chowkidar in 1989 who satisfied departmental requirements were regularized w.e.f. 1 April 1995 (para 51).
On those bases the Court concluded: (a) the omission of the words "continuity of service" in the earlier award does not imply denial of that relief where reinstatement (with back wages) was ordered and no contrary pleading exists; (b) the Industrial Adjudicator had applied an overly technical interpretation by drawing an adverse inference from the phrase "with immediate effect" (paras 18–19); and (c) given the respondent's policy and the RTI material, there was no need to remand the matter back to the Industrial Tribunal (para 22).
Consequently the Court modified the Tribunal's order to direct the management to consider petitioners' cases for regularization on the basis of the departmental policy treating them as in continuous service from the date of engagement if they otherwise fulfill the policy criteria; the management was given eight weeks to consider the cases and the Registry was directed to send a copy of the judgment for compliance (para 22).
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The writ petition was disposed of by modifying the Industrial Tribunal's order. The Court directed that the respondent (Delhi Jal Board) will consider the petitioners' cases for regularization on their respective posts under the departmental policy, treating them as being in continuous service from the date of their engagement, if they otherwise fulfill the policy criteria. The management must consider the cases within eight weeks of receipt of the judgment and the Registry is to send a copy of the judgment for compliance (para 22). The petition stands disposed of accordingly (para 23).
Implications:
- Direct effect: Petitioners are to be considered for regularization by the management treating their service as continuous from date of engagement for purposes of meeting the departmental eligibility criteria, subject to actual fulfillment of those criteria within the policy (para 22).
- Procedure: No remand to the Industrial Tribunal was ordered; the Court itself modified the Tribunal's order and provided an eight-week period for the management to act (para 22).
- Broader precedent: The Court applied and reconciled several precedents on the legal consequences of reinstatement (notably Gurpreet Singh, Vasantika R. Dalia, Deepali GunduSurwase and authorities discussed therein) to hold that continuity of service may follow reinstatement where termination was void and continuity was not expressly denied and no contrary pleading exists. The judgment does not state that it establishes a new general principle beyond its application to the facts; it explains and applies existing authorities.
This summary is strictly based on the contents of the provided judicial opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.
W.P.(C) 1132/2011 Page 1 of 12 $~
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI Date of Decision: 7th October, 2015
+ W.P.(C) 1132/2011
OM PRAKASH AND ANR. ..... Petitioner Through: Mr Rajiv Agarwal and Mr Sachin Kumar, Advocates
versus
DELHI JAL BOARD ..... Respondent Through: Mr Rajesh Sachdeva and Ms Shobha Gupta, Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SUNITA GUPTA
J U D G M E N T
: SUNITA GUPTA, J.
1. Challenge in this writ petition is to the Award dated 22ndFebruary, 2010 passed by the Industrial Tribunal-II, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi in ID No. 114/2008 whereby it was held that the workman was entitled to be considered for regularization on their respective posts on the basis of policy of regularization followed by Management, if they fulfil the criteria for regularization but they are not entitled for regularization from initial date of their engagement, i.e., 1989.
2. The petitioner No.1 joined the services of the respondent w.e.f. 1st June, 1989 as a chowkidar while petitioner No.2 joined services of the respondent w.e.f. 10th November, 1989 as beldar. Services of both the petitioners (hereinafter referred to as "workmen") were terminated on 1st
1
October, 1991. The termination was challenged by the workmen and vide Award dated 31stMay, 2001, the termination was held to be illegal and unjustified. The workmen were held entitled for re-instatement in service with 50% back wages. It is the case of the workmen that despite reinstatement, the respondent failed to regularize their services. Therefore, the union of the workmen, namely, the Municipal Employees Union espoused the cause of the workmen for regularization and effected legal demand notice on 22ndNovember, 2005. As the management failed to respond to the legal demand notice, an industrial dispute was raised by the union by filing a statement of claim before the Conciliation Officer. On failure of conciliation proceedings, GNCT of Delhi referred the following dispute to the Industrial Tribunal:-
"Whether demand of (i) Sh. Om Prakash, S/o Sh. Bhairo Ram Chowkidar and (ii) Sh. Bhagwati Prasad, S/o Sh. Shiam Dutt Beldar for regularization on their respective posts from the initial date of joining is legal and/or justified/and if yes, to what relief they are entitled?"
3. The statement of claim was filed by the workmen before the Industrial Adjudicator alleging that they were entitled to be treated as regular and permanent employees from the initial date of their joining in proper pay scale and allowances on the principle of "equal pay for equal work" at par with their counter parts. A written statement was filed by the respondent disputing the claim of the workmen on the ground that the management has its own policy of regularization in phased manner according to which an employee should complete 240 days in one calendar year and 720 days in a period of four years. The workmen never worked for 240 days in any calendar year preceding to their alleged termination of service, hence they
2
are not entitled for regularization. Both the parties adduced their evidence. The Industrial Adjudicator came to a conclusion that vide award Ex.WW1/4, the workmen were ordered to be reinstated in service "with immediate effect" and, as such, there was nothing in the award that the workmen were actually to be reinstated with continuity of service. In the absence of such direction, the period of absence of the workmen after termination of their services till the date of reinstatement cannot be taken into consideration for the purpose of computing continuity and total service of the workmen.
