Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Baboo Lal Sharma Petitioner v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi & Ors. S

Delhi High Court
Sep 18, 2015
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary: Rev.Pet.No.346/2015 (Baboo Lal Sharma) — High Court of Delhi (18 September 2015)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Baboo Lal Sharma, sought appointment as a TGT (Sanskrit) with respondent no.1 (Directorate of Education, Government of NCT of Delhi). The advertised eligibility required a Bachelor degree (Honours/Pass) or equivalent with at least 45% marks in aggregate. The petitioner’s B.A. aggregate was 44.27% and was treated as below the 45% requirement.

The petitioner had undertaken a B.A. course (History, Political Science and Sociology) at Maharishi Dayanand Saraswati University (MDS), Ajmer (1996–98), and later took an additional course in Sanskrit under Ordinance 203 of the university, successfully completing it in 2005. He also obtained an M.A. in Sanskrit (degree conferred July 2002) and an M.Ed/B.Ed (2007) with teaching methodology in Sanskrit.

The respondent advertised vacancies in October 2007; the petitioner appeared in the recruitment examination (11 May 2008) and was listed among successful candidates (results notified 29 October 2008). A memorandum of offer was issued on 10 April 2009 and documents scrutinised on 28 April 2009. On 24 September 2009 respondent no.1 cancelled his candidature on the ground that the B.A. additional course could not be considered for eligibility.

The petitioner challenged the cancellation through the Central Administrative Tribunal (O.A. Nos. 3628/2009 and 2787/2009), obtaining an initial favourable order; subsequent rounds of litigation led to remand and further tribunal decisions, culminating in a tribunal order rejecting a later application on 9 August 2012 and dismissal of review on 30 November 2012. The petitioner then filed a writ petition which was dismissed by this Court on 9 April 2015.

By way of the present review petition (Rev.Pet.No.346/2015), filed with an accompanying application (CM No.13184/2015) for condonation of delay, the petitioner sought review of the 9 April 2015 judgment. The Court condoned the delay in filing the review petition and heard the matter.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Division Bench's judgment dated 9 April 2015 dismissing the writ petition contained an error apparent on the face of the record that justified review.
  2. Whether the petitioner’s B.A. additional course in Sanskrit (as permitted by Ordinance 203 of MDS University) and his subsequent M.A. in Sanskrit satisfied the recruitment rules for the post of TGT (Sanskrit), despite the petitioner having below 45% aggregate in his B.A. graduation.
  3. Whether the precedent in W.P.(C) No.1520/2012 (Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors. v. Sachin Gupta and connected matters, judgment dated 7 August 2013) applied to the petitioner’s case and required a purposive interpretation of the corrigendum/requirements so as to treat study of the subject in "all parts/years in which the subject was taught" as sufficient.
  4. Whether a Government of NCT of Delhi notification dated 17 January 1994 (relaxing the 45% requirement for candidates possessing a post-graduate qualification in the concerned Modern Indian Language) applied to the petitioner and thereby relaxed the graduate-level 45% requirement.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner relied on Ordinance 203 of MDS University to show he was authorised to take an additional optional subject (Sanskrit) and that he had successfully cleared that additional course in 2005, completing Sanskrit in all parts in which the subject was taught during the graduation course.
  • The petitioner emphasized that he also possessed a post-graduate degree (M.A. in Sanskrit) and a B.Ed (with Sanskrit teaching methodology), contending that these qualifications should render him eligible for appointment as TGT (Sanskrit).
  • The petitioner sought review of the earlier judgment dismissing his writ petition, contending that the Division Bench did not have before it certain material, including the 7 August 2013 decision in Sachin Gupta and the Government notification dated 17 January 1994, which would have affected the outcome.

