- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kerala State Public Service Commission v. State Information Commission
Factual and Procedural Background
The writ appeals arise from a judgment dated 10.02.2012 directing the Kerala Public Service Commission (KPSC) to provide answer sheets to candidates who requested them. The appeals challenge this direction. The matter was subsequently addressed by the Supreme Court in a related case concerning the disclosure of answer sheets and related information to candidates.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Kerala Public Service Commission is obligated to provide candidates with their evaluated answer sheets and details of interview marks under the Right to Information.
- Whether the identity of examiners who evaluated answer sheets should be disclosed to candidates.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Kerala Public Service Commission and Others v. State Information Commission and Another [2016 (1) KHC 533 (SC)] |
- KPSC is bound to provide answer sheets and interview marks to candidates. - A fiduciary relationship exists between KPSC and examiners, making examiner identities exempt from disclosure. - Disclosure of examiner identity may lead to public unrest and endanger examiners. |
The court relied on this Supreme Court judgment to uphold the obligation of KPSC to provide answer sheets and marks to candidates while refusing to disclose the identity of examiners, emphasizing the fiduciary relationship and potential negative consequences of disclosure. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the Supreme Court’s judgment which clarified the nature of the relationship between the Public Service Commission and examiners as principal-agent, establishing a fiduciary relationship. This relationship exempts examiner identities from disclosure to protect examiners from potential retaliation and to maintain the integrity of the evaluation process. Conversely, the court recognized that answer sheets and interview marks do not fall under fiduciary secrecy and should be disclosed to candidates to ensure transparency and fairness in competitive examinations. The court concluded that since the Supreme Court has addressed these issues authoritatively, nothing further remains to be considered in the appeals.
Holding and Implications
The appeals and the writ petition are dismissed.
The Kerala Public Service Commission is directed to comply with the Supreme Court’s judgment by providing candidates their answer sheets and interview marks if available. However, the identity of examiners shall not be disclosed due to the fiduciary relationship and to prevent possible adverse consequences. This decision directly affects the parties by confirming disclosure obligations while protecting examiner confidentiality. No new precedent was established beyond the authoritative Supreme Court ruling.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT:
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR.ASHOK BHUSHAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE A.M.SHAFFIQUE
TUESDAY, THE 22ND DAY OF MARCH 2016/2ND CHAITHRA, 1938 WA. No. 816 of 2012 () IN WP(C).21949/2011 -------------------------------------------
AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT IN WP(C) 21949/2011 OF HIGH COURT OF
KERALA DATED 10.02.2012
APPELLANT(S)/PETITIONERS:
------------------------------------------------
1. KERALA STATE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, OFFICE OF THE KPSC,
PATTOM, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
2. THE STATE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER,
KERALA STATE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION, PATTOM,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
3. THE APPELLATE AUTHORITY,
KERALA STATE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION, PATTOM,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
BY ADV. SRI.P.C.SASIDHARAN, SC, KPSC
RESPONDENT(S)/RESPONDENTS:
----------------------------------------------------
1. STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION, KERALA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, PIN-695001.
2. ANU P.V., PARACKAL HOUSE,
CHEMBANTHOTTI P.O., SREEKANDAPURAM VIA, KANNUR DISTRICT-670631.
R2 BY ADV. SRI.P.NARAYANAN
R1 BY SRI.M.AJAY, SC, STATE INFORMATION COMMN
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 22-03-2016, ALONG WITH WA. 989/2012, WA. 1144/2012, WPC. 18755/2012, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
1
WA. No. 816 of 2012 ()
APPENDIX
APPELLANTS' ANNEXURES:-
A1:- COPY OF THE ORDER ISSUED BY THE SUPREME COURT IN S.L.P NO.15919-15950
OF 2011.
RESPONDENTS' ANNEXURES:-NIL
KRJ
//TRUE COPY//
P.A TO JUDGE
2
ASHOK BHUSHAN, C.J &
A.M.SHAFFIQUE, J
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = W.A Nos.816/2012, 989 of 2012, 1144 of 2012 &
W.P(C) No.18755/2012
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = Dated this the 22ndday of March, 2016
JUDGMENT
Shaffique, J
The writ appeals are filed against the judgment dated 10.2.2012 by which, direction has been issued to the Kerala Public Service Commission (KPSC) to provide answer sheets to the candidates. The matter is now decided by the judgment of the Supreme Court in
Kerala Public Service Commission and Others v. State Information commission and Another [2016 (1) KHC 533 (SC)]. The Apex Court after considering similar issue observed that KPSC is bound to provide answer sheets and said information to the candidates. It is held at paragraphs (9) and (10) as under:-
"9. In the present, the PSC has taken upon itself in appointing the examiners to evaluate the answer papers
3
WA.816,989,1144/12 & W.P(C).18755/12 -:2:-
and as such, the PSC and examiners stand in a principal- agent relationship. Here the PSC in the shoes of a Principal has entrusted the task of evaluating the answer papers to the Examiners. Consequently, Examiners in the position of agents are bound to evaluate the answer papers as per the instructions given by the PSC. As a result, a fiduciary relationship is established between the PSC and the Examiners. Therefore, any information shared between them is not liable to be disclosed. Furthermore, the information seeker has no role to play in this and we don't see any logical reason as to how this will benefit him or the public at large. We would like to point out that the disclosure of the identity of Examiners is in the least interest of the general public and also any attempt to reveal the examiners identity will give rise to dire consequences. Therefore, in our considered opinion revealing examiner's identity will only lead to confusion and public unrest. Hence, we are not inclined to agree with the decision of the Kerala High Court with respect to the second question.
10. In the present case the request of the information seeker about the information of his answer sheets and details of the interview marks can be and should be provided to him. It is not something which a
4
WA.816,989,1144/12 & W.P(C).18755/12 -:3:-
public authority keeps it under a fiduciary capacity. Even disclosing the marks and the answer sheets to the candidates will ensure that the candidates have been given marks according to their performance in the exam. This practice will ensure a fair play in this competitive environment, where candidate puts his time in preparing for the competitive exams, but, the request of the information seeker about the details of the person who had examined/checked the paper cannot and shall not be provided to the information seeker as the relationship between the public authority i.e. Service Commission and the Examiners is totally within the fiduciary relationship. The Commission has reposed trust on the examiners that they will check the exam papers with utmost care, honesty and impartially and, similarly, the Examiners have faith that they will not be facing any unfortunate consequences for doing their job properly. If we allow disclosing name of the examiners in every exam, the unsuccessful candidates may try to take revenge from the examiners for doing their job properly. This may, further, create situation where the potential candidates in the next similar exam, especially in the same state or in the same level will try to contact the disclosed examiners for any potential gain by illegal means in the potential exam."
5
WA.816,989,1144/12 & W.P(C).18755/12 -:4:-
2. Having regard to the observations made by the Supreme Court nothing else survives to be considered in these matters. Hence, we observe that KPSC shall comply with the direction in the judgment if the answer sheets are available with them. The appeals and the writ petition are dismissed. Sd/-
ASHOK BHUSHAN
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/-
A.M.SHAFFIQUE
JUDGE
krj.22/3/16
6
Alert