4. It was further observed that the ratio of Secretary, State of Karnataka vs. Uma Devi and Ors., AIR 2006 SC 1806 is fully attracted to the facts of the present case. As per the case of the management, according to its policy of regularization of daily wagers/muster roll employees, an employee who has completed service of 720 days within a period of four years can be considered for regularization. Therefore, the workmen were entitled to be considered for regularization on their respective post on the basis of policy of regularization if they fulfil criteria set out in the policy. However, they were not entitled for regularization from the initial date of their engagement, i.e., 1989.
5. Assailing the findings of learned Industrial Tribunal, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that reinstatement of the workmen along with 50% of back wages implies that the workmen are deemed to be employed from the date of their initial appointment, i.e. 1989 and their seniority for the purpose of regularization has to be counted from that date. Relying upon
Vasantika R. Dalia vs. Baroda Municipal Corporation, (1997) 5 SLR 752 and Gurpreet Singh vs. State of Punjab and Ors., (2002) 9 SCC 492, it was
3
submitted that the mere fact that the word "continuity of service" has not been mentioned in the award does not mean that this relief was denied to the workmen. Once the workmen were directed to be reinstated in service along with back wages, the continuity of service is direct consequence. Back wages upto the period of 2ndMay, 2005 stands paid in terms of the award. Further, it was not even the case of the respondent/management that there was any break in service of the workmen and the period of services rendered by them before their reinstatement is not to be considered for the purpose of their regularization. This was never part of the pleadings and the parties were not at variance in regard to the issue. The learned Industrial Adjudicator of its own proceeded to consider the said issue which is contrary to the settled legal position. A very technical approach has been adopted by the Industrial Adjudicator.
6. Reference was also made to the cross-examination of the respondent's witness Sh. K.K. Sharma, who admitted that the workmen rendered continuous and uninterrupted service from their initial date of appointment till their services were terminated on 1stOctober, 1991. The counsel further submits that information was sought under Right to Information Act and the workmen were informed that the persons who were engaged with the management as Beldar/Chowkidar during the year 1989 have been regularized w.e.f. 1stApril, 1985 under the Phase Programme of 1989-90. Even the management's witness could not deny that the services of the chowkidar and beldar appointed after 1989 on muster roll have been regularized. As such, it was submitted that once the workmen were ordered to be reinstated in service with 50% back wages, it was to be treated as a case of reinstatement with continuity of service and, therefore, the matter be
4
remanded back to the Industrial Adjudicator for fresh decision.
7. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent submits that there is no infirmity in the award as there was no direction in the earlier award that the reinstatement was to be with continuity of service, therefore, no interference is called for.
8. I have given my considerable thoughts to the respective submissions of the learned counsel for the parties and have perused the record.
9. The dispute which was referred to the Industrial Tribunal by GNCT of Delhi was "Whether the workmen were entitled for regularization on their respective posts from the initial date of joining". It is not in dispute that the workman Om Prakash joined the management as Chowkidar on 1stJune, 1989 while Bhagwati Prasad joined as Beldar on 10th November, 1989 as a daily rated/casual muster roll worker. Their services were terminated w.e.f. 1stOctober, 1991. An industrial dispute was raised by the workmen. Matter was referred to the Labour Court. Vide award dated 31stMay, 2001, the termination was held to be illegal and the workmen were ordered to be reinstated in service "with immediate effect" and 50% back wages. Pursuant to this order, the workmen were reinstated in service and the back wages were also paid to them. Undisputedly, the respondent has a policy of regularization of daily wagers/muster roll employees. As per the policy, an employee who has rendered continuous service of 240 days in a calendar year or 720 days in a period of four years is entitled to be considered for regularization. However, it is the case of respondent that since the petitioners did not work for 240 days in any calendar year preceding to their
5
alleged termination of service, as such, they were not entitled for regularization.
10. The moot question for consideration is whether reinstatement "with immediate effect" would tantamount to "continuity of service".