Respondents’ Position

  • Learned counsel for the respondents acknowledged that the review petitioner relied on the judgment in W.P.(C) No.1520/2012 (Sachin Gupta) and conceded that the ratio of that decision would apply to the petitioner’s case.
  • The respondents admitted that the Government of NCT of Delhi notification dated 17 January 1994 (relaxing the 45% aggregate requirement for candidates possessing a post-graduate qualification in the relevant Modern Indian Language) had not been placed before the Division Bench when it passed the 9 April 2015 order.
  • Ultimately the respondents accepted that the prayer in the review petition was justified (see para 18 of the judgment).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
W.P.(C) No.1520/2012, Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors. v. Sachin Gupta & connected matters (judgment dated 7 August 2013) The decision established that a literal interpretation of a corrigendum that would render candidates ineligible merely because a university did not teach a given elective in all three years would be absurd; instead a purposive interpretation is required — a candidate should have studied the subject "in all parts/years in which the subject was taught during the Graduation course." It also considered that a person with a post-graduate degree in the concerned language may be at least as well, if not better, equipped to teach that language than someone who only studied it at graduate level. The Court applied this precedent to hold that the petitioner’s study of Sanskrit in the B.A. additional course (covering all parts in which Sanskrit was taught) and his M.A. in Sanskrit fell within the Sachin Gupta interpretation. The Court relied on Sachin Gupta to conclude the Division Bench’s earlier strict literal approach (para 10 of the 9 April 2015 judgment) was erroneous and recalled that portion, leading to the petitioner being held eligible.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a stepwise manner:

  1. Condonation and procedural step: The Court first heard and allowed the application (CM No.13184/2015) to condone delay in filing the review petition.
  2. Factual appraisal: The Court set out the petitioner's qualifications and the administrative chronology, including the offer of appointment, the cancellation of candidature on 24 September 2009, the tribunal proceedings and the dismissal of the writ petition on 9 April 2015.
  3. Examination of earlier judgment: The Court noted that the April 2015 judgment had held that the B.A. additional course was not relevant and that the petitioner’s M.A. could not be used to satisfy the recruitment rules; the April 2015 view applied a strict literal interpretation of the eligibility criteria and concluded the petitioner had not secured 45% marks nor undertaken Sanskrit as part of his subjects in the degree course.
  4. Assessment of controlling precedent: The Court drew attention to the Division Bench’s decision in Sachin Gupta (7 August 2013), particularly paras 30, 32 and para 41 (quoted in the judgment) which favoured a purposive interpretation of the corrigendum and held that candidates who have studied the relevant subject "in all parts/years in which the subject was taught during the Graduation course" should not be rendered ineligible merely because the subject was not taught in all three years across different universities. The Sachin Gupta decision also addressed that a postgraduate in a language may be better equipped to teach the subject than someone who studied it only at graduate level.
  5. Identification of material non-placed before earlier Bench: The Court observed that the Division Bench which decided on 9 April 2015 had not been placed with the Sachin Gupta decision in its entirety (it was only pointed to paras 30 and 32) nor with the Government of NCT of Delhi notification dated 17 January 1994 which relaxes the 45% requirement for candidates possessing a post-graduate qualification in the concerned Modern Indian Language (MIL).
  6. Legal conclusion: The Court held that the omission to place the relevant precedent and the Government notification before the earlier bench resulted in an error apparent on the face of the record. Applying the Sachin Gupta interpretation and the 1994 notification, the Court concluded that the petitioner had fulfilled the basic eligibility criteria and possessed the required educational qualifications.
  7. Remedial direction and scope of relief: The Court recalled paragraph 10 of the earlier judgment (the portion adverse to the petitioner), held that the petitioner was validly appointed, and directed respondent no.1 to permit the petitioner to join at a place of posting to be effected by respondent no.1. The Court denied back wages but granted consequential benefits including seniority as per merit in the select panel and notional pay fixation with the date of joining treated as that on which the person immediately junior joined duty. The respondents were directed to pass orders in terms of the judgment within four weeks.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The review petition was allowed. The Court recalled the findings in paragraph 10 of its earlier judgment dated 9 April 2015 and held that the petitioner fulfilled the basic eligibility criteria under the recruitment rules and notification. The petitioner’s claim for appointment as TGT (Sanskrit) was upheld with directions as to joining and consequential benefits; however, the petitioner was not entitled to back wages.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on parties: The petitioner is to be treated as validly appointed and is to be permitted to join a posting to be effected by respondent no.1. He is entitled to consequential benefits — seniority according to his merit position in the select panel and notional pay fixation (with the date of joining treated as the date the person immediately junior joined duty) — but not entitled to back wages.
  • Administrative consequence: Respondent authorities were directed to pass orders in conformity with this judgment within four weeks.
  • Precedential effect: The Court’s decision relies on existing Division Bench precedent (Sachin Gupta) and a governmental notification; the judgment corrects an earlier error by applying those materials. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond applying the cited precedent and notification to the facts of this case.

Order pronouncing the judgment: Gita Mittal, J. (with I.S. Mehta, J. concurring). Date: 18 September 2015. The review application delaying filing was condoned by order of the Court (CM No.13184/2015).

Show all summary ...

W.P.(C)No.7309/2013 Page 1 of 12 $~13

* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI Rev.Pet.No.346/2015 and CM No.13184/2015 in + W.P.(C) 7309/2013

% Date of decision : 18th September, 2015

BABOO LAL SHARMA ..... Petitioner Through : Mr. Amarjit Singh Bedi, Md. Asfar Heyat Warsi and Mr.

Varun Chandiok, Advs.

versus

GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS. ... Respondents

Through : Mr. Arun Panwar, Adv. for Mr. Raman Duggal, Standing

Counsel (Civil) for GNCTD/R-

1&2.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE GITA MITTAL HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE I.S.MEHTA

JUDGMENT (ORAL)

GITA MITTAL, J.

CM No.13184/2015

Heard. For the reasons stated in the application, the delay in filing the accompanying review petition is condoned. The application is disposed of.

1

Rev.Pet.No.346/2015

1. By way of the present review petition, the petitioner seeks review of the judgment dated 9thApril, 2015 passed by this court dismissing the writ petition. It is submitted by learned counsel for the respondents that no reply is necessary inasmuch as the review petitioner is relying on the judgment dated 7thAugust, 2013 passed in

W.P.(C)No.1520/2012, Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors. v. Sachin Gupta and a batch of connected writ petitions. It is submitted by learned counsel for the respondents that the respondents are not at issue with the petitioner on the fact that the judgment of Sachin Gupta would clearly apply to the case of the petitioner and that the writ petition filed by him deserves to be allowed for this reason alone. Learned counsel points out that the correct paras of this precedent were not pointed out to the court resulting in the judgment under review.

2. The facts giving rise to the instant writ petition are in a narrow compass. The petitioner was seeking appointment as a teacher to the post of TGT (Sanskrit) by the respondent no. 1. The essential

2

eligibility criteria for the same was possession of a Bachelor Degree (Honours/Pass) or equivalent from any recognized University and should have secured 45% marks in aggregate. In his Bacheler"s degree, the petitioner had secured 44.27 marks in aggregate which were treated as being below the criteria of possessing the minimum 45% marks in aggregate at the graduation level.

3. For the purposes of appreciating the submissions of the review petitioner, we set out hereunder the qualifications of the petitioner. He is stated to have undertaken a B.A. Degree course with History Political Science and Sociology from Maharishi Dayanand Saraswati University, Ajmer between 1996-98. The petitioner relies on Ordinance 203 of the MDS University, Ajmer, to the effect that "any candidate who has passed the B.A.(Pass and Hons.) B.Sc. (Pass and Hons.) B.Sc. (Ag) or B.Com (Pass and Hons.) exam of the university or an examination recognized by the university as equivalent thereto shall be allowed to present himself for examination in any subsequent year in any of one of the optional subjects prescribed for the B.A. examination and not already taken by him at the degree examination,

3

and if successful will be given a certificate to the effect. Such a candidate shall be required to appear in all the papers of that subject in one and the same year, provided that his is not registered for any other examination of the university in the same years". It is submitted by the petitioner that as permitted under the rules of the said university, he applied for the additional course with Sanskrit as the additional optional subject which was cleared by him in 2005. As a result, the petitioner completed the subject in question i.e. Sanskrit in all parts in which this subject was taught during graduation course with sanskrit. In the meantime, the petitioner also cleared his post- graduation as well and a degree of M.A. in Sanskrit was conferred upon him in July, 2002 by the MDS University, Ajmer. In 2007, the petitioner passed his B.ED examination from the university of Kashmir, Sri Nagar with first class distinction inter alia for teaching method Sanskrit.