11. The word "reinstatement" has not been defined in the Act and the Rules. As per Shorter Oxford English Dictionary, Vol. II, 3rdEdition, the word "reinstate" means to reinstall or re-establish (a person or thing in a place, station, condition, etc.); to restore to its proper or original state; to reinstate afresh and the word "reinstatement" means the action of reinstating; re-establishment. As per Law Lexicon, 2ndEdition, the word
"reinstate" means to reinstall; to re-establish; to place again in a former state, condition or office; to restore to a state or position from which the object or person had been removed and the word "reinstatement" means establishing in former condition, position or authority (as) reinstatement of a deposed prince. As per Merriam Webster Dictionary, the word "reinstate" means to place again (as in possession or in a former position), to restore to a previous effective state. As per Black's Law Dictionary, 6thEdition, "reinstatement"
means 'to reinstall, to re-establish, to place again in a former state, condition, or office? To restore to a state or position from which the object or person had been removed.'
12. The very idea of restoring an employee to the position which he held before dismissal or removal or termination of service implies that the employee will be put in the same position in which he would have been but for the illegal action taken by the employer.
6
13. In Gurpreet Singh (Supra), the plaintiff's services were terminated. A suit was filed by him for declaring the order of termination as null and void. The suit was dismissed. The Lower Appellate Court held the termination to be illegal and directed reinstatement of plaintiff in service, however, he was held not to be entitled to any arrears of salary for the period for which he did not work. The plaintiff assailed the appellate decree by filing a second appeal. The High Court not only confirmed the decree of the Lower Appellate Court that the plaintiff will not be entitled to any arrears of salary but also further added that he will not get his continuity of service. The appeal was preferred before the Hon'ble Supreme Court and it was held as under:-
"Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and on examining the materials on record, we fail to understand how the continuity of service could be denied once the plaintiff is directed to be reinstated in service on setting aside the order of termination. It is not a case of fresh appointment, but it is a case of reinstatement. That being the position, direction of the High Court that the plaintiff will not get continuity of service cannot be sustained and we set aside the part of the impugned order. So far as the arrears of salary is concerned, we see no infirmity with the direction which was given by the lower appellate court taking into account the facts and circumstances including the fact that the suit was filed after a considerable length of time. That part of the decree denying the arrears of salary stands affirmed and this appeal stands allowed in part to the extent indicated above."
14. Again in Vasantika R. Dalia (supra), the petitioner was employed with Baroda Municipal Corporation as stenographer and her services were terminated without following requirement of Section 25F of Industrial Disputes Act. The Labour Court granted relief of reinstatement in favour of the petitioner without any back wages. The challenge was laid by Municipal Corporation contesting the relief of reinstatement as was granted by the Labour Court but this petition failed. The workman also filed Special Civil
7
Application No. 5497 of 1988 contesting the award denying back wages and consequential relief which was dismissed. As such, the award attained finality. The award granting relief of reinstatement was not implemented by the corporation. Therefore, a contempt petition was filed. However, the workman was reinstated in service and, therefore, the contempt petition was disposed of as having become infructuous. Thereafter, the dispute arose between the parties about the "continuity of service". The Assistant Municipal Commissioner declined to grant any such relief. Therefore, the matter went to Gujarat High Court. It was held that once the relief of reinstatement was granted, continuity of service was the direct consequence rather inherent in the relief of this nature. The relevant observations are extracted as under:-
"By this award the relief of reinstatement has been granted but the relief of back wages has been denied specifically and the relief of continuity of service has not been denied in any terms except that along with the relief of reinstatement the word "continuity" has not been mentioned. It may be straightway observed that once the relief of reinstatement is granted, the continuity of service is the direct consequence rather inherent in the relief of this nature, more particularly when the Division Bench has already held that the termination was void. If the termination order was void the meaning is that in the eye of law the relief of reinstatement has to be granted as if the impugned award had never been passed. The question of back wages is, therefore, dependent on variable factors of gainful employment during the period of enforced idleness and therefore, in a given case the relief of back wages may not be granted depending upon the finding on the question of gainful employment or otherwise during the period of enforced idleness. When the relief of reinstatement is granted and the continuity of service is not specifically denied the party has to be relegated to the same position as was held by it at the time of termination. When the order of termination has been found to be void, the petitioner holds the relief of reinstatement with no mention of specific denial of continuity of service, the concerned workman has to be relegated to the position which was obtaining at the time of termination of her services and there is no question of denying the continuity of services for the period for which the services have been interrupted on account of an unlawful and void order."
8
15. Again in Deepali GunduSurwase vs. Kranti Junior Adhyapak Mahavidyalaya (D.Ed.) and Ors. (2013) 10 SCC 324, the question for consideration was entitlement of the workman for full back wages after the termination was held to be illegal and order for reinstatement in service was passed. Although in the present writ petition, this Court is not concerned with the grant of back wages because undisputedly the same were ordered and have been paid to the petitioner. However, certain observations regarding the effect of reinstatement in service have a bearing on the present case. Hon'ble Supreme Court noted the judgment rendered by two judge bench in J.K. Synthetics Ltd. v. K.P. Agrawal and Anr., (2007) 2 SCC 433 where it was held as under:-
"There is also a misconception that whenever reinstatement is directed,
"continuity of service" and "consequential benefits" should follow, as a matter of course. The disastrous effect of granting several promotions as a "consequential benefit" to a person who has not worked for 10 to 15 years and who does not have the benefit of necessary experience for discharging the higher duties and functions of promotional posts, is seldom visualised while granting consequential benefits automatically. Whenever courts or tribunals direct reinstatement, they should apply their judicial mind to the facts and circumstances to decide whether
"continuity of service" and/or "consequential benefits" should also be directed."