4. The respondent had issued an advertisement for the post of TGT (Sanskrit) in October, 2007 in the schools of Government of NCT of Delhi run by the Directorate of Education. The petitioner

4

appeared in the examination conducted by the respondent on 11th May, 2008 and his name had appeared in the list of successful candidates in the results notified on 29thOctober, 2008.

5. On 10thApril, 2009, the petitioner was issued a memorandum of offer of appointment. His documents were scrutinised on 28th April, 2009. As no information was received by him, the petitioner sought information under Right to Information Act on the 8thof July 2009. It is only thereafter on 24thSeptember, 2009, the respondent no.1 passed an order directing cancellation of the candidature of the petitioner on the ground that the B.A. Additional course undergone by him could not be considered as rendering the petitioner eligible for appointment to the post.

6. The petitioner approached the Central Administrative Tribunal by way of O.A.No.3628/2009 seeking a direction to the respondent for appointment and posting on the post of TGT (Sanskrit). By its order dated 6thOctober, 2009, the tribunal directed the respondent to dispose of the petitioner"s representation. As no response was received from the respondent, yet another O.A.No.2787/2009 was

5

filed by the petitioner which was decided in his favour by the judgment dated 11thMarch, 2001.

7. The respondent assailed the judgment of the tribunal by way of W.P.(C)No.6006/2010. The same was considered and by an order dated 4thOctober, 2010, the matter was remanded to the tribunal. The matter was decided again by the tribunal on 21stDecember, 2010 directing the respondent no.1 to reconsider the matter and take a final decision in consultation with respondent no.3.

8. On 1stMarch, 2011, respondent no.1 sought clarification on the issue of eligibility of the petitioner from the respondent no.3. Despite the clarification given by respondent no.3 on 26thApril, 2011, the respondent no.1 rejected the petitioner"s candidature by an order dated 27thMay, 2011 without giving any explanation. The petitioner assailed the said action by third petition before the Central Administrative Tribunal which unfortunately was rejected by an order dated 9thAugust, 2012. The petitioner"s review application was dismissed on 30thNovember, 2012 by the tribunal resulting in filing of the present writ petition.

6

9. The writ petition also came to be dismissed by this court by the judgment dated 9thApril, 2015. This court was of the view that the acquisition of a B.A. additional course was not relevant for the purposes of assessing the petitioner"s eligibility for appointment to the post of TGT (Sanskrit) in terms of the recruitment rules. Furthermore, no benefit can be taken by the petitioner of his having been successfully completed the M.A. (Sanskrit) degree course for the purposes of his engagement as TGT (Sanskrit). This court in the judgment dated 9thApril, 2015 was of the view that the eligibility criteria has to be strictly applied and the petitioner"s candidature was rightly rejected for the reason that he had not secured 45% marks in the additional B.A. Degree course and that he had not undertaken Sanskrit as part of his subjects in that course.

10. Our attention is drawn to the consideration of this very aspect by a co-ordinate Bench of this court in the judgment dated 7thAugust, 2013 in Sachin Gupta which is in the following terms :

"41. All universities in India do not offer a particular elective subject in all three years" of graduation course as in the case of Nainika, Vikram Singh and Sachin Gupta,

7

where Delhi University did not teach English/Hindi/Economics in all three years of B.A. program/B.Com (H) course (s) conducted by it. If the corrigendum dated March 30, 2010 is given a literal interpretation, all such candidates who have studied concerned subject i.e. the subject for which they have applied from the Universities which are not teaching said subject in all three years" of Graduation course offered by them would be rendered ineligible for appointment to the post of T.G.T. despite the fact they have studied the concerned subject in all parts/years in which the subject is taught by the university and have a good understanding thereof. This is absurd. It is a settled legal position that where literal meaning of a statute or rule leads to an absurdity, the principle of literal interpretation need not be followed and recourse should be taken to the purposive and meaningful interpretation to avoid injustice, absurdity and contradiction so that the intent of the purpose of Legis lature is given effect to. Therefore, a WP(C) 1520/2012 & conn.matters meaningful and practical interpretation has to be given to the corrigendum dated March 30, 2010 and same should be interpreted as follows: „the candidate should have studied the subject concerned as mentioned in the RRs in all parts/years in which the subject was taught during the Graduation course."