16. Hon'ble Apex Court also noted the observation made by three judge bench in HindustanTin works(P) Ltd. vs. The Employees of The HIndustan Tin Works where it was observed as under:-
"It is no more open to debate that in the field of industrial jurisprudence a declaration can be given that the termination of service is bad and the workman continues to be in service. The spectre of common law doctrine that contract of personal service cannot be specifically enforced or the doctrine of mitigation of damages does not haunt in this branch of law."
17. Various propositions culled out from the various judgments were laid down and the observation relevant to the present case is to the following
9
effect:-
"The observation made in J.K. Synthetics Ltd. v. K.P. Agrawal (supra) that on reinstatement the employee/workman cannot claim continuity of service as of right is contrary to the ratio of the judgments of three Judge Benches referred to hereinabove and cannot be treated as good law. This part of the judgment is also against the very concept of reinstatement of an employee/workman."
18. In view of the aforesaid decisions, coupled with the fact that while granting the relief of reinstatement even the back wages were also granted. That being so, the mere fact that along with the relief of reinstatement the word "continuity of service" has not been mentioned does not mean that the said relief was not granted. That being so, the mere fact that the word "with immediate effect" was mentioned in the award does not mean that the Court impliedly declined the relief of continuity of service.
19. There is another aspect of the matter. Even the respondent has not pleaded in the written statement that there was any break in service or that it was a case of fresh appointment or that the period of service rendered by them before their reinstatement cannot be taken into consideration for the purpose of their regularization on their respective posts. That being so, in the absence of any such pleading, the learned Industrial Adjudicator took a very technical view only on the basis of words "with immediate effect" to interpret that the benefit of continuity of service was not awarded to the petitioner and, accordingly, although it was observed that the workmen was entitled to be considered for regularization as per the policy of the management but they were held not to be entitled for regularization from initial date of their engagement, i.e., 1989.
10
20. Learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon Rameshwar Singh & Anr. vs. Delhi Jal Board, 2014 SCC online Del 7335. It was also a case where the petitioners were muster roll workers. Their termination was held to be illegal and unjustified and they were reinstated in service with back wages. The workmen claimed regularization of their services in proper pay scale and allowances which was not acceded to by the management. Industrial dispute was raised. The matter came up before a Single Judge of this Court and it was observed that the workmen were continuously working with respondent for the last more than 30 years. The case was not for promotion of the petitioners but one of regularization. Keeping in view the fact that the workmen were working since long in the same post they were entitled to be regularized and this order was passed despite the fact that it was the case of the management that they did not fulfil the requisite qualification. An appeal was preferred before the Division Bench of this Court which was dismissed.
21. The present case rather stands on a much better footing as the respondent has not disputed that there is a policy for regularization of the muster roll employees. Petitioners have placed on record following information received by them under Right to Information Act:-
"The matter relates to seeking date of regularization in respect of the persons who were engaged on muster roll during the year 1989 as Beldar/Chowkidar with the department.
In this connection, it may be mentioned that the department has framed a policy of regularization in respect of Group-D(Un-skilled) Muster Roll workers inter alia stipulates that the muster roll workers who have been engaged in between a particular Block (a block comprises of two years as per decision of the Competent Authority) and have completed 720 days muster roll attendance in four years starting from first day of the block of two years and the last day of the fourth calendar years, only is considered for regularization. Hence, only the muster roll workers who fulfil the above requirement in
11
accordance with the departmental policy of regularization is eligible for regularization. However, as per information sought by the applicant, it is submitted that the persons who were engaged with the department as Beldar/Chowkidar during the year 1989 and have possessed the above requirement, have been regularized w.e.f. 01.04.1995 under the Phased Programme of 89-90."
22. That being so, there is no need for remanding the matter to the Industrial Tribunal. The order of the Industrial Tribunal is modified only to the extent that the management will consider the case of workmen for regularization on their respective post on the basis of policy of regularization framed by the management treating them to be in continuous service from the date of their engagement, if they otherwise fulfil the criteria for regularization as per the policy of the management within a period of eight weeks of receipt of this judgment. Registry is directed to send copy of judgment to the respondent for compliance.
23. The petition stands disposed of accordingly.
(SUNITA GUPTA)
JUDGE
OCTOBER 07, 2015
rs
12
Alert