11. We also find that the Division Bench has considered the teaching ability of a person who has studied the concerned language at the graduate as well as at the post-graduate level in the following terms :

8

"50. In view of aforesaid authoritative pronouncements, we hold that respondent Neelam Rana is eligible for being appointed to the post of T.G.T.(English), particularly when the Directorate of Education has placed no material before us to show that the person who has studied English at graduate level would be better equipped to teach English to students vis -à-vis a person who has obtained a Post G graduate degree in English language."

However, on 9thApril, 2015, the attention of this court was drawn only to paras 30 and 32 of Sachin Gupta and not to the above findings.

12. In the case in hand, the petitioner has acquired a post-graduate degree in the Sanskrit language and has to be considered better to teach Sanskrit vis-a-vis a person who has studied the same under graduate degree course.

13. In view of the above, the fact that the petitioner had undertaken study of Sanskrit language for all parts in the B.A. additional course, was a relevant factor for consideration of his eligibility, as mentioned in the recruitment rules. The acquisition of the post-graduate degree in Sanskrit renders the petitioner even better qualified to teach in the position than a person with a mere graduate degree.

9

14. Our attention is also drawn to the notification issued by the Government of NCT of Delhi dated 17thJanuary, 1994 regarding the method of recruitment and qualifications necessary for appointment to the post of TGT (Sanskrit) in the Directorate of Education of the Government. Amongst the amendments notified by the concerned government, so far as the qualifications required for direct recruitment are concerned, the respondents have notified the following eligibility qualifications :

"(For appointment as Hindi Teachers only) Sahitya Rattan of Hindi Sahitya Sammellan Prayag having secured atleast 45 per cent marks in aggregate with English in Matriculation provided further that the requirement as to the minimum of 45 per cent marks in the aggregate shall be relaxable in the case of

(a) candidate who possesses a Post Graduate Qualification in MIL concerned from a recognised University (b) candidates belonging to SC/ST (c) Physically handicapped candidates."

(Emphasis by us)

15. As a result, for a candidate possessing a post-graduate qualification in MIL (Modern Indian Language), a minimum requirement of 45% marks in aggregate at the graduate level is relaxable.

10

16. It is admitted by the learned counsel for the respondent that the said notification was also not brought to the notice of the Bench when it passed the order dated 9thApril, 2015 resulting in the dismissal of the petitioner"s claim.

17. In view of the above discussion, we find that the relevant law on the subject as well as binding notification of the Government of NCT of Delhi was not placed before the Division Bench of this court, resulting in an error apparent on the face of the record.

18. The prayer made in the review petition is justified and admitted by the respondent. The findings of the Division Bench of this court in para 10 of the judgment dated 9thApril, 2015 are hereby recalled. It is held that the petitioner fulfilled the basic eligibility criteria laid down in the recruitment rules and notified in the advertisement are possessed the required educational qualifications. The petitioner was, therefore, validly appointed and has to be permitted to join at a place of posting to be effected by the respondent no.1.

19. The claim of the petitioner in the petition before the tribunal as per the Original Application seeking appointment to the post of TGT

11

(Sanskrit) is upheld with the exception that he shall not be entitled to back wages but would be entitled to all consequential benefits such as seniority as per his merit position in the select panel and notional pay fixation with reference to the date of his joining being treated as the one on which the person immediately junior to them joined duty.

20. The respondents shall pass the orders in terms of the above within a period of four weeks from today.

This petition is allowed in the above terms. Dasti.

GITA MITTAL, J

I.S.MEHTA, J

SEPTEMBER 18, 2015

aj

12